Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Brexit has robbed us of so much?

512 replies

elzober · 17/08/2022 22:44

A friend of mine from America recently obtained citizenship of an EU country due to family links. She's now ready to look for a job and open to anything as she doesn't have a degree but worked in the family agricultural business back home. She's fluent in English.

A few years ago I would have been able to invite her to stay with me here in the UK, help her get established and set her up to apply for one of the many jobs over here. But now I can't do any of that.

The ridiculous part is I know local businesses that are really struggling to recruit, can't find people locally and have struggled with the lack of EU workers since Brexit. Particularly in hospitality, agriculture and travel.

Why did we close the door to people who filled these vacancies and contributed to society and paid taxes?

She would have been a decent tax payer, nice member of the community but she's not allowed in.

She's probably going to Ireland now as apparently there's lots more opportunities there since we became an isolated island.

I will never forgive the Conservatives for this shambles. Don't get me started on the fact that a British passport is now worthless and we've lost our right to live in 27 countries. Madness.

OP posts:
Stopsnowing · 18/08/2022 02:17

This country has got a shortage of care workers health workers hospitality workers and agricultural workers. And is in a crisis Blame Brexit. We are now stuck on a small island.

EdBallsDay · 18/08/2022 02:15

Bloody hell, I will try one more time.

Standards of living in many other EU countries are higher. Per capita income is higher in many. They also had freedom of movement. More UK citizens moved to other EU countries using freedom of movement than EU citizens emigrating from any other EU nation. Yet salaries in those other countries and working conditions did not always deteriorate. If the issue of low salaries and poor working conditions was caused by EU migration, why would it affect the UK and not, say, Denmark or Germany or France? The answer is that they have robust employment legislation, to protect employees.

You have swallowed propaganda and are blaming the wrong people. Stagnation of salaries was primarily due to poor regulation and poor productivity due to a lack of investment or economic strategy. I.e. caused entirely by the UK Government. Hence them feeding you xenophobic lies to make you blame migrants.

Do you grasp logic sufficiently to discern that this demonstrates that the causal link you are claiming between EU migration to the UK and poor salaries is false?

WAKE UP!!

Sandra1984 · 18/08/2022 01:48

@Rosewaterblossom The argument was about what they are paid to do that 40 hour week in the first place, which wasn't enough for many years.

The salary seemed to be enough for the EU workers. I’m a EU migrant myself and all my friends serving coffee and waitressing in restaurants were perfectly making a living, (some of them even saving money).
None of them were living in council flats, buying flat screens or applying for benefits (as you need to pay taxes for 7 years before applying for any benefit if you’re an EU migrant). I really don’t understand what’s the beef with all this “oh the exploited EU migrants!” that some English people love to boast about.

Rosewaterblossom · 18/08/2022 01:34

EdBallsDay · 18/08/2022 01:30

Jesus Christ. Obviously the economic contribution of a person to society is calculated by taking their tax contribution and subtracting the costs they exact on services. If the answer is positive, they are adding economic value. If the answer is negative, then despite paying some tax they are net recipients of state subsidy i.e. being supported by those who do put in more economic value than they take out. EU migrants in the UK as a whole fell into the former group. The majority of UK citizens fall into the latter and are being carried by other taxpayers.

This is basic addition and subtraction, how do you not get it??

I can have a more rational discussion than this with my three year old. You have clearly had a propaganda overdose, do not understand economics or tax or international trade and are unwilling to look at facts and learn about these things, either.

How depressing.

I'm out.

A worker doing say 40 hours per week who falls in the tax bracket will be contributing tax etc great and your argumentis valid. Buts its not about that.

The argument was about what they are paid to do that 40 hour week in the first place, which wasn't enough for many years.

EdBallsDay · 18/08/2022 01:30

Jesus Christ. Obviously the economic contribution of a person to society is calculated by taking their tax contribution and subtracting the costs they exact on services. If the answer is positive, they are adding economic value. If the answer is negative, then despite paying some tax they are net recipients of state subsidy i.e. being supported by those who do put in more economic value than they take out. EU migrants in the UK as a whole fell into the former group. The majority of UK citizens fall into the latter and are being carried by other taxpayers.

This is basic addition and subtraction, how do you not get it??

I can have a more rational discussion than this with my three year old. You have clearly had a propaganda overdose, do not understand economics or tax or international trade and are unwilling to look at facts and learn about these things, either.

How depressing.

I'm out.

Rosewaterblossom · 18/08/2022 01:27

Sandra1984 · 18/08/2022 01:20

Of course they’re gasping, you just lost a whole work force of very efficient workers in hospitality, factories, agriculture and careers etc… etc.. who gave no problems and paid their taxes. Now there not enough people to fill those jobs. Factories, restaurants and hospitals are all gasping. And minimum wage was raised a year ago. Still no workers. Were are the miríads of English people waiting to fill those jobs? Are they at home waiting for the minimum salary to be raised again?

The minimum wages rise was forced upon employers (rightly so) because wage rises were so stagnant for so long, workers could no longer afford to live on their salaries. Its still not a living wage even now, a living wage British people are wanting yes because they aren't cheap labour like employers have become accustomed to.

HRTQueen · 18/08/2022 01:27

I think there are bigger issues than it’s not so easy for me to go and work in Spain there are areas that desperately need EU workers but this is also cheap labour we need to be paying people a decent wage regardless of where they are from

the world is a changing palace, I know a number of people (from here and other parts of Europe) who are now going to work in the Middle East and South East Asia people follow money its not here as it once was

I think companies/NHS/social care agencies will most likely start working closer with the government to support workers coming over but is it as attractive here we are about to hit a recession and rocketing prices for fuel but life is much easier here than many countries

Having a British passport is a bonus compared to the vast majority of countries, we are not viewed as being a population who migrates for work or that we may go missing once our visa expires (though met a number who did in Australia)

Rosewaterblossom · 18/08/2022 01:22

EdBallsDay · 18/08/2022 01:20

Who said they weren't paying tax?

Again, what are you on about?

I said they were net contributors. I.e. the paid more in tax than they used in services such as the NHS, education, social housing or claiming in benefits.

A large majority of the UK population are net recipients, i.e. they take more out of the system than they put in.

Ergo, EU citizens living and working in the UK were subsidising the UK citizens here, as well as filling critical roles and skills shortages.

Where did I say they didn't pay tax? Do you have any grasp of the very basics of economics?

No one said anything about what they were taking out in services. The argument was about wages and employers exploiting it.

Sandra1984 · 18/08/2022 01:20

Rosewaterblossom · 18/08/2022 01:11

If that were true people wouldn't be gasping at the losses of thousands of workers across the lower pay scale board in catering/hospitality/NHS/carers/cleaners/farming etc.

Of course they’re gasping, you just lost a whole work force of very efficient workers in hospitality, factories, agriculture and careers etc… etc.. who gave no problems and paid their taxes. Now there not enough people to fill those jobs. Factories, restaurants and hospitals are all gasping. And minimum wage was raised a year ago. Still no workers. Were are the miríads of English people waiting to fill those jobs? Are they at home waiting for the minimum salary to be raised again?

EdBallsDay · 18/08/2022 01:20

Who said they weren't paying tax?

Again, what are you on about?

I said they were net contributors. I.e. the paid more in tax than they used in services such as the NHS, education, social housing or claiming in benefits.

A large majority of the UK population are net recipients, i.e. they take more out of the system than they put in.

Ergo, EU citizens living and working in the UK were subsidising the UK citizens here, as well as filling critical roles and skills shortages.

Where did I say they didn't pay tax? Do you have any grasp of the very basics of economics?

Rosewaterblossom · 18/08/2022 01:20

EdBallsDay · 18/08/2022 01:17

And you don't think that some well-qualified people might be required for the NHS or agriculture etc?

Honestly. 🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️

Eh

EdBallsDay · 18/08/2022 01:17

And you don't think that some well-qualified people might be required for the NHS or agriculture etc?

Honestly. 🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️

Rosewaterblossom · 18/08/2022 01:17

EdBallsDay · 18/08/2022 01:15

If that were true people wouldn't be gasping at the losses of thousands of workers across the lower pay scale board in catering/hospitality/NHS/carers/cleaners/farming etc.

What? You don't understand that it could be possible thaz some people left these industries and far more left professional positions - often in our essential services - at the same time?

It isn't a case of "if that were true". EU migrants as a whole were net contributors to UK tax, consistently. There are robust studies that proved this, time and again. Look them up.

Who said they weren't paying tax?

EdBallsDay · 18/08/2022 01:15

If that were true people wouldn't be gasping at the losses of thousands of workers across the lower pay scale board in catering/hospitality/NHS/carers/cleaners/farming etc.

What? You don't understand that it could be possible thaz some people left these industries and far more left professional positions - often in our essential services - at the same time?

It isn't a case of "if that were true". EU migrants as a whole were net contributors to UK tax, consistently. There are robust studies that proved this, time and again. Look them up.

ilovesooty · 18/08/2022 01:13

MotherofPearl · 17/08/2022 23:28

When these problems were mentioned they were immediately dismissed as 'Project Fear', remember?

Agreed, but it's pretty obvious how this thread is going to go.

Rosewaterblossom · 18/08/2022 01:11

EdBallsDay · 18/08/2022 01:08

Low wages were due to UK political decisions to have a low-regulated employment market. Data showed consistently for many years than on average EU migrants to the UK were kore highly educated, more qualified, less likely to claim any kind of benefits or use the NHS or live in social housing than the average UK citizen, and were on average net taxpayers not net recipients like the majority of the UK population. We should have thanked them a lot, not made them feel unwelcome. Trying looking at some data.

If that were true people wouldn't be gasping at the losses of thousands of workers across the lower pay scale board in catering/hospitality/NHS/carers/cleaners/farming etc.

EdBallsDay · 18/08/2022 01:08

Rosewaterblossom · 18/08/2022 01:01

It's not the EU workers that were the problem per se, it was the fact employers could get away with paying them less and they'd work under poorer conditions which seems to have set a precedent.

Low wages were due to UK political decisions to have a low-regulated employment market. Data showed consistently for many years than on average EU migrants to the UK were kore highly educated, more qualified, less likely to claim any kind of benefits or use the NHS or live in social housing than the average UK citizen, and were on average net taxpayers not net recipients like the majority of the UK population. We should have thanked them a lot, not made them feel unwelcome. Trying looking at some data.

Rosewaterblossom · 18/08/2022 01:04

elzober · 18/08/2022 00:56

Yeah it's typical Brexiteer behaviour. Blame it all on the EU and the migrants and ignore the other side

Or ignore the fact we are now suffering because our wages have stagnated from cheap labour from the EU for too many years.

Rosewaterblossom · 18/08/2022 01:01

It's not the EU workers that were the problem per se, it was the fact employers could get away with paying them less and they'd work under poorer conditions which seems to have set a precedent.

Lunar270 · 18/08/2022 01:01

OP. I mostly try to forget about Brexit but so much of my work/industry involves collaboration with EU countries. I've lost umpteen excellent colleagues over the years because they've all buggered off. These were high paid professionals that we no longer have.

Personally I love driving/touring on the mainland but stuff waiting at Dover during the holiday season.

I could go on but agree totally. We need to try and make the most of Brexit but it really is shit.

EdBallsDay · 18/08/2022 00:59

And anybody who isn't seriously angry about it clearly hasn't looked up any of the data, even 6 years later. The mind boggles.

EdBallsDay · 18/08/2022 00:58

Also doesn't help when the Government makes exporting so impractical and expensive by imposing huge red tape (oh the irony) that our balance of payments deficit rises from 2% to 8%. What effect do people think that has had on exchange rates??

I mean, really. Anybody complaining about the cost of living crisis who isn't campaigning for Brexit to be reversed is frankly bonkers. We can't do anything about the supply chain shocks caused by Covid, or the war in Ukraine. But this, was shooting ourselves in the foot and head for no benefit whatsoever and was completely avoidable.

Sandra1984 · 18/08/2022 00:57

Rosewaterblossom · 18/08/2022 00:48

Employers will largely pay the minimum they can get away with which they've been allowed to do for far too long. Now they are whining they can't recruit! Well pay people the proper wage instead of exploiting EU workers then! British people will work, like they have done for hundreds of years. But not for the pittance EU workers are happy to be paid.

Minimum wages were raised like a year ago, and despite brexit and all the jazz they’re still very… “minimum”. Maybe the problem is (hold your breath here) not the migruntz but those in power who decide the minimum wages?

elzober · 18/08/2022 00:56

EdBallsDay · 18/08/2022 00:55

Oh dear. There were more migrants from the UK living in other EU nations utilising freedom of movement than had relocated from any other EU country. It's such a shame people spout stuff that is so ignorant and removed from any of the data.

Yeah it's typical Brexiteer behaviour. Blame it all on the EU and the migrants and ignore the other side

OP posts:
EdBallsDay · 18/08/2022 00:55

Rosewaterblossom · 18/08/2022 00:48

Employers will largely pay the minimum they can get away with which they've been allowed to do for far too long. Now they are whining they can't recruit! Well pay people the proper wage instead of exploiting EU workers then! British people will work, like they have done for hundreds of years. But not for the pittance EU workers are happy to be paid.

Oh dear. There were more migrants from the UK living in other EU nations utilising freedom of movement than had relocated from any other EU country. It's such a shame people spout stuff that is so ignorant and removed from any of the data.