Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Comments my gp left on my health record

163 replies

watermelonlipbalm · 17/08/2022 21:44

Hi all, I'm just wanting an opinion as to whether it was appropriate for a GP to note these comments on my health record.
I've only just really realised that you have access to your medical records via the NHS app so I was having a nosy through them this morning and I was just a bit shocked to see what a GP had wrote.
I had a telephone call with a GP a few weeks ago. I actually obtained the contact details from the practice as to how to put a complaint in about the doctor because she really upset me with her attitude towards me and my worries when we had our telephone appointment. Unfortunately I just haven't gotten around to actually write the email yet, but nevertheless, the conversation did leave me feeling upset.
I won't go into exact detail, but I've been really worried about bleeding between my periods. It was completely unusual for me, it started faintly but ended up being quite heavy and I was passing a few clots aswell. Last year I had some bleeding between my periods, albeit completely different to this. I spoke to the Doctor Who referred me for bloods and a scan immediately. So I don't think it's surprising for me to not expect this to happen again. So when I had a telephone call from her I requested this and she shot me down pretty much straight away. She said that she would want me to bleed for three cycles before they would investigate further. I was quite surprised and just said that I didn't really agree with this and I would like to have bloods and a scan like I did last time. She became very abrupt with me at this point and despite agreeing to refer me she made it abundantly clear she wasn't happy about doing it and even said to me "i'm not gonna sit here on the phone arguing with you when I have other patients to call". The conversation wasn't an argument. It was me expressing my concerns and her not reassuring me enough for me to feel happy leaving the call. Whenever you see Doctors on telly, online, in magazines they're are always telling you that they are happy to help your queries. I did not get the impression from this doctor. And it just really upset me.
Anyway going back to the app this morning I noticed that she noted that the call was "a difficult call". Now I know that that isn't exactly an offensive term, but I don't really see the relevance of putting that on my health record. The call was a difficult call because she was clearly in a bad mood that day and wasn't that interested in my concerns. It's frustrated me even more than what I already was at a worrying time for me. I'm just after opinions really. Is this a relevant thing to put on a health record?
I work with vulnerable customers albeit in the financial industry and not medical. We would never be allowed to make a comment like that on somebody's file. You can only really state facts and not opinion. I mean I suppose is a fact that it was a difficult call, but I don't really see what relevance that has to my health and why it should be documented for other professionals to read. Insinuating that I was the one being difficult and not her which is what the issue actually was.

OP posts:
Aprilx · 18/08/2022 05:47

It was a difficult call and actually I think it is relevant to your medical history. You know there are people that go around demanding treatment and tests that they don’t need because they like having procedures, she hasn’t gone as far as to suggest that, but it is perhaps useful background, just in case.

And yes, you had only just had scans and blood tests, i presume you are u to date with smear tests, I think it was reasonable to wait. It is not that unusual to have the occasional out of cycle bleed, I was regular as clockwork for thirty years but it still happened a couple of times.

TheWillow · 18/08/2022 05:37

watermelonlipbalm · 18/08/2022 00:14

So the point of this thread really was to understand if those comments were justified. Many have told me it's normal so thanks for that, I really just wanted to know this.
I have some background just for context behind the post.

The point of this thread was not to get your opinion on whether I am justified to make a complaint. I haven't provided the full details of the call and nobody in this thread was part of that call to undserstand how I was spoken to. I find it really hard to understand how people can tell me I shouldn't complain when you know very little detail about the complaint itself.

I work in complaints and I know it's extremely important that complaints are logged and managed. I don't normally make them, I'm not a bad person. I'll make my own decision as to how I proceed, I never asked for advice on that. If some of you think I'm coming across badly, then it's probably because I'm receiving judgement on something I haven't asked for and my situation has been taken out of context a few times on this thread. If you think it's wrong to make a complaint about a doctor then we will agree to disagree. Doctors are still employees and have a duty of care and ethics. If they aren't doing their job properly or have caused distress to one person, then they could've done it to others. So just be weary if you think they don't deserve complaints.

Thanks to those who read the OP and provided a different angle on the matter. If it's normal it's normal, so be it! Having never seen medical records before I didn't know this hence why I asked, which there's nothing wrong with.

I have nothing else to say.

I agree that the core question is useful to pose for here. However, you did choose shared a lot about your intention to complain and it came across as bullying the doctor.

Specifically the words you have used make it sound like the complaints procedure would be a power trip for you. You hoped she might get retraining or spoken to or lose her job and used a smiley emoticon at the idea of consequences. A GP job is stressful and dealing with complaints (which most here don't think is deserved in this case) adds extra mental load. This context is relevant

i worry that behaviour like this could really impact how the health service is run and funded. And while you are just one person, it is worrying that others are probably doing the same.

In many ways MN posters are complaining but you are dismissing them..... Maybe this is a bit like the doctor? Surely complaints are only useful if there is a learning opportunity. Additionally, like the doctor, you are the expert of this scenario but choosing to dismiss. Do you think it could be hypocritical to dismiss everyone's opinion?

It sounds like you are getting top notch diagnosis investigation. They are going outside procedure to help you. Maybe a thank you letter is in order for going above and beyond.

I hope your results are negative again and you are safe and well.

pollyglot · 18/08/2022 02:03

One one hand, OP, I can empathise. I had post-menopausal bleeding, and was put on the waiting list for a scan (12 weeks). Decided to get a private scan, which showed growths in my uterus. Immediately put on the urgent list for surgery, but pre-op checks revealed atrial fibrilation...Long story, but the locum GP neglected to submit the "all clear for surgery" report, and I ended up waiting way more than 12 weeks anyway, despite the "urgent" status of my surgery. I was very cross, as you can imagine, which I expressed verbally, and I read later on my notes "Mental health issues". My oncologist brother in the USA had told me, in consultation with his Ob-Gyn colleague, that I needed the surgery urgently, and emailed me regularly to check what was happening. Mistakes are made, reactions are noted, recollections may vary.
However, my very recent experiences, where my DH's aneurysm was diagnosed as a muscle sprain, and we were sent home from A&E with instructions to watch some Youtube videos about sitting properly at your computer chair to avoid problems made me pretty unhappy. DH ended up being helicoptered to a major hospital for urgent on a tennis-ball-sized aneurysm, and was unbelievably lucky to have survived. Believe me, I will have something to say about that. Specially as we were treated like idiots for thinking severe pain such as he was experiencing was a muscle sprain.

MulletsBeGone · 18/08/2022 01:47

Rogue1001MNer · 17/08/2022 23:07

I don't want to derail your thread, @watermelonlipbalm, but can I just ask...

After reading, I went to go and look up my records on my NHS ap, and I can't see any notes.
Just a list of prescriptions I've had.
Where on the ap is it?

You click on "your health" and then GP Health record but might have to contact your GP surgery and ask for detailed coded access. The app will tell you that's what you need to do

I've included screenshots to show what I mean. I asked my GP for access about two years ago, was told by receptionist it'll take a little while and then nothing, I've asked again last week because a consultant told me I'd have been able to see blood and scan test results on there too instead of spending hours on hold to the GP surgery to find out results.

Comments my gp left on my health record
Comments my gp left on my health record
CinnamonSquared · 18/08/2022 01:10

Hi OP,
I’m not sure if a comment like that is normal or not, but I get why it would make you feel a bit uncomfortable.
I had similar symptoms 2 years ago and had blood tests, etc for a full year because they couldn’t work out what it was and I was becoming anemic from all the bleeding (with clots, etc).
At one point, they thought my pituitary gland was the cause but it turned out I was reacting really badly to the mini pill and my body just can’t handle it, was fine on the combined but not allowed to take it because I was a smoker. Just mentioning in case a change in contraception could be the cause for you? It’s so scary, isn’t it?

Qazwsxefv · 18/08/2022 00:37

And this is why if a patient is “difficult” or “unpleasant” I write out what they say word for word expletives included - has caused upset when they later read it but it is a factual record of the conversation. I would love all consultations to be recorded - I don’t have anything to hide!

OP if you are worried you have cervical cancer an ultrasound and blood tests are not going to help rule that out- someone needs to take a look at your cervix for that

TurquoiseDress · 18/08/2022 00:33

I don't think it's an inappropriate comment to state that a consultation was a "difficult call"...because it sounds like it was one

As patients gain more access to their notes/entries there's going to be so much more of this going on!

wordler · 18/08/2022 00:17

SchnitzelVonCrummsTum · 18/08/2022 00:01

@wordler - this is not always the case. I am not a GP but work in a closely related field and am married to a GP. Sometimes a call is just difficult and it is appropriate to note that.

That's good to know but such a short sentence is open to so much interpretation what would that mean to you if you were the next GP to take a consultation with the OP?

The call was difficult because the patient is difficult?
The call was difficult because we didn't agree on a good course of action?
The call was difficult because we disagreed and left on a bad note?

What internal feelings would you have when approaching a new patient for the first time that a colleague had warned had been 'difficult'?

Was it noted down in the notes for the benefit of the GP in case there was a complaint about her tone later on?
Was it noted down to provide a warning to the next GP? Or to remind the GP that they'd 'had a conflict' if it came up again.

I mean I was thrilled to be a 'very pleasant lady' on my referral letter but it was odd because I hadn't been particularly nice or otherwise in my 5-min appointment about my skiing injury.

watermelonlipbalm · 18/08/2022 00:15

@SchnitzelVonCrummsTum thank you ☺️

OP posts:
watermelonlipbalm · 18/08/2022 00:14

So the point of this thread really was to understand if those comments were justified. Many have told me it's normal so thanks for that, I really just wanted to know this.
I have some background just for context behind the post.

The point of this thread was not to get your opinion on whether I am justified to make a complaint. I haven't provided the full details of the call and nobody in this thread was part of that call to undserstand how I was spoken to. I find it really hard to understand how people can tell me I shouldn't complain when you know very little detail about the complaint itself.

I work in complaints and I know it's extremely important that complaints are logged and managed. I don't normally make them, I'm not a bad person. I'll make my own decision as to how I proceed, I never asked for advice on that. If some of you think I'm coming across badly, then it's probably because I'm receiving judgement on something I haven't asked for and my situation has been taken out of context a few times on this thread. If you think it's wrong to make a complaint about a doctor then we will agree to disagree. Doctors are still employees and have a duty of care and ethics. If they aren't doing their job properly or have caused distress to one person, then they could've done it to others. So just be weary if you think they don't deserve complaints.

Thanks to those who read the OP and provided a different angle on the matter. If it's normal it's normal, so be it! Having never seen medical records before I didn't know this hence why I asked, which there's nothing wrong with.

I have nothing else to say.

OP posts:
bloodyplanes · 18/08/2022 00:05

Op you are not coming across very well on here! You come across as spiteful, vindictive and entitled. She gave you her advice and you refused to accept it, therefore she was perfectly right to say it was a difficult call. She didn't say anything rude about you so why make a complaint? As a GP she will have to justify why she is making unnecessary referrals and not following guidelines.

SchnitzelVonCrummsTum · 18/08/2022 00:02

@watermelonlipbalm - glad the explanations have helped with something that you understandably didn't expect to see. Please don't think it's the GP writing in code about anything. In my opinion (non-medical) it's not.

SchnitzelVonCrummsTum · 18/08/2022 00:01

@wordler - this is not always the case. I am not a GP but work in a closely related field and am married to a GP. Sometimes a call is just difficult and it is appropriate to note that.

watermelonlipbalm · 18/08/2022 00:00

bridgetreilly · 17/08/2022 23:47

OP, I don’t know why you posted in AIBU, since in your opinion, you have clearly never been unreasonable in your life.

What a Silly comment 😴
I was asking about the comments on the health records but the majority didn't read the OP correctly.
Many have also explained that it is normal to write comments like that and explained why so that's fine.

OP posts:
Cherchezlaspice · 18/08/2022 00:00

wordler · 17/08/2022 23:47

The problem is that medical professionals often write in 'code' to each other to tell other medical professionals things in a way which won't cause offense or lawsuits if seen by the patient themselves.

So all the people saying "well it was a difficult call' aren't realising that noting it is a red flag about the disposition of the patient.

I only found this out when I had a referral letter for a specialist and the introduction went on about "my patient is a very pleasant lady" in flowery terms for the first paragraph and I asked my friend who is a GP why I was being described as a 'lady' and what had me being pleasant to do with getting my leg seen to.

She then told me not to worry it was code for the specialist that I was a nice patient who was genuine and not going to be any trouble.

So, he called you a ‘pleasant lady’ because he thought you were nice and not stressful to deal with. That’s not coded language, in any way. That’s just straightforward use of the English language.

1blossomtree · 17/08/2022 23:52

thanks @saraclara !

User8273738273737 · 17/08/2022 23:50

Honestly people on here think we need to bow to doctors and if we have fears or concerns there’s something wrong with us (see above: someone saying the pp was “very unpleasant” because they were afraid of something being done to them and reacted, AND APOLOGISED FOR IT).

I’m so glad you’ve never had to fight to get treatment because you were disbelieved and left for almost a year seriously unwell when it could have been resolved much sooner. I’m so glad you were never fobbed off and treated with what I can only describe as disdain, and still have to advocate for yourself at times of vulnerability. I’m so glad you’ve never worked in the NHS and saw how some healthcare professionals talk about patients sometimes. I’ve had experience of all 3 and I can only hope you never have reason to change your view.

saraclara · 17/08/2022 23:50

Rogue1001MNer · 17/08/2022 23:07

I don't want to derail your thread, @watermelonlipbalm, but can I just ask...

After reading, I went to go and look up my records on my NHS ap, and I can't see any notes.
Just a list of prescriptions I've had.
Where on the ap is it?

You have to fill in some forms and apply to have access. Everyone is entitled to it, but it's not there by default, as not everyone wants to be faced with information about their health that they might not be aware of. When you apply it warns you that there might be information there that could be hard to read, and you need to agree to take responsibility for that.

My surgery has a link that you can click on to ask for access. It takes a few weeks before you get it. Someone had to check through first to ensure that there's no information there with implications for another person (not the medical staff themselves, but maybe a family member whose called then with a concern about you or something like that) whose confidentiality needs to be respected.

Hopefully this helps @1blossomtree too

bridgetreilly · 17/08/2022 23:47

OP, I don’t know why you posted in AIBU, since in your opinion, you have clearly never been unreasonable in your life.

wordler · 17/08/2022 23:47

The problem is that medical professionals often write in 'code' to each other to tell other medical professionals things in a way which won't cause offense or lawsuits if seen by the patient themselves.

So all the people saying "well it was a difficult call' aren't realising that noting it is a red flag about the disposition of the patient.

I only found this out when I had a referral letter for a specialist and the introduction went on about "my patient is a very pleasant lady" in flowery terms for the first paragraph and I asked my friend who is a GP why I was being described as a 'lady' and what had me being pleasant to do with getting my leg seen to.

She then told me not to worry it was code for the specialist that I was a nice patient who was genuine and not going to be any trouble.

Cherchezlaspice · 17/08/2022 23:44

I'm just wanting an opinion as to whether it was appropriate for a GP to note these comments on my health record

Yes, it’s appropriate. It sounds like it was a difficult call and that was noted.

You aren’t coming across as massively reasonable on this thread, so I imagine the call was quite trying for her. She has my sympathies. The idea that anyone would think if was appropriate to complain about this is genuinely astonishing.

Haydnbridge · 17/08/2022 23:43

You said yourself it was a difficult call. She didn't say YOU were difficult. You're way overthinking this.

LaMarschallin · 17/08/2022 23:41

For people who have mentioned that the GP might "lose her job" or "get into trouble", she won't because she hasn't done anything wrong.
A minor complaint from the OP won't have that sort of power.

Nor will the GP get extra "support" whatever the OP means by this; just the sort of meaningless phrase that gets trotted out. Obviously, the best support would be for the NHS to provide more time to deal with patients... I doubt she has the time for "retraining".

The cumulative effect of the stresses of her job, including pointless complaints, may make the GP choose to leave, sadly, but that's quite different.

Rachie1973 · 17/08/2022 23:40

OP you really aren’t presenting well at all. What do you hope to gain from complaining about her?

SchnitzelVonCrummsTum · 17/08/2022 23:39

@watermelonlipbalm okay, that's helpful. To answer your question, this would not be an unusual thing to note in records. It relates to the tone of the call, as you very correctly say, not to the idea that you have behaved in a difficult way. The GP likely found the call difficult and it does sound like you found it difficult too.

It would be a relatively routine thing to note in this sort of circumstance and I can also understand why patients would not automatically know that doctors would record this information, as we don't routinely see our own notes. So you being initially surprised or concerned by it makes sense - but it also seems to be an accurate statement about the call itself (based on your account of the call - I'm not trying to project context etc). If you agree that the call was difficult then I would not complain - if you do not agree that the call was difficult then you could ask for an addendum to be added to the notes of the consultation to that effect.

Swipe left for the next trending thread