Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

NHS Excluding people in treatment for mental health conditions.

93 replies

Heathe · 18/08/2022 19:05

Going to enable voting but realise this may not do me any favours. I am currently in treatment for a mental health condition, and currently applying for roles within mental health trusts. I have previously worked during this treatment so can demonstrate I can handle treatment and working, however, many of the jobs are stating that a person has to be in recovery, has to have experience of recovery etc.

These are Lived Experience, Expert by Experience, Peer Support Roles, Support Worker roles etc.

I'm just wondering whether excluding people currently in treatment for mental health conditions is actually against the Equality Act as a mental health condition is a protected characteristic.

Apart from the fact it has made me feel completely inadequate and has really knocked my confidence, I am starting to feel really frustrated that people who are treating patients with mental health conditions are so open to excluding them in this way, particularly when many of us are in group therapy so we have experience of hearing and dealing with other people's concerns and issues.

I'm interested to hear if anyone has a legal perspective on this, or if anyone else has found this when applying for roles?

YANBU - this is shit

YABU - this is sensible

OP posts:
DancingBeanstalk · 18/08/2022 20:06

I have suffered with my mental health and required treatment myself. I would not be happy with someone also suffering attempting to help me - this isn’t one friend to another just winging it.

You need to be fully recovered and in the right head space and recovery experience to help others recover.

NuttyinNotts · 18/08/2022 20:05

But does recovered automatically mean not having any treatment? Is that a reasonable bar? Stability is important, progress is important definitely, as is insight but those things can be there whilst someone has treatment that maintains their progress.

Heathe · 18/08/2022 20:03

Thanks for all the replies by the way, I do really appreciate them.

OP posts:
Heathe · 18/08/2022 20:03

But the requirement of most therapy courses is that you yourself are in therapy / analysis / supervision?

OP posts:
DancingBeanstalk · 18/08/2022 20:01

As much as you want to, you are not mentally well enough to help others suffering with their mental health when you are not fully recovered yourself.

lljkk · 18/08/2022 20:00

My first 2 thoughts about requirement OP objects to were

  1. duty of care to the applicant. Should not employ someone who may be harmed by the job (that stupid word triggered). Would it be like expecting someone to run a race when their leg is still broken not healed.
  2. role model. Someone who can offer hope to others, knows the path to recovery, by being in a much better place since they were in the worst place. The core unique function of this person is to know what recovery is like and to have a view what the whole journey may be like.
BadNomad · 18/08/2022 19:58

It is because you can't objectively support someone professionally when you are currently needing support for the same or similar issue. A lot of therapy-type roles and courses have this condition.

Heathe · 18/08/2022 19:58

@niccyb my fear at the moment is that I will never go back to work; feeling like my brain is starting to rot from lack of use! I hope your friend is doing better?

OP posts:
Heathe · 18/08/2022 19:56

Can someone explain why you are saying they are not excluding anyone receiving treatment when they are literally using not receiving treatment as the definition for being in recovery?

@niccyb yes, I have my old job offered back to me however I’ve been advised that it wouldn’t be advisable to take it as it involves lots of travel and I cannot protect my therapy time this time around… which I fully understand.

OP posts:
ButyouwereuptoyouroldtricksinChaptersFourFiveandSix · 18/08/2022 19:43

Have you clarified that this is what they mean? I’d have thought they didn’t intend to exclude and would apply anyway. Interesting question about the equality act I don’t know the answer but would like to

Heathe · 18/08/2022 19:43

And @lisers you haven't had my experience of group therapy clearly (expected, but trust me some staff were absolutely not involved in the peer support that we were expected to give each other (and yes, I do realise this is not how group therapy should have been done but that's how it was and the clinic thankfully was shut down))

OP posts:
niccyb · 18/08/2022 19:43

you have referred to the NHS but have applied/been offered other job roles?
It must depend on the treatment you are receiving? I would think intense psychotherapy for example would mean you need to concentrate on getting better. What if you didn’t get on with your colleagues or due to the stress of the job you suffered a set back? However I may be wrong.

My friend had intense psychotherapy following a marriage breakdown amongst other things and was told not to go back to work or start a new job unless treatment was complete! She has never been back to work since as she never recovered. Hope you get better OP

Bundlesofchocforme · 18/08/2022 19:42

I work on an inpatient ward and it is so so hard at times. Our peer support workers are often our most precious and cherished resource but their job is arguably the hardest of all. They expose themselves daily to their deepest demons and make themselves vulnerable in order to support and give hope to our patients in their darkest moments. To do this they need buckets of resilience and huge amounts of care from the rest of the team. I haven’t voted as I don’t know you or your story but I would say a good ten years of being well is needed for our psw’s to fulfil their role. I think it’s different to accessing therapy, lots of our team access therapy and it’s generally seen as a strength.

Heathe · 18/08/2022 19:41

Arguing or asking about legal standpoints is not going to demonstrate you are well enough to be employed.

I am asking a question on mumsnet - I've hardly gone back to the NHS Trusts - and I am not one of the people who are talking to solicitors - I wanted to hear views, which I have, and which I have listened too.

OP posts:
Foreverlexicon · 18/08/2022 19:35

@Heathe the ironic thing is now I’m in, they couldn’t care less to try and support me when I’ve struggled and reached out!

I find it a vicious cycle. I’ve had psychological screening as moving to a department which deals with some particularly unpleasant incidents with flying colours because my MH is entirely unrelated to my job. However, I can’t get support for it as that will prevent me getting the same role elsewhere despite being able to prove I’m entirely capable of doing the role 🤷🏻‍♀️

Some things can’t be healed. I have struggled with anxiety and depression my whole life. I have ups and downs and I have some specific triggers. As long as I manage my triggers, I’m relatively fine and those triggers are generally not something I come across at work.

Heathe · 18/08/2022 19:32

If my therapy was at 8pm at night (as it has been), I wouldn't actually have to say anything about it to anyone - there's no way they would no. So it's the timings of therapy as well (the NHS does not offer after work appointments sadly, and I cannot afford to switch back to private therapy - another bugbear about this whole situation).

But for some of us, there is literally no concept of recovery, it's learning to manage.

OP posts:
AlternativelyWired · 18/08/2022 19:32

@Andromachehadabadday I agree. I say that as someone who has had clinical depression, general anxiety disorder and an eating disorder. I think it also depends on the condition.

lisers · 18/08/2022 19:31

@Heathe Attending group supervision as a participant is not the same as attending as an employee. If you are being advised you need to be in recovery to be successful in gaining one of these posts you should focus on your recovery. Arguing or asking about legal standpoints is not going to demonstrate you are well enough to be employed.

Andromachehadabadday · 18/08/2022 19:29

I vote yabu.

Because they aren’t specifically excluding anyone receiving treatment. The op is misleading.

They want, specifically, want people who are in recovery for very clear reasons. Which excludes anyone that’s not in recovery. Many jobs ask for certain experience. Which excludes everyone who doesn’t have that experience.

Heathe · 18/08/2022 19:29

@NuttyinNotts exactly - that's how I feel. Some conditions you don't recover from, you learn to manage and live alongside with, as a lot of clinicians say "recovery is a very poor concept" for those conditions, yet we still have the bar of recovery held against us whilst applying for jobs.

OP posts:
Heathe · 18/08/2022 19:28

@Foreverlexicon that is really horrible, I am sorry - it's blanket policies like this that should not exist.

I have one hour of individual therapy a week now- but due to the timings I have to tell whoever I work for. I don't take any medication and have never been sectioned / an inpatient.

OP posts:
Holly60 · 18/08/2022 19:25

Sorry - all successful applicants

Holly60 · 18/08/2022 19:24

Heathe · 18/08/2022 19:22

You wouldn't know about my treatment though - that would be confidential. So patients would not know I was still accessing therapy? Just like you wouldn't know your line manager in any other job was accessing therapy.

But as it stands I would know that ALL applicants for the job have been deemed to be in recovery. You are suggesting a scenario where I would know that the person I'm taking to MIGHT still be needing a lot of support for their own mental health. I wouldn't be comfortable with that

Foreverlexicon · 18/08/2022 19:24

I can’t edit but I missed out; I failed the medical when they took one glance and saw I was on antidepressants which I had started whilst my mum was dying and I was caring for her, her menagerie of pets and working full time.

NuttyinNotts · 18/08/2022 19:24

If you exclude anyone "in treatment" then peer support will be less relevant for supporting people with serious mental illness. Many people with a diagnosis of schizophrenia will be on lifetime meds, even if they manage their symptoms well, for example. Having peer support around experiences that most people can't get their head around is invaluable.