Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why people adopt feral dogs from Eastern Europe?

240 replies

Elmore · 17/08/2022 22:59

I don’t get it, there’s thousands of dogs in the U.K. that need homes, so why go to the effort (and expense) of importing these wild street dogs?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Bernadinetta · 18/08/2022 06:46

bloodyplanes · 17/08/2022 23:41

Trying to adopt a dog in the uk is harder than adopting a child!!!

What the fuck? Have you adopted a child?

shandon14 · 18/08/2022 06:40

Another person here who would never have got approval from a UK rehoming charity (live in a flat) and who didn't want to support a puppy farm. We have given a wonderful dog a chance to live. Not any hint of aggression and after a settling in period she is gaining her confidence and is a true member of our family.

It's all about the charity you adopt from, ours was excellent- very little risk of importing diseases etc as vet care and risk management were excellent.

Bosky · 18/08/2022 06:16

I adopted an older dog in 2009, having found her via The Oldies Club which aggregates info from shelters and rehoming organisations across the UK:
www.oldies.org.uk/

I adopted another older dog in 2019, having found her via DogsBlog, which also aggregates info from shelters and rehoming organisations across the UK:
www.dogsblog.com/

Both sites allow you to filter information according to numerous specifications like "Good with kids" (Oldies), "Not Cat Tested" (DogsBlog) - there are loads of these sorts of criteria on both sites.

This might get over some of the problems reported by PP, of organisations deciding whether or not you are suitable as adopters: you choose the criteria that match what you have to offer and then you only get to see a list of dogs that are a good match.

I also looked at other sites that advertised dogs for rehoming but I found those ones the most useful starting points because of the ability to filter by specific criteria.

My main reason for posting though is that I noticed a huge change in the dogs available across the UK between 2009 and 2019.

In 2009 it was very rare to see mention of a dog who had been born abroad.

In 2019 there were masses of dogs for rehoming had been imported or were still abroad and were looking for people to fund their care abroad, importation and rehoming in the UK.

Those that had already been imported were a mix of "new imports" and dogs that had been handed in to shelters, or abandoned, by the people who had originally adopted them from abroad.

This is an interesting article:

Rescuing dogs from abroad – does it make sense?

It concludes:

"SO, does it make sense to import rescue dogs from foreign fields or streets? Probably not.

Do these dogs impede domestic unwanted from finding new homes? Probably not.

Are the oft stated risks and problems caused by these dogs over-emphasized? Probably yes.

It is undoubtedly a messy situation which causes considerable angst amongst various animal charities and the veterinary profession, but I’m sure you will get no argument from those individuals who have been saved from the wretched conditions they have been kept in certain countries and given the chance of a life worth living."

animalrightsandwrongs.uk/2018/09/rescuing-dogs-from-abroad/

If people are uncertain about adopting an imported dog (rather than being for or against) perhaps they could consider dogs who were imported but have since been returned to a rehoming organisation?

The good news is that Oldies Club has abandoned its "Overlooked Oldies" list because it is not needed at the moment:
www.oldies.org.uk/2020/we-arent-using-the-overlooked-page-at-the-moment

There are plenty of other dogs listed there though, including dogs who have been imported:
www.oldies.org.uk/category/adopt-an-oldie

There are also plenty of older dogs on DogsBlog, including dogs who have been imported:
www.dogsblog.com/category/age/6-years/

Flippety · 18/08/2022 05:55

Elmore · 17/08/2022 23:47

One thing I do know is that people that have foreign rescue dogs are like vegans - they just have to let everybody know about it

You don’t do yourself any favours with this comment and it gives us more insight in to your lack of tolerance for anything/anyone that may not fit your way of life, any ‘foreign’ perspectives

Shortjanet · 18/08/2022 05:42

I totally understand the reasons people rescue from overseas. Difficulty getting a UK rescue and seeing the sad plight of street dogs etc. That said I do think it would be great if more could be done to improve the welfare of the dogs without importing them. If the money spent on transport, import paperwork etc were redirected into neutering, welfare schemes and education I suspect many more dogs could be helped.

As has been commented above though my main concern is of the diseases we are importing. Regulations and vaccination offer protection from a small number including rabies, but detecting diseases like brucella canis, leishmania, heartworm rely on additional, non mandatory testing. Some are zoonotic so pose a risk to people as well as other dogs and whilst vectors for some diseases have not previously been present in the UK this may not remain the case. The potential for huge animal suffering in this country from imported disease worries me enormously.

SugarHorse · 18/08/2022 04:21

Elmore · 17/08/2022 23:05

The ones I’ve encountered have always been very aggressive and had owners that seemed a bit clueless, so I guess it’s a safety issue? I just wanna know why people feel the need? I get the feeling the dogs would be happier on the streets

If you genuinely feel that the dogs would be happier on the streets, then you have no clue about what life is like for stray dogs in Eastern Europe. You really need to do some research into it and then you might manage to not ask such a stupid question.

carefullycourageous · 18/08/2022 04:20

All the overseas rescues I have met and known have been wonderful Plenty of dogs both bred here and imported have issues and we are seeing increasing problems with dogs in this country - we need to be a bit less fairytale about dogs.

DangerouslyBored · 18/08/2022 04:18

I just want to say a huge thank you to those who have gone to the effort and hard work of adopting a dog from overseas ❤️ Their suffering is unimaginable. I hope this shitty thread doesn’t put off others from doing something so wonderful as helping a dog in desperate need.

All the overseas rescues I have met and known have been wonderful and so, so grateful to finally know love and compassion 🥲

DangerouslyBored · 18/08/2022 04:14

Phrenologistsfinger · 18/08/2022 01:40

Well I’m vegan and I have a Romanian rescue and I wouldn’t brought it up if you hadn’t posted such an ignorant and provocative OP.

Absolutely. What a shitty thread to start. Hope you and your beautiful overseas rescue are very happy together ❤️

Vikinga · 18/08/2022 04:06

I haven't tried to adopt a dog but support dog rescues and everytime I've checked the criteria, I wouldn't have been able to adopt any. I have a dog and kids. However, I would make a great owner as my kids are great with dogs, I wfh and love close to woods. My dog is my constant companion and when my boyfriend is over, his dog and my dog get on well.

carefullycourageous · 18/08/2022 03:59

I'm amazed it is legal, tbh. I think importation of live animals is something to be discouraged in general because it drives a trade and risks importing diseases or problem animals.

agedasiago · 18/08/2022 03:50

There's a war in Ukraine; perhaps you could be.a little bit more compassionate??🚜🇺🇦🐶🌻

Also if you can't tell a troll from a real reply (if you can find one) the issue is U.

Phrenologistsfinger · 18/08/2022 01:40

Elmore · 17/08/2022 23:47

One thing I do know is that people that have foreign rescue dogs are like vegans - they just have to let everybody know about it

Well I’m vegan and I have a Romanian rescue and I wouldn’t brought it up if you hadn’t posted such an ignorant and provocative OP.

Phrenologistsfinger · 18/08/2022 01:36

My Romanian rescue is the love of my life and has kept me going during covid and miscarriages when I was close to giving up. There are millions like her in extreme suffering (nothing like what UK dogs go through - the state run pounds often don’t feed or treat the dogs and after a short stay they get put down with spades, beaten to death with metal poles, injections of petrol or being slammed against walls by their hind legs)… it’s a level of brutality most Brits cannot comprehend.

They are also objectively better than UK dogs - mongrels, more intelligent, not inbred, more robust (genetically) and characterful. Street dogs every time! She has never ever been aggressive, even at her most fearful.

I will rescue more!

Hollido · 18/08/2022 01:29

People are stupid about dogs in the UK. In other countries they're more clear minded. Look at the people running these so-called rescue operations. Most of the time they're just underemployed. But combine the kind of toot they peddle with the Facebook hun mentality and there you have why people import foreign street dogs of uncertain provenance.

HinchcliffeandMurgatroyd · 18/08/2022 01:21

80sMum · 18/08/2022 01:16

Isn't it also an indicator, though, that an awful lot of people who get dogs probably shouldn't have them, because their home and/or circumstances are unsuitable for keeping a dog?

My difficulty in getting my second and third dog is that they weren’t the first dog. That’s quite frankly batshit. Dogs are happier with company. You just have to be careful about temperamental matching.

I’ve WFH for years but occasionally have to make site visits. No problem for my dogs to be sat for a day or be alone for three hours once a month, but again that is enough for rescues to turn you down.

We have loads of space. Loads of experience. Loads of time and are very dog centred. It’s silly that people are driven to buy puppies for terrible breeders.

HinchcliffeandMurgatroyd · 18/08/2022 01:16

Elmore · 17/08/2022 23:31

So thanks to PPs I get that dog charities in the U.K. seem to be turning away a lot of prospective homes, but is importing dogs that have an unknown temperament and that could be carrying diseases responsible? The ones I’ve met were very badly behaved and aggressive, and i honestly think could be the next pit bulls

I adopted a puppy from a foreign street litter a few years ago. She’s a poppet, and very placid, if a bit regal.

The flight, which brought about two dozen dogs to adoptive homes, was organised by a charitable dog rescue in that country, headed up by an expat. They treated & assessed the dogs before deciding if they were suitable for placement sand they had experience British based volunteers to vet adopters (veterinary and personal references, plus an interview and only to experienced dog owners).

I went with the foreign rescue because a) I’d rather afoot than buy a puppy, b) the foreign rescues see a lot of dogs destroyed by local authorities due to lack of capacity and c) our British rescues are ridiculously fussy about placing dogs in homes with existing dogs.

I can’t really see a downside when it’s done properly like that.

Did you imagine it was ad hoc and unorganised?

80sMum · 18/08/2022 01:16

justasking111 · 17/08/2022 23:04

Have you tried to adopt a dog here the criteria is so limited. No children, no other pets, no going out to work, size of garden. That's why puppy farms exist

Isn't it also an indicator, though, that an awful lot of people who get dogs probably shouldn't have them, because their home and/or circumstances are unsuitable for keeping a dog?

Summerfun54321 · 18/08/2022 01:12

The reality is that no one needs a dog. It’s just a want and humans are selfish creatures so they’ll go about pleasing themselves rather than thinking of the greater good. You don’t have to have a degree in zoology to know foreign imports of stray animals is a terrible idea. You can’t even taken fruit or veg across boarders in many countries, let alone a wild animal to take home and domesticate.

99redballoonsgobyy · 18/08/2022 01:09

@CinnamonJellyBeans wow interesting post. Just shows that dogs trust don't actually care about dogs at all they are just money spinners to them. poor dogs spending months, years even in the dogs Trust kennels whilst they could be in lovely suitable homes. like you say hardly anyone meets there ridiculously stupid unrealistic criteria.

ExPatHereForAChat · 18/08/2022 01:06

When UK charities won't rehome there's often a sound reason (no garden, young children, owners working all day) but people don't like being told no.

I work alongside dogs and a good proportion of these EU imports are poorly socialised and show fear aggression. They need experienced owners but, sadly, they don't often get them.

The main worry though, is the serious potential for them bringing over diseases (as discussed by PPs). The amount of times an eastern european dog has been presented to me with a cough and I've asked if they've had a heartworm test and the owner hasn't a clue what I'm talking about.

Oh and it's not unheard of for some charities to completely wash their hands of the dog once they've been exported, even if they become seriously ill or are discovered to have severe behavioural issues.

Adopter beware, that's what I'd say.

Isaidnoalready · 18/08/2022 00:55

My mom.has decades of experience in dog ownership semi detached house that only one dog has escaped from (so she put in a second front door afterwards) she has an occasional job but a recluse of a partner who is always home they rejected her because she lives on a main road this road is 30 mph her house and garden is like Fort knox only one dog has ever escaped and that was on funeral day who knew the dog would take off like a rocket looking for its owner who we had just buried we caught the dog and it was fine mistake never repeated but no she was rejected over and over again she didn't want a greyhound she wanted a small dog and the romainian rescue gave her just that the dog is safe well cared for and it's a shame no British rescue would look at her as an owner

99redballoonsgobyy · 18/08/2022 00:50

As daft as it sounds it's probably much easier to adopt a rescue dog from abroad than it is from the UK! Have you seen how difficult it is to get a dog from the dogs home in the UK hardly anybody must meet the criteria. No children even visiting children, no other pets, you must not work as you need to be with the dog 24/7. home visits etc it's absolutely ridiculous. friends of mine were after a rescue dog a couple in their 50s who's previous dog had died. they found the process at the local dogs home so stressful and intrusive and didn't meet the criteria as they had an adult cat and both worked part time. they gave up in the end and had to get a puppy even though the didn't want a puppy and would have preferred a rescue dog. So a poor rescue dog in need missed out on a lovely home. This couple absolutely adore their dog.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 18/08/2022 00:38

The Dogs trust currently has 14,000 dogs. It's income last year was 111M. That's eight grand per dog per year. A lot of this money is spent on infrastructure, admin and fundraising. Here are some typical salaries:

Head of philanthropy at blue cross £53K
Solutions Architect with the RSPCA £57K
Data selections executive (wfh) RSPCA £28K
Data assistant Dogs Trust (wfh) £28K
Community engagement officer Dogs trust £24K
HR policy advisor Dogs Trust £41K

I notice that a lot of the jobs are nothing to do with actual dogs. The highest paid jobs are ones that enhance and maintain the income stream. The jobs that actually involve working with the dogs are poorly paid, or voluntary, unless it's in a medical or psychological capacity.

If you're the Dog's trust and you gave actually gave a dog to everybody who was actually suitable to own a dog, you'll soon get rid of those 14,000 dogs and you will have to scale back, or cease operations, so the business goes bust. It would be like an art gallery with no exhibits, asking for donations.

So what they do is invent impossible criteria, so no one can actually get a dog, so they can hang on to the dogs and generate more income and keep the business going.

This is very different to the foreign dog charities, staffed mostly by local volunteers. No fancy ads or campaigns. No high-paid executives. The dogs don't actually generate income, so it's in their best interests to rehome them to decent owners ASAP.

Having said that: the woman whose existing dogs were infected by the Romanian pregnant dog is a terrible story of incompetence by that charity.

Walkerbean16 · 18/08/2022 00:34

I suppose though there’s not much incentive for Romanian rescues to neuter dogs when they’re being paid to send them elsewhere..

They do neuter the dogs as soon as they are old enough, the rescuers do it because they care not to make money.

All animals must adhere to rules regarding testing and vaccinations etc