Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...to insist on getting a family pet if my husband doesn’t want one?

193 replies

Pickmeup78 · 17/08/2022 16:50

I always wanted a cat growing up, but my parents didn’t allow it. Now I’m an adult with 2 children (7 and 9), who would both love to have a cat and so do I. We live in a house with garden, in a green London neighbourhood and I work from home so would have plenty of time to look after a cat.

However. My husband (who did grow up with cats) doesn’t want one. He thinks they smell, especially their litter tray, and he’s against all the meat that goes into cat food production - so he’s against it from a personal and an environmental perspective.

We’ve had several discussions about adopting a cat in the past, and I’ve always given up arguing my points (ie. always wanted a cat myself, would be lovely for the kids to have one) just to keep the peace.

But now, with so many unwanted cats up for adoption in our local cat shelter, I feel like I just want to go for it. I’ve signed up with the shelter, and made an appointment for a pre-adoption meeting.

I would obvs discuss it again with husband before actually getting it, but am thinking about putting everything in place and finding a suitable cat at the shelter beforehand. I expect that we‘ll have a big row, he will be in a massive a huff, I will plead that I will take full responsibility for the cat, and he will finally give in - very reluctantly so.

Am I being unreasonable to push this through and finally get a furry friend? Or am I out of order?

OP posts:
HeckyPeck · 17/08/2022 23:51

He is very used to things going his way, and reacts really strongly to everything I suggest that is not his ‘thing’ e.g. cooking something that’s not what he likes even if I love it, watching I film that I’ve chosen that he’s not sure about (will make me turn it off even!)

He makes you turn off films if he doesn't enjoy them and "reacts strongly" to you cooking food you like. I vote on replacing him with a cat.

Seriously though OP, that's not how a loving relationship should be.

Pickmeup78 · 17/08/2022 23:44

All your answers are really helpful, thanks!

Clumping - lots of good points for why having a cat really can impact everyday life.

Having read all this, I think I will tread a bit more carefully, and seek another discussion with DH at a good moment first. And also suggest getting an older rescue, to shorten the commitment span somewhat.

Goodnight all 😻

OP posts:
XSnoe · 17/08/2022 23:36

There are no problems with my relationship but if DH came home with an animal and insisted it stayed I would definitely leave.

If someone left their partner over bringing a pet home, I'd think that person didn't really love their partner all that much in the first place.

CloudCatz · 17/08/2022 23:31

and regardless of what anyone else says, no matter how well maintained the litter tray is, the house still smells like cat.

Most people I know who have cats don't have litter trays. The cat just goes outside.

Rowen32 · 17/08/2022 22:49

Can you get two and keep them outside? That feels like a compromise.
Inside, no, I don't think that's fair.

Augustwine · 17/08/2022 22:41

gatehouseoffleet · 17/08/2022 21:42

Disagree. I simply could not live with a dog. So if the OP's DH simply cannot live with a cat, that's reasonable. The OP and her kids can clearly live without one, because they do.

Anyway, pet ownership is exploitative. People only have them for their own delectation. It's not for the animals' benefit and I hope in a few years the pendulum will swing back the other way and people will stop having pets.

But you could live with a dog (unless you have a life threatening allergy or severe phobia) you just wouldn’t be happy about it. Like the OP is not happy about living without a cat. I don’t think the husbands desire to not have a cat is more important than the op and kids desire to have a cat.

savehannah · 17/08/2022 22:24

See, my DH loves cats (we had two for 15 years and he adored them.) But he is adamant about not getting another even though three kids and I would get another one in a shot. His reasons are mostly financial (cost of food/vets) and that we have new furniture that could get damaged. I get it but still think it would be so good for all pur mental health especially DD and DH! I have considered just getting one without him agreeing. But only because I know he loves them! Getting a cat when one partner really doesn't like them is harsh.

GoldenTobes · 17/08/2022 22:10

"Anyway, pet ownership is exploitative. People only have them for their own delectation. It's not for the animals' benefit and I hope in a few years the pendulum will swing back the other way and people will stop having pets."

Yawn!!! People have had pets for hundreds of years so I wouldn't hold your breath breath!

bellac11 · 17/08/2022 21:45

gatehouseoffleet · 17/08/2022 21:42

Disagree. I simply could not live with a dog. So if the OP's DH simply cannot live with a cat, that's reasonable. The OP and her kids can clearly live without one, because they do.

Anyway, pet ownership is exploitative. People only have them for their own delectation. It's not for the animals' benefit and I hope in a few years the pendulum will swing back the other way and people will stop having pets.

You dont know cats do you!!!

gatehouseoffleet · 17/08/2022 21:42

GoldenTobes · 17/08/2022 20:04

"When the kids grow up and leave home they can have as many cats as they want"

Unless they have a selfish partner who stops them!
If he leaves you because of a cat then there were more problems in the relationship than just pet ownership.

Disagree. I simply could not live with a dog. So if the OP's DH simply cannot live with a cat, that's reasonable. The OP and her kids can clearly live without one, because they do.

Anyway, pet ownership is exploitative. People only have them for their own delectation. It's not for the animals' benefit and I hope in a few years the pendulum will swing back the other way and people will stop having pets.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 17/08/2022 21:39

I think YABVU. And I do think it’s like agreeing on having another baby - the one that says no has ultimate veto power.

I don’t know what I’d do if my husband plotted something similar behind my back, but I know that I won’t share my house with an animal.

gatehouseoffleet · 17/08/2022 21:37

MrsRobinsonsHandprints · 17/08/2022 16:57

It's a cat not another baby. Why should the wants of one rule over rule the wants of three.

Because the impact of keeping the status quo is far less than changing things (see Brexit for an example!)

If someone doesn't want something, you don't do it.

I said on the other thread if my husband insisted on a dog I would divorce him, I could not live with one. I might just about be able to tolerate a cat.

It is like having another child - especially if you get a puppy or a kitten - they really need a lot of looking after and training - and I just wouldn't want a dog in the house. Lots of responsibility and then you can't do anything without worrying about what to do with them eg if you go on holiday. Total deal breaker for me. I assume if you have a nice leafy house in London you can afford it, but even so, I am not sure I'd be adding household costs at this time.

blubberball · 17/08/2022 21:24

Could you volunteer at an animal rescue instead? You get your cat fix, but your home remains cat free

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 17/08/2022 21:08

If you are not on board then cats in the house are an utter pain in the arse !

They scatter litter when they 'track' it
The odd accident and you have to fathom "why" ?
Their biscuits get everywhere
They wreck furniture and carpets even with a scratch post
They bring things (worms are a favourite for mine)
They stay out till 2am when they feel like ignoring you
They are £ to vaccinate/worm/flea and even with insurance £ vet bills
Our female throws things off the table (2 fruit bowls , remote controls )
They hide under the sofa and attack your feet
We're lucky that our adult DC cat sit , I don't think ours woud like Cattery life

If we didn't love these little ratbags these would be a challenge Grin

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 17/08/2022 21:07

Also, you might think I'm ridiculous in disliking all the things I mentioned and that to you, those things are nothing. But if I was your partner and you loved me, would you really want to do something that would make me feel that way constantly for the next fifteen years? It's not a recipe for nuptial harmony.

luckylavender · 17/08/2022 21:05

If my DH insisted on a cat it would be game over. They give me the creeps. And they stink.

GreeboIsMySpiritAnimal · 17/08/2022 21:03

We've got a dog, a cat, and a tank full of fish. My husband wanted none of them. Tough titties, the DC and I did, he was outvoted.

My compromise was agreeing that we've probably got enough animals now.

samyeagar · 17/08/2022 20:49

and regardless of what anyone else says, no matter how well maintained the litter tray is, the house still smells like cat.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 17/08/2022 20:43

Those were of course indoor cats. With outdoor cats you might inflict the litter tray problem on your neighbours instead, making your life a little easier, and don't have to worry about keeping doors and windows shut, but then you have to worry about fleas, and it catching local birds, and dead things being deposited in your house, and your pet possibly getting squashed in the road, and God knows what being tracked into your house and bed and kitchen counters from outside.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 17/08/2022 20:31

Cats really involve very little disruption.

For cat lovers, maybe.

I am not a cat lover, but lived with and looked after a couple of cats for a few months.

I was consciously aware of the cats almost 100% of the time. The feeding and litter tray is only a tiny fraction of it.

I had to make sure the bedroom door was always shut even if I was only popping in to grab something, so the cats wouldn't follow me in and at least my bedding wouldn't be covered in dander and fur even if everything else was. No other door in the house (except the bathroom for brief periods — not too long as their litter tray lived in there) could be closed because it infuriated the cats and they'd yowl and scratch, so I had to let them interrupt my Zoom meetings. I developed a feint-and-return trick so I could go to the loo alone.

I was always conscious that no surface in the house was ever truly clean — everything felt covered in a thin, sticky layer of cat, and there's only so much cleaning you can do. I was washing my hands many times a day more than I usually would. I could never put food straight on a surface even if I'd cleaned it an hour before. Never leave food unattended. Never leave a plate or chopping board out to be used. Never leave the hob unattended, until it was cool enough not to damage paws. Never eat certain foods without constant pestering (ice cream particularly bad). Always aware of the possibility of stepping in/sitting on/otherwise encountering revolting things that have come out of a cat — to be fair, these two were very good at using their litter tray but hairballs and vomit don't seem to be something you can train a cat to do in the litter tray, and one time, one of them had diarrhoea and didn't make it to the tray. And speaking of the litter tray, despite all measures the cats tracked litter out all over the bathroom floor and beyond, so walking with bare feet in the bathroom was impossible unless you swept beforehand.

I could never leave an outside door or window open to get air. Never move around the house or walk up and down stairs without checking I wasn't about to kick a cat or trip over it. Never sit down to relax without them coming to lie next to me (which, okay, I was there in part to look after the cats and it was quite cute, but one of them in particular liked to aim his anus directly at my face). Never able to get anything done without the risk of at least one cat wanting to be involved, getting in my way, getting things that I wanted to stay clean covered in fur and dander and other cat dirt.

They needed lots of interaction and exercise, and they choose who they want that interaction off, most of the time.

The two cats I looked after were sweet, friendly little things, and I'm fond of them. But living with them and looking after them was a big favour and absolutely not something I would choose for my own home.

Davros · 17/08/2022 20:27

Get a cat. Your DH's ideas are out-if-date. Feed it only dry food, our 15 year old has only ever had that and a few treats. She's only visited the vet once a year for her annual service, apart from when she got bitten by a dog which was covered by insurance. They mostly don't have litter trays if they go out, at her great age ours has a covered tray and I use fully disposable cardboard inners. She has been the best thing ever for DD and any emotional issues

nokidshere · 17/08/2022 20:24

"When the kids grow up and leave home they can have as many cats as they want"

Unless they have a selfish partner who stops them!
If he leaves you because of a cat then there were more problems in the relationship than just pet ownership.

I've told my son that if he wants pets he needs to be sure the person he ends up with is on the same page. There are no problems with my relationship but if DH came home with an animal and insisted it stayed I would definitely leave.

nokidshere · 17/08/2022 20:21

I agree that just getting a cat could cause problems but he is being very unreasonable if this is something you have wanted your whole life. Why should he have the final say on what is also your life?

If it had been that important her whole life she wouldn't/shouldn't have married someone who doesn't want one.

I wouldn't have lived with anyone who wanted pets of any description. It's a complete deal breaker for me.

Horological · 17/08/2022 20:08

I was in this situation and I went ahead and got the cat and DH fell in love with her. BUT, he has used his initial reluctance as an excuse for never doing anything for her eg. feed her, take her to the vet etc. etc.

Sometimes people say no because they don't like to get their heads around change, or something new. I really don't think it's such a terrible thing to override him. Cats really involve very little disruption.

Obviously if he was really afraid of them (some people are, but don't like to admit it), if he had an allergy or if you couldn't afford it as a family that's different. But if just can't be bothered to get his head around it for your sake, knowing how much you want one then I would go ahead.

GoldenTobes · 17/08/2022 20:04

"When the kids grow up and leave home they can have as many cats as they want"

Unless they have a selfish partner who stops them!
If he leaves you because of a cat then there were more problems in the relationship than just pet ownership.