Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have said something?!

284 replies

Briony22 · 18/08/2022 18:21

At the supermarket earlier, and parked in a parent and child space with DH and 10 month old DS.

As I was getting DS out of the car a car pulled into the parent and child space next to us, and a woman got out and started walking towards the supermarket without any kids.

I called after her and said "You know you've parked in a P&C space, yeah?" and she started huffing and puffing that she had her son with her, who was in the car. I pointed out that the spaces are for parents with children who need the extra room to get them out of the car, and then she said that her son was disabled and that she had a disabled badge. I then said that the disabled spaces were in another area of the car park, at which point she started getting her son out of the car and telling him that he had to come into the shop "because that mental lady was kicking off".

I'm just so sick of entitled fuckers using these spaces without any need to when I've often struggled trying to get DS out of his car seat without sufficient space.

DH was mortified and said I should have just left it.

WIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Purpleforthewin · 20/08/2022 11:30

allyouneedismarmite · 20/08/2022 11:24

The thread is about the OP’s question but you and I were discussing why the son was removed from the car. Tempted to go for the screenshot again… think I’ll just leave it. 😂

Probably best to leave it as clearly we can't even agree on what we were discussing never mind anything else🤣

allyouneedismarmite · 20/08/2022 11:24

Purpleforthewin · 20/08/2022 10:54

Well that is not accurate. We were discussing a question posed by the OP, my response wasn't about having a dig but this is AIBU so by nature of the question the OP is going to be told that yes she was unreasonable to say something because at the point she approached the woman she had no way of knowing the woman's intentions or situation. Anything that happened after that point doesn't change that.
We don't the woman's exact words as the OP only quoted a few words but even so what someone said when harassed may not be a true reflection of her intentions and still has no bearing on the ops actions.

The thread is about the OP’s question but you and I were discussing why the son was removed from the car. Tempted to go for the screenshot again… think I’ll just leave it. 😂

Purpleforthewin · 20/08/2022 10:54

allyouneedismarmite · 20/08/2022 08:41

@Purpleforthewin We were discussing why the woman removed her son from the car. But by all means, take the opportunity for another dig at the OP.

Well that is not accurate. We were discussing a question posed by the OP, my response wasn't about having a dig but this is AIBU so by nature of the question the OP is going to be told that yes she was unreasonable to say something because at the point she approached the woman she had no way of knowing the woman's intentions or situation. Anything that happened after that point doesn't change that.
We don't the woman's exact words as the OP only quoted a few words but even so what someone said when harassed may not be a true reflection of her intentions and still has no bearing on the ops actions.

WTF475878237NC · 20/08/2022 08:51

Surely everyone knows those spares are for getting kids in and out. Not for people who will leave them in the car anyway.

allyouneedismarmite · 20/08/2022 08:41

@Purpleforthewin We were discussing why the woman removed her son from the car. But by all means, take the opportunity for another dig at the OP.

dribblewibble · 20/08/2022 06:28

turquoise1988 · 19/08/2022 17:06

Just because someone agree with the OP, it doesn't mean that they disrespect disabled rights Hmm.

As several people have pointed out, rights for the disabled, whether these are seen disabilities or not, are important.

I can't say I'd have said anything to the woman in question to be honest. But the OP was still technically correct - the disabled person in the car wasn't actually going to get out of the car, thus not warranting them needing the space. The woman only took her disabled child out after the OP made a point, because she felt embarrassed that someone else had noticed.

That's it really? I don't see how anyone can argue otherwise?

The lady wasn't in a disabled space. She was in a P&C space and therefore the rules for disabled spaces do not apply.

cornishcrusader · 20/08/2022 04:40

To those who referred to me being "cuntish" and "nasty", you've really upset me, and I suggest you think before spouting such vitriol in future - you have no idea what's going on in someone's life.

Are you not being a touch hypocritical here....or do I assume you know exactly what was going on in the life of the lady you wrongly accused?

Purpleforthewin · 19/08/2022 23:15

Well the face value is that the op judged and confronted a stranger in a car park without knowing the full situation.
The woman may have been abusing the spaces or she may not. No one but her knows.

allyouneedismarmite · 19/08/2022 21:27

@Purpleforthewin No I meant the part about taking what OP said at face value…

Purpleforthewin · 19/08/2022 21:02

allyouneedismarmite · 19/08/2022 20:39

I’m going to refer you to the last paragraph of @turquoise1988’s post above.

Exactly none of us know the full story including the op.

LOLOLOLOLOLOLOL · 19/08/2022 21:00

turquoise1988 · 19/08/2022 20:51

@LOLOLOLOLOLOLOL Well, in your opinion she was bang out of order, and I've admitted that I wouldn't have said anything either. But I guess OP felt annoyed about it and felt like she should say something? It likely comes down to a) different personalities and how confident people feel about confrontation and b) the fact that we live in an increasingly entitled society where more people feel like they should speak up and challenge it.

I guess good given the responses on here, she'll realise she's in the wrong and won't do it again?

When she followed up with, you don't know what people are dealing with was unbelievable self centred, because she was worrying about her and not the person she'd taken it upon herself to chastise.

A massive lesson learnt by Op!

turquoise1988 · 19/08/2022 20:51

@LOLOLOLOLOLOLOL Well, in your opinion she was bang out of order, and I've admitted that I wouldn't have said anything either. But I guess OP felt annoyed about it and felt like she should say something? It likely comes down to a) different personalities and how confident people feel about confrontation and b) the fact that we live in an increasingly entitled society where more people feel like they should speak up and challenge it.

Wowwe · 19/08/2022 20:49

I would have fucked you right off. You was let off lightly imo

LOLOLOLOLOLOLOL · 19/08/2022 20:43

turquoise1988 · 19/08/2022 20:00

@Purpleforthewin I don't know, I read this part of the OP which said that the woman the OP confronted was...

"telling him that he had to come into the shop "because that mental lady was kicking off".

I took that to mean that she wasn't going to take him in, but she ended up doing so because the OP spoke to her about those spaces being for people who needed to open doors wide enough.

As I said, I wouldn't have 'policed' the bays in the same way the OP did, but ultimately, what she is saying is right. You shouldn't use those spaces unless you need to open doors wide for access in and out of your vehicle.

People can dress it up with 'maybes' and emotive responses regarding disability, but we can only really take what the OP says at face value, as none of us were actually there at the same time, were we?

But what we do know is that OP was bang out of order playing parking police?

allyouneedismarmite · 19/08/2022 20:39

Purpleforthewin · 19/08/2022 20:28

That doesn't mean anything particularly as we are hearing from the op who is obviously biased and probably paraphrased what they woman said

I’m going to refer you to the last paragraph of @turquoise1988’s post above.

DemelzaandRoss · 19/08/2022 20:32

YABU. Just that. Not a good example for your own children either. To have a go at a person with a disabled child is extremely low.

Purpleforthewin · 19/08/2022 20:28

allyouneedismarmite · 19/08/2022 19:54

She told the child he had to go into the shop because of OP. So we do know.

That doesn't mean anything particularly as we are hearing from the op who is obviously biased and probably paraphrased what they woman said

turquoise1988 · 19/08/2022 20:00

@Purpleforthewin I don't know, I read this part of the OP which said that the woman the OP confronted was...

"telling him that he had to come into the shop "because that mental lady was kicking off".

I took that to mean that she wasn't going to take him in, but she ended up doing so because the OP spoke to her about those spaces being for people who needed to open doors wide enough.

As I said, I wouldn't have 'policed' the bays in the same way the OP did, but ultimately, what she is saying is right. You shouldn't use those spaces unless you need to open doors wide for access in and out of your vehicle.

People can dress it up with 'maybes' and emotive responses regarding disability, but we can only really take what the OP says at face value, as none of us were actually there at the same time, were we?

allyouneedismarmite · 19/08/2022 19:54

Purpleforthewin · 19/08/2022 19:38

"The woman only took her disabled child out after the OP made a point, because she felt embarrassed that someone else had noticed.

That's it really? I don't see how anyone can argue otherwise?"

We don't actually know this though. The OP saw that woman walk away from the car with the child inside but she didn't wait to find out what would have happened next. I would leave my child in the car while getting a trolley as that can be easier but if harassed by someone I might be more inclined to carry her over to get away from that person quicker.

She told the child he had to go into the shop because of OP. So we do know.

allyouneedismarmite · 19/08/2022 19:53

FarmerRefuted · 19/08/2022 19:27

Disabled doesn't equal helpless, disabled children can be left alone (needs depending, obviously).

I wondered about this too. But because he was a child, not because he was disabled. I’m assuming he was older and we’re not talking about a toddler.

Purpleforthewin · 19/08/2022 19:38

"The woman only took her disabled child out after the OP made a point, because she felt embarrassed that someone else had noticed.

That's it really? I don't see how anyone can argue otherwise?"

We don't actually know this though. The OP saw that woman walk away from the car with the child inside but she didn't wait to find out what would have happened next. I would leave my child in the car while getting a trolley as that can be easier but if harassed by someone I might be more inclined to carry her over to get away from that person quicker.

FarmerRefuted · 19/08/2022 19:27

anglesee · 19/08/2022 17:25

She left her disabled kid in the car alone?

Disabled doesn't equal helpless, disabled children can be left alone (needs depending, obviously).

LOLOLOLOLOLOLOL · 19/08/2022 17:25

turquoise1988 · 19/08/2022 17:06

Just because someone agree with the OP, it doesn't mean that they disrespect disabled rights Hmm.

As several people have pointed out, rights for the disabled, whether these are seen disabilities or not, are important.

I can't say I'd have said anything to the woman in question to be honest. But the OP was still technically correct - the disabled person in the car wasn't actually going to get out of the car, thus not warranting them needing the space. The woman only took her disabled child out after the OP made a point, because she felt embarrassed that someone else had noticed.

That's it really? I don't see how anyone can argue otherwise?

it still remains the OP isn't employed to police the parking at her local supermarket!

I think that's it really?

anglesee · 19/08/2022 17:25

She left her disabled kid in the car alone?

turquoise1988 · 19/08/2022 17:06

Just because someone agree with the OP, it doesn't mean that they disrespect disabled rights Hmm.

As several people have pointed out, rights for the disabled, whether these are seen disabilities or not, are important.

I can't say I'd have said anything to the woman in question to be honest. But the OP was still technically correct - the disabled person in the car wasn't actually going to get out of the car, thus not warranting them needing the space. The woman only took her disabled child out after the OP made a point, because she felt embarrassed that someone else had noticed.

That's it really? I don't see how anyone can argue otherwise?