Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why people adopt feral dogs from Eastern Europe?

240 replies

Elmore · 17/08/2022 22:59

I don’t get it, there’s thousands of dogs in the U.K. that need homes, so why go to the effort (and expense) of importing these wild street dogs?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Jennybeans401 · 18/08/2022 07:54

*rehomed

ChuckItBucket · 18/08/2022 07:53

I can’t even… I had no idea my small terrier cross is a status symbol. I wonder if she knows.

exactly what status do you imagine people are gaining?

Jennybeans401 · 18/08/2022 07:53

We've considered it recently because we can't adopt a dog in the UK. Every time we check the different shelters we find that the dogs are not suitable for families with children. Our local shelter has so many dogs that cannot be removed for this reason that they said they cannot take on more dogs.

Mumofsend · 18/08/2022 07:52

We adopted a 9 month old puppy from Southern Spain. I know several of the team personally so chose them. Our dog it was his mum who was rescued whilst heavily pregnant. Mum is deemed unadoptable due to her issues but is in a long term home based environment with wonderful carers and 8 other dogs. They helped her with the puppies and all 8 of them have gone to wonderful homes and are wonderful dogs.

All UK rescues were a blanket no due to a child.

Our dog has been with us a year and is a wonderful part of our family.

phlebasconsidered · 18/08/2022 07:52

@Latenightreader
Romainia has a problem with dogs as a result of years under a dictator. Ceaucescu forced people into state residences which did not allow animals so many dogs were abandoned. Over time they bred and grew into a problem. The subsequent end of the regime left Romainia pretty impoverished and dogs were not really their priority.

They are now literally picked up from the streets and sent to kill shelters for mass killing. They are certainly NOT bred for puppy farming. Don't be ignorant- take some time to google things at least.

MarshaMelrose · 18/08/2022 07:51

You honestly think the reason people adopt from abroad is just because it’s a status symbol?

Some of them, yes.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 18/08/2022 07:47

agree op
it seems wrong
why is it so difficult in uk?
is it because they want too much from prospective owners

ChuckItBucket · 18/08/2022 07:47

Meanwhile thousands of healthy, nice - natured dogs in rescue centres and stray kennels are put to sleep every year. And why? Because it's now a status symbol to say you got your dog from abroad.

this might be the dumbest statement on this thread so far. You honestly think the reason people adopt from abroad is just because it’s a status symbol?

I adopted from abroad because I wanted a mongrel dog. I didn’t apply to any UK rescue centres first and now I have two lovely dogs.

Latenightreader · 18/08/2022 07:45

This thread has been an eye opener. I’ve always been concerned that some foreign rescues were little more than puppy farms and I now have plenty of food for thought of different perspectives. Thank you.

anotherbrewplease · 18/08/2022 07:44

The ones I’ve met were very badly behaved and aggressive, and i honestly think could be the next pit bulls

If you say so love - you must be a complete expert on dogs.

We got our rescue from Balkan Underdogs - mainly because we were not able to get a rescue dog from UK shelter for the reasons others have outlined. We didn't do it as a 'status symbol' Confused

phlebasconsidered · 18/08/2022 07:37

I tried for over a year to find a dog from our local rspca and Wood Green. Because we already have an old good boy, work and have 2 older kids, it just wasn't happening despite the fact that my mum is over with the dog all.day every day.

Eventually, we found a small local rescue centre that rescued from home and abroad. They did a home check and we got our lovely 6 month old puppy from Romania. She was fully tested, vaccinated and chipped. She has some scars on her head from her life in the kill shelter prior to rescue.

She is adorable- so loving and intelligent and quick to learn. I've never had a dog housetrain so quickly and she picked up other commands from simply copying my older dog. Her capacity for love and loyalty is amazing given how she had her start. She does have quirks- she has one ear up and one ear down, "talks" rather than barks and she climbs trees. She has more automatic understanding of a pack than any other dog i have had though- she is brilliant with other dogs.

The vet said she was fit and healthy and would be bombproof, being such a mongrel. He is Romanian himself and said nobody who had seen the shelters could deny the dogs a chance. A lot of people are ignorant about European rescues, but once they meet her they change their minds.

MarshaMelrose · 18/08/2022 07:36

Orangello · 18/08/2022 07:27

Meanwhile thousands of healthy, nice - natured dogs in rescue centres and stray kennels are put to sleep every year. And why? Because it's now a status symbol to say you got your dog from abroad.

Because, as many people have said, kennels will rather put a dog to sleep than re-home to a perfectly lovely family who, shock horror, might work or live on a main road.

🙄 That's not true. Don't you think the best thing about working in a home us seeing dogs go to a good home and then them revisiting, happy with their new owners. You think that people working on minimum wage looking after animals want to see them put to sleep? Do you know how many unsuitable people enquire about dogs? With unsuitable homes, no gardens, unsuitable family situation etc. Every time a dog is rehomed and that rehoming fails, the risk of the dog not finding a suitable home increases. The art of good homing is matching a dog with suitable owners.

Buildingthefuture · 18/08/2022 07:33

To say all imported dogs are “feral” is a sweeping generalisation and factually incorrect. I have volunteered for an overseas rescue, as well as for uk rescues, for a number of years. The vast, vast majority of adoptions go well and I could put you in touch with literally thousands of owners who have adopted from abroad (for all the reasons pps have stated) successfully. But you don’t read about those people, you only hear about the ones that go wrong. Personally, I have adopted from both the uk and further afield many, many times. There has been literally no difference in my foreign or uk rescues, other than that the foreign ones are clean in the house from day 1!! No idea why this is, but it’s consistent. I’ve been challenged on why I adopt from abroad too….the interesting thing is that that challenge always comes from people who have NEVER adopted, from the Uk or anywhere??
Shelters in the uk are full of lockdown dogs…..bought from money grabbing breeders by people who didn’t think it through and who then decide to just throw the dog away.
Providing a loving, safe home for an unwanted animal, wherever it’s from will always be a good thing to me and far better than buying a puppy and lining the pockets of breeders. And all the while I’m taking responsibility for my animals, I’m paying for them and they aren’t negatively impacting anyone else (I adopt from reputable charities, I’m aware of the health checks required and ensure they are done) it’s nothing to do with you or anybody.

Keepgoing88 · 18/08/2022 07:29

my best friend adopted an Eastern European dog. He is an utter nightmare, sheepdog cross type breed, not necessarily massively dangerous but can’t be trusted around kids, barks at them , digs up lawns, wrecks furniture… to be honest I don’t like going to her house any more because of the dog

User478 · 18/08/2022 07:28

Some foreign rescues are just puppy farms in disguise.

There are several "rescues" who will get you your choice of golden retriever puppy from Turkey.

Orangello · 18/08/2022 07:27

Meanwhile thousands of healthy, nice - natured dogs in rescue centres and stray kennels are put to sleep every year. And why? Because it's now a status symbol to say you got your dog from abroad.

Because, as many people have said, kennels will rather put a dog to sleep than re-home to a perfectly lovely family who, shock horror, might work or live on a main road.

MarshaMelrose · 18/08/2022 07:17

No, there isn’t loads and loads of dogs in the UK to adopt!

Yes, there are loads of dogs to adopt in the UK!

sjxoxo · 18/08/2022 07:15

It’s very hard to adopt I’m the UK and no, there isn’t loads and loads of dogs in the UK to adopt! The UK has a great love for domestic animals in ways that other cultures don’t - there’s nothing wrong with adopting from wherever. It’s one more that is given a good life and care. The problem in the UK is dog breeders and demand for fashionable dogs like frenchies these last few years. I am assuming you don’t have a dog OP! xo

RoseAndRose · 18/08/2022 07:12

They’re more likely to be street dogs than feral dogs but I agree that even with those rescues who assess via fostering before putting out for adoption, they can be very much an unknown quantity. I wouldn’t have one, I wouldn’t recommend anyone with DC to even consider having one.

A1b2c3d4e5f6g7 · 18/08/2022 07:11

I have a beautiful Romanian rescue, would love to get another. There are many of them where I live in London, all lovely dogs. He's good with children and cats, and the rescue I got him from test for that. The English based rescue we adopted from broke down all of the costs in getting him over here with the right documentation, microchip, neutering, vaccines etc. The fee they charge only just covers that. I topped it up to what I would have paid for a puppy. The dogs live in appalling conditions, look at some videos on YouTube if you can bear it.

He was very afraid when we got him, we put in a lot of work, I absolutely love him.

hapinthewood · 18/08/2022 07:08

Owners often bring up the fact their dog is a foreign rescue because people will ask, what breed is he/she, or ask for paw in exchange for a treat, or wonder why the dog has no recall or awareness of their name. In younger dogs the latter 2 can be taught. So my explanation was (no I'm not a negligent owner who hasn't trained my dog), she's from a foreign rescue, Lord only knows what mix of breeds she is.

MarshaMelrose · 18/08/2022 07:05

LimeTwists · 17/08/2022 23:06

Because feral street dogs are in more need? They have far worse lives and treatment than the unwanted dogs you can apply to adopt from UK shelters. I volunteered at the RSPCA kennels near me: the dogs are fed and sheltered, not running lose scavenging, sleeping on streets and being treated cruelly as vermin. Also, because UK shelters make perfectly good prospective owners jump through ridiculous hoops to adopt unwanted dogs, whereas charities overseas are a bit more grateful that people are bothering to apply.

The dogs might be fed and sheltered in RSPCA kennels but if they can't be rehomed, one of two things happen. Either some of them will be PTS so that other dogs can be taken in; or dogs that desperately need to be brought in, can't be because there's no space, which again leads owners to abandoning them, having them euthanized or given away to useless owners.

UK charities are experienced and know where problems lie in rehoming. That's why they are careful where they rehome. Overseas charities just need to get them off their premises so they can take more in to sell or rehome. They don't do proper checking of whether the dogs are safe, or whether the prospective owner is a good match.

In just the last 6 weeks I've heard of two dogs from Greece. One is my chiropodist's that she's had to give back because it wasn't suitable with her 18mth daughter! And the other is from a dog walker who has had to refuse to walk the dog as the longer it's settled in, the more aggressive it's become.

Meanwhile thousands of healthy, nice - natured dogs in rescue centres and stray kennels are put to sleep every year. And why? Because it's now a status symbol to say you got your dog from abroad.

hapinthewood · 18/08/2022 06:55

I adopted a Romanian dog who'd been rescued from the street and lived in a shelter ran by one man doing his best. The shelter was being closed by the local council so another more organised shelter with links to the uk took as many dogs as they could. My girl was cat friendly which was my biggest requirement. Whilst I'd love a greyhound from the dogs trust, that can't happen with a cat. I knew my girl had terminal cancer when I got her, she had many quirks but aggression wasn't one of them. She lived like a queen for 10 months and I don't regret a moment

Palladin · 18/08/2022 06:54

You're clearly very ignorant, OP. Please take the time to try and process the information from better informed posters on this thread.

Mummyoflittledragon · 18/08/2022 06:53

There are a few foreign born rescue dogs around here. Some were rather feral at first. Thankfully all owners have been responsible with them, successfully training their dogs. As a result the dogs are less reactive and more sociable with other dogs.