Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Comments my gp left on my health record

163 replies

watermelonlipbalm · 17/08/2022 21:44

Hi all, I'm just wanting an opinion as to whether it was appropriate for a GP to note these comments on my health record.
I've only just really realised that you have access to your medical records via the NHS app so I was having a nosy through them this morning and I was just a bit shocked to see what a GP had wrote.
I had a telephone call with a GP a few weeks ago. I actually obtained the contact details from the practice as to how to put a complaint in about the doctor because she really upset me with her attitude towards me and my worries when we had our telephone appointment. Unfortunately I just haven't gotten around to actually write the email yet, but nevertheless, the conversation did leave me feeling upset.
I won't go into exact detail, but I've been really worried about bleeding between my periods. It was completely unusual for me, it started faintly but ended up being quite heavy and I was passing a few clots aswell. Last year I had some bleeding between my periods, albeit completely different to this. I spoke to the Doctor Who referred me for bloods and a scan immediately. So I don't think it's surprising for me to not expect this to happen again. So when I had a telephone call from her I requested this and she shot me down pretty much straight away. She said that she would want me to bleed for three cycles before they would investigate further. I was quite surprised and just said that I didn't really agree with this and I would like to have bloods and a scan like I did last time. She became very abrupt with me at this point and despite agreeing to refer me she made it abundantly clear she wasn't happy about doing it and even said to me "i'm not gonna sit here on the phone arguing with you when I have other patients to call". The conversation wasn't an argument. It was me expressing my concerns and her not reassuring me enough for me to feel happy leaving the call. Whenever you see Doctors on telly, online, in magazines they're are always telling you that they are happy to help your queries. I did not get the impression from this doctor. And it just really upset me.
Anyway going back to the app this morning I noticed that she noted that the call was "a difficult call". Now I know that that isn't exactly an offensive term, but I don't really see the relevance of putting that on my health record. The call was a difficult call because she was clearly in a bad mood that day and wasn't that interested in my concerns. It's frustrated me even more than what I already was at a worrying time for me. I'm just after opinions really. Is this a relevant thing to put on a health record?
I work with vulnerable customers albeit in the financial industry and not medical. We would never be allowed to make a comment like that on somebody's file. You can only really state facts and not opinion. I mean I suppose is a fact that it was a difficult call, but I don't really see what relevance that has to my health and why it should be documented for other professionals to read. Insinuating that I was the one being difficult and not her which is what the issue actually was.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Alltheprettyseahorses · 19/08/2022 08:55

It's not one-off bleeding for a start, reading the OP is always a good idea I find. As for endemic clinical negligence, I suppose all the recent scandals have just passed you by not to mention the stories often finish with the healthcare trusts' own statements of apology. But yeah, you attack the source not the evidence, maybe you'd be happier if it was in the guardian instead.

LetHimHaveIt · 18/08/2022 22:49

'They're not your joke of the day.'

Then they oughtn't to have sought a platform from the sort of publication which treats all its 'contributors' as one. The sort of crap peddled by rags like this veers hysterically between mawkish and sensational, and if you think the stories therein evidence some sort of endemic clinical negligence, then you're off your rocker.

TheWillow · 18/08/2022 21:53

Alltheprettyseahorses · 18/08/2022 21:43

Yes I am serious. These are real people suffering from medical mismanagement, many have died, some are children. They're not your joke of the day. Like I said, I hope OP has nothing to worry about because according to too many posters she should ignore her worrying symptoms and fade away in the corner so as not to cause trouble.

No, the suggestion is to see if it happens again in the next month. It's often normal to have one off bleeding. This isn't mismanagement.

Often stories in those sources aren't reliable

Alltheprettyseahorses · 18/08/2022 21:43

LetHimHaveIt · 18/08/2022 09:51

This takes the bloody biscuit, this does. 'Take A Break' magazine? Are you actually serious? 'Hubby said he was delivering Chinese takeaways - but it was his prawn balls getting dipped in sweet 'n' sour!' 'Nightclub toilet horror - 48 abdominal stitches after being slashed with a bottle of toffee vodka!'

Yeah - I bet their desks are positively groaning under the weight of Pulitzers and Paul Foot awards. Investigate journalism at its best.

Yes I am serious. These are real people suffering from medical mismanagement, many have died, some are children. They're not your joke of the day. Like I said, I hope OP has nothing to worry about because according to too many posters she should ignore her worrying symptoms and fade away in the corner so as not to cause trouble.

bakebeans · 18/08/2022 10:18

Ncfreely · 17/08/2022 22:23

OP in the gentlest way, it was a difficult call. She did not say YOU were difficult. She has to accurately record the conversation. In my job I have to do attendance notes of every call and I always accurately record the conversation in case it comes back to bite me later.

I do think that if you are worried you should push or get a second opinion though. Always always worth getting checked out. Your concerns are totally valid.

👏👏 I second this!

yikesanotherbooboo · 18/08/2022 09:58

OP,as many have said the comment wasn't a judgement of you but of the interaction.I can guarantee that future hcps will see it in that light.Best of luck with your investigations.

LetHimHaveIt · 18/08/2022 09:51

Alltheprettyseahorses · 18/08/2022 08:29

The doctor sounds very judgemental imo. On a tangent I read my mum's old take a break etc magazines and I don't think a week goes by without at least 1 case where someone has been severely affected by medical mismanagement, mainly symptoms being ignored and made to feel a nuisance. I hope everything is fine with you OP, you've just questioned one of the mumsnet Sacred Cows so I'm not surprised by some of the responses.

This takes the bloody biscuit, this does. 'Take A Break' magazine? Are you actually serious? 'Hubby said he was delivering Chinese takeaways - but it was his prawn balls getting dipped in sweet 'n' sour!' 'Nightclub toilet horror - 48 abdominal stitches after being slashed with a bottle of toffee vodka!'

Yeah - I bet their desks are positively groaning under the weight of Pulitzers and Paul Foot awards. Investigate journalism at its best.

TheOrigRights · 18/08/2022 09:43

On a tangent I read my mum's old take a break etc magazines and I don't think a week goes by without at least 1 case where someone has been severely affected by medical mismanagement

I wouldn't rely on articles in Take a Break to make informed decisions about anything medical issues

neverbeenskiing · 18/08/2022 09:41

In addition to documenting the facts, HCP's are absolutely allowed to give opinions in a patients notes as long as in doing so they do not say anything offensive, untrue or unprofessional. It was, by your own admission, a "difficult call" for you, OP! The GP is entitled to note that she also found the call difficult, in fact this is sensible so that if a colleague has any interaction with you about the same issue they will be aware that it needs to be handled sensitively because you were likely unhappy with the last call. She has not used any inappropriate, offensive or insulting language to express this, nor has she written anything that was factually incorrect so I don't see how you have any basis to complain about what's written in your records.

HoppingPavlova · 18/08/2022 09:41

*Whenever you see Doctors on telly, online, in magazines they're are always telling you that they are happy to help your queries.

🤣🤣🤣 Meanwhile, in the real world …….

xogossipgirlxo · 18/08/2022 09:29

We did put "difficult patient" on record, to warn other medical staff. Nothing new to me.

Longtimeposternc · 18/08/2022 09:15

AnImaginaryCat · 18/08/2022 07:11

No we don't know "the full details of the call" and also it's true "nobody in this thread was part of that call to undserstand how I was spoken to."

Works both ways though, we have no idea how you spoke to the GP either. Though we can get an idea from your responses on the thread. After all no nobody retells an even on AIBU with the truth, and generally go to great pains to let people know how reasonable they were.

From what you have told us it appears you demanded, though you seem to disagree with "demand", so let's say "strongly requested" repeat tests because the last set hadn't shown up the cancer you're convinced you have (which you admit you feel because you have (self-diagnosed?) health anxiety.

Your GP informed you you'd need to wait three cycles but you disagreed because last time you didn't have to wait and you wanted that again.(Despite the fact that last time you hadn't already had a scan, so it's not the same situation.)

The GP, goes against her advice of waiting and agrees to the scan, because you strongly requested it so much.

You the "aren't happy to leave the call" (in other words refused to leave the call, but another word you objected to) until the GP reassures you that you are right to want a scan and that you could have cervical cancer. (It also comes across that somewhere along the line you mention that you think you might have cervical cancer and the GP doesn't think that.)

So now there's a scan happening that the GP advised against that she'll need to justify having booked. The reason it's booked it because of you requesting it during a 'difficult call' call, and that fact is recorded in your notes.

Would you prefer it written that you demanded it because you are convinced you have cervical cancer?

Also this

i am very glad I am not a doctor!

Longtimeposternc · 18/08/2022 09:12

TheUsualChaos · 17/08/2022 22:46

And this is why we get so many unnecessary referrals from GPs these days. Under increasing pressure from patients for "something to be done" when often an initial watch and wait approach is perfectly justified in many, many situations. Fear of complaints from patients if they don't get their own way. Lack of time due to massive system underfunding to properly explain/discuss their reasoning to patient particularly when a patient isn't getting the answer they wanted/expected. Result of all this = quicker and easier to just refer for a scan or other test and so the waiting lists for said tests get longer and longer.

This

Dirtylittleroses · 18/08/2022 08:36

It was a very difficult call so worth acknowledging and recording this. I don’t get your issue to be honest, it’s not like she wrote you were a a bitch.

reading your posts though, do you think you’re an over sensitive and argumentative person?

Alltheprettyseahorses · 18/08/2022 08:29

The doctor sounds very judgemental imo. On a tangent I read my mum's old take a break etc magazines and I don't think a week goes by without at least 1 case where someone has been severely affected by medical mismanagement, mainly symptoms being ignored and made to feel a nuisance. I hope everything is fine with you OP, you've just questioned one of the mumsnet Sacred Cows so I'm not surprised by some of the responses.

Lovemypeaceandquiet · 18/08/2022 08:09

And that’s a basis for your complaint, the fact that the GP put it on your records, not the call itself.

Consider wasting yours and the GPs time.

Lovemypeaceandquiet · 18/08/2022 08:07

Everything else aside, it’s factual - the call was difficult.

stayathomer · 18/08/2022 07:59

It did sound like a difficult call though. The doctor had a way of doing things (like she’s trained to), and you tried to tell her to do things differently. As someone above said ‘difficult call’ was a diplomatic way of saying it and whoever looks at the notes will know that you aren’t on the same page as the doctor on that issue.

Eastangular2000 · 18/08/2022 07:53

watermelonlipbalm · 18/08/2022 00:00

What a Silly comment 😴
I was asking about the comments on the health records but the majority didn't read the OP correctly.
Many have also explained that it is normal to write comments like that and explained why so that's fine.

This is a perfect example of your rudeness and arrogance. I can only imagine how difficult the call was for the GP. You had already been seen once and had scans, you then came back with another set of symptoms and had swabs and then you went back again to ask for further scans, in the meantime you had wound yourself into a frenzy thinking you had cervical cancer. Indeed you appear to have started several threads regarding your symptoms on Mumsnet, I presume you started multiple threads to get either the attention or answers you wanted. Whether you have health anxiety of whether you are simply difficult and demanding is difficult to know, but the way you have posted on this thread to anyone who disagrees with you, suggests the latter.

LetHimHaveIt · 18/08/2022 07:37

Bollocks. Total and utter bollocks.

Iwonder08 · 18/08/2022 07:35

This thread just shows how long the medical service standards are here in UK. The patient was dismissed as being difficult for asking for a rather routine test which they led to believe are fairly standard given the previous experience. Instead of communicating politely about whatever guidelines (assuming they exist), reassure the patient that from their point of view they have nothing to worry about at this stage the doctor branded her 'difficult' to make sure every other consultant/go reading her note will be informed of their perception and actually told her she is not going to waste more time on the phone as there more important patients waiting. It is literally a part of GP's job to answer patients questions about their health. The patients are not supposed made feel like they are causing annoyance and inconvenience. But of course people immediately defend GP as they might get upset and leave if the patient complains. It is a well known fact women in UK are regularly dismissed, especially when it concerns any gynecological issues, no wonder most don't have enough with such attitudes in the society.

Monday55 · 18/08/2022 07:30

OP You requested to have tests done, the GP said no. However, you wouldn't take no for an answer which is what turned your request into a demand. You made that phone call expecting to get the tests done and you weren't willing to leave the phone call until the GP had booked them.. seriously can you not seee how difficult this is?

AnImaginaryCat · 18/08/2022 07:11

watermelonlipbalm · 18/08/2022 00:14

So the point of this thread really was to understand if those comments were justified. Many have told me it's normal so thanks for that, I really just wanted to know this.
I have some background just for context behind the post.

The point of this thread was not to get your opinion on whether I am justified to make a complaint. I haven't provided the full details of the call and nobody in this thread was part of that call to undserstand how I was spoken to. I find it really hard to understand how people can tell me I shouldn't complain when you know very little detail about the complaint itself.

I work in complaints and I know it's extremely important that complaints are logged and managed. I don't normally make them, I'm not a bad person. I'll make my own decision as to how I proceed, I never asked for advice on that. If some of you think I'm coming across badly, then it's probably because I'm receiving judgement on something I haven't asked for and my situation has been taken out of context a few times on this thread. If you think it's wrong to make a complaint about a doctor then we will agree to disagree. Doctors are still employees and have a duty of care and ethics. If they aren't doing their job properly or have caused distress to one person, then they could've done it to others. So just be weary if you think they don't deserve complaints.

Thanks to those who read the OP and provided a different angle on the matter. If it's normal it's normal, so be it! Having never seen medical records before I didn't know this hence why I asked, which there's nothing wrong with.

I have nothing else to say.

No we don't know "the full details of the call" and also it's true "nobody in this thread was part of that call to undserstand how I was spoken to."

Works both ways though, we have no idea how you spoke to the GP either. Though we can get an idea from your responses on the thread. After all no nobody retells an even on AIBU with the truth, and generally go to great pains to let people know how reasonable they were.

From what you have told us it appears you demanded, though you seem to disagree with "demand", so let's say "strongly requested" repeat tests because the last set hadn't shown up the cancer you're convinced you have (which you admit you feel because you have (self-diagnosed?) health anxiety.

Your GP informed you you'd need to wait three cycles but you disagreed because last time you didn't have to wait and you wanted that again.(Despite the fact that last time you hadn't already had a scan, so it's not the same situation.)

The GP, goes against her advice of waiting and agrees to the scan, because you strongly requested it so much.

You the "aren't happy to leave the call" (in other words refused to leave the call, but another word you objected to) until the GP reassures you that you are right to want a scan and that you could have cervical cancer. (It also comes across that somewhere along the line you mention that you think you might have cervical cancer and the GP doesn't think that.)

So now there's a scan happening that the GP advised against that she'll need to justify having booked. The reason it's booked it because of you requesting it during a 'difficult call' call, and that fact is recorded in your notes.

Would you prefer it written that you demanded it because you are convinced you have cervical cancer?

londonrach · 18/08/2022 06:25

But it was a difficult call. I write medical notes as part of my job. Its factual. Have you checked nice guidelines re bleeding and Waiting so many more cycles till next scan

LetHimHaveIt · 18/08/2022 06:16

'Hopefully she well get the further training and support that she clearly needs ☺️'

Yeah; it's silly little comments and emojis like this that make me - and many others on this thread - think you are indeed bloody difficult.