Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Stepkids are "our" kids

143 replies

sayless · 17/08/2022 19:04

When I met DP he was a stepdad. He'd been in her life since she was 6 months old and raised her as his own. He split with her mum when she was 3. He still saw her every weekend and provided for her by buying things (not giving cash as her mum had a drink and weed problem). The mum stopped him seeing her about 9 months ago when she moved her new boyfriend in.

I have two girls (7 & 12), their dad died 5 years ago so obviously isn't around. DP is their stepdad and in that role, they adore him.

This is probably all in my head but I feel like how can he love my kids when he met them at an older age? How can he love them like his own when they aren't?

He doesn't have any bio children. He's only 32 so it is something we may consider in future but he says he's happy to have them or not have them as he knows it's not ideal for me (I'm 35, my kids were prem and I nearly died in labour).

I see so many couples who split up and stepdad isn't interested in seeing the kids anymore...

AIBU yes stepdads can love kids like their own

YNBU it isn't the same bond

OP posts:
Groooot · 18/08/2022 09:01

And no not loving your step children like your own doesn't make you not a good person or lacking in some way.

I don't love my step children in the same realm as my son. But I'm still kind to them, I still care for them, I still treat them with respect. I'm still a good step mother to them and I'm still a good person.

Groooot · 18/08/2022 08:58

PeekAtYou · 17/08/2022 19:07

Do you believe that people who adopt don't love their kids as much as people who have biological kids?

Can we please stop pretending step parenting in most cases is comparable to adoption. It isn't.

How can he love them like his own when they aren't?

Does he need to? I don't love my step children like my own and I'd be Hmm at my husband if he ever suggested I should.

It is of course slightly different in your case as your children have no father around so he may step into that role more than your average step parent but does he HAVE to love them like his own?

Are they happy? Is he kind to them? Does he treat them with love and care? If yes, does it matter?

Yes it's possible but it's not reasonable to expect it imo.

monsterastuckiosa · 18/08/2022 08:55

Which isn't to say, by the way, that parents shouldn't feel high emotion about their kids post-separation, or that it's unreasonable to worry... I'm not bashing parents for caring, at all – it's just worth being aware that it also has an impact.

monsterastuckiosa · 18/08/2022 08:54

I think most of the problems here come with parents of step kids isn't it? Rather than the kids themselves

Very true – and not necessarily because of multiple houses / 4 people instead of 2.

The emotional weight and worry that parents carry about it (OP's version is just one example) can make the whole endeavour very tense. High expectations, touchy subjects, needing to 'make up for' a separation by over-doing things, worrying about if things are 'enough' or 'the same'... the whole thing is fraught with emotion and often lack of communication, which can make it really difficult to just focus on 'loving the kids'.

Most of my difficulties as a step-parent came from navigating DP's emotions and expectations – nothing to do with DSS at all.

The less pressure there is on 'how it's going', the better it's likely to 'go'.

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 18/08/2022 08:43

I think most of the problems here come with parents of step kids isn't it? Rather than the kids themselves. It's being raised by 4 adults with conflicting values and different levels of authority. If there's only one household that must be easier to love the kids because there's less getting in the way? (I mean easier - not saying it's impossible to love step kids when there's more than one household, just that it's challenging when you're navigating different adult relationships in addition to the kids ones) so you can focus on the kids relationship instead of managing 3-4 different adult roles for the kids.

Endlesslypatient82 · 18/08/2022 08:31

There are some lovely posts on this thread that really fill you with hope about human nature!

a person who can’t love his SC as much as his own biological children is not somehow lesser in “human nature” then a person who can!

Endlesslypatient82 · 18/08/2022 08:29

I am not a step mum

but can categorically tell you that I could never ever love a step child even as fraction as much as my own.

BrownEyedFool · 18/08/2022 08:27

Some of these stories have brought a tear to my eye. So lovely to read about good men (and women) on MN!

RainyWaves · 18/08/2022 08:11

My DH loves my DC as if they are his own (no biological DC of his own, although he would have liked to and is very family orientated).

What I notice most is that he really “knows” them as people and notices the important stuff. He has said things like “ X child went straight up to her room after school, is everything okay as she didn’t seem quite herself ?” when I hadn’t noticed anything (and he has been right!). I respect his opinion about parenting - although he follows my lead generally - because he is talking about people who he knows well and understands, it is just generic “this is what parents should do”.

Financially he contributes equally, without question, but more importantly he shares the load in other ways. For example, he makes time to finish work early to be at school events as he knows what’s important to them, and we always make sure at least one of us can attend. They love him in return and it’s a real relationship that has built over time where they all have their own little things that they do together.

They have their own biological dad who they also love and he does them, but it’s a very different relationship. That’s EOW and he is not available or interested in anything to do with them that falls outside of that weekend, no matter what, including emergencies or medical apts.

I suppose that has been a difference too, that DH isn’t stepping on anyone’s toes by building such strong relationships. His DM also treats them in the same way as her biological grandchildren.

They were 5 (twins) and 7 when he met them. I know he would carry on seeing them if we weren’t together, they have asked him a few times about that (not sure why, we aren’t on the verge of splitting!)

LuckySantangelo35 · 18/08/2022 07:56

@sayless

YABU

he doesn’t need to love them as his own

Sarahmayo · 18/08/2022 07:45

@Besttobe8001 Thank you 😊 x

Mummyoflittledragon · 18/08/2022 07:35

My stepfather came to me when I was in my teens. He was the only grandfather dd knew. He showed me more love and care than I had been used to growing up. He died a few years ago and is sorely missed.

Ilovelurchers · 18/08/2022 07:30

There are some lovely posts on this thread that really fill you with hope about human nature!

For me, I had 4 adult "step-sons" with my ex - some of whom had partners etc and one had a child. While we were together I certainly thought of them as family. It was a difficult split and I am now only close to the youngest. We text most days, share all important life news etc. I am proud of his achievements and worry when things aren't going well for him. I definitely love him - not quite as a son but feel more protective than just a friendship.....It is kind of in between.

It's not the same as my feelings for my biological child but it doesn't need to be. Love is always a blessing whatever form it takes.

DelilahBucket · 18/08/2022 07:27

My husband loves my son like his own. DS was three when we got together. They've got an incredible bond, and very different to what DS has with his biological father which is complete disinterest on both sides. We don't have any children together, we can't.

ColmanFlamingo · 18/08/2022 07:18

My DH has been an amazing SD to my DC since the age of 8.
We are so lucky to have him and be definitely loves DC as his own. They have a wonderful relationship all of their own. DC's never referred to him as her stepdad, only as Dad but calls him by his Christian name to him.

toomuchlaundry · 18/08/2022 07:02

@Hankunamatata if he adopted them he should do shared contact shouldn’t he. Surely the implications of adoption would be explained to them during the process. If not willing to take on the extra responsibilities he should have just remained as stepdad

Houselamp · 18/08/2022 06:46

I know its not exactly the same but me and my husband are foster carers, we have done both short and long term placements,
Our oldest son came to us when he was 12, initially for short term which turned into long term, he is in his late 20s now and we have both loved him exactly as if he were our own for years and years. He knows we would do anything for him, he has his own children now and still comes over every weekend and in the week.

The care and dedication comes immediatly, the attachment builds gradually and the love is there pretty early on. I think it helps when they are under 16 at the start as there is time to build 'childhood memories'.
We cannot reminise with him about his life before he came to us, but he still says things like "remember that time we went camping and I got to ride a horse" or "that summer holiday was brilliant, remember dad took me to that football match and we had ice cream on the beach".
We have shared memories, he still had a childhood with us and he knew he was loved the whole time. You can definitely love kids that are not biologically yours, even when they are older.

Besttobe8001 · 18/08/2022 06:01

Sarahmayo · 17/08/2022 22:44

My DH has been a brilliant Step Dad to my 3 DD, who he met when they were 10 and twins 8. We have been together for 8 years. I believe it is possible to love a child you have met when they were older. I can see my DH loves my DDs and they love him, they call him Dad, biological father doesn't show much interest and they call him by his name rather than Dad, this has been their choice completely.
In regards to having a child together, I would seriously recommend sitting down and having a really serious conversation with your DP on this one. My DH insisted for years he didn't want any children of his own and I was fine with that, although I made it clear I was happy to have one if he wanted. Move along a few years, and he's completely changed his mind and is now desperate to have a baby. Although I'm now 40 and I so wish he'd said this 5 years ago, however after a year of trying, a MMC and a Chemical I am now 9 weeks pregnant and 🤞🏻 so far this time everything is going well.
I would certainly recommend finding out his true feelings on having a baby though

Good luck with your pregnancy x

Besttobe8001 · 18/08/2022 06:00

Does it matter?

For example. I love my nieces. I would die for them. I sacrifice time and money for them. I love the nuances of their personalities and I love contributing positively to their lives. I love spending time with them and they love me.

Do I love them as much as my brother and sil do? Obviously not. But I love them as much as any non parent could. And that's the most that can be expected of me.

onlythreenow · 18/08/2022 05:44

My friend adopted his then wives children when they married. They split when kids were teens but as he said he is dad so did shared contact and plys active role in their lives

I also know people who have done this.

Hankunamatata · 17/08/2022 22:50

My friend adopted his then wives children when they married. They split when kids were teens but as he said he is dad so did shared contact and plys active role in their lives

Sarahmayo · 17/08/2022 22:44

My DH has been a brilliant Step Dad to my 3 DD, who he met when they were 10 and twins 8. We have been together for 8 years. I believe it is possible to love a child you have met when they were older. I can see my DH loves my DDs and they love him, they call him Dad, biological father doesn't show much interest and they call him by his name rather than Dad, this has been their choice completely.
In regards to having a child together, I would seriously recommend sitting down and having a really serious conversation with your DP on this one. My DH insisted for years he didn't want any children of his own and I was fine with that, although I made it clear I was happy to have one if he wanted. Move along a few years, and he's completely changed his mind and is now desperate to have a baby. Although I'm now 40 and I so wish he'd said this 5 years ago, however after a year of trying, a MMC and a Chemical I am now 9 weeks pregnant and 🤞🏻 so far this time everything is going well.
I would certainly recommend finding out his true feelings on having a baby though

Livelovebehappy · 17/08/2022 21:21

i think it’s easy to love them when they’re well behaved, but might be different when they become teens with their raging hormones and irrational behaviour. I think biological parents struggle to love them, never mind someone not related by blood.

23pairs · 17/08/2022 21:17

I definitely believe that you can. I have a DSS who I adore (he's 10 now, we've been together since he was 2 and he has only ever known us together, and his mum and her partner together) and I just cannot imagine loving him less/differently than I would love my own child. I'd do anything for him, we love spending time together, he's truly amazing.

We haven't had any children together (I've had multiple miscarriages) and I understand that people tell me it may change if/when we do, but I just cannot imagine adoring him any less than I do now. I feel blessed to be a part of his life.

girlmom21 · 17/08/2022 21:04

My dad loves my step sister like his own and my step moms the same with me. We all started living together when she and I were both 5

Swipe left for the next trending thread