Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why people adopt feral dogs from Eastern Europe?

240 replies

Elmore · 17/08/2022 22:59

I don’t get it, there’s thousands of dogs in the U.K. that need homes, so why go to the effort (and expense) of importing these wild street dogs?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
MarshaMelrose · 18/08/2022 10:04

Eunorition · 18/08/2022 09:58

Because shelters in the UK have no interest in giving any of their dogs to people with children, jobs, existing pets, hair, limbs or eyes.

This is such a load of rubbish. Of course they rehome to families with children, with existing pets, and jobs if appropriate. I have no idea what hair, limbs or else refer to.
People who work in rescue centres get minimum wage. They work there because they love the animals. You think they'd prefer to see them pts rather than in a good home? 🙄

MarshaMelrose · 18/08/2022 10:00

ChuckItBucket · 18/08/2022 09:53

Someone who knows seems to know more than you about this has just posted to say the dogs are killed using plastic bags or set on fire. That doesn’t happen to dogs in UK shelters who are well fed, kindly treated, and painlessly euthanised if a home can’t be found for them

If that's true why don't the charities there have them put to sleep humanely like the charities in the UK do. Pentobarbital isn't that expensive and you don't need to pay a qualified vet to do it. One of the charity workers can do it. Because even if they rehome dogs across Europe, they're still going to have dogs in their kill centre. So why not do some charity work in there?

Eunorition · 18/08/2022 09:58

Because shelters in the UK have no interest in giving any of their dogs to people with children, jobs, existing pets, hair, limbs or eyes.

shortandpaleandoldandugly · 18/08/2022 09:57

I know two people who have adopted from Romania. One works full time, lives alone in a desperately messy house that you'd have to see to believe (think hoarder tendencies) and has also got several cats and various other pets. There's no way she'd have passed a UK home check. The other lives in an upstairs flat with no access to a garden and very little room inside. Again, would not have been accepted by a UK rescue. In both cases a refusal would have been absolutely the right thing. Instead, they brought two more dogs into the country. I struggle to get behind that as a positive thing to be honest.

ChuckItBucket · 18/08/2022 09:53

MarshaMelrose · 18/08/2022 09:43

Complete bullsh1t.

It's not BS. You've just said there were plenty of good dogs looking for homes in British kennels which you didn't fancy having. Some of those will be put to sleep because no one fancied them. How is that different from them being put to sleep in Romania? Other than we call it PTS in a kennel and they call it an emotive kill shelter?

Someone who knows seems to know more than you about this has just posted to say the dogs are killed using plastic bags or set on fire. That doesn’t happen to dogs in UK shelters who are well fed, kindly treated, and painlessly euthanised if a home can’t be found for them

A1b2c3d4e5f6g7 · 18/08/2022 09:53

@CentralBark thank you so much

Costacoffeeplease · 18/08/2022 09:52

I see the op has disappeared.

Anyway, I’m at the opposite end of this issue. I live in Europe and volunteer in animal rescue. I have bottle fed countless abandoned puppies and kittens. Some of the pups are rehomed here , but quite a few have been rehomed in the U.K.

The charities I work with assess all the dogs, all are health tested and treated as necessary and often go into foster homes for a full assessment. No ‘feral’ dogs are offered for adoption, ever.

I do despair of people who make grand pronouncements without doing the tiniest amount of research 🙄

fatnotfluffy · 18/08/2022 09:46

I have no idea why people do this either, though I know people who have. An animal you met on holiday and formed a bond with, maybe. A random animal from a website that you haven't had chance to meet and assess its personality, I just don't get it. I do hope that some of the proceeds from people doing this are going towards a TNR programme though.

MarshaMelrose · 18/08/2022 09:43

Complete bullsh1t.

It's not BS. You've just said there were plenty of good dogs looking for homes in British kennels which you didn't fancy having. Some of those will be put to sleep because no one fancied them. How is that different from them being put to sleep in Romania? Other than we call it PTS in a kennel and they call it an emotive kill shelter?

YanTanTetheraPetheraPimp · 18/08/2022 09:37

@CentralBark
Well said.
Here’s my wonderful rescue in her usual position!

To not understand why people adopt feral dogs from Eastern Europe?
YanTanTetheraPetheraPimp · 18/08/2022 09:33

Meanwhile thousands of healthy, nice - natured dogs in rescue centres and stray kennels are put to sleep every year. And why? Because it's now a status symbol to say you got your dog from abroad
Complete bullsh1t.
I applied to at least 24 different dog charities, RSPCA, Dogs Trust etc across the south of England and Wales, looking for a dog, not necessarily a puppy. We are retired, keen walkers, have an enclosed garden, plenty of local walks, would take the dog on holiday with us, experienced dog owners etc.
We got nowhere because either you already had to have a dog or they were staffie crosses/rotwelier crosses which I didn’t want because of bad experiences.
I now have a wonderful Romanian rescue, we were thoroughly vetted and had a home inspection. She came from a kill shelter (so if the PP who thought they were better off left running feral would like to see just what that means for dogs I suggest they Google it 😱).
She’s settled in beautifully, she’s actually been easier than some of my previous dogs!) and I would definitely go down that route again.
She came fully vaccinated, microchipped, wormed and with passport.

I don’t think I need to justify why to anyone else, but I am getting really pissed off with the ludicrous statements being made by people who quite frankly appear to be sh1t stirring rather than accepting we have free choice in this country.

CentralBark · 18/08/2022 09:33

Hi,

I co-founded and run a charity that adopts dogs from Eastern Europe. There's lots of misinformed commenting on here, so whilst I usually wouldn't engage I wanted to clear a few things up.

1 - DISEASES: all dogs that enter the UK must pass DEFRA requirements. That means they must be chipped and vaccinated for all the obvious nasties (including rabies) and their blood is tested a month later to confirm the presence of antibodies. On arrival in the UK dogs must pass a vet check and a 48 hour quarantine in DEFRA approved kennels. Dogs coming into the UK are safer from a disease perspective than any already in the UK. Recently there has been extensive clamping down on dogs travelling in to the UK to control Romanian puppy farming, so every dog leaving a country has a file 'opened' and that file cannot be 'closed' until the dog completes. Every dog has a huge file of paperwork and extensive tracking, far more than a UK dog. Obviously behaviour can be hidden in some ways, but aggressive dogs will not pass the vet check.

The only thing they may not be vaccinated for is Kennel Cough because it doesn't exist in some Eastern European countries.

2 - WHY ADOPT FROM EASTERN EUROPE: well that's multi-layered and you may agree or not. The main argument - if I were being a bit blunt - is what difference does it make? A dog in need is a dog in need.

However, I think the answer is more complicated. Firstly, UK rescues place INSANE requirements on adopters. We generally rehome to wonderful people who have jobs/mild disabilities/children all of which gets them rejected from other rescues. We have even rehomed to people who WFH but live in flats next to green spaces

Secondly, in my opinion and experience, UK rescue dogs are often (not always obvs) in rescue because idiots have adopted cute puppies with no idea how to train them and the consequence is they have learnt bad behaviour. Our dogs have two desires: a loving home and food. And they will do whatever you want them to do if they get those two things. Street dogs rarely have terrible behaviours because that wouldn't help them survive. Survival on the street requires being people and dog friendly, so the friendliest gene pool tends to survive. Of course, once in a home they can if allowed develop a 'you can't have this' attitude, they aren't perfect, but having rehired over a thousand Eastern European dogs, only a handful have developed behavioural issues.

Lastly, conditions in these countries are worth saving dogs from. In the country I operate in the average monthly income is €300, and city workers in the dog pounds are horrific. Drugs that are supposed to be used to humanely euthanise dogs are stolen by workers and sold to subsidise their income. We recently took over welfare at a city fund and the dogs were being 'euthanised' with plastic shopping bags/being set fire. In the UK the WORST fate a dog faces is humane euthanising. To not be active in these countries and showing those in charge that people outside the country are watching puts yet more dogs at risk of horrific endings.

I might add - rehoming in the UK is the SMALLEST part of our work. Our main goal is proving we can humanely control dog populations through neutering, sadly people don't donate to CNR schemes, they like their donation to have a 'face' - it's why so many rescues are forced to share sad rescue videos.

Anyway. I hope that's useful to some people. I'm not interested in getting into big debates about it, but it's blatantly silly to tar ALL dogs from one country/area with the same brush based on a couple of experiences across a lifetime. I have had dogs all my life. I now have 3 dogs, 2 from Romania and 1 from Serbia. I've never had a moment of aggression from any of them and they are the easiest dogs I've ever owned. I cannot recommend Eastern European dogs highly enough.

If you are considering adopting a dog from abroad, go with one that has rescue back-up/a fostering system in the UK. Ideally do a foster-to-adopt placement to make sure the dog is right for you.

MarshaMelrose · 18/08/2022 09:25

They are also objectively better than UK dogs - mongrels, more intelligent, not inbred, more robust (genetically) and characterful.

🙄

FairyLightAddict · 18/08/2022 09:17

phlebasconsidered · 18/08/2022 07:37

I tried for over a year to find a dog from our local rspca and Wood Green. Because we already have an old good boy, work and have 2 older kids, it just wasn't happening despite the fact that my mum is over with the dog all.day every day.

Eventually, we found a small local rescue centre that rescued from home and abroad. They did a home check and we got our lovely 6 month old puppy from Romania. She was fully tested, vaccinated and chipped. She has some scars on her head from her life in the kill shelter prior to rescue.

She is adorable- so loving and intelligent and quick to learn. I've never had a dog housetrain so quickly and she picked up other commands from simply copying my older dog. Her capacity for love and loyalty is amazing given how she had her start. She does have quirks- she has one ear up and one ear down, "talks" rather than barks and she climbs trees. She has more automatic understanding of a pack than any other dog i have had though- she is brilliant with other dogs.

The vet said she was fit and healthy and would be bombproof, being such a mongrel. He is Romanian himself and said nobody who had seen the shelters could deny the dogs a chance. A lot of people are ignorant about European rescues, but once they meet her they change their minds.

I love your dog climbs trees! Really tickled me.

Soontobe60 · 18/08/2022 09:16

Phrenologistsfinger · 18/08/2022 01:36

My Romanian rescue is the love of my life and has kept me going during covid and miscarriages when I was close to giving up. There are millions like her in extreme suffering (nothing like what UK dogs go through - the state run pounds often don’t feed or treat the dogs and after a short stay they get put down with spades, beaten to death with metal poles, injections of petrol or being slammed against walls by their hind legs)… it’s a level of brutality most Brits cannot comprehend.

They are also objectively better than UK dogs - mongrels, more intelligent, not inbred, more robust (genetically) and characterful. Street dogs every time! She has never ever been aggressive, even at her most fearful.

I will rescue more!

I’d be interested to see the proof that what you say is true.

ManateeFair · 18/08/2022 09:10

Elmore · 17/08/2022 23:05

The ones I’ve encountered have always been very aggressive and had owners that seemed a bit clueless, so I guess it’s a safety issue? I just wanna know why people feel the need? I get the feeling the dogs would be happier on the streets

None of the ones I know have been aggressive. Literally none. And none of them have clueless owners.

And of course they wouldn’t ‘be happier on the streets’ without regular food, warmth, comfort or veterinary care, in countries with minimal welfare laws.

Maybe just mind your own business. A dog isn’t less worthy of care because it happened to be born somewhere else.

Newuser82 · 18/08/2022 09:08

@ChuckItBucket and I certainly wouldn't say that UK rescues were without problems.

Newuser82 · 18/08/2022 09:07

@ChuckItBucket it wouldn't be true to say I didn't have any experience with foreign rescues and I said they often don't have back up support. I appreciate this isn't the case everywhere.

Soontobe60 · 18/08/2022 09:06

Mississipi71 · 17/08/2022 23:00

How does it affect you?

It affects anyone who may encounter that dog. I have a neighbour who’s adopted 2. They’re aggressive, bark constantly, have to be muzzled when out walking and even then still try to attack other dogs.

FallOutPloy · 18/08/2022 09:01

Also (unpopular opinion incoming) I have horses as well as dogs, and I don't understand the point blank refusal to have dogs and cats humanly euthanised. Horse owners tend to be much more pragmatic about the future of a tricky/dangerous horse. If UK rescues are overrun by dogs that are not suitable for most normal family set ups, then there needs to be an honest discussion about whether a lifetime in a cage/run is really a life worth living.

FallOutPloy · 18/08/2022 09:00

I'd feel better about it if people admitted that many of these charities are more like businesses. I don't see anything wrong with buying a dog from abroad, but the "adopt a poor neglected street dog for £500 narrative feels disingenuous.

FWIW I think the reason that so many UK rescues are so fussy about rehoming is that they're terrified of being sued, or just general Bad Optics, if it goes tits up. It feels to me like a massive risk both ways for anyone acquiring a dog from abroad. Will/should UK rescues accept these dogs if they turn out to be unsuitable for the family?

honkeytonkwoman38 · 18/08/2022 08:57

You seem quite bitter about it op. There are bigger issues in life!

ChuckItBucket · 18/08/2022 08:54

Newuser82 · 18/08/2022 08:49

I agree in that I think it's very problematic bringing foreign rescue dogs into the country. I used to work in an animal rejoining centre and am surprised by the strict criteria that people are saying they needed to meet in order to rehome as that wasn't my experience at all.

I did however see many dogs pts or else spending months sometimes years miserable in kennels as no one wanted to take them.

In my (admittedly limited experience) of foreign rescue dogs they are very often under socialised, fearful and often aggressive. The new owners are often landed with behavioural and health issues and are often unprepared for these. There is often poor or no after care or support like there is with rescues from this country and I certainly wouldn't have rehomed any animal
Without a meet and greet first to see if everyone got on which is obviously harder with a foreign rescue unless the animal os in foster care in this country first.

Again I think it's hugely problematic and never something I would consider especially as I have children.

You could have just said you don’t know anything about foreign rescues. My rescue has full rescue backup, they’ll take the dogs back if I can’t care for them anymore, they did a full home check and they’ll periodically ask how we’re getting on. It’s pretty annoying to have people who haven’t got a clue writing off all overseas rescues the way you have while pretending that UK rescues are without issues and result in perfect dogs. Doesn’t work like that.

I do agree that people with young children should consider very carefully what the right way to getting a dog is but that doesn’t automatically discount an overseas rescue

ChuckItBucket · 18/08/2022 08:49

Mumofsend · 18/08/2022 08:20

Mine cost £250 donation to the charity, £290 for his transport.

Mine was similar yet the poster I quoted seemed to think you could set up and run a shelter on the amount it cost to import one dog.

I just think a lot of people commenting have no actual experience of getting one of these dogs or their experience is limited to “one I saw in the park was naughty”.

Newuser82 · 18/08/2022 08:49

I agree in that I think it's very problematic bringing foreign rescue dogs into the country. I used to work in an animal rejoining centre and am surprised by the strict criteria that people are saying they needed to meet in order to rehome as that wasn't my experience at all.

I did however see many dogs pts or else spending months sometimes years miserable in kennels as no one wanted to take them.

In my (admittedly limited experience) of foreign rescue dogs they are very often under socialised, fearful and often aggressive. The new owners are often landed with behavioural and health issues and are often unprepared for these. There is often poor or no after care or support like there is with rescues from this country and I certainly wouldn't have rehomed any animal
Without a meet and greet first to see if everyone got on which is obviously harder with a foreign rescue unless the animal os in foster care in this country first.

Again I think it's hugely problematic and never something I would consider especially as I have children.