Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Brexit has robbed us of so much?

512 replies

elzober · 17/08/2022 22:44

A friend of mine from America recently obtained citizenship of an EU country due to family links. She's now ready to look for a job and open to anything as she doesn't have a degree but worked in the family agricultural business back home. She's fluent in English.

A few years ago I would have been able to invite her to stay with me here in the UK, help her get established and set her up to apply for one of the many jobs over here. But now I can't do any of that.

The ridiculous part is I know local businesses that are really struggling to recruit, can't find people locally and have struggled with the lack of EU workers since Brexit. Particularly in hospitality, agriculture and travel.

Why did we close the door to people who filled these vacancies and contributed to society and paid taxes?

She would have been a decent tax payer, nice member of the community but she's not allowed in.

She's probably going to Ireland now as apparently there's lots more opportunities there since we became an isolated island.

I will never forgive the Conservatives for this shambles. Don't get me started on the fact that a British passport is now worthless and we've lost our right to live in 27 countries. Madness.

OP posts:
BlueberryMuffin817 · 21/08/2022 12:21

@Bubblebubblebah A "large employer" is one that has an annual turnover of over £10.2m. A £1400 fee every four years is pretty negligible. As is paying an extra £1000 on top of each employee's salary. I suspect most employer's probably price this in and offer a slightly lower salary. As I said, the majority of the cost is paid by the employee. That's like saying wages shouldn't ever go up because prices might get higher.

Companies are not forced to become sponsors. They have to decide there is a business need and choose to apply. It's a pretty drawn out process so if a company decides to go through it they clearly think the small cost is worth it to access a wider pool of talent.

BlueberryMuffin817 · 21/08/2022 12:12

@Alexandra2001 @Rosewaterblossom

Just to clarify there was never any requirement under the RLMT that it be advertised throughout the entire EU. Advertising requirements were as follows.

"In order to satisfy the RLMT, employers must advertise the position for a minimum period of 28 days. The advertisement must have full details on the position, including the job title, the job description, an indication of salary, skills and qualifications required, location(s) of employment, and closing date for applications.

The role must also be advertised in at least two places as listed in the Sponsor Guidance issued by UK Visas and Immigration. These include, but are not limited to, national newspapers, the internet, and recruitment agencies."

Basically the employer needs to show they made a good effort to recruit someone who doesn't need to be sponsored and hasn't created an impossible job description and advertised it for a day in order to hire a specific person.

However, keep in mind that people don't usually discuss their immigration status. You may very well work with people from lots of different countries but it doesn't mean they are here on a work visa. Their visa could be dependent on their marriage, family, or ancestry. They could be on the Youth Mobility scheme, a student visa, or an entrepreneurial visa. They may also have Indefinite Leave to Remain or dual citizenship. None of these people will have restrictions on what jobs they can take. Only someone whose status in the UK is tied to their employment will need a job to sponsor them and thus would have been subjected to the RLMT under the old rules.

It's also helpful to keep this in mind when the government talks about visa numbers, as it will include all these categories, not just people coming to work. You even need a visa if you come over to work in a creative field or as a professional sportsperson! A lot of these visa holders will be spouses or family members of British Citizens. And quite often one immigrant will have applied for multiple visas over their time in the UK so every new visa issued does not mean someone new has entered the country (I personally have had 5 if you count my student visa from 12 years ago).

Anewdayanewdawn · 21/08/2022 11:39

‘The same people against Brexit would have been against the end of apartheid in South Africa,’

yup. Lots of similarities…

Anewdayanewdawn · 21/08/2022 11:39

Agreed OP. I’m a duel National, as our my kids through me and I’m glad they still have the option to be Europeans as well as British.
PS if the friend has an Irish passport they can still live/work etc in the U.K.

SerendipityJane · 21/08/2022 11:35

The same people against Brexit would have been against the end of apartheid in South Africa,

As someone whose mother was arrested in an anti apartheid demonstration, how fucking dare you. Just how fucking dare you.

ParsleySageRosemary · 21/08/2022 11:35

Nevertheless being poor in the south east or in London itself is to have many more opportunities open to you than somewhere in the north that most southerners wouldn’t be able to locate on a map. In terms of funding, the diversity of people and languages, and in terms of ease of transport. It is a very different proposition to transport oneself to Europe from the valleys of Wales, the ends of Cornwall or the north than it is from the south east.

Crikeyalmighty · 21/08/2022 11:09

@ParsleySageRosemary As someone who lived in a midlands mining town till I was 30, got divorced and moved 'down south' a lot of this is true, however these poor grotty areas do exist all over , Bristol is full of them as is Southampton, Swindon, Reading etc. on a recent holiday in Majorca it was an eye opener listening to many 'working class families' conversations and were clearly on their 3rd or 4th holiday abroad that year and many were from the north west and midlands. Working class as Brits tend to define it covers a wide range of assets and income levels and is not a geographical thing. We used to live below an elderly but very posh lady who clearly had very little money - poverty isn't just a preserve of big northern council estates. I'm not a Tory at all but there does seem to be an attitude that poverty only exists in sink hole areas- it's not true, it's more complicated than that.

Camomila · 21/08/2022 11:06

There was nowhere in Europe where British people could go and do that.

Wages don't necessarily need to be higher to have a better quality of life though - especially of the COL is lower and the weather is better.

Tinytinseltown · 21/08/2022 11:01

Just to really boil it down, I feel like it’s a simple as the company you keep.

Best Remain people: ordinary people pissed off with the elites
Best Leave people: also ordinary people pissed off with the elites

Worst Remain people: some bankers, some tories, some international figures and institutions you don’t personally like
Worst Leave people: Britain First, the EDL, the BNP, the DUP, UKIP, the Traditional Britain Group (who supported apartheid, lest we forget), the nutter wing of the tories (including the ERG), the nutter wing of Labour, other bankers (who seem to have bet against the pound for their own gain…), every anti-women’s rights activist group, and so on and so on

If you have come to the same conclusion as the latter, then you need to accept you’re on the side of the bad guys, even if you personally don’t feel like you’re a bad person. ‘Leave’ is the one position that seems to have paleoconservatives, neofascists, asset stripping bankers, and Marxists on the same side. Whatever you may think, they most definitely don’t give a shit about you, and Brexit was never about helping out ordinary people.
🤷

notimagain · 21/08/2022 10:56

That's interesting, however I'll be honest and say the picture you paint doesn't quite square with what I heard when of members of my former professional body lobbied "the EU" over a series of legislative issues that would effect us as a workforce. Those that were at the coal face of negotiations talked at length to MEPs, not commissioners, and ultimately it was the MEPs, not commission members, who had the final say by way of a vote over whether such legislation should enacted EU wide or not.

Ultimately it didn't do us much good because the industry bosses did a better job of lobbying the MEPs than our lot did..but ultimately in that instance it was the MEPs who voted to change the rules, after a lobbying process, it was not a change done on the hoof by unelected bureaucrats.

Thesefeetaremadeforwalking · 21/08/2022 10:29

@notimagain

Remind us what Nigel Farage did for a living for a few years?...

He was a Commodities Trader before he was an MEP

I don't recall him being a bureaucrat and he was certainly elected to a parliament.

Agreed

However, the EU parliament is not democratic. To call it a 'parliament' is an oxymoron. The main assertion of democratic illegitimacy focuses on the European Parliament lacking the power to determine the direction of EU Law, with the European Commission being the only institution empowered to initiate legislation and having a near monopoly on legislative initiative.

The European Commission is a non-elected institution. It's members take an oath to put the interests of the EU before those of the Member States

MEPs do not have the ability to create legislation only to vote; yes/no/abstain.

Hard-core socialists like Skinner and Corbyn did not support the concept of the EU on the grounds of non-democracy. Socialism itself is democratic, seen as the highest democratic form by its proponents and at one point being one and the same with democracy.
Therefore I can't for the life of me understand why any socialist would not support Brexit.

ParsleySageRosemary · 21/08/2022 09:54

are locally called middle class.

And, to clarify because it seems to need saying, are, in local terms, very well off. I knew no one else like me at Uni.

ParsleySageRosemary · 21/08/2022 09:43

Bubblebubblebah · 21/08/2022 08:07

I still don't understand why british working class couldn't utilise the free movement like others did. I really think some aspect of "going to work in warehouse/hospitality/manufacture/trade abroad (or here for many snyway)is below us" was in play. Or was it the lack if other languages?

I think you don’t fully understand one of the following: the geography of Britain, the poverty levels in some parts of the country, the insularity that can be a direct result, the lack of education, the politics and attitudes inherent in a class system… oh lots of things.

I grew up poor on a typical squalid northern estate. Left home to go to Uni at 18 with what my parents gave me which was little enough. I did not even have sufficient clothing. The idea of spending whatever it was then, £60 on a passport and then on travelling over to the continent would have been laughable when I could barely afford to pay rent and feed myself. I knew plenty who could not have afforded to go to Uni - just in terms of travel - even had they got the results, and why try hard to get them when you know that.

I know several people who have still never been abroad in their lives, who think the next town is a foreign country. The kind of people who went abroad even to do crap work as students, whom southerners insist on calling ‘working class’ because they come from the north and not landed estates, are locally called middle class.

Living in that kind of environment means you do not hear other languages and rarely get the chance to learn them. Again why even bother trying against those kind of odds.

Honestly a lot of mumsnet posters really need to learn more about their own country, and recognise the impact of both geography and regional inequality.

Tinytinseltown · 21/08/2022 09:41

Thesefeetaremadeforwalking · 21/08/2022 09:30

@Figmentofmyimagination

When expressed as a political ideology, nationalism holds that territorial communities called nations are necessary for human flourishing and that each nation should therefore be accorded a degree of autonomy in determining its own affairs. This idea provides the rationale for self-determination in world politics. Communities that can legitimately claim that they are a ‘nation’ should, , have a right to self-determination.

But it seems you don't believe in the concept of UK running our own affairs, you'd rather have some unelected bureaucrats in Brussels telling us what to do?

The 'nanny-state' mentality of you and your ilk is what is wrecking this country because people no longer want to take responsibility for anything.

Nationalism arose in the 1800s as a post Westphalian idea that nations exist as a largely ethnically and linguistically homogenous whole and that they would be sovereign equals on that basis. It was bullshit then, and it’s bullshit now. Nationalism only works if you’re the biggest country, and in that country it only works if you’re the biggest ethnic group in that country. Wow betide you if you aren’t either of those things.

Moreover, it’s the 21st century. If you think even for a second you should be able to accept that countries do not objectively exist, they’re a product of history, accident and occasionally design, but ultimately they’re a power structure we hold in our heads as we are story telling animals - same was we ‘accept’ that a company or a bank exists, but it doesn’t actually, it’s just people.

if you start putting the rights of imaginary concepts above individual people then we’re all screwed. Nationalism is about the most intellectually lazy ideology out there, which is why it’s flourished in the mass communication age. I’m young enough to be called a digital native, but old enough to just about remember dial up, and it’s amazing to watch how many ‘free thinkers’ living in the online world are just mass consuming other people’s opinions (often people who have something to profit out of it) and parroting their lies; it’s exactly what happened with Brexit, and it’s still going on to this day.

notimagain · 21/08/2022 09:40

But it seems you don't believe in the concept of UK running our own affairs, you'd rather have some unelected bureaucrats in Brussels telling us what to do?

Ah, great, if all else fails it's back to conflating the commission and the parliament.

Remind us what Nigel Farage did for a living for a few years?...I don't recall him being a bureaucrat and he was certainly elected to a parliament.

AndreaC74 · 21/08/2022 09:39

Where in Europe could British people earn enough in tourism to be able to work for a few years, return home and buy a house? There wasn't anywhere

Thats irrelevant, as no one working in a whole host of jobs here in the UK can afford to buy a house or afford rent in most parts of the Uk.
FWIW, i and many others earned a lot of money working in the EU but not in tourism, it also gave me the skills to get a much better job than i previously had in the UK.

We do not need migrant labour, at least not in anything like the amount we had in the EU. Just pay British people high enough wages to make the job attractive. If you can't do that, you don't have a viable job to offer, you need to restructure your business or close it down

Sorry but thats not true at all, there are simply not enough of us (of working age) so Aldi pay more, care workers leave to work for Aldi, and with just 375k long term unemployed, many of who are, bluntly, unemployable, who does the care work? (replace care work with a whole host of jobs we have shortages in) perhaps you think there are 110k nhs staff sat at home?

If there wasn't the jobs, the EU workers wouldn't have come here... employers don't employ people for the fun of it and many filled skilled roles, there weren't all picking fruit.

The same people against Brexit would have been against the end of apartheid in South Africa, or the end of Slavery in the US. Moaning about how terrible it would be for the economy and how everyone would be worse off. They were correct in the short term, when you have an economy built around having a ready supply of cheap or free labour, when that ends it will take a lot of time for things to get better. But it doesn't mean it's not the right thing to do, for everyone

I campaigned against Apartheid, nonsensical to compare the two, Brexit cuts us off from one of the worlds richest trading blocs..

I wouldn't be soooo against Brexit IF we had a decent trading arrangement with the EU but we don't, we have a very poor agreement, made worse by the NI protocol and the dangers to the GFA, where there probably isn't a solution that enables free UK trade and protects the EU from some of the stuff we intend to import.
We cannot even protect our highly successful life sciences from the effects of Brexit, removed from 3 v important science projects.

Florenz · 21/08/2022 09:31

I'm no fan of the Tories. But they did have a referendum, and did make Brexit happen. Now that we're out and as long as Labour do not make overtures about going back into the EU, I think Labour will gain votes from people that switched to the Tories in the last few elections.

Thesefeetaremadeforwalking · 21/08/2022 09:30

@Figmentofmyimagination

When expressed as a political ideology, nationalism holds that territorial communities called nations are necessary for human flourishing and that each nation should therefore be accorded a degree of autonomy in determining its own affairs. This idea provides the rationale for self-determination in world politics. Communities that can legitimately claim that they are a ‘nation’ should, , have a right to self-determination.

But it seems you don't believe in the concept of UK running our own affairs, you'd rather have some unelected bureaucrats in Brussels telling us what to do?

The 'nanny-state' mentality of you and your ilk is what is wrecking this country because people no longer want to take responsibility for anything.

wheredidIleavemystyle · 21/08/2022 09:26

Florenz · 21/08/2022 02:20

This thread is ridiculous. So many people just hate Brexit and aren't prepared to listen to reason. There's a reason why Brexit won the vote in the first place, because people were suffering and not being listened to and there was a once in a lifetime opportunity to make their feelings known.

You were had. The very people causing your suffering were the ones who used your discontent to offer you a "solution" that isn't going to help one bit, instead it'll make everything so much worse. They lied to you and are still lying to you.

These fuckers are exploiting you - and me, and everyone who's not a multi millionaire. The Tories used to stand for small business at least, they don't even stand for that now.

They are about to attack our working rights and human rights. It's fucking bleak.

What will it take for those who voted Brexit because they believed the Tory lies to realise they're being conned? When are you going to get angry?

We really need you to get angry and help us vote these fuckers out, they are parasites and can't be trusted. Boris Johnson didn't even believe in Brexit, he was a Remainder! He only switched sides because he saw it was an opportunity for him to get into power. Brexit happened because of the utterly selfish egos of two men wanting power, neither of whom actually wanted Brexit (Cameron also).

And now he's been kicked out, the two new candidates will both give us more of the same.

How much longer are you going to let these people play you for fools?

MrsRuggles · 21/08/2022 09:23

CareeringLi · 21/08/2022 02:14

I could have nuanced, statistic-driven, data-analysed conversations about Brexit 'til the sun sets on the sunny uplands.

But in a nutshell:

Brexit is a jagged, deep, pointless, disastrous self-inflicted wound.

Brexit is already undermining safety standards across the board - from safety at work to food standards, from rivers to drinking water.

Anyone defending Brexit is a fucking moron.

Politically, it's the sick, propped-up, gasping-for-life elephant in the room. Utter madness.

Brexit will never not make me fucking angry.

Thank you.

Florenz · 21/08/2022 09:21

AndreaC74 · 21/08/2022 08:52

There was nowhere in Europe where British people could go and do that

I did & many people i knew worked in Germany in the 80s and 90s.

Over 100k British people worked abroad in tourism alone.

We have an aging population, we need migrant labour, the EU enabled that, with a mobile workforce that could and has, quickly gone home, migrant labour from South Asia will a: be no where near as well qualified and b: will never return.

Where in Europe could British people earn enough in tourism to be able to work for a few years, return home and buy a house? There wasn't anywhere.

We do not need migrant labour, at least not in anything like the amount we had in the EU. Just pay British people high enough wages to make the job attractive. If you can't do that, you don't have a viable job to offer, you need to restructure your business or close it down.

The same people against Brexit would have been against the end of apartheid in South Africa, or the end of Slavery in the US. Moaning about how terrible it would be for the economy and how everyone would be worse off. They were correct in the short term, when you have an economy built around having a ready supply of cheap or free labour, when that ends it will take a lot of time for things to get better. But it doesn't mean it's not the right thing to do, for everyone.

MrsRuggles · 21/08/2022 09:20

Mississipi71 · 17/08/2022 23:02

It hasn't robbed me of anything.

Well ... because of brexit you now live in a country that performing very poorly economically. We have the worst inflation of the G7. Because of brexit. We have empty shelves and more expensive food and goods. EU countries have full shelves with cheaper food. Other countries are recovering from the Covid effects. We are not. The only country to have had brexited themselves.

Our country has lost international clout. NZ cannot understand why we have done a deal that benefits them and undercuts our farmers. Look at the contrast between the EU/Australia deal and the UK/Australia deal.

We've lost workers in healthcare - have you wondered why we have lost so many doctors, dentists, vets, carers? Drivers left and still have not been replaced.

So much more, beyond the scope of a MN post that anyone will read.

wheredidIleavemystyle · 21/08/2022 09:12

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 17/08/2022 23:28

What is the point of this thread? Brexit was an awful decision in my view, but it has happened and we won't be able to rejoin for decades, if ever. These threads just stir the shit and cause fights.

The people who "got Brexit done" are still in power. That's why it matters and why we still need to talk about it.

And, Brexit is far from "done". The next stage will be removing our human rights, again by appealing to racism and xenophobia but we will all lose out.

Liz Truss has talked about what's being called a "bonfire of rights" should she get to power, getting rid of human rights - each remaining EU law and regulation would be “evaluated on the basis of whether it supports UK growth or boosts investment”, with those deemed to do so replaced in new UK law. Any EU laws not replaced would simply disappear at the end of 2023.

Article: Truss vows to scrap remaining EU laws by end of 2023 risking ‘bonfire of rights’

If you're not scared by this, you should be. What pesky rights are they going to remove to make it easier for companies to exploit us and harder for us to seek legal recourse if our rights have been violated. Whatever they do it'll likely disproportionately impact the most marginalised including women and children .

Sunak is no better, he has the same politics and will do the same.

People need to realise that the Tories are toxic, they are not on our side (us being anyone except the ultra-rich). We need to vote these fuckers out, they at destroying our country and our children's futures.

Lonelycrab · 21/08/2022 08:59

Brexit was a particularly nasty brand of English nationalism and is yet another good example of why nationalism is a pernicious, divisive, and destructive force

Yup. Brings out the twats, spouting bullshit. Bullshit, bullshit, everywhere, spouted even from the heart of government now.

Lonelycrab · 21/08/2022 08:57

So the solution to working class people who couldn't get a decent job in the UK was to go to France to work at a ski chalet in the Alps

Oh nonsense I never said that, poor attempt at twisting things round. I was actually working in a factory as a packer at the time my friends were away, is that working class enough for you?

They went because they wanted to see a bit of the world around them whilst working. Something kids can’t do anymore. They went because they wanted to, and they could. Not because they had too. Ffs talk about clutching at straws lol

Swipe left for the next trending thread