Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU Only the parents should change nappies?

535 replies

Mum070322 · 18/08/2022 03:11

I’m very keen on consent and protecting my baby’s privacy and prefer that only myself and my partner are the ones to change DS nappy ( 6 months )

Obviously I understand if we’re not available due to nursery eventually or if someone else is babysitting then I’m happy for someone else to do it however this has not yet been the case.

a while ago my MIL was over and my baby started crying and rather than just give him back decided to take it upon herself to change him (I was standing right there) he continued crying throughout the change and she gave him back straight after but it annoyed me as it wasn’t her place to change him.

I didn’t say anything at the time DS was 4 months and I was trying to be nice and friendly but starting to find her more overbearing and I’m getting close to drawing a line.

OP posts:
FilthyforFirth · 28/03/2023 19:40

@MrsJamesofSutton I cannot tell if you are being serious or not? You believe yohr newborn needed consent to cut the umbilical cord??? Please tell me you are winding people up?!

If not, I hope you got consent for:

  • how you are feeding him
  • what clothes you dress him in
  • what carseat/pram he is in
  • where he goes on any given day
  • whether he wanted his immunisations/5 day blood test

If not, why not?!

VickyEadieofThigh · 28/03/2023 19:36

Pottedpalm · 28/03/2023 19:30

Barking.

Absolutely insane.

Pottedpalm · 28/03/2023 19:30

MrsJamesofSutton · 28/03/2023 19:15

@Mum070322

Ignore the snippy comments about how your baby gives consent for cuddles.

Your baby may not have language but he can communicate his wishes, either by crying if he is unhappy or smiling/holding out his arms to those to whom he does give consent/

I would hold my baby, so that he could fully see the person who was requesting a cuddle. I would then ask the person-adult or child-to hold out their arms-very softly, very slowly, very gently-towards my baby.

Baby would always react-sometimes by leaning towards the asker and/or smiling. This meant baby was happy to be held-baby had given consent using his own method of communication.

Baby would sometimes yell, sometimes violently lurching back-this was clearly not giving consent.

It's not difficult to understand.

I would employ the same method with nappy changes and, like you, I would always communicate with baby by describing what I was going to do at each stage and showing each item clearly. Ig baby cried, we would wait. He would not sit in shit, as some fools have said because he would cry, therefore letting me know that he required his nappy changing

I believe that in the future, it will be standard to ask for baby's consent and it should start at the beginning. In my birth plan, I asked that the midwife ask baby and me if the cord could be cut.

Obviously, it had to be cut-before people imaging that I thought that might not be the case- but it was a significant moment-baby and I agreed that it had to be cut My husband also said, "I consent" and it was a bonding moment for all of us.

Stick to your guns OP/

Barking.

RegardingMary · 28/03/2023 19:24

I wouldn't say it's inappropriate at all.

The issue you've got with it all is that you're expecting MiL to mind read. in reality she's trying to be hands on and helpful, it may not be your DMs way to do things, but most GPs would be happy to change nappies even with parents around.

Instead of expecting her to know how you want her to act, show/tell her. "I always let baby know what I'm doing as I do it." Or "He likes to be sung to or to play with this toy while he's being changed."

It sounds like she wants to be hands on, let her.

MrsJamesofSutton · 28/03/2023 19:22

I've just seen that this is an old thread. For fuck's sake-who resurrects these things!

MrsJamesofSutton · 28/03/2023 19:15

@Mum070322

Ignore the snippy comments about how your baby gives consent for cuddles.

Your baby may not have language but he can communicate his wishes, either by crying if he is unhappy or smiling/holding out his arms to those to whom he does give consent/

I would hold my baby, so that he could fully see the person who was requesting a cuddle. I would then ask the person-adult or child-to hold out their arms-very softly, very slowly, very gently-towards my baby.

Baby would always react-sometimes by leaning towards the asker and/or smiling. This meant baby was happy to be held-baby had given consent using his own method of communication.

Baby would sometimes yell, sometimes violently lurching back-this was clearly not giving consent.

It's not difficult to understand.

I would employ the same method with nappy changes and, like you, I would always communicate with baby by describing what I was going to do at each stage and showing each item clearly. Ig baby cried, we would wait. He would not sit in shit, as some fools have said because he would cry, therefore letting me know that he required his nappy changing

I believe that in the future, it will be standard to ask for baby's consent and it should start at the beginning. In my birth plan, I asked that the midwife ask baby and me if the cord could be cut.

Obviously, it had to be cut-before people imaging that I thought that might not be the case- but it was a significant moment-baby and I agreed that it had to be cut My husband also said, "I consent" and it was a bonding moment for all of us.

Stick to your guns OP/

slowquickstep · 28/03/2023 18:19

I wonder if the OP still has the same outlook

1offnamechange · 28/03/2023 17:47

Mum070322 · 18/08/2022 10:09

I think just to clarify I put this thread up just to gauge opinion I never had ago at MIL and I do think she’s a safe person I just think it’s inappropriate to take it upon yourself to change a baby

hense the reason I posted to genuinely see if it’s just me being a tiny bit ott.

as someone pointed out she just has a different way of doing things than my own DM which isn’t necessarily wrong

i wasn’t upset by her changing my baby if I had a big issue with it or with something im definitely not afraid to say so nor do I have an issue with her occasionally she can be annoying but so can my own DM

I never said she crossed a line with changing a nappy just that I was considering drawing a line.

half the people on here are yelling because I apparently hate her, because I like my baby to be happy during changes and talk to him and the rest because I prefer my baby to want to go to someone before I let them hold him

What? Nobody is "yelling" either opinion.
Just pointing out your rationale doesn't make sense.
If you accept that at some point your baby will have to be changed by someone other than you/DH and are okay with that - bearing in mind that they are unlikely to do the special cuddles or try and get 'consent' from the baby or whatever you do, then you should accept that it's fine for someone you know and trust to change the baby while you're there. Otherwise you're being completely hypocritical as by any measure option 1 is 'worse' in terms of potential danger, distress to baby, lack of "consent" (not saying any of these are likely at all) than option 2.

If anything it will be less upsetting now for you to wean the baby into the idea of being changed by granny, in his own home, while mum right there, than going from ONLY EVER being changed by you doing special cuddles beforehand straight to being changed by a complete stranger in a nursery with several other kids around.

Cazareeto1 · 28/03/2023 17:47

Carriecakes80 · 20/08/2022 03:58

I would say this is New Mum territory, and you need to step back and give yourself a shake! :-)
Babies cannot give consent, nor will any Nursery be asking for it from your babe, they have things to do, so your baby will cry, they'll see he is dirty, and they will change him, bish bash bosh, its not a biggie, you need to chill a little bit and start enjoying your baby, because these early days whizz by...stop obsessing over who cleans him, and be grateful of the love and help you obviously are getting that will help your lad grow up to feel loved and secure!

Mum of six here and believe me, baby does not give a crap who changes him/her, as long as they have a clean bum and a cuddle at the end of it! You go on like this though and your kid will pick up on your fears of anyone else forming a bond with them, and they will be so highly strung...and who needs that eh???

This right here!! ❤️ should listen, get someone to look after your bundle of joy for a few hours go and have lunch dinner, clear your head, and think pre baby would you have thought this? Is it really necessary at this stage, what happens when babe at nursery, they have not got time to ask each baby/child if they consent to being changed… especially if they can’t actually talk yet… be realistic, think of the bigger picture, and think how can a baby give consent to being changed when really they only cry for a few reasons, hunger, needs changed, needs winded, uncomfortable ie being uncomfortable with clothing, want huged or a medical problem which will be clear from their cry and amount they cry like colic, baby will cry a lot when lying down, uncontrollable non stop, need dr and meds for reflux and more winding and breaks during feeding. As mums with experience, looking at bigger picture and long run is always best as well as living in the moment. Relax and enjoy your baby and let your baby enjoy the love from the people who will always be there and always love them unconditionally, family matters. There is a great saying it takes a village to raise a child. Family is that village and your child will be emotionally stable with the love from family. Carry on the way you are, family will not want to see your family, or feel comfortable around you or your child for fear of not being able to express love to you both.

AllTheDifference · 28/03/2023 17:34

Your baby lacks capacity to consent to anything. So you have to act in their best interest.

Do what you need to do to fulfil your rigid parenting philosophy. But be careful. Parents like you can alienate loving family
members, and only realise it when it is too late. The grandparent-child bond suffers when too many rules are laid down. I have seen it happen.

PugInTheHouse · 28/03/2023 17:31

Cazareeto1 · 28/03/2023 17:24

Mum of 3 here, yes you are being very silly in this when it comes to a baby, most mums would actually be quite happy to not have to change a shtiy nappie once in a while… this isn’t being overbearing or not respectful to your wishes, this is another mum who just so happened to bring up your husband helping YOU by changing your child. No baby likes to be changed and will cry during this as it’s cold and especially if cleaning poo repetitive.. that is normal! Stoping to calm your child half way through changing is setting your self up for a huge fail when your child is mobile and took a crap! You will end up with poo everywhere, let’s be real here… get a grip and relise you are not the first person to have a child, your child is like every other child when comes to nappy changing… get over yourself! Tbh. Accept the real help like changing or baby sitting you will regret your decision when you hit terrible 2s and the even worse 3/4 year old stage when they have attitude! Yes teaching personal space and boundaries is a good thing but remember these people you are putting these rules on will at some point baby sit and really do you want the kid who won’t let them change him, so comes home sore from sitting in poo, or disrespectful to people baby sitting because he feels they are not respecting his boundaries when that may be something small like being told no… think carefully about the bigger picture baby stage only really lasts a year, don’t shoot yourself in the foot. Best advice I can give is reassessment on what you are doing, and not acting batsiht crazy….

This thread is 7 months old 🤷‍♀️

Cazareeto1 · 28/03/2023 17:24

Mum070322 · 18/08/2022 03:11

I’m very keen on consent and protecting my baby’s privacy and prefer that only myself and my partner are the ones to change DS nappy ( 6 months )

Obviously I understand if we’re not available due to nursery eventually or if someone else is babysitting then I’m happy for someone else to do it however this has not yet been the case.

a while ago my MIL was over and my baby started crying and rather than just give him back decided to take it upon herself to change him (I was standing right there) he continued crying throughout the change and she gave him back straight after but it annoyed me as it wasn’t her place to change him.

I didn’t say anything at the time DS was 4 months and I was trying to be nice and friendly but starting to find her more overbearing and I’m getting close to drawing a line.

Mum of 3 here, yes you are being very silly in this when it comes to a baby, most mums would actually be quite happy to not have to change a shtiy nappie once in a while… this isn’t being overbearing or not respectful to your wishes, this is another mum who just so happened to bring up your husband helping YOU by changing your child. No baby likes to be changed and will cry during this as it’s cold and especially if cleaning poo repetitive.. that is normal! Stoping to calm your child half way through changing is setting your self up for a huge fail when your child is mobile and took a crap! You will end up with poo everywhere, let’s be real here… get a grip and relise you are not the first person to have a child, your child is like every other child when comes to nappy changing… get over yourself! Tbh. Accept the real help like changing or baby sitting you will regret your decision when you hit terrible 2s and the even worse 3/4 year old stage when they have attitude! Yes teaching personal space and boundaries is a good thing but remember these people you are putting these rules on will at some point baby sit and really do you want the kid who won’t let them change him, so comes home sore from sitting in poo, or disrespectful to people baby sitting because he feels they are not respecting his boundaries when that may be something small like being told no… think carefully about the bigger picture baby stage only really lasts a year, don’t shoot yourself in the foot. Best advice I can give is reassessment on what you are doing, and not acting batsiht crazy….

helogast · 24/08/2022 07:00

Well said @OftenFierce

DaveGrohlsMrs · 23/08/2022 15:49

Are you my brother’s girlfriend?!😂

oggie679 · 23/08/2022 11:09

HoppingPavlova · 23/08/2022 09:32

The thing you should have done however was to step in and not let her do it. You could have politely said, 'thank you, but I would prefer to change him' and that should have been that.
You should put your boundaries in on things like this and explain what they are at an appropriate time. If anyone doesn't respect those boundaries then it's their problem not yours but you need to communicate them clearly.

Problem with this is it may work initially when OP is in holier than thou mode with PFB but after she ‘put her boundaries in’ and then has a baby sitting in shit screaming and toddler toilet training who needs the potty NOW, suddenly (and conveniently) those boundaries disappear pretty bloody quickly and OP will be back on here complaining MIL doesn’t help and just sat there watching. This is because MIL had been put firmly in her place previously. Everyone will then jump in and tell her to tell MIL off for being lazy/unhelpful and to go NC. Yeah. Yeah.

This! 👍🏻

HoppingPavlova · 23/08/2022 09:32

The thing you should have done however was to step in and not let her do it. You could have politely said, 'thank you, but I would prefer to change him' and that should have been that.
You should put your boundaries in on things like this and explain what they are at an appropriate time. If anyone doesn't respect those boundaries then it's their problem not yours but you need to communicate them clearly.

Problem with this is it may work initially when OP is in holier than thou mode with PFB but after she ‘put her boundaries in’ and then has a baby sitting in shit screaming and toddler toilet training who needs the potty NOW, suddenly (and conveniently) those boundaries disappear pretty bloody quickly and OP will be back on here complaining MIL doesn’t help and just sat there watching. This is because MIL had been put firmly in her place previously. Everyone will then jump in and tell her to tell MIL off for being lazy/unhelpful and to go NC. Yeah. Yeah.

sue20 · 22/08/2022 17:00

helogast · 18/08/2022 04:42

Your MIL should not have assumed that it was ok to change your baby's nappy. She should have said something along the lines of 'is it ok to go ahead and change him' or 'would you like me to change him for you' particularly the first time.

As you have said, this isn't anything to do with you trusting her, it is your preference which you are completely entitled to. Some mums are more sensitive about these type of things than others and you know what, that is completely ok! You feel how you feel and you shouldn't need the validation of others. The thing you should have done however was to step in and not let her do it. You could have politely said, 'thank you, but I would prefer to change him' and that should have been that.

You should put your boundaries in on things like this and explain what they are at an appropriate time. If anyone doesn't respect those boundaries then it's their problem not yours but you need to communicate them clearly. This is key to a healthy relationship with her going forwards otherwise resentment will build if you are sitting there watching her doing things you would prefer to be doing.

THIS!! All the people on here not getting the issue, which is a very common one. Between new mother and significant close family and how baby's care is negotiated.

bootsyjam · 22/08/2022 14:16

I'm not sure this actually happened. This story is on the DM website and it wouldn't surprise me that it has been written specifically to cause controversy and to get a story out of it. And a story it is....

sue20 · 21/08/2022 10:19

Jellycatspyjamas · 18/08/2022 03:32

So nursery workers or babysitters can change your child but their grandparent can’t? I suspect this is more about your feelings towards your MIL than anything to do with privacy and consent (consent being a ridiculous concept for a small baby who has no capacity to give informed consent at that age).

This is to do with your relationship with MIL. The feeling that she is becoming overbearing. I think the fact she didn’t say anything and went ahead with you standing there is inappropriate. She is assuming a mothers role in this action and also could tip into “this is how you do it” . I would push back a bit. It’s common. No babies shouldn’t need consent that would only be if they were in an endangered position.

Hagpie · 21/08/2022 08:12

You and I both consent parent and I still think you are being very unreasonable. It comes across as nitpicking at your poor MIL than anything else tbh and like you’re trying to cover up your dislike for her by saying what she did goes against our parenting style when no it bloody doesn’t. If you want her to say “I’m going to change your nappy now, alright?” to the baby then TELL HER but the actual act of grandparents changing a baby’s nappy fgs is totally normal. Maybe your mum doesn’t because she knows how you are? (Aka will get the hump over nothing)

Solonge · 20/08/2022 16:50

You needed to move in the circles of la Leche league….all about life and freedoms based on breastfeeding.

Fluffmum · 20/08/2022 15:39

You need to chill. Or you are going to make yourself ill.

OftenFierce · 20/08/2022 14:16

And cue the insults and insensitive comments. Seriously, what is wrong with people on this forum! If all you can say is "I hope my son doesn't marry someone like you" why don't you just shut up? But you love getting your thrill from anonymously insulting posters online. Gross. This forum could be a safe space but people who behave like this won't allow it. Thank goodness there are some very sensible forum users who provide great advice and take the time to explain their reasoning.

OP, I don't think you're being unreasonable. She should have asked first. You have every right to want to be the one in charge of changing nappies, feeding, and everything else concerning your baby. Please disregard the nasty comments.

You're probably feeling ashamed of those protective feelings but at the same time angry that she took the liberty to change the nappy without asking first. The good news is that you don't even need to explain WHY you feel the way you do, you're entitled to being protective of your baby. This has nothing to do with the quality of the baby-grandmother relationship like others have suggested.

Someone said she probably didn't ask because she sensed that you would turn down her offer, so she just dived right into it. If that's the case, that's some overbearing behaviour right there. Perhaps you need to think about healthy boundaries.

That said, I would not sweat it or bring it up with her just now, she won't understand. In the future, I would simply speak up and say "thank so much, but I'll do it" with a smile on your face. There, drama averted. If that creates drama (which is unlikely), then it's time for a conversation about boundaries. And please also remember that grandparents sometimes are SO eager to be helpful that it can be annoying for new parents, even if it comes from a good place.

Also, I just want to gently remind you that it's a really tiny tiny thing in the big scheme of things, so it's probably best to forget it and move on. 💐

Chickychoccyegg · 20/08/2022 13:44

lunar1 · 18/08/2022 10:25

I feel the same.

It trivialises the very nature of consent and makes it some kind of joke. You cannot have consent without informed consent, understanding what is being asked of you. Understanding the ramifications of a decision either way.

A baby does not have the capacity to give consent.

There were times when my babies didn't want to go to DH as they were both breastfed. That doesn't mean I didn't still hand them over for the sake of my sanity and their development.

I feel incredibly sorry for teachers, having to cope with intakes of children who have been raised to think they can withhold consent for activities.

You can still tell your baby what's happening without a ridiculous performance surrounding every activity.

I agree with all of this

Solonge · 20/08/2022 13:40

Now you appear cross with the answers you received. Your stance is very unusual. I would suggest very few mums feel the way you do. May be the way you were brought up. Big families tend to all muck in together and just do what needs doing. Maybe you were an only child with a nervous mum. We are how we were brought up.

Swipe left for the next trending thread