Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think C section is the best birth option?

285 replies

LilacSky95 · 17/08/2022 16:46

I've had 3 vaginal births and 1 c section. The recovery from the vaginal births was a breeze, but I've been left with a host of issues from those that will last a lifetime.

My c section recovery was harder, but after the initial pain etc were off I was ok, and it was so nice to be intact 'down there' afterwards.

AIBU to think surely it's better to risk any of the problems that can arrise from having a section, over all the awful things that women often have to deal with for a lifetime after vaginal birth?

Yes I know c section is major surgery, but loads of women end up needing surgery to correct the damage done by vaginal birth too, and even then will never be the same again. At least your problems that come with a c section will be sorted out at least 12 months after delivery, and tour vagina is unscathed.

I've already had one lot of surgery to try and fix my prolapses, and will need more surgery in the future. I cant help feel jaded that if I'd had c sections I wouldn't have to go through all of this so maybe my views are skewed. What do you think?

OP posts:
ancientgran · 18/08/2022 18:16

LilacSky95 · 18/08/2022 18:01

@ancientgran I've got propper monkey feet with wide gaps between the toes, can spread them so wide I can hold hands with my feet, yet I still suffered badly with prolapse and incontinence. Maybe I'm just unlucky!

When I was at school, many years ago, every term we were checked for athlete's foot. We would have to put our feet one by one on a bench in front of the PE teacher and spread our toes, most people used their fingers to separate their toes and people found it hilarious to watch how wide I could spread mine. I can also roll my tongue and wiggle my ears, I'm not sure what all that indicates but as I said my husband reckons I'm closely related to prehistoric humans or monkeys. I must google my strange abilities.

LilacSky95 · 18/08/2022 18:13

I wish I could vote twice. I completely agree. It's scandalous that the medical profession is not more honest with women about this

👏👏👏👏 my feelings exactly

OP posts:
CheeseyToasts · 18/08/2022 18:13

@ancientgran

It's not my narrative

It's factual data - foreceps are worse for the babies and mothers compared to a c-section when looking at data, over your anecdotal stories.

in cases where there were no signs of distress, infants were five to 10 times more likely to experience severe, potentially debilitating birth trauma when forceps or a vacuum were used at the mid-pelvic stage compared to if they were delivered via Caesarean section. Those traumas included brain bleeds, palsies that created permanent damage, and severe damage to the spleen or the liver.
Among mothers who had mid-pelvic forceps deliveries, 19 percent experienced third- or fourth-degree tearing and, for those who had vacuum deliveries, 12 percent had the same result. “These are severe tears,” says Muraca. “They’re the kind of tears that can cause long-term pelvic floor disorders like incontinence, pelvic pain, sexual problems and pelvic organ prolapse.” These delivery methods also resulted in higher rates of other types of obstetric trauma, including lacerations in the high vaginal tract and injuries to the pelvic joints or organs. And both mid-pelvic forceps and vacuum deliveries were associated with increased rates of postpartum hemorrhage compared to C-sections.

ancientgran · 18/08/2022 18:08

CheeseyToasts · 18/08/2022 18:04

@ancientgran do you honestly not comprehend the difference between an EMCS and ELCS?

You stating your forceps delivery was better than your EMCS doesn't mean it's better than an ELCS

Do you mean to be so aggressively rude? Obviously I know there is a difference but in all honesty I'm not sure that it is only EMCS that leads to a loss or alteration of sensation in the scar. I do know categorically that a difficult forceps delivery can end up with no issues to the mother as I am the living proof. I'm sure that isn't what you want to hear as it really doesn't fit with your narrative so apologies for that.

ancientgran · 18/08/2022 18:05

LilacSky95 · 18/08/2022 18:01

@ancientgran I've got propper monkey feet with wide gaps between the toes, can spread them so wide I can hold hands with my feet, yet I still suffered badly with prolapse and incontinence. Maybe I'm just unlucky!

So a study of two doesn't help. Would be useful for someone to study it though. As my obstetrician said they don't have a crystal ball about how a delivery will go but something so simple could help women make the best decision but obviously it can't be 100% as you prove.

CheeseyToasts · 18/08/2022 18:04

@ancientgran do you honestly not comprehend the difference between an EMCS and ELCS?

You stating your forceps delivery was better than your EMCS doesn't mean it's better than an ELCS

WellThatsMeScrewed · 18/08/2022 18:04

redglobox · 18/08/2022 18:00

I wish I could vote twice. I completely agree. It's scandalous that the medical profession is not more honest with women about this.

And that is the crux of it. Rather than battering each other we need to get angry at the medical profession (not medics themselves who are working bloody hard I know!) that does not centre women at the heart of healthcare. And never has done.

LilacSky95 · 18/08/2022 18:01

@ancientgran I've got propper monkey feet with wide gaps between the toes, can spread them so wide I can hold hands with my feet, yet I still suffered badly with prolapse and incontinence. Maybe I'm just unlucky!

OP posts:
CheeseyToasts · 18/08/2022 18:01

Confusion101 · 18/08/2022 17:53

Has anyone read studies about C sections and an increase in autism? A nurse stupidly brought it to my attention when I was pregnant and had me worried but there is some evidence there. Obviously hard to fully know and some research papers dispute it too! 🤷🏼‍♀️

Why would a c-section have any impact on autism

Just have a think about it and you'll see how ridiculous that is

Age of the parents and genetics are what matters with autism

FarmerRefuted · 18/08/2022 18:01

Confusion101 · 18/08/2022 17:53

Has anyone read studies about C sections and an increase in autism? A nurse stupidly brought it to my attention when I was pregnant and had me worried but there is some evidence there. Obviously hard to fully know and some research papers dispute it too! 🤷🏼‍♀️

Correlation is not causation and further/more recent studies that looked at other factors - in particular the rates of autism and ADHD in siblings - found that there was no increased risk.

WellThatsMeScrewed · 18/08/2022 18:01

I think what this whole debate shows is that women feel so defensive about the choices they made/didn’t make (and I include myself in that).

I am curious about why that is. Why we do it to ourselves?

I can hear all the pros to C-sections but I can’t help but say ‘but my choice was valid to and Ok’.

I appreciate that others are saying women need to be told the full risks, and they absolutely need to be. But women may still choose another decision and that is also ok.

redglobox · 18/08/2022 18:00

I wish I could vote twice. I completely agree. It's scandalous that the medical profession is not more honest with women about this.

ancientgran · 18/08/2022 17:59

Confusion101 · 18/08/2022 17:53

Has anyone read studies about C sections and an increase in autism? A nurse stupidly brought it to my attention when I was pregnant and had me worried but there is some evidence there. Obviously hard to fully know and some research papers dispute it too! 🤷🏼‍♀️

I've never heard that. I wonder if there is any research.

ancientgran · 18/08/2022 17:57

This is quite an interesting article about urinary incontinence and if it is actually anything to do with childbirth. www.webmd.com/urinary-incontinence-oab/news/20051202/urine-leakage-not-childbirth

The bit I found interesting from a personal point of view is right at the end Galloway offers advice for how women can know whether their pelvic floor is well suited to withstand the rigors of vaginal delivery.
"The nerves and muscles that enervate the feet are adjacent to those responsible for the pelvic floor," Galloway says. "If you were trying to distinguish whether you are at risk or not, look and see how complete is the form and function of your feet and toes. Those with the best, most versatile feet who can spread their toes like fingers are more likely to have better function in the pelvic floor."

I can spread my toes like fingers, my husband says it's being like a monkey, and I've had 3 vaginal deliveries of big babies and one being with forceps and I'm also over 20 years post menopause and I don't have incontinence issues and my vagina is in pretty good nick if I do say so myself. Is it connected to my toes? What a strange idea but maybe we should do a survey and see if everyone who has reported good vaginal births have "versatile" feet.

How useful would that be if it is true as women would be able to make more informed decisions. I'm looking at my widespread toes with new admiration.

Confusion101 · 18/08/2022 17:53

Has anyone read studies about C sections and an increase in autism? A nurse stupidly brought it to my attention when I was pregnant and had me worried but there is some evidence there. Obviously hard to fully know and some research papers dispute it too! 🤷🏼‍♀️

WellThatsMeScrewed · 18/08/2022 17:53

Cantanka · 18/08/2022 16:11

Someone has just called people who have vaginal births as having ‘wizard sleeves’ for vaginas. So yeh it’s me being mean

wizard sleeve is a vile term I agree but as someone with a significant birth injury from VB, I didn’t much like “we don’t all have a broken undercarriage you know”. I found broken undercarriage derogatory.

As I said upthread, there is no right or better way to give birth. It should be about empowerment and choice for each women. There is no doubt that many women face obstruction in their choice to have a caesarean because VB is pushed as being objectively better and safer. In fact, either is a perfectly valid choice which should be respected.

Oh come on you know that is not a term I would use. It was my emotional reaction to what others were saying!!!

ancientgran · 18/08/2022 17:43

CheeseyToasts · 18/08/2022 16:47

@ancientgran

Then you're in a minority

Studies find that forceps and vacuum deliveries can lead to more physical trauma for a mother and baby than a C-section would.

I'm not sure that means I'm in a minority, it just says it can lead to ....... Doesn't say how likely that is. For some, I'm sure I'm not unique, you could also say forceps deliveries can lead to more physical trauma than a C section would because that was my experience.

Obviously there might be more stats to show it is more likely but that doesn't say so.

I will say the swelling and bruising was awful for the first week but 30 years on it hasn't caused any other problems whereas the EMCS has.

LilacSky95 · 18/08/2022 17:33

LilacSky95 the thing is, if you’d had all births as CS, by the 4th you would likely be running into complications/ problems and it wouldn’t be smooth sailing.

true. Although I know women on their 4th and 5th(!) sections, Including some celebs who have had no problems, so theres no way of knowing what would have happened. My point is that the VAGINA and pelvic floor would be undamaged. I would happily take the other risks that come with CS , and have an intact, scar free, continent vagina.

OP posts:
CheeseyToasts · 18/08/2022 16:47

@ancientgran

Then you're in a minority

Studies find that forceps and vacuum deliveries can lead to more physical trauma for a mother and baby than a C-section would.

ancientgran · 18/08/2022 16:36

CheeseyToasts · 18/08/2022 15:43

I've clearly stated the odds for our local hospital in my comment

Less than half of women who enter in labour had an instrument free vaginal birth, and avoided an emergency c section

Those stats look in line with the national average

So, again, based on the odds you're more likely not to have a smooth sailing VB.

An instrument birth isn't always a problem though, mine resulted in a lot of bruising and piles which all healed so for me although I had a forceps delivery I wouldn't say that was as big an issue as the CS.

ancientgran · 18/08/2022 16:34

For people who know the stats how does it compare for the babies, is one safer than the other? There was a big difference with chest infections with my one that was EMCS, years of terrible chest infections but starting the day after she was born and someone told me that was more likely with CS but I have no idea if it is true.

ancientgran · 18/08/2022 16:30

Mysteryuser · 18/08/2022 14:26

I had an ELCS, at my request as I'd weighed up the evidence, over 21 years ago. Very glad that I did. My recovery was very quick, no infections ( other than a UTI probably caused by the catheter according to my GP) which went very quickly. My DM had two very easy vaginal births, with no damage at all, but MIL had a terrible time and lifelong issues. Although VB can be great, I think the unpredictability is the issue.
The important thing, I think, is that people are properly informed on the risks and benefits of CS and VB, without prejudice, and are encouraged and supported to make the decision which they feel is best for them.

After an EMCS with my third I was discussing what to do with my obstetrician. I said I'd prefer a VB but if things were going to go wrong and end up with an EMCS I'd prefer an elective. He said he'd like a crystal ball but we'd have to manage without. I went for the VB, almost ended up with an EMCS but a very nice registrar said, "Right, if you move this baby with the next contraction I'll deliver him, if you can't move him its the CS." So I moved him and he delivered him and apart from epic bruising all was well.

Cantanka · 18/08/2022 16:11

Someone has just called people who have vaginal births as having ‘wizard sleeves’ for vaginas. So yeh it’s me being mean

wizard sleeve is a vile term I agree but as someone with a significant birth injury from VB, I didn’t much like “we don’t all have a broken undercarriage you know”. I found broken undercarriage derogatory.

As I said upthread, there is no right or better way to give birth. It should be about empowerment and choice for each women. There is no doubt that many women face obstruction in their choice to have a caesarean because VB is pushed as being objectively better and safer. In fact, either is a perfectly valid choice which should be respected.

CheeseyToasts · 18/08/2022 15:45

WellThatsMeScrewed · 18/08/2022 15:08

So if we compare VB stats to ECS where there is REALLY GOOD care not shitty second rate NHS on its knees care I wonder what the stats would be?

They've compared just that in Canada which has a better health care system than here

ELCS still takes the 'crown' just about over vaginal births for maternal outcomes including complications and long term medical needs

CheeseyToasts · 18/08/2022 15:43

Blossomtoes · 18/08/2022 15:15

Odds are you're not going to have a straight forward VB

What are the odds? I don’t know anyone who hasn’t had one. There’s something quite unsettling about your aggressive evangelism for ELCS @CheeseyToasts. I really don’t understand why you’re so invested in other women’s birth choices.

I've clearly stated the odds for our local hospital in my comment

Less than half of women who enter in labour had an instrument free vaginal birth, and avoided an emergency c section

Those stats look in line with the national average

So, again, based on the odds you're more likely not to have a smooth sailing VB.