Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Brexit has robbed us of so much?

512 replies

elzober · 17/08/2022 22:44

A friend of mine from America recently obtained citizenship of an EU country due to family links. She's now ready to look for a job and open to anything as she doesn't have a degree but worked in the family agricultural business back home. She's fluent in English.

A few years ago I would have been able to invite her to stay with me here in the UK, help her get established and set her up to apply for one of the many jobs over here. But now I can't do any of that.

The ridiculous part is I know local businesses that are really struggling to recruit, can't find people locally and have struggled with the lack of EU workers since Brexit. Particularly in hospitality, agriculture and travel.

Why did we close the door to people who filled these vacancies and contributed to society and paid taxes?

She would have been a decent tax payer, nice member of the community but she's not allowed in.

She's probably going to Ireland now as apparently there's lots more opportunities there since we became an isolated island.

I will never forgive the Conservatives for this shambles. Don't get me started on the fact that a British passport is now worthless and we've lost our right to live in 27 countries. Madness.

OP posts:
Crikeyalmighty · 18/08/2022 15:57

@EdBallsDay Ha--- are you Yvette cooper?? Lol.

EdBallsDay · 18/08/2022 15:56

Crikeyalmighty · 18/08/2022 15:20

@EdBallsDay Indeed as I was saying below-- I'm sure Truss will have some little wheezes in to make sure those rates come down -

The rubbish I have seen too justifying all of it such as 'EU encouraging companies to leave by offering incentives (pre Brexit) other companies were incentivised to actually come here, it's swings and roundabouts and the EU can still offer sweeteners to any company who thinks it now makes more sense to be in the EU. !! We have basically just handed over a ton of our decent business on a plate. If we were all in the same position and EU had collapsed, then yes it would be different , but that isn't the situation.

Haha I know, it's comical isn't it?

Imagine other countries acting in their own best interests and those of their citizens, rather than putting the British first (who have spent years insulting them and lying about them and being xenophobic to them). How very dare they??? It's almost like they take their responsibilities to their own citizens seriously.

They should have ignored their own people and focused on carrying the (largely) English Patient to A&E after it chose to shoot itself in the face.

EdBallsDay · 18/08/2022 15:53

You could say the same of being a devout Christian or Muslim. Brexit is a religious experience, not a political choice. That's why it's worshippers can't see anything wrong with it and how it's going. That's why so many people on this thread are happy to suffer for their Brexit.

I would say this of any ideology with no rational basis that people try to inflict on others and harms society more than it benefits it. So yes.

EdBallsDay · 18/08/2022 15:52

Where are the blowhards who keep ridiculing the great unwashed, illiterate and uneducated voters when it comes to pre-elections? When the information (such as it is) could be useful? They are nowhere, unless it is to say that it's 'not their job to educate'. It doesn't stop them wailing and gnashing their teeth after the fact though.

If by "blowhards", you mean economists like me, we were shouting from the rooftops - publishing data and studies, running public meetings and producing webcasts, explaining the inevitable outcomes of the various options for the British public. Which went in a clear pattern from:

  1. No Brexit - best option;
  2. Stay in single market - some damage but manageable; to
  3. Hard Brexit - permanent and significant damage to the UK economy.

We were told everyone had had enough of us and knew better. Turns out they were wrong about that, too.

SerendipityJane · 18/08/2022 15:49

It's hard to conclude that anybody still supporting this is not either wilfully ignorant or incredibly thick.

You could say the same of being a devout Christian or Muslim. Brexit is a religious experience, not a political choice. That's why it's worshippers can't see anything wrong with it and how it's going. That's why so many people on this thread are happy to suffer for their Brexit.

The Boris Johnson denomination of the Tory party saw that behaviour and thought to themselves "if we could leverage that sentiment to vote for us, we could be in power for ever. Even if we turned out to be the most corrupt and venal government the UK has ever seen, people would still queue up to vote for us".

Why do people think that Brexit is now a thing (despite being "done") in the non event that is the tory leader contest ? Just wait till the election that Truss calls. You'll be hearing about Brexit all over again.

Crikeyalmighty · 18/08/2022 15:30

@LyingWitchInTheWardrobe there was a ton of this pre referendum - the problem is a great many were lied too - remember the 'we aren't planning on leaving the single market ' from so many voteleave people and some people simply didn't want to listen- they swallowed Farages bullshit or Barry's down the pub .

It's a bit like Trump in the USA and 'we are going to open up all the mines again and all that stuff' designed to appeal to those who want easy solutions to frustrations- how much of this actually happened? Zilch

Whammyyammy · 18/08/2022 15:29

You sound so ungrateful OP. We now put so much extra money into the NHS, we control our own borders, and not 1 person claiming benefits for being unemployed now in the uk all this foreigners are taking 'their jobs'.

And you can get a shiny new blue passport.

Definitely winning with brexit....we live in a utopia

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 18/08/2022 15:21

cigiwi, well you can froth and rage as much as you like, it will change nothing. This thread will merely become a facsimile of the others.

I'm disappointed in the leave result, I'm sad for the electorate who misguidedly voted for it. I'm reserving my future for the so-call-government who put us in harm's way and made this possible. That is what is unforgiveable.

I agree with PP that looking at the reasons why voters opted to leave would be a useful endeavour. I think that leave voters reading this thread would opt to do it again in retaliation for the invective and insults (of which there have been many). How is going on and on about it, on a chatboard, going to change anything let alone achieve anything positive?

Where are the blowhards who keep ridiculing the great unwashed, illiterate and uneducated voters when it comes to pre-elections? When the information (such as it is) could be useful? They are nowhere, unless it is to say that it's 'not their job to educate'. It doesn't stop them wailing and gnashing their teeth after the fact though.

We don't have a sound parliament, we have a corrupt government who lies - and that's across all parties. Who the hell are people supposed to trust? I don't know what the answer is, I don't think though that it is to be found on a brexit thread bemoaning what is now a done deal.

I would be very interested to listen/read the people who say they know/are informed because I don't believe that I am. If only we actually had any who would be willing to put a bit of time and energy into that, rather than this.

Crikeyalmighty · 18/08/2022 15:20

@EdBallsDay Indeed as I was saying below-- I'm sure Truss will have some little wheezes in to make sure those rates come down -

The rubbish I have seen too justifying all of it such as 'EU encouraging companies to leave by offering incentives (pre Brexit) other companies were incentivised to actually come here, it's swings and roundabouts and the EU can still offer sweeteners to any company who thinks it now makes more sense to be in the EU. !! We have basically just handed over a ton of our decent business on a plate. If we were all in the same position and EU had collapsed, then yes it would be different , but that isn't the situation.

Brefugee · 18/08/2022 15:19

I actually have more sympathy (although in the long term I think it's short term thinking) for the HGV drivers wives saying they are getting £4 an hour more- at least it's honest

I'm always happy to see anyone (who isn't benefitting from offshoring and betting against UK companies/currency) who can show they are now earning more due to Brexit (unless it's because they are working insane hours due to lack of staff). I would be genuinely happy if someone could show me even the first teeny-tiny green shoots of anything successful that is related to Brexit.

But i just don't see any. I'm not seeing any ideas about where these green shoots might come from. It has happened, it's a fact of life and much as i think it was batshit, we have to live with it. Maybe i just have a lack of imagination.

(actually i met a chap from Scotland over summer who is in an industry that is benefitting from Brexit, so that is good, but it isn't a huge industry and also has limits so personally good for him and his few coworkers, the rest of the country, not so much)

EdBallsDay · 18/08/2022 15:13

Crikeyalmighty · 18/08/2022 15:10

@EdBallsDay You've nailed it in one. There are a few posh mummy's on here (mumsnet- not specifically this thread) defending it to the hilt and I'm hazarding a bet they have benefited from either offshore rules or husbands in banking/currrency/hedge funds .

I actually have more sympathy (although in the long term I think it's short term thinking) for the HGV drivers wives saying they are getting £4 an hour more- at least it's honest and not pretending there are other huge benefits that the rest of us aren't seeing

Sadly their £4 per hour will be more than wiped out by the inflation and devaluation of GBP. In fact, doing some rough mental maths, it has been already and we haven't even entered the 5 quarter recession that's been forecasted yet. Plus inflation forecast to rocket up from 10% now to 13% in the winter.

Fun times.

Crikeyalmighty · 18/08/2022 15:10

@EdBallsDay You've nailed it in one. There are a few posh mummy's on here (mumsnet- not specifically this thread) defending it to the hilt and I'm hazarding a bet they have benefited from either offshore rules or husbands in banking/currrency/hedge funds .

I actually have more sympathy (although in the long term I think it's short term thinking) for the HGV drivers wives saying they are getting £4 an hour more- at least it's honest and not pretending there are other huge benefits that the rest of us aren't seeing

EdBallsDay · 18/08/2022 15:01

Or, one of the very tiny percentage who are making a fortune out of it e.g. betting against GBP on the currency markets.

EdBallsDay · 18/08/2022 15:01

HinchcliffeandMurgatroyd · 18/08/2022 14:35

Yes, what a mystery eh? Not even in the top 20 voter concerns, at all.

Maybe that’s it. Lots of people had an opinion about Europe but everyone considered domestic concerns to be unconnected and much more important?

Because they were. The problems in the UK in 2016 which featured in voter's concerns were entirely down to UK Government policy. Nothing to do with the EU.

Many of our current problems are caused by external forces that we can't control. That said, the horrific failures of UK Government policy over the last few decades have compounded these issues and made them much worse for us than they had to be. No energy security strategy, minimal labour market regulation, no food security strategy, no long-term economic strategy for infrastructure or productivity, no investment in education, no overhaul of our abysmal healthcare and pensions, nothing on food security, poor performance on the environment, care system and social services a mess, austerity so people have no buffer to cope with the next economic shock that would inevitably come eventually, Government ignoring advice on pandemic planning, etc etc.

However, these domestically created problems have been hugely compounded by the many, many negative effects of Brexit. Not least the quadrupling of our balance of payments deficit and the plummetting value of our currency, when due to said Government policies, we are heavily reliant on imports priced in USD. We are literally importing inflation as a direct result of Brexit! Then our Government tells employers not to raise salaries domestically so people can afford to live because the Government itself has ramped up our inflation rate with a hard Brexit.

What an absolutely sick joke. I have a black sense of humour and it would be funny if it was in an episode of Monty Python or something but we have to live with this.

It's hard to conclude that anybody still supporting this is not either wilfully ignorant or incredibly thick.

EdBallsDay · 18/08/2022 14:51

Sorry. I still can't - won't - forgive. 2016 and its aftermath was as much a betrayal of democracy as of ordinary people like me and my family. Resilience, yes of course. Revision of plans, sure. But forgive the lying scum who organised this shitstorm and those thick enough to vote for it against their own interests? Nope.

👏👏👏

Neither will I, until and unless they put it right and show some contrition for the damage they have done.

Crikeyalmighty · 18/08/2022 14:40

@Rosewaterblossom Thing is though that works both ways- I can't just rock up in the USA and live and work regardless of how talented I am unless they specifically require my experience- so whilst this is all well and nice for those in medicine, software, maybe engineering - it's not exactly helpful for those just looking for an office job or are semi retired etc or want to offer dog walking or whatever. With the EU you could do/be whatever without restraint.
'Most ' people coming from EU in recent times were tending to come for a few years and worked in 'hard to fill areas' - most EU professionals were not picking the UK unless very highly paid, highly skilled (surgeons etc) as the general view is that it's expensive in most parts worth living in and you don't get much for your tax money. Yes at the moment wages are going up in lower paid jobs due to shortages, hence why we now partly have higher prices, the costs are passed on to the consumer. I'm pretty sure the Tory's will be soon allowing lots of non EU immigrants in to balance that and making sure anyone who can 'in theory ' work will get benefit reductions if they don't take minimum wage jobs.

HinchcliffeandMurgatroyd · 18/08/2022 14:35

Yes, what a mystery eh? Not even in the top 20 voter concerns, at all.

Maybe that’s it. Lots of people had an opinion about Europe but everyone considered domestic concerns to be unconnected and much more important?

cigiwi · 18/08/2022 14:35

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 18/08/2022 12:09

Brilliant post!Star

All these people who 'won't forgive' and can't move on. Why can't you? We've lost some of the ease but not the ability. I work for a European company and voted to remain but, that's not what we got. Whinging about it achieves nothing and it's tedious.

As for the ludicrous yearning for someone who voted to leave to come onto a thread and 'admit their mistake'? How arrogant and self-serving... and I'm glad that nobody's entertained it.

Many of us didn't get what we wanted. We shouldn't even have been given this as a referendum vote but, we are where are. Time for resilience and revising plans now. Not this endless whining and navel-gazing.

Yes, we who "can't move on", with our "whining and navel-gazing" ... not at all like those who fully accepted the first UK referendum: that two-to-one democratic decision to remain.

Why can't we accept that the British people have spoken, just as Farage and Johnson and all the other true democrats did over 40+ years post '75?

Oh. Wait ...

No. Sorry. I still can't - won't - forgive. 2016 and its aftermath was as much a betrayal of democracy as of ordinary people like me and my family. Resilience, yes of course. Revision of plans, sure. But forgive the lying scum who organised this shitstorm and those thick enough to vote for it against their own interests? Nope.

HinchcliffeandMurgatroyd · 18/08/2022 14:34

@HinchcliffeandMurgatroyd, as I say, it may have been a topic of conversation in your pub 25 years ago (was something happening in the EU at that time?), but a quick look through SM platforms shows little interest in the EU prior to Brexit.

I’m thinking about it now you’ve questioned it, having never considered it unusual before.

I remember the single currency being debated quite a bit. That whole debacle rumbled in in the news for some time, didn’t it, so was “current” for a while. I also remember more sensible people trying to talk sense to others about bent bananas and the metric martyrs. No more so than other news stories of the day such as the good Friday agreement, Madonna signing an unknown singer called Alanis zmorrisette, the 1997 general election, Nr blobby in the charts…Just lots of news items big and small being chewed over.

It never struck me as unusual. I’m still not sure that it was.

EdBallsDay · 18/08/2022 14:25

All of that is fair enough, but it doesn’t reflect the reality that our secondary schools do a produce a sub section of leavers who are functionally illiterate. We have a large underclass in this country who scrape along, are more likely to do prison time, more likely to be long term unemployed, highly unlikely to vote…

It would be interesting to see research into who didn’t use their vote.

I agree. Imagine what all of those squirelled away tax haven funds could have done to start addressing these issues and improve quality if life across the board?

EdBallsDay · 18/08/2022 14:23

@HinchcliffeandMurgatroyd, as I say, it may have been a topic of conversation in your pub 25 years ago (was something happening in the EU at that time?), but a quick look through SM platforms shows little interest in the EU prior to Brexit.

Yes, what a mystery eh? Not even in the top 20 voter concerns, at all.

I wonder why extremely wealthy people threw millions and manipulating the referendum?

Oh yes, the tax havens, as I said above. That is the root cause of all of this. They harnessed the so rage about the poverty they were inflicting and directed it at the wrong people - ironically the EU who was doing something to finally expose how the British public were being mugged by implementing this Directive - so that they could maintain their wealth, and have opportunities to increase it further e.g. JRM moving his investment fund to Ireland and advising his investors that GBP would plummet in value due to Brexit, while publicly claiming it would benefit average UK citizens.

I do struggle to understand how anybody can still believe it was for the benefit of "normal" people in the face of such much proof to the contrary. It is cognitive dissonance of the highest order.

HinchcliffeandMurgatroyd · 18/08/2022 14:20

EdBallsDay · 18/08/2022 14:17

A lot of the people who didn’t understand enough to vote, won’t understand any of it. It’s not always apathy. Somethings it’s capacity. Demographics are very broad. You can’t expect everyone to be bright, politically/engaged and sophisticated.

I expect our education system to give every citizen a broad understand of political structures and how they operate. The ignorance of this in the UK is far greater than in most countries I have spent time in.

And I expect people - before voting on an issue - to do research and look at data and make informed decisions. Or ask experts, or listen to people who are informed rather than insulting them.

All of that is fair enough, but it doesn’t reflect the reality that our secondary schools do a produce a sub section of leavers who are functionally illiterate. We have a large underclass in this country who scrape along, are more likely to do prison time, more likely to be long term unemployed, highly unlikely to vote…

It would be interesting to see research into who didn’t use their vote.

TooBigForMyBoots · 18/08/2022 14:17

EdBallsDay · 18/08/2022 13:45

Bloody hell. Really? That sums it up doesn't it. How can people vote on something when they have no idea what it is, how it functions, what the benefits and costs are?? 😵‍💫🤯 I just cannot understand why they didn't google it beforehand and read one of the many studies available from the various maligned experts in economics who predicted exactly what the effects would be. Project reality indeed.

Along with lies and misrepresentation of facts, the Leave Campaign actively encouraged people not to trust experts. It has had repercussions beyond that though with Covid and other things.

@HinchcliffeandMurgatroyd, as I say, it may have been a topic of conversation in your pub 25 years ago (was something happening in the EU at that time?), but a quick look through SM platforms shows little interest in the EU prior to Brexit.

EdBallsDay · 18/08/2022 14:17

A lot of the people who didn’t understand enough to vote, won’t understand any of it. It’s not always apathy. Somethings it’s capacity. Demographics are very broad. You can’t expect everyone to be bright, politically/engaged and sophisticated.

I expect our education system to give every citizen a broad understand of political structures and how they operate. The ignorance of this in the UK is far greater than in most countries I have spent time in.

And I expect people - before voting on an issue - to do research and look at data and make informed decisions. Or ask experts, or listen to people who are informed rather than insulting them.

EdBallsDay · 18/08/2022 14:15

But they can only afford that with an efficient tax system. All the massive corporations squirreling away their profits in offshore accounts, getting tax subsidies are putting a spanner in that works.

You're not wrong but it won't happen. Brexit was pushed through quickly precisely to protect the tax havens and ensure our exist date meant we never had to implement the EU Anti-Tax Avoidance Directive which would have required public publication of beneficial owners of all of that money. Which would have made the public in the UK very angry, after years of austerity, and inevitably led to the demise of said tax havens, once people realised the scale of it.

This is why many of the individuals who funded the Brexit campaign happen to be extremely wealthy individuals with all of their money stashed in UK tax havens... the idea that these people who profit from poverty and low regulation here did this to raise the salaries of employees that many on this thread have spouted as the reason for Brexit is naive beyond belief.

As always, follow the money.

So in short, you may be right but that will not happen as our political class is captures by these vested interests. Otherwise they would never have pursued a hard Brexit off the back of a vote that was tied within a margin of error, after a campaign of misinformation and lies.

Anybody remember arch Brexiteers insisting during the campaign that nobody was suggesting leaving the single market, because that would be suicidal? All on video, all over the internet. Repeated assurances on that.

They backtracked from that very quickly after the vote because their wealthy backers realised that if in the single market, the Directive would still have to be implemented.