Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think C section is the best birth option?

285 replies

LilacSky95 · 17/08/2022 16:46

I've had 3 vaginal births and 1 c section. The recovery from the vaginal births was a breeze, but I've been left with a host of issues from those that will last a lifetime.

My c section recovery was harder, but after the initial pain etc were off I was ok, and it was so nice to be intact 'down there' afterwards.

AIBU to think surely it's better to risk any of the problems that can arrise from having a section, over all the awful things that women often have to deal with for a lifetime after vaginal birth?

Yes I know c section is major surgery, but loads of women end up needing surgery to correct the damage done by vaginal birth too, and even then will never be the same again. At least your problems that come with a c section will be sorted out at least 12 months after delivery, and tour vagina is unscathed.

I've already had one lot of surgery to try and fix my prolapses, and will need more surgery in the future. I cant help feel jaded that if I'd had c sections I wouldn't have to go through all of this so maybe my views are skewed. What do you think?

OP posts:
AnotherCF · 17/08/2022 21:13

2 uncomplicated VBs, no post birth issues, home the same day.

2nd DC was breech at 37. I educated myself about ECV, ECS, breech VB. The training and experience of health professionals around you is a HUGE factor in outcomes. Its shocking that womens health is not treated as important as it should be so outcomes can be better.

LadyFuHao · 17/08/2022 21:12

C-Sections aren't always plain sailing they can go very, very, very wrong. My anaesthetic during an emergency section didn't work. I wouldn't wish that experience on anyone ever.

UncomfortableBadger · 17/08/2022 21:10

I’m 4 weeks on from an emergency c-section (after a traumatic failed 4 day induction) and honestly the recovery has been brutal.

I’ve never felt more helpless & vulnerable than the first morning after the op, when I was delirious with pain & my husband had to help me out of bed on the ward, to shower me, put me into giant incontinence knickers and dress me.

I had a dural puncture from the epidural which led to the most horrific ice pick headache which was only relieved when I lay down completely flat. Not ideal when caring for a newborn. It took two attempts at a blood patch op & several days in hospital to fix it.

I then caught Covid from being in the hospital (the Covid cough in FUN when you are post c-section as it’s like your insides will all fall out).

I’m now battling an infected incision too and have been on drugs for weeks that aren’t compatible with breastfeeding, so we’ve ended up having to ditch breastfeeding altogether pro tem (I’m pumping in the meantime to try & keep supply up).

Honestly, the birth & subsequent recovery has been so dreadful that I can’t countenance ever having a second child.

Jamaisy82 · 17/08/2022 21:05

I think it all depends. You could have a vbac and it all go well or you could have c section and all go well or you could have a terrible experience with either. If you have had a terrible experience with one then your going to want to do the other. My first birth was an emcs I was 42 weeks and was induced and was in labour for so long but in end had to have an emergency as baby was losing their heartbeat. The whole thing was traumatic I was put under GA as was so stressed and panicked I was only 17. I stayed in hospital a week and yes it was tough. I've opted for elcs this time at 39 weeks as doctor told me about risks involved like original c section wound bursting open etc and I also didn't want to end up with an emergency again. My baby is breech also so elcs is best choice. I'm so scared I won't lie but either way has to be done.

Hugasauras · 17/08/2022 21:05

I was quite frightened of baby getting stuck and deprived of oxygen too. This happened to a friend of mine and her baby ended up with brain damage. It terrified me that a totally healthy baby could be so badly injured during birth, although I know that must be quite rare.

There's just so much to it all that it's such an individual decision.

LilacSky95 · 17/08/2022 21:04

Gawd, another anxiety-revving thread. MN is so in love with them. It doesn't help women to hear a heap of scare stories about how they give birth. There are challenges & hazards however a pregnancy ends. No zero-risk option.

sorry, it's not my intention to scare women or fear monger. However isn't this attitude part of the problem? We can't keep lying to pregnant women/women who plan on having children at some point and tell them all will be fine, when actually chances are it won't be. Os it not better to tell the truth and inform women of what could potentially happen to them so they don't go in blind like a lot of us did? I agree there's no need to unnecessarily scare anyone, but I don't think that's what's being done here at all. Many women on this thread have said they have had a lovely positive experience, with both CS and VB.

OP posts:
Cantanka · 17/08/2022 21:03

Blossomtoes · 17/08/2022 20:54

I don’t think your mum’s arrogant @Frida9, her experience is valid. Your sister’s been very unlucky.

her mother is arrogant. Being positive about her experiences is fair enough but calling c-sections wimpy is awful.

also I suppose frida sister is unlucky but what has happened to her isn’t that extreme or unsual. Lots of women have failed inductions, forceps and haemorrhages with ongoing damage.

Frida9 · 17/08/2022 20:57

No, knowing my mum she is arrogant. She was lucky and I'm built like her so I'm hoping I'll be lucky too but basically telling your daughter's that they will have failed if they don't try a VB is arrogant.

Motherofplants · 17/08/2022 20:55

I feel in the minority, but I had a cesarean for my first (breech) with a terrible painful recovery. No medical issues at all except numbness 3 years on, I'm just low pain tolerance apparently. The recovery was truly horrific for me, quite damaging mentally.

I decided very last minute to have a vbac for my second this year - got a precipitous labour with shoulder dystocia, 2nd degree tear only. This second recovery was an absolute doddle in comparison, a little soreness, but I was up as usual same day and no longer term pain. No zombie walks, playing with my 3 year old as normal next day when we were allowed home (baby was resuscitated so they kept us in overnight to be safe).

I would vbac any day of the week before doing another cesarean now (except for medical need ofc). But you can never know how it will be until you've already done it.

YouSoundLovely · 17/08/2022 20:54

3 births, all vaginal - two instrumental (ventouse), one of those with an episiotomy and PPH; one as a response to fetal distress at the very end of a short labour and causing a second degree tear - and the third induced, no instruments, and very precipitous indeed. I had/have uncomplicated recoveries and no short- or long-term problems whatsoever, was on my feet again right away. All of those deliveries had the potential to be traumatising, I think, esp the first, but none of them were. That's partly, I think, to do with having had focused and responsive care. I imagine some PP think my births sound like complete nightmares, but I was glad I had them all and suppose I just wanted to put the other side - that even quite complicated vaginal births don't necessarily lead to devastating long-term consequences.

Blossomtoes · 17/08/2022 20:54

I don’t think your mum’s arrogant @Frida9, her experience is valid. Your sister’s been very unlucky.

3amAndImStillAwake · 17/08/2022 20:54

Fixyourself · 17/08/2022 19:20

I’ve had both and much preferred the vb. Both were tough recoveries in different ways.
Cs has left me with a pouch that I just can’t shift.
Being induced can make a vb a horrible experience.

My induction with DD2 was better than my non-induced labour with DD1.

Obviously I know it's not like that for everyone, but just an example of how experiences are so varied, which is why I think OP is wrong to say there is a best option.

LuckySantangelo35 · 17/08/2022 20:53

What are women’s experience of getting an elective c section with the NHS now?

I had heard it could be difficult, you would really have to argue your case, maybe have to ask to see a different consultant etc

have things changed? I hope so!

Ponderingwindow · 17/08/2022 20:53

LuckySantangelo35 · 17/08/2022 20:46

@Ponderingwindow

difference to the baby is minimal

but it’s huge to the mother

@LuckySantangelo35
That is a bold statement to make without any evidence.

i am not an expert in this subject so I can’t make a definitive claim. I I only know that there are trade offs and that I personally was injured during my birth by c-section.

Quia · 17/08/2022 20:52

Two VB, one CS. No complications following the VBs, fast recovery afterwards, no ongoing problems with my vagina or cervix. Sepsis after the CS. No contest, VB wins every time.

EdPsychonaQuest · 17/08/2022 20:52

LilacSky95 · 17/08/2022 17:14

It's fantastic some women are happy with their vaginal birth, i just think women should be more informed of what you could be potentially dealing with for the rest of your life if you choose vaginal birth. The midwifes make it sound like it will all go back to its pre pregnancy state with no issues, and that c sections are awful. I was utterly shocked by the reality. No health professional ever told me I could end up with severe prolapse, painful granulated scar tissue, and issues with sex following a vaginal birth. I think if I'd been given that information I honestly would have chosen C section first time round

And if you had, and had still had your 4 children, all by c section, you would have been at significant risk of placental issues; praevia at best, percreta at worst. A friend had percreta on her 4 th section, died 3 times, had 24 units of blood, a hysterectomy and has ongoing bowel and bladder issues as a result of the placental tissue. The friend of a close friend died from percreta with her 3rd child. The baby was fine.

Multiple c sections are NOT better than multiple vaginal births. If you are definitely having just 1 or 2, maybe. Any more than that, it's more dangerous.

Frida9 · 17/08/2022 20:48

I've been really interested reading this thread, currently expecting my first, 16 weeks and no midwife has mentioned the birth yet.
My mum had 3 relatively easy vb's (one born with cord round neck) and has no major issues now 25+ years on except bladder weakness which pregnancy causes anyway.
My sister had an induction, failed epidural, forceps, haemorrhage and a week in hospital. she's now 30, urinary incontinent and begging her GP to help her.
I've no idea what I want because I don't know enough about my options, C section was always made out by my mum to be a wimpy option but after seeing what's happened to my sister I know she's just arrogant because it was easy for her. Hopefully I can talk to my midwife and decide for myself what I want.

LuckySantangelo35 · 17/08/2022 20:46

Ponderingwindow · 17/08/2022 20:10

You haven’t included the risks and benefits for the baby in your calculations. Vaginal birth is far from perfectly safe, but it also helps clear lungs and guarantees that the baby is indeed ready to be born. Just as babies can suffer injury during a vaginal birth, they can be injured during a c-section.

@Ponderingwindow

difference to the baby is minimal

but it’s huge to the mother

Stylishkidintheriot · 17/08/2022 20:45

For me I had a planned CS: it was bloody wonderful.

littlepeas · 17/08/2022 20:44

I’ve only had c sections, so can’t compare to vb:

dc1 - emergency CS for foetal distress (exhausting long labour).

dc2 - elective CS with big (approx 1200ml) haemorrhage (needed transfusion).

dc3 - the dream elective, no issues.

I recovered very quickly after all 3 though.

Biggest downside as far as I’m concerned is the risks in subsequent pregnancies. These increase the more cs you have and some of them can be very serious.

KevinTheKoala · 17/08/2022 20:42

I had one unmedicated vaginally birth with an episiotomy and forceps (so not great basically) and one cat 1 emergency c-section which was also not great. But I also understand that my recovery from the c-section was not typical (literally only allowed to drink 10ml of water every hour for 24 hours post op, on the HDU unable to close curtains for 48 hours after, catheter left in to monitor urine output for days, hooked up to continuous IV drips and monitors for days etc.) But frankly I preferred my recovery from the vaginal birth! I have complications from the c-section too sadly so I can't say that they are a better way to give birth. I don't think there is a 'better way' to give birth, other than the safest option for the mother and baby and that won't always be what the mother wants (I wanted a home birth with my second....got the complete opposite).

surreygirl1987 · 17/08/2022 20:41

My friend almost died from her vb. But another friend lost heaps of blood in a problematic cs. You just don't know what's going to happen.

surreygirl1987 · 17/08/2022 20:40

With my births, my c section was a million times better.

But recovery, vaginally birth was so much better.

It honestly depends on the circumstance and the person and (unless there are already known complications - eg my son was breech) - you're not going to know for definite until it's already happening!

Twinklinlight · 17/08/2022 20:37

On the whole I think c sections are a more civilised way of giving birth. I was fortunate to have the choice and even though the recovery was probably more difficult than a straight forward vaginal birth, the peace it brought knowing it should mean my dc was brought into the world safely was worth it. As it went I found the section recovery quite straight forward and was lucky to have no complications.

ColonelCarter · 17/08/2022 20:33

1 of each. C section was tonnes better. Faster, less painful recovery and no long term issues.