Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What's it really like for a child with 50/50 custody mum and dad?

260 replies

rejectshampoodemandtherealpoo · 17/08/2022 16:03

I can only ask for experience. I was brought up by a single parent with little involvement from the other. So I have no idea what it would be like to be shared.

What's it like for those of you who grew up with an arrangement like this where you live between two houses?

I want to know if it's overall good or bad. Just out of interest as I got thinking about this. Thankfully I don't have to consider it for my child but I am very curious.

OP posts:
Jellytottss · 18/08/2022 13:12

MayThe4th · 18/08/2022 12:23

I think it’s sad that any parents end up going to court to agree child access rather than being able to agree it for themselves.

Obviously I know that it has to be done sometimes, I just wish that more parents would agree access without it. In order to do what is best for the children’s relationships with them.

When I split from my ex I always said that we would parent equally. He went to each of us 50/50, my only stipulation was that it not be one week on one week off but half the week and eOW, but it was flexible. If he had to go somewhere then DC stayed with me and vice versa. But we were amicable then.

It was only when he found a new partner that things started to change, because she moved her children in and fell pregnant very quickly, made it very clear it was her house and that the money my ex paid me (he paid me SM as I had given up my career to enable him to build. Career earning a 6 figure salary) was actually her money. And slagged me off at every opportunity.

Within 6 months of her moving in DC had stopped staying there during the week, and within a year they stopped staying there at all, and they see their father maybe 10 times a year at most, and he lives a 5 minute walk from here.

But. I still believe that no-one has the right to withhold their children from their other parent, and in a similar situation I would still make the same decisions.

I've heard this a few times about its a shame you have to go to court to get things in place. Whilst court is stressful it's needed and each party is less likely to break the routine also firm boundaries are imposed imparticular for the non resident parent. Clearly if things were that amicable BOTH parents would still be together... mean while in real life shit happens.

Going to court shouldn't be a shamed thing. If that's what it takes well so be it.

CousinKrispy · 18/08/2022 12:36

Oh good, another thread bashing parents who share care 50/50.

Sometimes it may be the best choice for an individual family, including the child, but a load of posters will be happy to share about how in their uninformed opinion it's universally traumatic and awful and is done purely out of selfishness by the parents.

MayThe4th · 18/08/2022 12:23

I think it’s sad that any parents end up going to court to agree child access rather than being able to agree it for themselves.

Obviously I know that it has to be done sometimes, I just wish that more parents would agree access without it. In order to do what is best for the children’s relationships with them.

When I split from my ex I always said that we would parent equally. He went to each of us 50/50, my only stipulation was that it not be one week on one week off but half the week and eOW, but it was flexible. If he had to go somewhere then DC stayed with me and vice versa. But we were amicable then.

It was only when he found a new partner that things started to change, because she moved her children in and fell pregnant very quickly, made it very clear it was her house and that the money my ex paid me (he paid me SM as I had given up my career to enable him to build. Career earning a 6 figure salary) was actually her money. And slagged me off at every opportunity.

Within 6 months of her moving in DC had stopped staying there during the week, and within a year they stopped staying there at all, and they see their father maybe 10 times a year at most, and he lives a 5 minute walk from here.

But. I still believe that no-one has the right to withhold their children from their other parent, and in a similar situation I would still make the same decisions.

MaryLennoxsScowl · 18/08/2022 12:13

Oh, and we took a bag of our favourite clothes with us but had plenty at each house, had our own bedrooms, took the dog with us, brought the bikes over if we wanted to. We didn’t have electronic devices as it was before they were common so nothing hugely expensive that couldn’t be moved. Went to any events/activities from either house, brought friends to either home. It felt entirely normal to us.

Starlight86 · 18/08/2022 12:10

ariesalien · 17/08/2022 16:23

I've always said to DP that if we split, I won't do 50:50. Lots of time with both parents, flexible schedules, good communication... but I just don't think 50/50 is ultimately best for kids as courts say.
People I know that grew up with 50/50 hated it.

Maybe I'm biased because I also grew up with one parent and a secure home with some time with the other parent and that worked for me.

Genuinely interested, So would you assume your kids would be with you most of the time?

FatherJacksBrick · 18/08/2022 12:09

@justusandmoo - you are very welcome. It's also meant I have a brilliant relationship with both my stepmum and stepdad. I was with both of them long enough to form a relationship but they both got their own time to spend with my mum/dad without me there.

MaryLennoxsScowl · 18/08/2022 12:09

I grew up with 50/50 and was happy with it. We pitied the children who only saw their dads every other weekend. They had such fucked-up relationships with them and later with their boyfriends - the dads spoiled them and never said no to anything or dived into happy families with other women’s kids and the EOW children were left out, which led to them re-enacting weird relationships where they craved male attention and couldn’t treat them as equals. 50/50 gives as normal a relationship with each parent as possible (obviously barring abuse or disinterest from either parent), which leads to much better balanced kids. This is why the courts do it, it’s not some quixotic ideal about fairness - it’s to give the children a fair chance at a normal relationship with each parent. A lot of men fuck this up anyway, but that shouldn’t mean the children aren’t given the chance to do it - their dads would have fucked up whatever the custody arrangements were.

justusandmoo · 18/08/2022 12:06

FatherJacksBrick · 18/08/2022 11:08

I had a 50/50 custody set up as a child and it worked brilliantly. I spent a week at each house and swapped on a Friday. In the summer holidays I spent three weeks with each parent. Christmas was split equally.

I had two fully furnished bedrooms, I went to the same school but I had a wide spread of friends because of the two areas I lived in. I was made to feel both houses were mine and I was welcome in both of them. I was free to move my stuff between households as I saw fit. If I needed to spend time with a parent out with the schedule (weddings, funerals, birthdays) it was accommodated with no issues. If I wanted to spend time out with the schedule (my mum and I had a hobby that would sometimes fall on my dads weekends) I was free to spend the extra time with my mum.

When I left school and my mum moved away the decision as to who to live with was left up to me with full support from both sides and no guilt tripping.

Like all custody arrangements it will work as long as all responsible adults are reasonable and endeavour to co-parent amicably.

So nice to see this response. I've found myself questioning everything this morning when reading this thread. I actually started doubting what I KNOW is a really positive 50/50 set up.

To the point where I started questioning my daughter about it on our way to her dads house! She looked at the like I was bonkers and asked 'you alrite bestie?'. Hahahaha.

Thank you xx

ShippingNews · 18/08/2022 12:01

Two of my dgc have lived like that for 8 years, since they were 5 and 9. They seem ok with it, even though they had to put up with both parents bad-mouthing each other at times. The worst part was weekends, when they always had problems with meeting with friends, playing sports etc .

Merrymumoftwo · 18/08/2022 11:35

I think it depends on the individual situation. My siblings and are didn’t have this and as a result growing up felt replaced when my father moved in with the OW and her kids and admitted her youngest two were his. He made no effort to see much of us at all but expected us to all get along.
on talking about how I felt with a friend she explained she had 50/50 arrangement and hated it, though not at first. Her reason was that both parents moved on and had children that lived with them full time but she just moved between the two.

At 16 she asked her parents if she could maintain contact but just stay at one location. She was told it would not work as on the days she was at the other house, her room was used for her siblings.
She told me how upset she was on hearing this especially as when she told her parents how hurt she was and was met with but your only there part of the time, the other are always there. She ended up leaving both homes and lived with a friend breaking off contact with both parents after feeling unwanted.

I think it’s important to balance the needs of the child and be mindful that these change as the grow. I think it’s also important that as they grow older they should get more say in how their needs are met particularly if this involves the safe space they believe they have being used when they’re not there without their knowledge because that takes away that feeling of belonging.

CookPassBabtridge · 18/08/2022 11:24

And if both on low wage then one would claim it and share it with the other.. again based on having a good relationship.

FatherJacksBrick · 18/08/2022 11:23

To add to my earlier post - what I enjoyed the most was the routine. I could easily plan ahead as it was easy to work out where I would be. What I hated was in the early days when my dad would pop up at the end of Brownies to collect me as a surprise, or my mum would pop round to dads for dinner unexpectedly. That would leave me really discombobulated.

I guess the only hang over from the decade plus of doing the 50/50 thing I can think of is that I never really feel at home in a house. I like the house I live in, but it's not my home, just somewhere to keep my stuff til we pick somewhere else.

CookPassBabtridge · 18/08/2022 11:22

CloudCatz · 18/08/2022 11:19

They don't have favourite clothes or toys, just plenty of both. They have computer/xbox/ipads at both. Bikes/scooters. Uniform at both. They swap every few days so if they do want something at the other parents house they know they can have it soon.
All that changes hands is their school bags.

You say about not being able to afford to have two expensive things at both.. but they are two seperate households now.

I do wonder how this can work with low-income families who need to claim Universal Credit etc.

For example, who would get the child element? If the child doesn't have a main residence and lives 50/50 who gets child benefit? And if only one parent can claim money for the child, how does the other parent who may also be very poor afford childcare or all these items for the child if they cannot claim any money for said child?

It's another thing that is individual and works best if the parents get on.
I am on the low wage so I get the child benefit and universal credit. If he buys something expensive he'll talk to me about it first and get one for my house too so we're equal.

CloudCatz · 18/08/2022 11:22

Even with non-50/50 arrangements, I don't get how it works for those on benefits. If the NRP works but is on a very low income and claims Universal Credit, how can they pay for any childcare on the days the child is with them in the holidays etc?

CloudCatz · 18/08/2022 11:19

They don't have favourite clothes or toys, just plenty of both. They have computer/xbox/ipads at both. Bikes/scooters. Uniform at both. They swap every few days so if they do want something at the other parents house they know they can have it soon.
All that changes hands is their school bags.

You say about not being able to afford to have two expensive things at both.. but they are two seperate households now.

I do wonder how this can work with low-income families who need to claim Universal Credit etc.

For example, who would get the child element? If the child doesn't have a main residence and lives 50/50 who gets child benefit? And if only one parent can claim money for the child, how does the other parent who may also be very poor afford childcare or all these items for the child if they cannot claim any money for said child?

SammySueTwo · 18/08/2022 11:17

neverbeenskiing · 18/08/2022 10:59

How can you find out what is best for the child if they will lie to please the parents? Maybe a counsellor could help?

Counselling is confidential and children are just as entitled to that confidentiality as adults, barring any safeguarding issues obviously. No counsellor worth their salt would disclose anything to you unless your child was at risk.

I suppose you just have to try very hard to put yourself in that child's shoes and be honest with yourself about what is best for them, even if that doesn't tally with what you want. What is best in terms of consistency, routine, what is the least disruptive option? The same as you would for a child who wasn't yet old enough to communicate their wishes and feelings.

Sorry phrased that badly - of course a counsellor would never disclose anything to anyone but they could help a child understand what they want and how that child could approach their parents with this or another trusted adult.
You can try and put yourself in your child's shoes and you could come to the wrong conclusion. For example, I could imagine the least disruptive option would be for all children to be 80+ plus with one parent - one home, no disruption but spending one day a week and some holidays with parent 2. The imaginary child in question may actually find that option worse than the current set up.
One of mine early on decided they would rather be at their dad's one more night a week due to dad's gaming set up. All my friends thought I should put my foot down but I didn't and allowed my DC to chose. I don't know if I personally am doing the best because there are always harsh critics.
Given the complete uncertainty of what is best as your child won't tell you, you can't be sure when putting yourself into a DC's shoes you won't project some of your own feeling onto the situation etc, there seems no good answer to this other than 50:50 per the professionals and children doesn't work.
Therefore it is not a wholly illogical conclusion to read into it that you should try and stay together at all costs. (Not a personal conclusion.)

CookPassBabtridge · 18/08/2022 11:14

@latetothefisting They don't have favourite clothes or toys, just plenty of both. They have computer/xbox/ipads at both. Bikes/scooters. Uniform at both. They swap every few days so if they do want something at the other parents house they know they can have it soon.
All that changes hands is their school bags.
You say about not being able to afford to have two expensive things at both.. but they are two seperate households now.

neverbeenskiing · 18/08/2022 11:14

justusandmoo · 18/08/2022 10:57

This thread will is a real worry. People will
stay in terrible relationships based on the way some people have completely trashed a 50/50 set up.

Even those of us truthfully say it works well find ourselves being told that it's not true and that the kids are pretending to be happy. It's such a shame because for me and my daughter it work so so we'll. it's nothing to do with what she tells me it's more about her general happiness that I can see and feel on a daily basis.

If anyone is reading this and contemplating staying in a relationship because of it please don't. It can work very well in many situations x

I honestly think if anyone decides not to end a marriage or LTR based on one thread on an online forum, they were most likely never going to leave anyway. OP asked for an honest account of people's experiences of 50/50 arrangements and people have given an honest account of their experiences, as have you. It's a shame that not everyone's experience is positive, but it has been pointed out many times on this thread that 50/50 can work well in the right circumstances. I haven't seen anyone advocate for staying in a relationship that makes you unhappy.

PowerPack · 18/08/2022 11:14

They're also very very good at masking

PowerPack · 18/08/2022 11:11

justusandmoo · 18/08/2022 10:57

This thread will is a real worry. People will
stay in terrible relationships based on the way some people have completely trashed a 50/50 set up.

Even those of us truthfully say it works well find ourselves being told that it's not true and that the kids are pretending to be happy. It's such a shame because for me and my daughter it work so so we'll. it's nothing to do with what she tells me it's more about her general happiness that I can see and feel on a daily basis.

If anyone is reading this and contemplating staying in a relationship because of it please don't. It can work very well in many situations x

It's not about the pros and cons of separation, it's about what happens after that and priortising the child's interests rather than the parents' wants.

And for some children it may well work, but for a lot it doesn't.

It's just a simple fact that children tell parents what they want to hear. Yes I brushed my teeth, yes I did my homework, I'm happy to spend all summer with Granny/in holiday club, I don't mind if you can't afford a birthday party for me. Why would this be any different when the stakes are so much higher?

Sometimes of course they just have to do it anyway, but they won't always tell you what they're feeling, if it's going to hurt you.

CookPassBabtridge · 18/08/2022 11:08

generation*

FatherJacksBrick · 18/08/2022 11:08

I had a 50/50 custody set up as a child and it worked brilliantly. I spent a week at each house and swapped on a Friday. In the summer holidays I spent three weeks with each parent. Christmas was split equally.

I had two fully furnished bedrooms, I went to the same school but I had a wide spread of friends because of the two areas I lived in. I was made to feel both houses were mine and I was welcome in both of them. I was free to move my stuff between households as I saw fit. If I needed to spend time with a parent out with the schedule (weddings, funerals, birthdays) it was accommodated with no issues. If I wanted to spend time out with the schedule (my mum and I had a hobby that would sometimes fall on my dads weekends) I was free to spend the extra time with my mum.

When I left school and my mum moved away the decision as to who to live with was left up to me with full support from both sides and no guilt tripping.

Like all custody arrangements it will work as long as all responsible adults are reasonable and endeavour to co-parent amicably.

CookPassBabtridge · 18/08/2022 11:08

justusandmoo · 18/08/2022 10:57

This thread will is a real worry. People will
stay in terrible relationships based on the way some people have completely trashed a 50/50 set up.

Even those of us truthfully say it works well find ourselves being told that it's not true and that the kids are pretending to be happy. It's such a shame because for me and my daughter it work so so we'll. it's nothing to do with what she tells me it's more about her general happiness that I can see and feel on a daily basis.

If anyone is reading this and contemplating staying in a relationship because of it please don't. It can work very well in many situations x

🙌🏼🙌🏼
I think as a generarion we're a lot more tuned in to how our kids are feeling, and my boys are very happy. They don't tell me that, so I'm not being told "what I want to hear". I can see it in the way they talk, laugh, bounce around, their confidence etc.

Lesterjosephgale · 18/08/2022 11:08

The nesting sounds like the best solution for the children. They get to stay in their home and the parents are the ones having to cart their stuff back and forth. Kids can make plans with their friends without having to think about whose house they will be in that day etc.

neverbeenskiing · 18/08/2022 10:59

How can you find out what is best for the child if they will lie to please the parents? Maybe a counsellor could help?

Counselling is confidential and children are just as entitled to that confidentiality as adults, barring any safeguarding issues obviously. No counsellor worth their salt would disclose anything to you unless your child was at risk.

I suppose you just have to try very hard to put yourself in that child's shoes and be honest with yourself about what is best for them, even if that doesn't tally with what you want. What is best in terms of consistency, routine, what is the least disruptive option? The same as you would for a child who wasn't yet old enough to communicate their wishes and feelings.