Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What's it really like for a child with 50/50 custody mum and dad?

260 replies

rejectshampoodemandtherealpoo · 17/08/2022 16:03

I can only ask for experience. I was brought up by a single parent with little involvement from the other. So I have no idea what it would be like to be shared.

What's it like for those of you who grew up with an arrangement like this where you live between two houses?

I want to know if it's overall good or bad. Just out of interest as I got thinking about this. Thankfully I don't have to consider it for my child but I am very curious.

OP posts:
Jellytottss · 17/08/2022 18:30

Glad OP started this thread very interesting. The resident parent has a lot from time but you get to see your the most and most kids are attached to the mother the most. I've left my child (was dating his dad still then) for a whole week whilst I had a girls holiday and he was 9 months old. I think ultimately a child is too young to be passed between houses and it's uncommon so perhaps as a nation we are not used to the men pulling their weight also regarding parenting? I can't quite articulate it but I would miss my child and even though it's relentless at times and I would like his dad to do more than EOW and 3 weeks of the school holidays I don't think I would swop for a 50/50 split even if I could.

missymarrk · 17/08/2022 18:25

CookPassBabtridge · 17/08/2022 18:04

My kids don't live out of a suitcase, they have everything at both houses. Just trying to counter some of the negatives people are saying.
Just think this thread could be harmful to women wanting to split from an unhappy relationship but the idea of 50:50 might stop them.

Same. We are 50/50. DC has everything he needs at both houses and has been in that routine for 10 years now. I asked him once and he said well I'd prefer you both living together but that didn't work so this is good.

You definitely need to be quite organised. Only thing that ever needs moved around is football kit though.

We live about 5 miles apart.

He's very much at home in both houses.

Triotriotrio · 17/08/2022 18:23

I should now, we have 50/50 each but some months I have the kids 100% of the time, others he had them 100%. We don't add it up. If we did I'd say they spend 60% of time at mine, but I'm lovely so why wouldn't thay 😉😂

BadNomad · 17/08/2022 18:22

I "lived" with my mum and "stayed" with my dad during his contact time. When he got remarried, it then became "visiting" dad. I never saw his house as another home.

My friend had 50/50 with her parents. She says she didn't feel like she had one home, never mind two. She "stayed" with her mum one week then "stayed" with her dad the next.

Do children ever actually feel like they have two homes?

Triotriotrio · 17/08/2022 18:21

I think it is easier when they are older. I have 50/50 with my ex and basically the kids stay wherever they want except every other weekend when we have set time without the kids.

It works because a) we get on and b) we have older kids and can be a bit more flexible.

Tbh the thing we fall out over most is if the ex has planned to make the kids dinner and then they decide to come to mine!! That really gets his goat. Even if they tell him 6 days before.... He meal plans and apparently this is an insurmountable problem for him. I just roll my eyes and say there there in appropriate places.

It works really well for us. But it might not depending on the kids or adults relationships

Diamondinthesolesofhershoes · 17/08/2022 18:17

We do 2 week nights at his and 1 weekend a month. The majority of time he's here which I prefer obviously. His dad doesn't tend to do very much with him so I feel he's better and more stimulated here. It's also closer to his school

TeddyBearsTogether · 17/08/2022 18:17

A family member (male btw) has his boys 50/50, he loves it but the boys hate it. They want to be with their dad all the time and just see their mum at weekends.

Their situation is strange though because she's a nurse and works a shift pattern of 14 off, 7 days, 7 nights, so they spend 2 weeks at a time at each house. They also don't have a room at all at their mums as their older half sibling, siblings DP and siblings baby lives in the only spare room so they sleep on the sofa. Whereas even though they have another older half-sib at their dads they have a room and beds and toys.

My own DC goes to their dads EOWend and hates that too, they want to see their dad more so I think neither situation works well.

GiantSpaceHamster · 17/08/2022 18:12

notanothertakeaway · 17/08/2022 16:32

I don't think the courts favour 50 50, or at least not in the UK

Also, most adults wouldn't want to divide their time 50 50 between two homes. I don't know why they think a child would like it

No, you’re right, they don’t.

I’ve worked in the family court system for five years and can count on one hand the orders made for 50/50. As the very first response says, this kind of arrangement only works for children where their parents are consistent, communicate well and are at the least civil towards each other. Not qualities known to exist in families who are in court.

GiantSpaceHamster · 17/08/2022 18:10

rejectshampoodemandtherealpoo · 17/08/2022 16:17

I completely agree and wish the family courts did also. It seems like a bad idea but like I said I've not lived it so can't know.

This is exactly how the family courts view things in my area.

Jamaisy82 · 17/08/2022 18:08

@loveireland when he has her he takes her and picks her up from school each day he lives about 45 mins from school and the mam lives 5 mins.

WinterMusings · 17/08/2022 18:04

Sadly, I don't think there's a brilliant answer. It also varies enormously between kids.

I think the most children don't like it & don't benefit from it. I think they do best when they have 'home' & dads/mums house. They need A home as much as we do and I think few of us would want to be moving every week back & forth. As an adult I did a live in job for about 3 years. For various reasons I couldn't leave stuff in the room I used at work, so every bloody three weeks it was a full move in/move out. Had it been every week I may well have gone completely mad. Yes it was different as I had responsibilities at work so it was pretty full on, but even if I'd been looked after instead I wouldn't have chosen
it.

I can't be done with 'free floating children' either, so I guess it's EOW & holidays as it suits everyone.

none of its ideal, but neither is life on the whole!!

Thereisnolight · 17/08/2022 18:04

Unsurprised there is an association with mental illness.
I could see it working if the parents lived close to each other and got on reasonably well.
But throw in warring parents, step-parents and worst of all, unrelated blended siblings and the child ends up with nowhere to call home.

CookPassBabtridge · 17/08/2022 18:04

My kids don't live out of a suitcase, they have everything at both houses. Just trying to counter some of the negatives people are saying.
Just think this thread could be harmful to women wanting to split from an unhappy relationship but the idea of 50:50 might stop them.

JustLyra · 17/08/2022 18:02

I think it really depends on the child.

my nephew has been 50/50 his whole life pretty much. His parents live in the same street, they get on well so there’s no arguments, and he (he’s now 19) has always felt like a lucky kid who had two actual homes instead of one.

My ex insisted on it for a (thankfully) very short period when my girls were younger. They hated it. They never, ever felt at home in his house, because of the way him and his new wife treated them, and being there half the week was horrible for them.

There’s a family I know where the kids remain in the house 100% of the time and the adults move between the house and a flat. So they have 50/50 but the kids don’t need to move. It seems like a good arrangement but I don’t see it lasting so smoothly if either of the parents meet a new partner.

Letsmoveon · 17/08/2022 17:52

I lived in a 50:50 situation from age 6 which my parents decided upon (no court order). It had pros and cons and the latter outweighed the former. By the time I was 13-14 I started staying more at my DM’s as I was absolutely sick to death of living my life out of a suitcase and all the other upheaval that went with it.

I do think these arrangements are mostly to suit parental access to their DC as of course most parents don’t want to only see their DC fortnightly and a night in the week; however, the best situation for the child should always be paramount even if this causes grief to the parent who sees them the least. 50:50 situations should be reviewed regularly particularly as children get older and parents should be open to agreeing new arrangements.

My friend is going through a nasty custody battle over their 3 year old and her abusive ex wants 50:50. Not only is there abuse involved but I am horrified at the thought that a court could force a 3 year old to live in a 50:50 arrangement. I had a hard enough time as a 6 year old but 3? Absolutely bloody no from me, as someone who has lived through it as a child myself. Stuff what the parents want 😡

Titsflyingsouth · 17/08/2022 17:49

I'm a child of divorced parents and I also used to be a teacher and saw lots of kids from divorced homes.

It can work fine when parents work as a team and are on the same page about child rearing . When they commit to regular patterns of access and are consistent.

It's a nightmare when:

  1. parents are pitted against each other and constantly pumping the kid for intelligence or trying to score points against each other.

  2. Parents have wildly different parenting styles - lack of consistency of boundaries and rules becomes confusing and a source of arguments.

  3. When one parent dips in and out of the child's life randomly. This was a big trigger for a lot of kids I saw. Routine is everything!

  4. When parents prioritise the wishes of new spouses over their kids

  5. When living arrangements are insecure - temporary accommodation etc

Basically kids need to feel safe and they need consistency in their lives. If they have that, they can adapt to differing family structures without lasting impact. But it takes effort and commitment on the part of the parents...

Darhon · 17/08/2022 17:40

As in nested kids or moving between 2 homes? I can’t quite work out what the common set up was?

CookPassBabtridge · 17/08/2022 17:36

Courgeon · 17/08/2022 17:31

No personal experience but know if a family that do it. Kids seem fractious and unsettled. Both parents refuse to take the kids to their activities on the day its "their" week, so kids only go to swimming/tennis/rainbows etc every other week. Petty and stupid. The parents have done it so they get as much free time as possible. No consideration for the needs of the children.

Well yes that doesn't work as the parents aren't working as a team.

GreenIsle · 17/08/2022 17:32

Even if 50/50 one parents home never feels like home whilst the other does so feels uncomfortable as you grow older.

Courgeon · 17/08/2022 17:31

No personal experience but know if a family that do it. Kids seem fractious and unsettled. Both parents refuse to take the kids to their activities on the day its "their" week, so kids only go to swimming/tennis/rainbows etc every other week. Petty and stupid. The parents have done it so they get as much free time as possible. No consideration for the needs of the children.

CloudCatz · 17/08/2022 17:29

I didn't want two bastard homes

itwasntmetho · 17/08/2022 17:27

PowerPack · 17/08/2022 16:55

I know shared arrangements are popular now, but I'm not convinced they're in the inerest of the child.

A few years ago we had a horrible spell in our county where we had far too many teenagers committing suicide. Schools felt they were facing critism about the pressure children were under/bullying etc and did a piece of work to try and find out what was happening and how these awful deaths could be prevented.

It was only a small sample, although also far too large and research wasn't scientific, but the only things they all, every single one, had in common was that they had previously self harmed (although some a long time ago) and they had homelives where parents had split but both parents were still very much around/shared residency. Not all 50/50, but significant time spent with both parents.

Other than that the children were a real mix of sporty or not, academically gifted, average and struggling, popular and bullied, affluent, average, deprived. We couldn't find anything else in common.

Now obviously lots of children live in these situations without coming to such tragic harm and correlation doesn't equal cause etc, but I really feel strongly that that information is worth further research. People don't want to hear it though, everyone wants to believe "fair" is best, but who's it fair/best for?

I know I'd be unsettled if I was going to a different home on different days and that's without the pull of different parents. I'm sure lots manage to create home where that doesn't happen, but most children must feel it to some extent?

That's shocking. This should be looked into.

CloudCatz · 17/08/2022 17:26

Fucking horrible.

I just wanted a main base to have most of my stuff in. I didn't want to travel so much. Every other weekend and longer in holidays would have been MY preference.

badgerstink · 17/08/2022 17:24

Didn't work for me. Well it did for about 8 weeks but ExH is a pretty unreliable parent and they defaulted back to me.

If you've a slightly more mature, dependable Ex with whom you can communicate it would probably be ok

CookPassBabtridge · 17/08/2022 17:23

I adore my boys and see them all the time, it's made me an even better mum as they get so much more attention from me now, and same with him.
But it's harder on your own, so one of the positives is to get a rest. And it's only fair both parents, when they are both loving parents of course, get equal time with the kids and equal downtime.

Swipe left for the next trending thread