Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have said something?!

284 replies

Briony22 · 18/08/2022 18:21

At the supermarket earlier, and parked in a parent and child space with DH and 10 month old DS.

As I was getting DS out of the car a car pulled into the parent and child space next to us, and a woman got out and started walking towards the supermarket without any kids.

I called after her and said "You know you've parked in a P&C space, yeah?" and she started huffing and puffing that she had her son with her, who was in the car. I pointed out that the spaces are for parents with children who need the extra room to get them out of the car, and then she said that her son was disabled and that she had a disabled badge. I then said that the disabled spaces were in another area of the car park, at which point she started getting her son out of the car and telling him that he had to come into the shop "because that mental lady was kicking off".

I'm just so sick of entitled fuckers using these spaces without any need to when I've often struggled trying to get DS out of his car seat without sufficient space.

DH was mortified and said I should have just left it.

WIBU?

OP posts:
Hopefullysoon2022 · 19/08/2022 11:33

We'll @Briony22 I hope the next time someone has the audacity to park in p&c places,you'll keep your gob shut.
Or the next time you mightn't come off so well.

allyouneedismarmite · 19/08/2022 11:27

Meraas · 19/08/2022 11:13

Fair enough, thanks for pointing those out.

But I didn’t swear at you.

And bring so sensitive yourself yet militant about this poor woman is interesting.

I’d prefer to have a discussion without being insulted. If that’s being sensitive then so be it.

At this point you have admitted that you would be happy for someone who doesn’t need the parking space to park in it at the expense of someone who does. So that’s where you stand on this matter. My view is different. You have insulted me and then lied about it while continuing to insult me. I honestly don’t care what you think of me. You don’t know me.

I’m not going to engage with you any more. As I said before, let’s agree to disagree. Enjoy the rest of your day.

Meraas · 19/08/2022 11:13

allyouneedismarmite · 19/08/2022 10:45

Thought I was going mad when she claimed she hadn’t sworn at me!

Fair enough, thanks for pointing those out.

But I didn’t swear at you.

And bring so sensitive yourself yet militant about this poor woman is interesting.

longtompot · 19/08/2022 11:12

I think just before you told the woman where the blue badge spaces are is where you should have stopped.

The woman was in the wrong by parking in a parent and child space and not getting their child out. The whole point of those spaces is to allow room to get a child out safely.

She then felt she had to justify to parking there as she had a blue badge. Was she displaying the badge? Again, if you are using a badge the owner needs to get out of the car with you.

Until this thread I didn't realise a blue badge holder could park in a parent and child space with their badge, which I was called ignorant for not knowing, and my daughters have both had blue badges for a long time (both in their 20s).

If the child or blue badge owner are not getting out of the car to go into the shop with you, you are meant to park in a normal parking space.

In future I think it would probably be best not to say anything and if you feel someone is taking the piss by parking in a p&c space, just make a note of the number plate and let the store know.

allyouneedismarmite · 19/08/2022 10:45

MalloryMae · 19/08/2022 10:40

@allyouneedismarmite 😂 ouch! Love a screenshot

Thought I was going mad when she claimed she hadn’t sworn at me!

MalloryMae · 19/08/2022 10:40

@allyouneedismarmite 😂 ouch! Love a screenshot

allyouneedismarmite · 19/08/2022 10:36

@Meraas Still going to deny it?!

To have said something?!
To have said something?!
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 19/08/2022 10:33

In this particular instance YABU, as she had a disabled child with her.

I do think it’s out of order when perfectly able bodied adults on their own, or with older children (which I have) park in them. So I never would now mine are bigger.

But in your case YABU

Ski4130 · 19/08/2022 10:33

Briony22 · 18/08/2022 18:21

At the supermarket earlier, and parked in a parent and child space with DH and 10 month old DS.

As I was getting DS out of the car a car pulled into the parent and child space next to us, and a woman got out and started walking towards the supermarket without any kids.

I called after her and said "You know you've parked in a P&C space, yeah?" and she started huffing and puffing that she had her son with her, who was in the car. I pointed out that the spaces are for parents with children who need the extra room to get them out of the car, and then she said that her son was disabled and that she had a disabled badge. I then said that the disabled spaces were in another area of the car park, at which point she started getting her son out of the car and telling him that he had to come into the shop "because that mental lady was kicking off".

I'm just so sick of entitled fuckers using these spaces without any need to when I've often struggled trying to get DS out of his car seat without sufficient space.

DH was mortified and said I should have just left it.

WIBU?

Wha ...? You had a go at someone with a child parking in a parent & child space? A person with a disabled child?! New low right there. Get over yourself.

Meraas · 19/08/2022 10:30

@allyouneedismarmite and yet more exaggeration from you. I have not said the words 'shit' or 'fucking' to you at all, in any context.

If you have to make up swear words to show I have 'name called' then it's clear you have a weak argument.

I do think you have chosen to be obtuse at times and that your comments have been ableist and I stand by that. You are so sensitive for your self, yet have zero sympathy for this woman OP was haranguing. I should be surprised by this but I'm not.

allyouneedismarmite · 19/08/2022 10:03

Meraas · 19/08/2022 09:31

Where have I insulted you? Name one.

And what interpretation would you put on OP telling the woman that the disabled bays are somewhere else?

So according to you I don’t give a shit about disabled people, I’m so fucking superior, I live in cloud cuckoo land, I’m abelist and obtuse. Are you seriously saying none of that is insulting?! We’ve already covered what we think of OPs comments. I’m not going to start repeating myself. Please leave me alone now.

Bubblebubblebah · 19/08/2022 09:46

They should just make them at the back of the carpark which is always empty anyway. Ample space, no competition with the pesky blue badges...

Meraas · 19/08/2022 09:34

RocknRoller1 · 19/08/2022 09:30

@Meraas if the BB holder or child aren't going into the store then the intention of that space isn't being used correctly. Do I really care? No. Would I start a fight about it? Nah... but if that lady took the last BB and child friendly space and was going into the store by herself, then along comes another parent with a disabled child who is going into the store with them/can't be left by themselves for various reasons, then I can see why people might kick up a fuss. Or are you saying you'd be absolutely fine with that?

It wasn’t a BB space.

The woman said her child was disabled.

You can’t see all disabilities.

So yee, I’d be happy with her having that spot.

Meraas · 19/08/2022 09:31

allyouneedismarmite · 19/08/2022 09:28

@Meraas You have insulted me several times. I don’t see that as being calm. You could have easily made your points without name calling. You chose not to.

I agree that you can’t tell someone to move to a disabled bay. I don’t think that’s what happened here.

I’m not dismissing people pointing out disabled rights - I have explicitly acknowledged the importance of those rights. I just don’t think disabled rights are the issue here.

I’m not sure what it is you think I need to learn. If you have anything constructive to add to this discussion and can do it without hurling further insults, please do. If not then I’m not interested.

Where have I insulted you? Name one.

And what interpretation would you put on OP telling the woman that the disabled bays are somewhere else?

RocknRoller1 · 19/08/2022 09:30

@Meraas if the BB holder or child aren't going into the store then the intention of that space isn't being used correctly. Do I really care? No. Would I start a fight about it? Nah... but if that lady took the last BB and child friendly space and was going into the store by herself, then along comes another parent with a disabled child who is going into the store with them/can't be left by themselves for various reasons, then I can see why people might kick up a fuss. Or are you saying you'd be absolutely fine with that?

FarmerRefuted · 19/08/2022 09:29

The bottom line is unless you're employed by the owner of the car park and tasked with policing their car park then its actually none of your business where people are parking and you have no right to harass then over it.

allyouneedismarmite · 19/08/2022 09:28

@Meraas You have insulted me several times. I don’t see that as being calm. You could have easily made your points without name calling. You chose not to.

I agree that you can’t tell someone to move to a disabled bay. I don’t think that’s what happened here.

I’m not dismissing people pointing out disabled rights - I have explicitly acknowledged the importance of those rights. I just don’t think disabled rights are the issue here.

I’m not sure what it is you think I need to learn. If you have anything constructive to add to this discussion and can do it without hurling further insults, please do. If not then I’m not interested.

tallulahhula33 · 19/08/2022 09:27

It's annoying op i get that. I have a small baby and older dc so I've been there when you can't get the car seat out etc.

I don't think it's the fact that you called her out on parking there without a child (as that's clearly how it appeared on first glance). It's more the fact that you continued to berate her after she'd explained her situation. I think most people would just drop it at that not point not keep arguing.

Meraas · 19/08/2022 09:21

I doubt they'd feel the same if all BB and family spaces were full, to realise that a person was going into the store without their child or BB holder and therefore not needing the space as much as them. Or would they seriously be happy having to park in a non BB/child space with a disabled child with the knowledge that a space wasn't truly needed by other customers?

But who are you to judge whether the space was needed? You have no idea what disability that child had.

Meraas · 19/08/2022 09:17

@allyouneedismarmite I’ve been calm and clear with you throughout, your attempts at goadiness don’t faze me I’m afraid.

You still haven’t acknowledged that you can’t tell someone to move to a disabled bay, so you still don’t get it. As I said, dismissing those pointing out disabled rights as being emotional is the epitome of being ableist.

RocknRoller1 · 19/08/2022 09:14

Lots of people have been triggered here due to their own experiences and are projecting based on emotional pov due to the boys disability.

I doubt they'd feel the same if all BB and family spaces were full, to realise that a person was going into the store without their child or BB holder and therefore not needing the space as much as them. Or would they seriously be happy having to park in a non BB/child space with a disabled child with the knowledge that a space wasn't truly needed by other customers?

I don't think I would've said something to the lady in the OP especially as OP managed to get a space but would be interesting to know if lots of posters on here would feel the same if it was them in need of that space.

allyouneedismarmite · 19/08/2022 09:12

@Meraas You and I need to agree to disagree. You have formed a derogatory opinion of me and are ignoring anything I say that doesn’t feed into that. I absolutely agree that the rights of people with disabilities need to be protected. I just don’t think those rights were infringed in this particular instance. It’s very obvious from the language used in many of these posts that people have had an emotional reaction. That’s why you are wasting energy insulting me instead of calmly explaining your views. I’m not sure how you can deny that.

Meraas · 19/08/2022 09:08

But RTFT

Robin233 · 19/08/2022 09:03

But she didn't get out the car
.........

Meraas · 19/08/2022 08:52

allyouneedismarmite · 19/08/2022 07:50

She didn’t need the space. But because disability was mentioned many people have had an emotional response and started shouting about rights for the disabled. An incredibly important issue - but not really relevant here as the disabled boy’s rights were in no way infringed. Several posters have mentioned their own or their relative’s disabilities. It’s obviously an emotive issue. They are projecting their situation onto this and losing sight of what actually happened.

I’ve already listed dome reasons why she may have needed the bay. None of the OP’s cheerleaders seem to want to acknowledge them.

And trying to pass those of us explaining why you can’t tell someone to move to a disabled bay having as an emotional response is so dismissive. You have learnt nothing from this thread, except to dig in to your own sense of superiority.

The facts are:

The woman was perfectly entitled to park there.
The OP had no right to tell her where to park.

You and OP still don’t get it.