Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why people adopt feral dogs from Eastern Europe?

240 replies

Elmore · 17/08/2022 22:59

I don’t get it, there’s thousands of dogs in the U.K. that need homes, so why go to the effort (and expense) of importing these wild street dogs?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
MarshaMelrose · 18/08/2022 11:09

mountainsunsets · 18/08/2022 10:36

But @MarshaMelrose by that logic, no dog should ever be rehomed in case it doesn't work out.

The ideal person on paper could drop dead in three months and the dog will end up back in rescue.

You can't just say "well it might not work out" and use that as an excuse to never give those dogs a chance.

Not at all. No one wants a dog to stay in longer than it has to. It's bad for the dogs health.

Dogs are rehomed to families with children all the time. But not small children. Because of the number of times it doesn't work out, for a variety of reasons. And if the dog makes one snap at a child, even without touching it, it gets returned. Might not even have been the dogs fault. And then what. The shelter can't just rehome it in case it does actually have a temperament issue. So maybe they try and find it just a home with adults if they'll risk a dog that snapped. And how many people actually don't come in contact with children. It's not like it's impossible but it's very difficult. And while it's waiting, it's blocking a kennel for another dog. And on top of all that, the family go around saying the shelter are dreadful because they rehomed a dangerous dog.

And say your neighbours work all day. You don't see them come home and the dog barks. What would your thoughts be on that? Irresponsible owner? Irresponsible animal shelter?

Of course dogs are rehomed to a variety of people. But there are some situations that I would refuse. I've been in the roughest houses and they've been the greatest owners. Dog sprawled on the settee whilst the kids are sat on the floor. I've been to wealthy places wherever dog has been left outside tied to a kennel with no water and an eye infection. You can't predict who will be good owner and who will be bad one by looking at anyone. But there are just some situations that are repetitively a problem and shelters do avoid try and avoid them.

Are some too cautious? I'm sure so. But none of them went into the job not wanting the animals to have a good outcome.

RestingMurderousFace · 18/08/2022 11:07

He sounds ace @WhackingPhoenix We’re going on o need a pic, just to make sure 😉

WhackingPhoenix · 18/08/2022 10:59

My Romanian rescue is asleep on the floor with his teddy because he’s let the cats steal his bed. Super aggressive. He’s not a small, fluffy and cuddly-looking dog; he’s tall and muscular with pointy ears so some people probably make their own judgements on him based on how he looks, but he’s a little sweetie. I didn’t know anything about him until they asked if I could foster him, I agreed and went to meet him, fell head over heels in love and adopted him permanently.

I lost sight of him briefly at the beach the other day as he blends in completely with rocks and sand due to his colouring, found him 10 seconds later peering into a rockpool with a toddler and her dad 😂

He does a popular dog sport, he swims, climbs trees, runs miles. He’s a smashing little guy and I adore him. I don’t tend to tell people where he’s from unless they ask if he’s from abroad. He gets a lot of attention when we’re out as he’s unusual-looking and people like to ask about him but I don’t mind telling them, but that is certainly not why I got him. I’ll tell him he’s a status symbol though, I expect he’ll be pleased.

tttigress · 18/08/2022 10:58

A lot of dogs in UK rescue centres are bull terrier types which you aren't allowed to have unless you fit a lot of criteria (basically you need a garden, no children, to have plenty of time for the dog)

Pugdogmom · 18/08/2022 10:56

I don't have an issue with people adopting dogs from anywhere, however many of these dogs are rescued from dreadful conditions and have been through trauma. They need careful handling and positive training.

Two of my neighbours have Romanian rescues. One is extremely reactive to other dogs ( fear based). They won't take advice on how to train a reactive dog, and let it walk on on a flexible lead. 🙄. It attacked a small dog and the Council have already advised that it is muzzled and gave a list of dog trainers. Still haven't listened.

The other neighbour ( who I don't know very well) , also has a reactive dog, and she spends all her time yelling at the poor thing.

Am not sure what home checks are done for these dogs, however as they aren't being actively mistreated on eyes of law, I don't think much can be done.

YanTanTetheraPetheraPimp · 18/08/2022 10:52

MarshaMelrose · 18/08/2022 09:43

Complete bullsh1t.

It's not BS. You've just said there were plenty of good dogs looking for homes in British kennels which you didn't fancy having. Some of those will be put to sleep because no one fancied them. How is that different from them being put to sleep in Romania? Other than we call it PTS in a kennel and they call it an emotive kill shelter?

My awful experiences were with a staffie (severely bitten on my legs and arm) and Rottweiler (thanks to a pig ignorant owner who admitted he couldn’t control it - I was knocked me to the ground, hit my head and unconscious and bitten on the back of my neck)
Sufficiently good reason I think?!
🙄🤬

MarshaMelrose · 18/08/2022 10:48

CentralBark · 18/08/2022 10:24

No one except a vet should be putting any animal to sleep.

But to respond to your comment, we do. Animals that are un-rehomable due to illness/aggression we humanely euthanise at our shelter. We even 'trade' with the city pounds that we will organise to have these animals PTS if you allow us to bring our vet in for a day to neuter the dogs the pound. We don't want to rehome dogs to the UK, we actually lose money by doing so - it costs around £550 per dog to bring it (legally and safely) to the UK. We charge a £300 adoption fee. For every dog we rehome in the UK we home another 3 in the country we operate.

But - I cannot stress this enough - pounds there aren't like here. Some city pounds don't even have workers there from Fri eve-sunday morning, so the dogs are not fed/cleaned in that time. One pound (that we have since taken over) used to put small dogs in with big dogs on a Friday night so the big dogs would kill and eat the small ones. One vet (now in jail) was stitching up bitches after neutering with ribbon "for fun". These dogs were dying in agony.

I cannot describe the levels of depravity SOME (not all) Eastern European shelters succumb to. During the floods a few years ago we went to a flooding shelter and BEGGED them to release all their 36 dogs to us. They refused, left all the dogs chained in cages. They all drowned. To them this was a gift - their shelter was empty. They made their money (they get paid per dog that leaves the shelter whether dead or alive) by getting rid of all the dogs AND they got to laugh at us for caring about 'stupid dogs'.

And, of course, there is legal resistance within the countries. We cannot just walk into a shelter and euthanise them all, even if we wanted to. (And we don't).

You may not agree, and that's fine, but in my very experienced opinion I am absolutely comfortable prioritising dogs in these countries over UK dogs. I have also adopted amazing dogs from UK shelters, and I absolutely will again, but their fate is nothing compared to those in Eastern EU countries.

No one except a vet should be putting any animal to sleep.

I strongly disagree. There are plenty of places in the UK where non vets euthanise afte training. I would think it's even easier to sort out in a country that clearly doesn't care about animals.

I'm not saying life is great for dogs in different countries. It must be heart breaking to see. Of course people see the videos online and want to rescue them. In kennels if you have a dog with one eye and a dog with two eyes, which do you think would be chosen first? People love a story that they saved something. It's rewarding.

But what you're saying is that the dogs abroad deserve to live over the dogs in the uk because the dogs in the uk are well cared for and can be pts humanely. What I'm saying is that you have the means to euthanize, it's something you already do, so if dogs are ill-treated in the pound go pay and euthanize them. Because somewhere along the line, there, here, France, Estonia, wherever you're sending the dogs, some dog is being euthanized because there's a finite number of homes.

ginghamstarfish · 18/08/2022 10:46

it's more instagrammable, you can boast about it more, virtue signalling etc etc

Orangello · 18/08/2022 10:41

How is a homechecker to know which one you are.

Well exactly. So the rescue refuses adopters, just in case, better to keep the dog in the kennel waiting for this magical dog expert with no other commitments.

mountainsunsets · 18/08/2022 10:36

But @MarshaMelrose by that logic, no dog should ever be rehomed in case it doesn't work out.

The ideal person on paper could drop dead in three months and the dog will end up back in rescue.

You can't just say "well it might not work out" and use that as an excuse to never give those dogs a chance.

SunnyD44 · 18/08/2022 10:36

1 - DISEASES: all dogs that enter the UK must pass DEFRA requirements. That means they must be chipped and vaccinated for all the obvious nasties (including rabies) and their blood is tested a month later to confirm the presence of antibodies. On arrival in the UK dogs must pass a vet check and a 48 hour quarantine in DEFRA approved kennels. Dogs coming into the UK are safer from a disease perspective than any already in the UK.

The trouble is with this is that there are some diseases they’re not tested for and if they do come over here our dogs would be much less immune to them.

There is also a massive issue with people getting dogs abroad but not from reputable rescues like yours.

It started off that a few non-profit charities were doing this and now it seems that other places have jumped on the bandwagon and now it’s really common and easier to get a dog from abroad.

I am a dog lover and rescuing any dog is a good thing IMO regardless of what country they come from.
The conditions in other countries are often absolutely awful especially compared to the kennels over here where they’re treated well and have a decent standard of living.

I have now been put off by rescuing from abroad because I have dogs and the story about the women and her dogs who contracted a foreign disease means I won’t be willing to take that risk.
However if I didn’t have dogs already, then I would be happy to rescue from abroad.

RestingMurderousFace · 18/08/2022 10:36

Look at the state of these feral, disease ridden ‘forrins’. Maybe I just got exceptionally lucky, three times. 🙄

To not understand why people adopt feral dogs from Eastern Europe?
Paramummy3 · 18/08/2022 10:34

because it is, genuinely, almost impossible to adopt a dog from a UK rescue if you have kids/work

Orangello · 18/08/2022 10:33

These dogs are not really suitable pets for families. They need specific care from experienced animal handlers.

See this makes sense. And answers the question why an average family won't and should not adopt those dogs - because an average family is not an experienced handler with no other commitments, therefore not appropriate for a dog that needs one. Not the case that you just want a fashionable foreign rescue.

stormywhethers321 · 18/08/2022 10:31

I have a former street dog who is the sweetest thing alive. She literally wouldn't hurt a fly, and all she wants from life is a soft bed to nap in and lots of jerky treats, Her initial paperwork from the vet has a note that says "really sweet dog", and that's from someone who was seeing her while she was stressed and confused. My kids sometimes sleep with their head on her like she's a pillow.

MarshaMelrose · 18/08/2022 10:30

We are not suitable to adopt as we work and have small children.

You might great. You might be responsible and keep it separate from your small children when it gets boisterous. You might come home in your lunch time to let the dog out. You might have a relative that us reliable in their commitment to looking after the dog during the day. You might not get a dog with separation anxiety when you're at work and that howls all day.

But not everyone is you. No one gets a dog thinking it won't work out. Most people get one thinking it will be a bit of work but not knowing how hard. And that's why they end up being returned. Because people let the dogs jump on the kids, the kids cry, get scared, get scratched. Dog gets returned.
It becomes too much of a commitment to return home at lunch everyday. It's a drag. Feel guilty, not serving dogs needs, blah, blah, blah. Dog gets returned
Relative made a commitment but now looking after a grandchild whose allergic, or they got a job, or they're moving, blah, blah,blah. Dog gets returned.
Dog gets left every day. Feels lonely. Howls. Neighbours complain. Council called. Dog gets returned.
And I could go on.

This might not be you but this is people in your situation. How is a homechecker to know which one you are.

Every time a dog is returned, its chance of getting a successful home decreases and it's risk of being PTS increases. They don't rehome lightly. And they don't refuse lightly. They want the dogs gone from the kennels because they have a waiting list of dogs to come in.

InChocolateWeTrust · 18/08/2022 10:26

There's a gap between what the british public want from rescues, and what rescues have as their own objective.

Rescues are only interested in the dog. They are not bothered about whether the dog has the characteristics to be a good family pet, they are only bothered about locating a home for the dog that places its needs/wants above everything else.

Their ideal adopter is an altruistic volunteer with no other commitments, who is solely focussed on the dog - essentially an extension of the rescue itself.

The general public perceive rescues as places to acquire a pet.

In the UK most rescues dont like to talk about this (because it would reduce their income flows) but the reason they dont want to home their dogs to families etc is because a high proportion of the dogs ending up in rescues are difficult breeds, poorly socialised, aggressive or reactive, or displaying other undesirable behaviours like guarding. Many have had traumatic experiences and have challenging behaviours as a result. These dogs are not really suitable pets for families. They need specific care from experienced animal handlers.

So actually what we end up with is a shortage of pet dogs. This leads to the inevitable puppy farms, imports etc.

There are two ways to resolve this:

  • increase decent, regulated supply of suitable pet dogs. Perhaps charities with the necessary expertise could get involved in breeding, providing training to new owners etc, income from this could cross subsidise caring properly for challenging rescue dogs who in reality aren't suitable for most domestic homes.
  • reduce demand by creating limitations and restrictions on who can own a dog. Licenses, testing, fines etc. This is likely to be politically unpopular and will never happen.
CentralBark · 18/08/2022 10:24

MarshaMelrose · 18/08/2022 10:00

If that's true why don't the charities there have them put to sleep humanely like the charities in the UK do. Pentobarbital isn't that expensive and you don't need to pay a qualified vet to do it. One of the charity workers can do it. Because even if they rehome dogs across Europe, they're still going to have dogs in their kill centre. So why not do some charity work in there?

No one except a vet should be putting any animal to sleep.

But to respond to your comment, we do. Animals that are un-rehomable due to illness/aggression we humanely euthanise at our shelter. We even 'trade' with the city pounds that we will organise to have these animals PTS if you allow us to bring our vet in for a day to neuter the dogs the pound. We don't want to rehome dogs to the UK, we actually lose money by doing so - it costs around £550 per dog to bring it (legally and safely) to the UK. We charge a £300 adoption fee. For every dog we rehome in the UK we home another 3 in the country we operate.

But - I cannot stress this enough - pounds there aren't like here. Some city pounds don't even have workers there from Fri eve-sunday morning, so the dogs are not fed/cleaned in that time. One pound (that we have since taken over) used to put small dogs in with big dogs on a Friday night so the big dogs would kill and eat the small ones. One vet (now in jail) was stitching up bitches after neutering with ribbon "for fun". These dogs were dying in agony.

I cannot describe the levels of depravity SOME (not all) Eastern European shelters succumb to. During the floods a few years ago we went to a flooding shelter and BEGGED them to release all their 36 dogs to us. They refused, left all the dogs chained in cages. They all drowned. To them this was a gift - their shelter was empty. They made their money (they get paid per dog that leaves the shelter whether dead or alive) by getting rid of all the dogs AND they got to laugh at us for caring about 'stupid dogs'.

And, of course, there is legal resistance within the countries. We cannot just walk into a shelter and euthanise them all, even if we wanted to. (And we don't).

You may not agree, and that's fine, but in my very experienced opinion I am absolutely comfortable prioritising dogs in these countries over UK dogs. I have also adopted amazing dogs from UK shelters, and I absolutely will again, but their fate is nothing compared to those in Eastern EU countries.

mountainsunsets · 18/08/2022 10:24

People who work in rescue centres get minimum wage. They work there because they love the animals. You think they'd prefer to see them pts rather than in a good home?

The minimum wage workers and the volunteers aren't the ones who set the criteria for rehoming though.

And the criteria for rehoming are ridiculous. We were turned down because we had cats and because our garden was too small and also because DH's parents (who live round the corner) would be helping with the dog occasionally Hmm

We got a puppy who is now four - he lives happily with three cats, has an amazing relationship with my in-laws and is walked for hours a day and comes to work with me so is rarely left.

WhenISnappedAndFarted · 18/08/2022 10:17

I've got a dog from Romania.

He's a collie crossed with something. He's absolutely gorgeous, he isn't feral at all but he is hard work.

I didn't know he was from Romania when I saw his picture on the website and fell in love with him.

supertedious · 18/08/2022 10:16

We adopted beautiful puppy then 6 months old from Romania. He was found on the streets and in a terrible state.
We had a number of extensive home checks and we had to proof that the dog would be registered with a vet. We were offered a lot of UK based support and follow ups.
Our now 3 year old boy is the sweetest and most affectionate dog and so gentle with our children. I would trust him more then our older home bred JR who we have had since a puppy.

Yes we took a risk but then getting any dog is a risk to an extent. A good nature is not guaranteed in any animal.

Orangello · 18/08/2022 10:14

🙄 That's not true.

OK guess all the people on this thread saying they were unable to adopt in the UK are lying then and are all actually Cruella DeVille in disguise?

We are not suitable to adopt as we work and have small children.
We have 2 Eastern European dogs who have the best life a dog could ask for. But apparently what we could offer was still not 'appropriate' for any UK rescue we approached.

I don't doubt volunteers are compassionate and doing what they think is best for dogs, but the 'best' seems to be close to utopia. To say that a dog is better in a shelter than in a home on a main street, like a pp posted?

A580Hojas · 18/08/2022 10:13

"Meanwhile thousands of healthy, nice - natured dogs in rescue centres and stray kennels are put to sleep every year. And why? Because it's now a status symbol to say you got your dog from abroad."

But this totally isn't true is it? Enough people have said on this thread that it is nigh on impossible to rescue a dog from the established UK rescues.

mountainsunsets · 18/08/2022 10:10

I don't agree with importing foreign rescues but I also don't agree with how restrictive UK charities are when it comes to the rehoming process.

It's almost impossible to adopt in this country if you have children, other animals, a job or a small garden. No wonder people buy from breeders or go abroad.

CentralBark · 18/08/2022 10:09

shortandpaleandoldandugly · 18/08/2022 09:57

I know two people who have adopted from Romania. One works full time, lives alone in a desperately messy house that you'd have to see to believe (think hoarder tendencies) and has also got several cats and various other pets. There's no way she'd have passed a UK home check. The other lives in an upstairs flat with no access to a garden and very little room inside. Again, would not have been accepted by a UK rescue. In both cases a refusal would have been absolutely the right thing. Instead, they brought two more dogs into the country. I struggle to get behind that as a positive thing to be honest.

I do think that's terrible. Our homes all have to pass rigourous home checks much like UK rescues, and we check in on the dogs regularly.

It's sad, but due to the appalling conditions for stray dogs in places like Romania, some Romanian rescues are little more than a lone desperate dog lover. The way they see it is ANY home is better than the dog staying in Romania, and the see the UK as some magical place of wealth and kindness. But I agree, the home you detailed sounds inappropriate for any pet.