Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My husband wants to start sending our 15 year old son, to stay with his mum on a Friday night.

136 replies

Anonymous170822 · 17/08/2022 23:15

Hello all, I need a sounding board and that, would normally be my husband, however, this involves him and his mum.

My husband and I, have been married for 19 years and we share 3 children together they are 18,15 and almost 3 years old.

My husband, wants us to send our middle child, over to his mother's house, on Friday evening like we used to do. Before our 18 year old moved out of our family home, (in October 2019).

Our 18 year old, has totally rebelled, and my husband's mum, took our son's side, things got really ugly so much so, that my mother in law, said to my husband, to treat her, as if she was dead, (that was in February this year), by the way my husband is my mother in law's, only child.

The thing is, there has been more downs, than ups, when it comes to my mother in law. She doesn't realise boundaries and thinks it's fine to be interfering in my marriage to her son.

It all started 18 years ago, when I was pregnant with my first child, I walked into, my mother in law's house, she and my husband were having a conversation regarding what religion our child, was going to be baptized and she said, that, if our child was going to be baptized a different religion than to what, my husband's family was, then my mother in law, wanted nothing to do with our child. She was, going to be God mother however, after that conversation, I said no.

The truth is my mother in law, lives on her own and is always emotionally guilt tripping my husband, regarding her loneliness and that nobody cares about her, but that is not true. Over the years, I've worked very hard to forgive and forget and to reach out and include her in our family and inviting her to our, family events such as birthdays, Christmases, Easters, school plays, family days, out her answer would always be sure you wouldn't want me there. We also invited and made her part of our last two children baptisms, were she was asked by my husband and I to be God mother to our last two children. I've put my feelings to one side, and to bite my tongue, on more than one occasion, for my husband's sake. But his mum still insists that she doesn't feel welcome in our home and she doesn't participate or involve herself as grandmother role with our 3rd child.

Things over the years were amicable, to begin with, for example she gave us furniture and kitchen appliances, for our first home and for our third home, she gave us some money to which I acknowledge and very appreciated of, but wouldn't any parent do the same, to help their child and their child's family if they could. But because of this, my husband, thinks that we should forget, all about the water that have gone, under the bridge.

You see, it's not as simple, as that, it has came out, in the wash, that over the years, my mother in law has been speaking badly about my husband and I, this happened before our eldest child moved out of home, (both children were going over to their Nanny's home on a regular basis, on a Friday evening).

Our middle child informed my husband and I, that his mother had been casting up old arguments and making belittling comments, about us, each time that the children went over. I mentioned this to my husband and he said, sure that's mum she's always been like that. I said, to him that your mum, isn't taken any responsibility, for contributing to the downfall, of our family unit, I said, she thinks that she hasn't done anything wrong. And my husband agreed. And said, she doesn't take responsibility for anything, that she's done wrong because in her eyes she hasn't.

However, last night my husband, took his mother, to see a consultant privately, regarding her health and because of what the consultant said, they are making out, as if she's on deaths door, even though no tests were done.

My mother in law, can be nice but when she's bad, she's one of the worst, and my husband would also have taken my mother in law's side, until lately, when he saw, what way his mother was yet again, interfering with us and our eldest child, (who she thinks is the golden child), rather than taken her own son's side.

And now because of this latest news, about her health and the fact that our eldest child, moved out of her home in March of this year, who has very little to do, with her now. My husband wants to ease his conscience, by sending our middle child over, even though she refused to go to our child's 15th birthday in late July to which she was invited to.

So, am I being unreasonable here, by preventing our child from going over?

OP posts:
Anonymous170822 · 18/08/2022 08:58

unkownone · 18/08/2022 02:03

My MIL Is a bit similar ...but thankfully her and FIL just moved a long long way so it solved our issues. I ended up letting mine stay over on the rare occasion. I had to pull right back after MIL kept telling my 16year old she can leave school if she wanted to. She also would make up stuff about DH silly things to try and paint him in a bad way..and she just hated me for what ever reason. When the kids were older and would tell me because they were older we were able to explain the MIL said a lot of rubbish and to ignore most of it. But if she was the one that talked your eldest into moving in with her..then no way.

Thank you
Your absolutely right

OP posts:
BeenHereAWhileNow · 18/08/2022 08:58

If she’s at ‘deaths door’ does your dh really want to risk your 15 year old being the person to find her dead one morning?

Hangingoninthere88 · 18/08/2022 08:57

Allost all 15YO's are emotionally mature enough to make an autonomous decision about such a thing. If your child isn't then maybe you should work on it. If they are then this whole issue is a moot point as forcing a practical adult to do anything will only lead to them resenting you. What does your 15YO actually want?

Sooverthisnow · 18/08/2022 08:52

Generally you don’t “send” a 15 year old anywhere. What would he like to do?

MyLifeIsFictional · 18/08/2022 08:49

your MIL is your children's Godmother? That's weird to start with. You should have set boundaries a long time ago.

It's up to your 15yo if he wants to go to Grandma's (clue: most 15yo's would rather shit in their hands and then clap than go to their Grandma's when they could be out with their mates)

Strikes me that you and your husband were both brought up to be obedient and neither of you know what a healthy relationship should be.

ShepherdMoons · 18/08/2022 08:47

It sounds weird, at the age of 15 your son should have some say over where he goes.

ParsleyPesto · 18/08/2022 08:40

Well if she is at death’s door then clearly she cannot be responsible for anyone else 🤷‍♀️

butterpuffed · 18/08/2022 08:17

Your eldest son lived with your MIL for a few months and your middle son wants to see her once a week so they obviously both like her .

MarshaMelrose · 18/08/2022 08:13

So he's "sacrificing" his son to appease his mum?

How is his son being sacrificed?
His son used to go every week and enjoyed himself. He's now wanting to go again.

diddl · 18/08/2022 08:11

He can only handle her in small doses

Yet he thinks a child should stay over alone?

So he's "sacrificing" his son to appease his mum?

What a shit father he is.

Although it seems that things would be tricky when you were pregnant with your first.

She's the Godmother to 2 of your kids yet you don't really get on with her?

How fucked up is that?

WeAreBob · 18/08/2022 08:11

DaughterofDawn · 18/08/2022 01:33

Why is there always one comment questioning their english skills? Her grammar and spelling was fine. Is it just that you don’t like OP so you’re trying to passive aggressively patronize her? Because that’s certainly how it is coming off. You do realize that the UK is not the only english speaking country right?

Her grammar was absolutely not fine. She chucks a comma in every few words for some bizarre reason. It is understandable but it is also total nonsense.

There was no need for someone to comment on it because you can just about get what she is saying however it is very, very wrong to say that her writing is correct. Because then she will think she is using commas correctly when she used almost all of them in places they do not belong and it makes the reading a challenge. I'm dyslexic and that was a challenge to read.

Zoeslatesttrope · 18/08/2022 07:54

Your son wants to go so let him. It's his grandmother.

worriedatthistime · 18/08/2022 07:50

@olympicsrock well you didn't understand as OP said she didn't cause him to move out
Plus we very much only have one side if this hefe

worriedatthistime · 18/08/2022 07:49

So if you stop the 15 year olf going , what will you do when their 16/17 when you can't stop them
Surely you can have a honest conversation with your 15 year old and explain your reservations

1DoesNotSimplyWalkIntoMordor · 18/08/2022 07:48

Wish people would stop with the nasty comments about the use of punctuation marks, if a poster is from another country then different rules about punctuation can apply, for example a comma followed by and or but is perfectly acceptable in one Eastern European country but not in the UK. I often proof read things written by colleagues from other European countries and see the same mistakes. Of course there could be other factors involved as well.

worriedatthistime · 18/08/2022 07:44

Surely its the 15 year olds choice
Plus you have taken gifts and money ,you never insisted your dh sent them back or addressed it at the time with your dh so he is part of this problem its not all on your mil

riserved · 18/08/2022 07:43

I understood the OP perfectly....or so I thought. Then I read the OP's later posts and everything changed.Confused

jammiewhammie65 · 18/08/2022 07:42

So your husband wants to send a 15!year old to look after his mum because she's on her own. Tell him to do it himself. That's the most ridiculous thing I ever heard. You do know you don't have to do what he says right ? Your child your decision this is England 2022

Blondebakingmumma · 18/08/2022 07:34

If my own parents or my husband’s parents spoke poorly to one or both of our children about us ONCE, we would be low contact with no unsupervised time. No way would I put up with that toxic crap

MarshaMelrose · 18/08/2022 07:27

The MIL is toxic , she caused a family breakup during Covid when the old child who was 16 to move in with her.

I'm not sure you're right about that. The op said....

I never said that she was instrumental on regards to my 18 year old moving out, she basically informed the child that once he turns 18 he doesn't have to live here.

kateandme · 18/08/2022 07:24

No sometimes it is up to the 15 year old.
As a parent you sometimes have to say no to protect them from harm.

MarshaMelrose · 18/08/2022 07:23

onlythreenow · 18/08/2022 06:56

What does your son want to do? Surely his opinion is the one which is most important.

He wants to go.

Aiionwatha · 18/08/2022 07:05

You are being unreasonable in your use of commas.

olympicsrock · 18/08/2022 06:57

This thread is a bit wierd. I understood the OP perfectly. The MIL is toxic , she caused a family breakup during Covid when the old child who was 16 to move in with her.
OP you have a DH problem where your husband puts his mothers wishes over your own.
Let the middle child go over there occasionally but have a word first to warn them that DGM has caused a lot of trouble and does not always tell the truth.
Stop including the old witch in your family plans.

onlythreenow · 18/08/2022 06:56

What does your son want to do? Surely his opinion is the one which is most important.