Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think C section is the best birth option?

285 replies

LilacSky95 · 17/08/2022 16:46

I've had 3 vaginal births and 1 c section. The recovery from the vaginal births was a breeze, but I've been left with a host of issues from those that will last a lifetime.

My c section recovery was harder, but after the initial pain etc were off I was ok, and it was so nice to be intact 'down there' afterwards.

AIBU to think surely it's better to risk any of the problems that can arrise from having a section, over all the awful things that women often have to deal with for a lifetime after vaginal birth?

Yes I know c section is major surgery, but loads of women end up needing surgery to correct the damage done by vaginal birth too, and even then will never be the same again. At least your problems that come with a c section will be sorted out at least 12 months after delivery, and tour vagina is unscathed.

I've already had one lot of surgery to try and fix my prolapses, and will need more surgery in the future. I cant help feel jaded that if I'd had c sections I wouldn't have to go through all of this so maybe my views are skewed. What do you think?

OP posts:
Hbhhhh193948484848 · 17/08/2022 20:31

@mynameiscalypso

Re my last post - mine was an emergency after a failed induction so your comment makes sense actually - maybe that’s why I had so many problems as it’s riskier. Perhaps an elective is better , still think I could of contracted the sepsis though , just awful 😩

Hbhhhh193948484848 · 17/08/2022 20:27

No it’s not easier , I had an emergency c section under general where I haemorrhaged and also got sepsis. I then got acute urinary retention where my bladder almost ruptured - excruciating. I also have adhesions causing me pain four years on.

Childbirth is hard either way.

WellThatsMeScrewed · 17/08/2022 20:26

This debate always makes me slightly annoyed. I really think the poor maternity care women receive leading upto, during and after birth makes it an unfair debate.

If we could guarantee that each woman giving birth had a dedicated, well qualified team around her during VB I wonder if the stats would favour VB more? Possibly not but that is something I wonder about.

So for example - if there were not pressures on resources the decision to go to CSec might be made earlier and not a ‘emergency’. Or there would be free physio for ALL women after birth.

Either way what is essential is that womens voices are listened to, that their right to choose is central to decision making and that their lives are valued. Unfortunately the current state of affairs is a long way off from this, particularly so if you are black or a woman of colour.

Mommabear20 · 17/08/2022 20:21

Have had 2 VB, 1 was a 2nd degree tear, the other an episiotomy, and I was still healed and feeling better before my sister who had a section 5 weeks before I delivered (the one with episiotomy). I was able to be Up and about straight after birth, whereas she couldn't even lift her baby for a week and had to be handed him!
VB every time in my opinion! It's the way we're designed to deliver. Can't wait for my third!

Cantanka · 17/08/2022 20:19

Ponderingwindow · 17/08/2022 20:10

You haven’t included the risks and benefits for the baby in your calculations. Vaginal birth is far from perfectly safe, but it also helps clear lungs and guarantees that the baby is indeed ready to be born. Just as babies can suffer injury during a vaginal birth, they can be injured during a c-section.

I’ll stand corrected as I don’t have evidence to hand but are babies not more likely to die/suffer hypoxic brain injury in vaginal birth, for example if they get stuck?

I agree that for the majority of babies who don’t suffer that fate, there is evidence of baby being more likely to be on NICU after a c-section.

DeadButDelicious · 17/08/2022 20:17

My first birth, which was vaginal, was horrendous. My second, which was a section, was brilliant. If I were having any more, which I am most definitely not, I wouldn't even think twice about it, elective section all the way.

Twizbe · 17/08/2022 20:14

The issue with the stats quoted here is that they are not personalised.

For every woman the risk profile is unique. Her age, physical health, baby's health, gestation, position for labour, previous obstetric history etc all feed into these risks.

Ilikecheesycrackers · 17/08/2022 20:10

I've had 2 VBs without any problems or long term bad effects (children are adults now). I agree that potential consequences of both VB and c section should be discussed so that people can make an informed decision.

Ponderingwindow · 17/08/2022 20:10

You haven’t included the risks and benefits for the baby in your calculations. Vaginal birth is far from perfectly safe, but it also helps clear lungs and guarantees that the baby is indeed ready to be born. Just as babies can suffer injury during a vaginal birth, they can be injured during a c-section.

MassiveSalad22 · 17/08/2022 20:09

ShirleyPhallus · 17/08/2022 17:02

I think it depends on what the issues are from a vaginal birth as to what’s safer for the mum. Statistically I believe a vaginal birth is the safest option for the baby and better for lungs etc.

In order, I think it would go:


  1. healthy, straightforward vaginal birth with easy recovery

  2. elective section

  3. emergency section

  4. complicated vaginal birth with complications ie forceps / 3rd degree tear

This. I had 4, then two 2s! My babies reflect their births too - first is crazy whirlwind and needed loads of things ironing out in the newborn days, and the second two are so chilled (and amazing sleepers!).

BetweenTwoLungs · 17/08/2022 20:09

I don’t think there’s any better way to give birth but I think that the risks of sections are often focused on and tbe risks of vaginal births downplayed. As a first time mum, your chance of an uncomplicated spontaneous vaginal birth is only 50% - the other 50% either have an assisted delivery (around 25%) or an emergency c section (around 25%). So even before you start, if you opt for a vsginal delivery you’ve got a 25% chance of ending up with a more risky c-section regardless.

You’ve got a 5-7% chance of having a 3rd/4th degree tear, even if the birth is classed as ‘uncomplicated’. One study found that 48% of vaginal births report some degree of urinal incontinence compared to 27% of c sections, so the risk isn’t removed but it’s much less. The increased risks relating to c-sections are actually very very small risks increasing to slightly higher but still very small risks. And as mentioned, these stats often combined with emergency c sections.

I’d love a guaranteed uncomplicated vaginal birth but it’s literally a 50/50 chance, and so I’m going to be opting for an elective section. Having said all this I think women must be allowed to choose.

The data I’ve used is from here:

www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng192/evidence/a-the-benefits-and-risks-of-planned-caesarean-birth-pdf-9071941646

www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng192/resources/appendix-a-benefits-and-risks-of-vaginal-and-caesarean-birth-pdf-9074971693

And this also makes for an interesting read, although not U.K. based - www.cmaj.ca/content/cmaj/193/18/E634.full.pdf

RadFad · 17/08/2022 20:08

I've had emergency C-section and then a vbac. Initially recovery of vbac was harder as had episiotomy but once that healed (which it thankfully did without issue) I found them similar.
For me sitting down after episiotomy stitches was so much more painful than anything my section threw at me.

TopKnotch · 17/08/2022 20:07

"LilacSky95 · Today 17:14

It's fantastic some women are happy with their vaginal birth, i just think women should be more informed of what you could be potentially dealing with for the rest of your life if you choose vaginal birth. The midwifes make it sound like it will all go back to its pre pregnancy state with no issues, and that c sections are awful. I was utterly shocked by the reality. No health professional ever told me I could end up with severe prolapse, painful granulated scar tissue, and issues with sex following a vaginal birth. I think if I'd been given that information I honestly would have chosen C section first time round"

You could invert the terms here though couldn't you? You yourself are not listing the potential complications of a CS. I have friends who have scar issues etc many years down the line. One acquaintance had weeks of an open wound that wouldn't heal - she had to have a team of nurses visiting and a vacuum system attached...

I know many many women who had v straightforward vaginal deliveries and for them, an operation risking infection, epidural issues, bleeding, reduced mobility, blood clots, adhesions, scar numbness and puckering, continence issues etc would be completely disproportionate.

There is no certified, risk free option to giving birth. You're not able to state that one is better than the other for everyone. Each situation has a different balance of risks, benefits, preferences and circumstances.

I personally would have given my house to not have an epidural - the thought absolutely terrifies me and I luckily had 3 totally fine VB with absolutely no long term issues over a decade later.

I've got friends who have had to have counseling due to the flashbacks from the CS, some who have only had one child due to trauma from their VB. I've got friends who've escaped scot-free from both situations too (the majority).

YABVU to make out it's a black and white case.

Twizbe · 17/08/2022 20:07

FleetingGlance · 17/08/2022 19:55

i think in any sane country every single woman should have the option of an elective c-section if they wish. No judgement, no hassle, no justifying.

SO MUCH myths exist about ELECTIVE c-sections as emergency c-section data is often mixed in for the dangers, the cost etc which needs to be addressed as it completely goes against the right to balanced and accurate information for decision-making women.

Who has emergency c-sections? Mainly women attempting vaginal births!

There are so many myths surrounding vaginal births too.

This is what annoys me so much with these threads. It's all vaginal birth = shit, c section = great.

It's not that binary and it's possible to have a great vaginal birth. I'd hate to live in a country where my only real birth option was a c section. Sadly that is the case in some places.

Oh and I have friends who had emergency c sections without attempting a vaginal birth first.

45hopperbunny · 17/08/2022 20:06

I’ve had one VB and one C Section.

First VB an anaesthetist punctured my spine and caused me to have low pressure in the brain which resulted in a spinal headache. All because I needed an emergency epidural (I needed to be put on a drip to push my contractions together as DD was in distress and she needed to come out asap) and he went too far to the right. I also lost 3L of blood and had a third degree tear. 7 days stay in the hospital where the midwives were absolutely AWFUL which resulted in DD loosing a lot of weight and getting ill. Oh I also needed CAT scans, MRIs and three procedures to fix what happened to me. I now suffer from permanent migraines and neck pain/stiffness. A negligence case is currently open towards the NHS because of what happened to me.

C section was an absolute breeze. Because I had CBT therapy after what happened to me with DD, my therapist helped me write up a physiological birth plan which told everyone what happened to me and what I’d like to happen during my second labour. I was given an anaesthetist consultant who was aware what happened to me and took extra care when doing the spinal as I was scared to get back into that position. I was able to hold DS straight away and I wasn’t able to do that with DD. Amazing experience and I wish I had requested a C section first time round. Only downside is that DS was in NICU for 6 weeks and was having seizures and many different issues so that made my experience much more stressful than the first. However the C section itself was a 10/10 experience.

I realise I’ve been unfortunate both times and hopefully my experience is rare but seriously, I’d never have a VB again. I don’t see the importance in it at all

Badger1970 · 17/08/2022 20:05

I had 2 vaginal births and 2 c sections - 1st an emergency and 2nd was recommended.

I've since spent years writhing in pain with scar tissue/surgical adhesions that's wrapped itself around my uterus and bowels.

I am very grateful that mine were born healthy and alive (2nd was stillborn) but if I'd known the long term implications...... I'm not sure I'd have ever signed that consent form.

PrivateHall · 17/08/2022 20:02

Cantanka · 17/08/2022 20:00

I don’t think there’s a “better” way to give birth, each woman will assess her own risks and decide accordingly. I agree with you in terms of my own experience, but I also know lots of women who have had great experiences with vaginal births and absolutely didn’t want sections.

What is absolutely wrong is the NHS’s insistence that vaginal birth is objectively better. It isn’t, and they wouldn’t be saying that about any process which had a significant risk of obliterating men’s genitals, where a surgical alternative existed.

This is so true!

Oaty8 · 17/08/2022 20:01

Yes I agree OP and the reality is you can opt for an elective section on the nhs although it’s only accepted more so in some trusts since the occenden report.

I had a recent elective section, it was an amazing birth. Home within 24 hours, out and about by day 4. I’ve had 2 friends since say they’ll be opting for the same and other friends initially a bit aghast as very pro vaginal births, hypnobirthing birthing etc but every one has since commented how I recovered physically much quicker than them.

I work in the nhs and unfortunately have heard/seen the results of vaginal births gone wrong. My friend who worked as a junior doctor in obs and gynaecology said there was no way she’d have a vaginal birth and that made my (already fairly set) decision for me. Two of the midwives looking after me also said I’d made a great choice.

Theres no knowing if you’ll be the lucky one and have a straight forward vaginal birth before you try so to me an elective c section was less risky.

A straight forward elective section is not more expensive than a complex vaginal birth and there are a lot of complex vaginal births. Plus a large amount of statistics on c sections lump elective and emergency sections together and if you’ve had a long labour, complications and then a c section it’s not the same and emergency sections typically have different outcomes/recovery times.

Women should be able to choose the birth they want whatever that is.

Cantanka · 17/08/2022 20:00

I don’t think there’s a “better” way to give birth, each woman will assess her own risks and decide accordingly. I agree with you in terms of my own experience, but I also know lots of women who have had great experiences with vaginal births and absolutely didn’t want sections.

What is absolutely wrong is the NHS’s insistence that vaginal birth is objectively better. It isn’t, and they wouldn’t be saying that about any process which had a significant risk of obliterating men’s genitals, where a surgical alternative existed.

OceanbreezeSun · 17/08/2022 19:59

I come from a family of women ( my mum and 3 sisters) who had uncomplicated, quick vaginal births with their babies ( no medical intervention, except for one of my sisters who needed stitches for big baby no.3)

I (very) wrongly assumed I’d have a similar labour/birth, but I ended up being induced after my waters broke but contractions stopped, I was in labour for nearly 2 days, then needed an emergency forceps delivery with an episiotomy.

If the forceps didn’t work, I would of needed an EC. I was more scared of the thought of a c section tbh. My close friend had a very bad experience with recovery after hers and has had some complications years later because of it.

Despite the rather dramatic delivery - I think I was lucky. My stitches healed quite quickly and were not very painful. I didn’t suffer any short term or long term issues like prolapse, which could of easily happened.

I am currently pregnancy with baby no2 - I am quite nervous about the delivery this time around, but as it stands now, I would still rather have a vaginal delivery over a C section.

lifesnotaspectatorsport · 17/08/2022 19:58

I don't think it's necessarily the best option for everyone but I absolutely want every woman to be able to make an informed & personal choice.

For me that would mean explaining the possible repercussions of both VB and CS, any factors that might affect your decision eg age, number of children you want, position of baby etc.

I wanted and got 2 sections, I researched it thoroughly and I'm happy with my choice. No one tried to influence me (had all kids abroad, I'm aware there's more push towards VB in the U.K.)

For what it's worth, the sections themselves were unpleasant but the recovery was straightforward. No problems with bonding or breastfeeding, and no damage to my vulva or vagina. No prolapse, no incontinence, sex feels just as good as before. I had twins for my second birth so I feel pretty lucky overall to be left with no more than a pale scar with slight lumpiness at one end of it. (I did have appalling piles and had to have surgery on those at 34 weeks pregnant so I didn't get off scot free!)

Could I have had a straightforward vaginal birth? Unlikely given my age and a breech followed by twin pregnancy. But even if they'd been totally normal pregnancies I was more afraid of the possible outcomes of VB vs a section.

pointythings · 17/08/2022 19:57

I don't know - I had two VBs, the first with ventouse, the second with a tear, needed a fair number of stitches both times.

But I haven't been left with any real issues at all and I was back in pre preg jeans within 10 days both times.

FleetingGlance · 17/08/2022 19:55

i think in any sane country every single woman should have the option of an elective c-section if they wish. No judgement, no hassle, no justifying.

SO MUCH myths exist about ELECTIVE c-sections as emergency c-section data is often mixed in for the dangers, the cost etc which needs to be addressed as it completely goes against the right to balanced and accurate information for decision-making women.

Who has emergency c-sections? Mainly women attempting vaginal births!

PrivateHall · 17/08/2022 19:55

Gruffling · 17/08/2022 19:47

Yanbu. Once your butthole tears open in childbirth, it never really works the same again in my experience.

Whilst c sections are more expensive, this should be offset by the cost of the suffering of women's birth injuries...and NICU stays for shoulder dystocia babies. I'm sure the cost of my daughter's NICU stay and the cost of my own treatment to try and rectify my birth injuries would have funded more than a few c sections.

Some babies end up in NICU due to TTN - generally caused by babies not experiencing labour and having fluid pushed from their lungs during contractions. Also complicated by the fact the baby wasn't actually ready to be born yet. I see this more often that babies being admitted to NICU due to shoulder dystocia.

PrivateHall · 17/08/2022 19:52

I am a midwife and the most serious complications I have saw for women have been due to C/S rather than VB, however it would be the other way round in terms of safety for the baby (though overall birth is very safe for most babies of course).

That being said, I had two vaginal births then was advised a section for my third; I declined as I really didn't want a section. I had a third VB and all was fine.

I completely disagree with the thread title, the 'best birth option' is one where the woman was listened to and had her wishes facilitated. Whether that be home birth, water birth, vaginal birth, elective section etc.

You don't get to decide what is best for other women OP.

Swipe left for the next trending thread