Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Really pushing the Mirena coil

64 replies

KatieBenz · 18/08/2022 22:05

I had a hysterospcy today. Not a pleasant experience as my surgeon took a large polyp out.
I found it strange that my consultant, when talking through the procedure, was really promoting a mirena coil. I’m in my 50’s and have never had one. Why would I consider it now?

OP posts:
Meseekslookatme · 19/08/2022 10:31

Soontobe60 · 19/08/2022 08:08

Even though there’s a GP posting on here who’s confirmed that there is no financial incentive for GP’s to fit them?
Even though there is a whole wealth of evidence that they work brilliantly in the vast majority of users?

All contraceptives, indeed all prescribed medication comes with warnings and lists of d]side effects. Does that mean you won’t take ANY of them? I think some people on this thread lack basic common sense.

Because also, there's so many women that post on here desperate to get them out and having barriers throw up.
How often do we see people pleading to have them taken back out because of symptoms that no one should put up with.
So many have to threaten to remove it themselves to get it out.
Female medicine is shit. Utterly shit.
We are treated like children that don't require pain relief.
It's disgusting and we are quite rightly wary.

Galarunner · 19/08/2022 09:08

DeedIDo · 19/08/2022 08:52

When they were pushing the Mirena at me pre-menopause they reassured me that the hormones stay in the uterus, so i definitely wouldn't have any of 5e issues I had previously had with progesterone. (I couldn't take the combined Pill and the mini-Pill was even worse).

However, if they now offer it for systemic menopause symptoms, presumably that is not the case.

I was never convinced I was told the truth and decided it wasn't worth the risk.

The reason the mirena is used with HRT as you need to take progesterone to protect your womb when taking HRT. This can be done with a prostegrene pill or the coil. For many women the mirena coil is a very effective way of doing this. You can't take oestrogen safely without progesterone ( if you still have a womb and are still pre menopausal. )

DeedIDo · 19/08/2022 08:52

When they were pushing the Mirena at me pre-menopause they reassured me that the hormones stay in the uterus, so i definitely wouldn't have any of 5e issues I had previously had with progesterone. (I couldn't take the combined Pill and the mini-Pill was even worse).

However, if they now offer it for systemic menopause symptoms, presumably that is not the case.

I was never convinced I was told the truth and decided it wasn't worth the risk.

Willowkins · 19/08/2022 08:38

I had a few and they worked well for me - up to the point they didn't. And it became increasingly difficult to get them changed/removed because my GP stopped doing it, and the local sexual health clinic would only do it if it was for contraception - which left the local hospital (good luck with that). I much prefer the capsules because I have more control.

TheDogsMother · 19/08/2022 08:27

I had exactly the same experience OP. Hysteroscopy due to unexpected bleeding and they removed a polyp. I was relatively new to HRT but post menopausal. I just felt I'd had enough of random bleeding and had read about some side effects with the Mirena coil so I didn't want to risk more even issues. Still not sure if it's the right decision but things have settled down for me now.

soupmaker · 19/08/2022 08:26

@MrsPelligrinoPetrichor I have friends who had the mirena fitted, it didn't work for them, they got it removed on request.

It's not for you, fine. But stop talking rubbish

Soontobe60 · 19/08/2022 08:14

Meseekslookatme · 19/08/2022 07:57

I've literally been on my back, legs splayed with a speculum hanging out of me having a copper one and they STILL pushed mirena right up until they unwrapped the one I booked in for.
There absolutely HAS to be an incentive because they've certainly not given a shit about what's best for me before or since.

I’ve had a mirena in for a long time - I don’t give a damn if GPs did get paid for fitting them (which I know they don’t), because it was an actual life saver for me. It stopped my incredibly painful, heavy periods which meant I didn’t need to continue taking time off from my job every month putting me at risk of losing that job; I stopped feeling at deaths door every month; my life in general improved massively. All as a result of a little piece of plastic impregnated with the hormones my body needed in order to function well.

Twizbe · 19/08/2022 08:10

@FancyFelix I've heard great things.

My issue was that I've reacted badly to hormones before and I have a cervical ectropion which is hormone reactive. I felt that those combined might mean more bleeding rather than less. I didn't want to try it if I couldn't have it removed easily either.

The last gynaecologist I saw was the one who diagnosed the ectropion and said that mirena was likely not the best idea for me. This gynae was also the first one who I felt really listened to my issues and didn't just roll their eyes at my experience with hormones previously.

Soontobe60 · 19/08/2022 08:08

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 19/08/2022 07:52

I wouldn't have anything fitted that couldn't be easily removed if I wanted it. I also think there's financial incentive as they really push it.

Even though there’s a GP posting on here who’s confirmed that there is no financial incentive for GP’s to fit them?
Even though there is a whole wealth of evidence that they work brilliantly in the vast majority of users?

All contraceptives, indeed all prescribed medication comes with warnings and lists of d]side effects. Does that mean you won’t take ANY of them? I think some people on this thread lack basic common sense.

memorial · 19/08/2022 08:00

FancyFelix · 19/08/2022 06:36

It has been life changing for me. I don't understand why people are so opposed to even considering it.

Because its much easier to slag off GPs than actually consider that they might actually be doing their job ie advising on best management.

memorial · 19/08/2022 07:58

InChocolateWeTrust · 19/08/2022 07:17

Drs get kickbacks for mirenas which is why they push them over the similarly effective cheap old fashioned copper coil.

Bellshill
( GP partner of 20 years)

Meseekslookatme · 19/08/2022 07:57

Twizbe · 18/08/2022 22:37

Doctors do love that coil, I wonder if there is any commission on them.

I've lost count of the number of doctors who tried to get me to have one - flatly refused every time.

I've literally been on my back, legs splayed with a speculum hanging out of me having a copper one and they STILL pushed mirena right up until they unwrapped the one I booked in for.
There absolutely HAS to be an incentive because they've certainly not given a shit about what's best for me before or since.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 19/08/2022 07:55

**while

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 19/08/2022 07:53

KatieBenz · 19/08/2022 07:21

Thanks for all of your input. I was a little taken aback as I haven’t taken hrt for a year. Perhaps they should mention it in the leaflet they give you. It would have been nice to look into it beforehand and not make an on the spot decision.

Very hard to make a decision which having a procedure like that done. They're pretty traumatic by all accounts,was very pleased I didn't need one.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 19/08/2022 07:52

monkeysox · 18/08/2022 22:40

They really pushed them over the past ten years but then my local GP no longer removes or fits them. Outsourced to virgin healthcare and can't get appointments. It's a scandal.

I wouldn't have anything fitted that couldn't be easily removed if I wanted it. I also think there's financial incentive as they really push it.

Galarunner · 19/08/2022 07:51

My really good friend is a GP , she has one as part of her HRT ( same as me works brilliantly) I think it's a bit of a myth that doctors make individual profit out of fitting them. I always get mine replaced at a sexual health clinic rather than the GP these days anyway ( I am on my 4th) as the doctors there seem to be make it a bit less painful than the GP, probably because they do a lot more. HRT and mirena is a very good combination for me.

Kittyshopping · 19/08/2022 07:46

Would highly recommend. Don’t go looking for negative reviews as it’s not a balanced cohort. Those of us happy "Mirenas" don’t tend to comment or post on it. Mine stopped horrible flooding every month and saw me through the menopause.

yikesanotherbooboo · 19/08/2022 07:39

@InChocolateWeTrust this isn't true.
The fitting of mirenas , copper coils and implants get some small reimbursement because it is a service which costs money in terms of training and manpower.
They're use isn't pushed because of this , as you can see from numerous posts insufficient doctors and hcps are trained in their use and hence the long waits .
They are 'pushed' because they work really well for contraception and in the case of mirena as a treatment for heavy periods, as a way of stabilising the uterine lining and as a way of administering progesterone for HRT.in the latter case with the smallest dose of progesterone and thus less side effects.They are very well tolerated but of course don't suit everyone.

KatieBenz · 19/08/2022 07:21

Thanks for all of your input. I was a little taken aback as I haven’t taken hrt for a year. Perhaps they should mention it in the leaflet they give you. It would have been nice to look into it beforehand and not make an on the spot decision.

OP posts:
InChocolateWeTrust · 19/08/2022 07:17

Drs get kickbacks for mirenas which is why they push them over the similarly effective cheap old fashioned copper coil.

Putonyourshoes · 19/08/2022 07:10

MarieInternette · 18/08/2022 22:37

I have had something similar. It seems GP’s are very keen to push the Mirena coil onto menopausal women. (The cynic in me wonders if there is a financial incentive for this?) However, after having done my own research I’ve decided against it. Too many horror stories from women who have had awful side effects from it ( inc cysts, bloating, weight gain, depression, migraine etc). GP did not advise of any side effects.

Look at some of the FB groups for Mirena coil users. People discussing their experiences with Mirena and then make your mind up.

I think there’s a bit of confirmation bias with this. If you go looking for negative experiences with a certain contraceptive you’ll find them. And there’s also the element of how much an anecdote stands out if it’s a paragraph long about negative side effects, compared to a quick “it’s always worked well for me”.
There will always be people who have a bad experience with any kind of contraception. GPs are “keen to push” the Mirena coil because research shows it’s very effective, especially for menopausal women.

soupmaker · 19/08/2022 07:03

I'm on my second and it's been absolutely life changing. I suffered from PMDD after DD1 was born. Was on medication but stopped taking it when pregnant with DD2. Despite EBF her my period and the PMDD came back, couldn't use medication and continue BFing so GP suggested the mirena coil. I've had no PMDD symptoms since it was fitted. Am early 50s and haven't had much trouble with menopause symptoms thanks to it. If it works for you it's brilliant.

Afterfire · 19/08/2022 06:59

They can form part of the progesterone part of HRT. So if you have a mirena that’s the progesterone bit and then you can have oestrogel for the oestrogen. However, you can take the mini pill and utrogestan or just double the utrogestan with instead - these are alternative options to the coil. I would never have a coil - too many horror stories for me and don’t like anything invasive so I take the mini pill, then take 100mg utrogestan every day and then 2 pumps of oestrogel as HRT. It means I never have any periods or bleeding and it works well for me (I’m 41 and I’m early menopause).

Ylvamoon · 19/08/2022 06:50

I'm on my 3rd. I prefer the Mirena to other types of contraception.

I also suffer from migraine but found out that they are actually worse without the coil.

Mine "run out" just after covid hid so couldn't change it until nearly 2 years later! 18 months of these 2 years were horrendous with migraine.

I think what one really has to consider is that everyone is different. What works for one doesn't work for others...
I actually got pregnant on the pill -I know MN thiks it's impossible.but here we are!

FancyFelix · 19/08/2022 06:36

Caneparrot · 18/08/2022 22:49

I’m a GP and also have a gynae background - zero financial incentive to fit them, they just work really well when they work (appreciate they don’t work for all, but the vast majority). Really great as part of HRT (makes it much more straightforward/titratable) and can really be life altering for women with heavy bleeds/fibroids.

It has been life changing for me. I don't understand why people are so opposed to even considering it.