Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What's it really like for a child with 50/50 custody mum and dad?

260 replies

rejectshampoodemandtherealpoo · 17/08/2022 16:03

I can only ask for experience. I was brought up by a single parent with little involvement from the other. So I have no idea what it would be like to be shared.

What's it like for those of you who grew up with an arrangement like this where you live between two houses?

I want to know if it's overall good or bad. Just out of interest as I got thinking about this. Thankfully I don't have to consider it for my child but I am very curious.

OP posts:
Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 18/08/2022 07:44

CookPassBabtridge · 17/08/2022 20:01

I could have written this 🖤 It's good to hear others rocking this set-up.
Key to it definitely seems to be parents who get on well.. no animosity, we're on the same page so always back each other up, talk highly of each other, we've both made it a really positive experience.
I daresay some of the ones saying it's harmful are jealous of posters having good relations with the ex.

@CookPassBabtridge

Odd conclusion to reach given that most of the people who have said they disagree with it are people who have experienced it for themselves. Lots of parents saying it works for their children, but most of the people responding as "the children" disagree. So it's hardly jealousy, and I do wonder if there's a bit of a confirmation bias in all these parents that proclaim how much their kids love it.

Anyway, there will be lots of factors that influence whether it works or not. Yes the relationship (and proximinity) of the parents, the set up at each house and also the child itself (their nature, personality etc). Some kids won't mind or will even thrive with it. Others won't be so happy.

justusandmoo · 18/08/2022 07:36

ariesalien · 17/08/2022 16:23

I've always said to DP that if we split, I won't do 50:50. Lots of time with both parents, flexible schedules, good communication... but I just don't think 50/50 is ultimately best for kids as courts say.
People I know that grew up with 50/50 hated it.

Maybe I'm biased because I also grew up with one parent and a secure home with some time with the other parent and that worked for me.

You wouldn't mind only seeing them every other weekend and one day in the week? Honestly I'd hate that and so would my daughter x

SammyScrounge · 18/08/2022 00:04

notanothertakeaway · 17/08/2022 16:12

It requires v good communication and co-operation between the parents eg about homework, party invites, clothes etc

It seemed to work smoothly for my nephew, but TBH, I think 50 50 is usually for the parents' benefit, rather than the child. I think it's best for children to have one secure home, with plenty of time at other parent but not 50 50

I agree. Children get confused if the two homes are run differently,.or the parents try to win favour with the child by indulging him or her and causing trouble in the other house.

Schoolwork suffers too. Fave excuse for not doing homework? left their books in the wrong house.

It's all a lot to ask of a child.

HeckyPeck · 18/08/2022 00:02

Getoff · 17/08/2022 16:55

I've always said to DP that if we split, I won't do 50:50.

So if for some reason you had to choose between 50:50 and only having your children every other weekend, you'd choose the latter?

Just wondering if by fortunate coincidence what you think is best for the children also happens to be best for you.

This is a good point and I suspect a lot of people saying they are against 50:50 would change their minds if they didn't think they would be the one to get the majority of their time with their children.

Pinkyxx · 17/08/2022 23:40

@PrimarilyParented yes I think you're right and I do wish that the courts considered this in their decisions. Children in these situations never develop the sense of security having a stable, predictable home creates. They don't feel they 'belong', have a home, never know where they are going to be at a given point.. Even with limited contact and a fixed schedule as my DD has said, even very simple things that become complicated and anxiety provoking... for example, when her friends talk about doing X, Y, Z in the future she just sits there thinking I've no idea whose house I will be in at that point in time which dictates what I can / can't do.. hence she just withdraws from the discussion. She envies kids who just know they will be 'at home', aren't bounced from place to place, waking up and thinking ''where am I''? before orienting themselves to which house they are actually in, living out of bags etc..

Maybe it works for some children with very child focused parents, but I can't help think that for the most part kids say what their parents want to hear.

TheLostNights · 17/08/2022 22:46

I knew a dad who claimed his 6 yr old son said that he was pleased him and his mum had split up because he now gets to have more fun and do lots of things. This was said about 6 months after the separation. I definitely think kids say what they think parents want to hear especially if they have seen the parent very distressed after the split which was what was happening here.

PowerPack · 17/08/2022 21:49

Darhon · 17/08/2022 19:16

You see them on the week off. Easier then when you have the kids more often and only the odd weekend without them. Means no merging has to happen until you are completely sure.

But what about when things get serious, you're wanting to share a home or even new children with the new partner, which is surely quite likely if you split while DC are young?

PowerPack · 17/08/2022 21:44

One of the sad things I see in my work is children often tell their parents they love it, quite convincingly (all sorts of things) when it's actually just them telling parents what they want to hear. I think this happens even more so when they're trying to keep two separate parents happy

I've had it with my own teen son too. For far too long he was telling me a situation was all good because to tell me otherwise would make my life difficult, when actually it almost brought him to breaking point (this wasn't separation related but for some children it is). I really thought I was a parent he could talk to about anything too Sad

Anywhereelse · 17/08/2022 21:39

I was 50:50 from age 7 and spent 3 weeks at a time with each parent; this was their decision due to my DF working pattern and the courts were never involved. It was ok in primary years but looking back I was living out of a suitcase for years, my DF made almost no effort to give me a nice bedroom and I had no books, toys or clothes kept there, and they lived 45-60 minutes away from each other but in the same city.

I had no idea where I was half the time, and my DF would go out and leave me home alone for long periods of time. It wasn’t a great set up and I was a sad, lonely child. Even my school reports in Primary always say I cried a lot, but the arrangement suited my parents and they didn’t care what was best for me. At least they got on well so there was no warring.

As has already been mentioned before this arrangement works best if the parents are amicable, live close to each other, there is flexibility, and children's opinions are listened to. It’s a recipe for unhappiness and resentment otherwise.

PrimarilyParented · 17/08/2022 21:26

@Pinkyxx your post proves what I was saying. Feeling homeless happens whether it’s a 50:50 split or an 85:15 split, it’s about how the parents treat their children and homes and how the kids feel about their homes.

Lunabun · 17/08/2022 20:51

I would never claim to speak for someone else, but my parents split up and I would have hated 50/50. I'm very glad I had one stable home where I felt I belonged, and I got to see my other parent regularly without being pulled from one place to another.

justusandmoo · 17/08/2022 20:49

Willyoujustbequiet · 17/08/2022 19:38

It's not in the best interests of the child. It's for the parents benefit in most cases which just isn't right. Any parent who thinks otherwise is kidding themselves.

Kids need stability and a proper home. Fortunately the courts still tend to support this.

Totally disagree with this. It's such a sweeping statement to make. My 13 year old would most definitely prove you wrong! Lol xx

Qwertyyui · 17/08/2022 20:46

We did 50/50 from DD being 4 when she started school. This was because she used to be with my ex every weekend before this and with school I would have never seen her. She was 50/50 til around Covid time and expressed she wanted more time at mine due to wanting a bit less moving around. I offered to change days she was here/there to have less moving around but that was a firm no as she wanted to see me more. She used to be at her dad's mon/wed/fri and alternate Saturdays. Now she has dropped the Friday and is there mon/wed alternate weekends. We only live 5 mins away from her dad and we still are friends so he comes here a lot for tea and we have trips away so he sees her a lot more. I think it's important to listen to what the kids want. It wasn't a nice conversation with her dad but he understood and I sugar coated it to be about permanence rather than she prefers being here. It takes open communication and lots of us remembering what she needs each days and dropping things off/picking them up so she isn't lugging all her stuff places. We have uniforms at both houses and essentials and when one house gets a surplus of things we divide them back so both houses are stocked well. My DSC however only sleep 1 night a week and that's what they want and we follow their lead. Plus my DH shifts are such 50/50 just wouldn't work without me doing a lot of care and the kids would rather be with their mum than me!

justusandmoo · 17/08/2022 20:46

50/50 works really really well for my daughter. Now that she's older (13) we do week on/ week off so that it's easier with school stuff etc. when she was younger she split the week so she wouldn't go without either of us for too long.

BUT I have a brilliant relationship with her dad. We message a lot about her but also about other random stuff like tv shows, work
etc. he's one of my best friends.

My current partner has two little girls (6 and 8) and they come over other weekend and one night in the week. I'm not convinced that 50/50 would be in their best interest x

Augustlou30 · 17/08/2022 20:45

Wow it's hard not to feel a bit shit reading through this. My ex have done 50/50 for over 6 years now, kids are now 12 and 9. He'd not have considered being with his children any less and I'd have not expected him to accept any less. We live 10 mins apart, talk most days, with the exception of school shoes there never anything that needs to be packed and taken to the others house. We did use activities and committ to each taking them during our time. He lives with a new partner my kids get on with as do I. I have had a partner for years but we don't live together. My kids are very well adjusted and happy. I'd struggle to work if I had them anymore than I do and they'd just end up in childcare more.

I just could not have stayed in such an unhappy marriage and we get on much better now. 50/50 works for us all and as the kids get older they can live where they like.

Doyoumind · 17/08/2022 20:40

rejectshampoodemandtherealpoo · 17/08/2022 17:08

They do if the parents can't agree and the principle is that the children have equal right to time with both parents.

I do have a CAO. In my case, I think it was clear to the court what was really best for DC. Ex is abusive and was uninvolved before I left him.

devildeepbluesea · 17/08/2022 20:37

And ExDH has alsways been an extremely involved parent.

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 17/08/2022 20:36

We do 50-50 and it works but we all get along really well and we live within 10 mins walk of each other. I think if parents lived further apart it would be difficult as the kids got older.

devildeepbluesea · 17/08/2022 20:35

devildeepbluesea · 17/08/2022 18:33

We do 50/50 with 3 nights on, 3 nights off. Plenty of leeway if either of us want to take DD somewhere, or if we have other plans. DD is 9 and has actively asked to keep this arrangement. We’re both fine with it and it works well because we get on.

As DD gets older I realise that this may need to change, and I’m open to this. Whatever works best for DD.

Just to add one more thing: we always said that we would only make significant geographical moves “together but apart”. ExDH wanted to move about 4 years ago and I was open to it, but wasn’t keen on his chosen location. I suggested a different location, he agreed and we moved. We still live less than 4 miles from each other, I pop round regularly to see DD if she’s with ExDH and we do stuff as a “family” quite often.

I do realise we are extremely fortunate, but in my defence I’d say I’ve put a hell of a lot of work into maintaining the relationship- and I expect ExDH feels the same.

Flittingaboutagain · 17/08/2022 20:32

I would have hated 50:50. Mum was absolutely more in involved and aware of the importance of our social lives and activities and living with her seeing our Dad every other weekend and twice for dinner in the week was perfect for us. We could see this when wed have longer stints with him the holidays. He just didn't keep up the continuity and routines we enjoyed in the same way beyond a few days.

HailAdrian · 17/08/2022 20:20

I think it's a good option for parents who value their own free time tbh.

Saynotopineappleonpizza2021 · 17/08/2022 20:17

I hated it being 50/50, I felt like nowhere was "home". I wanted to live with mum and see dad every other weekend

Pinkyxx · 17/08/2022 20:06

I think it depends on the child, how well the parents communicate, how willing both parties are to support hobbies / social activities and practical aspects like cooperation & how close they live to one and another. It can be a pretty miserable existence if parents can't / won't cooperate or live far apart..

Ex and I have been separated for over 10 years, we don't have 50/50. Ex applied to court for 50/50 and they decided 85 / 15 so basically 1 night EOW + a few extra days in the hols. He moved 90 mins away to where his new partner lived... DD seemed to manage okish when she was little, but when school started it went down hill and it's just got harder ever since. She really struggles with moving between 2 home and feels she has no home. Her Dad insists all contact time is spent as ''step family time'' with his new wife / her kids. He also refuses to accommodate hobbies or social stuff citing impact to their ability to do stuff as a family & he's not prepared to drive her anywhere - so she essentially has never been able to do anything that falls on his weekends.. she has never been allowed to move clothes, or toys between homes, and he refuses to flex times at all if she has a party for example. We've had a litany of issues over the years from school uniform, home work , PE bags, favorite teddies / toys being left at his & no way to get them back before the next contact and parties, play dates missed, the fact she couldn't do hobbies at the weekend.... where I live swimming lessons were all on the weekends so she couldn't even learn to swim until she was old enough to do crash courses in the school holidays.. Now she's a teen it is just constant drama on stuff she wants to do with her friends at weekends.. she asks him to make an exception, he says no, they argue, she goes in a strop and they have an awful weekend.. For her the entire thing just sucks and she frankly hates & resents it... Living between parents homes isn't easy and I do agree with others who suggest it's all down to how the parents approach..

If we'd had 50/50 it would have been utterly intolerable for her and I'm certain she would have just refused to go. Her 'ideal' solution is that she live with me and only ever sees her Dad for a few hours from time to time, or joins him on holidays.... that way, she argues, she has a home and can ''live like a normal kid''....

CookPassBabtridge · 17/08/2022 20:01

Bigchezemakeme · 17/08/2022 19:32

We do 50/50. My daughter (8) loves it. Raves about benefits of 2 homes, 2 bedrooms, 2 holidays etc. Ex and I get on extremely well though and hang out together quite a bit so it’s not long stretches of time at either place. She actually really seamlessly moves between the two and we make sure any logistics are in the background and her stuff is always in the right place for her. Also we live around the corner from each other.

I could have written this 🖤 It's good to hear others rocking this set-up.
Key to it definitely seems to be parents who get on well.. no animosity, we're on the same page so always back each other up, talk highly of each other, we've both made it a really positive experience.
I daresay some of the ones saying it's harmful are jealous of posters having good relations with the ex.

rejectshampoodemandtherealpoo · 17/08/2022 19:49

SnackSizeRaisin · 17/08/2022 19:45

A bit like people who say their 1 year old loves nursery. People like to delude themselves. It's fine to say something is acceptable rather than fantastic.

I've worked in a nursery and that's never the case unfortunately. It's necessity and we have to forgive ourselves for what we need to do to survive.

OP posts: