Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What's it really like for a child with 50/50 custody mum and dad?

260 replies

rejectshampoodemandtherealpoo · 17/08/2022 16:03

I can only ask for experience. I was brought up by a single parent with little involvement from the other. So I have no idea what it would be like to be shared.

What's it like for those of you who grew up with an arrangement like this where you live between two houses?

I want to know if it's overall good or bad. Just out of interest as I got thinking about this. Thankfully I don't have to consider it for my child but I am very curious.

OP posts:
justusandmoo · 18/08/2022 14:17

@EhUpDuck we'll have to agree to disagree on that one then. I couldn't live in a marriage where I didn't love that person any more. That's not a healthy environment for any child.

Splitting up equally has its consequences and difficulties though I agree.

Xx

EhUpDuck · 18/08/2022 14:12

LastWordsOfALiar · 18/08/2022 14:07

I doubt there's a "one size fits all" approach. 50/50 won't work for some children, for others it may be their preference.

Ideally, rather than the specific arrangement, I think parents should focus on listening and observing their children and responding to what they need at that time. Being open to the other parent and th child and allowing themselves to put their kids needs and wants above their own.

And people and circumstances change. So what works one year, may not the next.

I guess it's inevitable that egos will get in the way.

I think, mostly importantly, people need to choose their partners in the best way they can to prevent divorce as much as possible. And be prepared to put work and effort into relationships. People split over the most ridiculous stuff and this is the result.

Absolutely.

EhUpDuck · 18/08/2022 14:11

justusandmoo · 18/08/2022 14:03

@EhUpDuck I'm not usually that surprised by Mumsnet but you have definitely managed it. To think living in an unhappy household or an abusive one is better than having 50/50 access is just crazy. Justifying it by saying you are putting the kids first is even worse. But as you say - you do you.

Of course that would be ‘crazy’ (ableist slur notwithstanding). It’s also not what I said. I expressly said abuse or such sadness that a parent isn’t able (or willing) to contain their emotions around their DC absolutely should end in divorce. Just not ‘we’ve fallen out of love, still best friends though, hang out and chat all the time and the kids are totally fine with it all’. That, I won’t lie, I don’t get. And I’d rather be an adult and manage my own emotions around a less than perfect relationship and accept the consequences of my own choices than inflict those consequences on innocent DC. Because part of being an adult, and a parent, is accepting you make mistakes and doing your best with the results; not forcing the consequences of those mistakes onto young DC to manage when they don’t have the emotional or mental maturity to do so and have no power to control their environment. I think parents should put their DC first (and yes, that will absolutely sometimes mean divorce rather than a clearly unhappy home). But sometimes it means NOT divorcing just so you can have half your time free to pursue new relationships while they split their lives. That’s the DC suffering (whether a large or small amount, it’s clearly suffering as no one would ever choose to live like that, as shown by the abhorrence towards nesting shown on this thread) while the adults get to do as they wish and live their best lives. I choose to put my needs after my DC’s, as (i’d thought!) was largely accepted as being a basic part of parenting.

justusandmoo · 18/08/2022 14:11

@Grizzlac why don't you actually READ things before posting. I clearly stated that I don't think it's always for the best. I specifically said that my partners two don't do 50/50 and I don't think it would be in their best interest to.

What I have said is that it works really well for my daughter for various reasons. People have different circumstances. I am not outraged as you put it but it does get to me when people like you make sweeping statements around it always being wrong.

Please read things properly before you post.

LastWordsOfALiar · 18/08/2022 14:07

I doubt there's a "one size fits all" approach. 50/50 won't work for some children, for others it may be their preference.

Ideally, rather than the specific arrangement, I think parents should focus on listening and observing their children and responding to what they need at that time. Being open to the other parent and th child and allowing themselves to put their kids needs and wants above their own.

And people and circumstances change. So what works one year, may not the next.

I guess it's inevitable that egos will get in the way.

I think, mostly importantly, people need to choose their partners in the best way they can to prevent divorce as much as possible. And be prepared to put work and effort into relationships. People split over the most ridiculous stuff and this is the result.

Grizzlac · 18/08/2022 14:04

Revolvingwhore · 18/08/2022 14:00

It's not good for kids, and it's offensive to the collective intelligence to suggest it is. You're outraged clearly, but I don't see why.

Conversely, I think it’s exceptionally clear why @CookPassBabtridge and @justusandmoo are so invested and so outraged at any suggestion 50:50 isn’t good for kids, even when it comes from people who actually lived it as kids (which notably, neither of them mention having experienced). But sure, their kids are definitely completely supported to share their real feelings about splitting their lives between two houses and families with them without prejudice, whatever those feelings might be.

justusandmoo · 18/08/2022 14:03

@EhUpDuck I'm not usually that surprised by Mumsnet but you have definitely managed it. To think living in an unhappy household or an abusive one is better than having 50/50 access is just crazy. Justifying it by saying you are putting the kids first is even worse. But as you say - you do you.

Revolvingwhore · 18/08/2022 14:00

justusandmoo · 18/08/2022 13:43

@Revolvingwhore how on EARTH do you figure that you know how another woman's kids are feeling? It's absolutely beyond me that someone would come online and deliberately try to make someone feel like s*.

It's not good for kids, and it's offensive to the collective intelligence to suggest it is. You're outraged clearly, but I don't see why.

EhUpDuck · 18/08/2022 13:55

CookPassBabtridge · 18/08/2022 13:35

@EhUpDuck What a load of martyred bullshit.

we have definitely swung too far the other way if me saying I’ll put my childrens lifelong happiness above my temporary contentment with a less-than-ideal situation is ‘martyred bullshit’. You do you, and I really hope your kids are as happy as you say and aren’t lying to themselves and you. I will never understand putting your kids through two homes and a break up cos you somehow can no longer tolerate living with your best friend. I’d always, always rather suffer than my DC suffer. But you do you.

ThePenOfMyAunt · 18/08/2022 13:48

One of DH's relatives has this arrangement. The child seems happy and well adjusted BUT there has been clashes over schools, and invariable the mother ends up conceding to the father's preferences, and she has the worse logistics.

justusandmoo · 18/08/2022 13:46

FloydPepper · 18/08/2022 13:45

I’m about to read the thread to see, but normally on here they tend to go the same way

”it’s bad for the kids, they should me mainly with one parent”
”can that be the dad?”
”oh no! Definitely not”

😂 how did you guess!!?

FloydPepper · 18/08/2022 13:45

I’m about to read the thread to see, but normally on here they tend to go the same way

”it’s bad for the kids, they should me mainly with one parent”
”can that be the dad?”
”oh no! Definitely not”

justusandmoo · 18/08/2022 13:43

@Revolvingwhore how on EARTH do you figure that you know how another woman's kids are feeling? It's absolutely beyond me that someone would come online and deliberately try to make someone feel like s*.

Revolvingwhore · 18/08/2022 13:40

CousinKrispy · 18/08/2022 12:36

Oh good, another thread bashing parents who share care 50/50.

Sometimes it may be the best choice for an individual family, including the child, but a load of posters will be happy to share about how in their uninformed opinion it's universally traumatic and awful and is done purely out of selfishness by the parents.

You keep telling yourself your kids love it.

maddy68 · 18/08/2022 13:40

I was one of those kids. My homework was a pita. I had usually left something at the other parents that I needed.

Same with clothes. Pe kits etc.

You have to be ultra organised

dameofdilemma · 18/08/2022 13:38

Before anyone tries to extrapolate too much from the 'I know lots of 50/50 kids and they're all miserable/self-harming etc' posts...

Statistically children from lone parent families are more likely to live in poverty, more likely to live in temporary accommodation, more likely to suffer mental health concerns, more likely to be excluded from school.
But we wouldn't extrapolate from that 'therefore you should never be a lone parent and you're only thinking of yourself if you do'.

As others have said, children's unhappiness attributed to 50/50 may well stem from the marital breakdown in general - the impact of new partners, acrimonious parental relationships etc - all of which may well exist without 50/50.

I guess its easy to criticise 50/50 parenting on MN though if you're assuming the EOW parent will be the dad, never the mum. But in real life not every mum is a SAHP. Not every dad is a philandering loser.

justusandmoo · 18/08/2022 13:37

CookPassBabtridge · 18/08/2022 13:35

@EhUpDuck What a load of martyred bullshit.

Couldn't put it any better myself!

CookPassBabtridge · 18/08/2022 13:35

@EhUpDuck What a load of martyred bullshit.

ClottedCreamAndStrawberries · 18/08/2022 13:22

I don’t know personally. However, my friend and her sisters used to live for two weeks with their mum and two weeks at their dad’s. They seemed happy enough with seeing them both equally although seemed to prefer the dad. However, from an outside point of view, it always looked very chaotic and like they didn’t really have a base. It was like they were going on holiday in changeover day and they were always leaving things at the ‘other’ house. Weird set up but that’s just my view.

PowerPack · 18/08/2022 13:21

PowerPack · 18/08/2022 13:20

I have a colleague who is doing this. They have retained the family home and bought one flat, which the parents live in alternate weeks.

It sounds awful to me, but if you do it anyother way that's effectively the life the children are living.

I mean if you do 50:50 any other way

PowerPack · 18/08/2022 13:20

autocollantes · 18/08/2022 13:16

I looked into nesting because I don't want the kids never feeling like they're at home - plus we're divorcing, the kids should be as unimpacted as is possible - but that would mean keeping the family home for the kids and buying/renting two smaller properties for me and STBX to live in when not nesting. It's very expensive.

I think now the best solution is EOW at STBX's with him being responsible for them alternating 2-3 school days a week until after dinner. So either at mine or his, but they sleep at mine. This means the responsibility is more fairly shared but the kids don't go back and forwards as much.

I know it'll mean me seeing him more but I can suck it up if it's better for the kids.

What I'm not going to do is take all the responsibility, deal with all the drudgery of rearing kids, while they miss him and he plays Disney Dad (which he would) and has loads of free time. There are practical, exhausting aspects to parenting and I think the idea of 50-50 is attractive because kids see both parents and both parents get a break (which is fair). But I'm not convinced for my kids that they'll do well with regularly changing homes.

I do know some kids who do 50-50 and seem ok with it. So I'm not bashing anyone if works for.

I have a colleague who is doing this. They have retained the family home and bought one flat, which the parents live in alternate weeks.

It sounds awful to me, but if you do it anyother way that's effectively the life the children are living.

autocollantes · 18/08/2022 13:17

*EOW = every other WEEKEND

autocollantes · 18/08/2022 13:16

I looked into nesting because I don't want the kids never feeling like they're at home - plus we're divorcing, the kids should be as unimpacted as is possible - but that would mean keeping the family home for the kids and buying/renting two smaller properties for me and STBX to live in when not nesting. It's very expensive.

I think now the best solution is EOW at STBX's with him being responsible for them alternating 2-3 school days a week until after dinner. So either at mine or his, but they sleep at mine. This means the responsibility is more fairly shared but the kids don't go back and forwards as much.

I know it'll mean me seeing him more but I can suck it up if it's better for the kids.

What I'm not going to do is take all the responsibility, deal with all the drudgery of rearing kids, while they miss him and he plays Disney Dad (which he would) and has loads of free time. There are practical, exhausting aspects to parenting and I think the idea of 50-50 is attractive because kids see both parents and both parents get a break (which is fair). But I'm not convinced for my kids that they'll do well with regularly changing homes.

I do know some kids who do 50-50 and seem ok with it. So I'm not bashing anyone if works for.

Runwalkskijump · 18/08/2022 13:15

Getoff · 17/08/2022 16:55

I've always said to DP that if we split, I won't do 50:50.

So if for some reason you had to choose between 50:50 and only having your children every other weekend, you'd choose the latter?

Just wondering if by fortunate coincidence what you think is best for the children also happens to be best for you.

This.

EhUpDuck · 18/08/2022 13:13

CousinKrispy · 18/08/2022 12:36

Oh good, another thread bashing parents who share care 50/50.

Sometimes it may be the best choice for an individual family, including the child, but a load of posters will be happy to share about how in their uninformed opinion it's universally traumatic and awful and is done purely out of selfishness by the parents.

But it’s not uninformed opinion; the majority of posts critiquing 50:50 are from people who actually loved it as children or from professionals who hear the honest opinions of children hurt by it, while the vast majority of posts praising 50:50 are from parents. That is telling. My parents split when I was young, we had semi-regular contact with my Dad growing up until he moved away when I was early teens. I couldn’t imagine splitting time between two houses and the accounts of children only referring to ‘mum’s house’ or ‘dad’s house’ rather than ‘my house’ are really sad. Absolutely kids lie to themselves as well as parents to protect the parents. When I was growing up I was adamant ‘staying together for the kids’ was rubbish, having separated parents had no ill effects and was better for everyone, and I genuinely believed that for a time and masked well, was clever as did well at school easily. As an adult with young DC now, I will not split from my DH unless things become very, very bad. Those saying they’re ‘best friends’ with their ex; I genuinely don’t see how you couldn’t manage to stay together for a few years to avoid all this stress for your children if things are so friendly?! How could you choose to have less time with your kids and put them through the trauma of a split (and it is a trauma) to split from someone you have THAT good a relationship with still? Once you have kids they come first, and yes, that might mean staying in an unfulfilling/not perfect marriage until they’re grown. It’s not their fault your feelings changed. My relationship isn’t amazing, we’re not in love and argue sometimes (away from DC), but we get on day to day, are both engaged parents, are friendly in general. We’re just not in love and are far from best friends. I’m not putting my DC through the stress of a break up and life of navigating contact etc for a chance for me to find a better relationship. That’s on me; maybe I’ll find one once they’re grown, maybe I won’t. Nesting is absolutely the best for kids as far as I can see it and it’s brutally telling how so many posters here wouldn’t even consider it. If you couldn’t live between two homes, how awful to subject your kids to it. Sure, they ‘love it’. I was super happy with my parents’ divorce as a child. As a young adult, that became clear it wasn’t actually true, although in my case I am still glad my parents split. It hurt me though, on a lifelong basis. And the main issue being ‘future partners’ is actually really upsetting to me. You put your kids first. Not yourself, not a potential future partner. If you meet one then nesting would mean you can’t live with them til the kids are grown or only on a part time basis. That is so far below the threshold of sacrifice I don’t know what to call it, but it’s what you do in order to put your kids first, have them not have to live between two homes and enable them to have as positive relationship with each parent as possible. I actually don’t think it’s outrageous if some people read this and think again about splitting up where it’s just a case of not being ‘in love’ any more. Divorce is not best for kids unless either parent can’t contain their emotions and shield kids from it or there is abuse, in which case of course divorce is better. A friendly relationship that’s not full of love is fine, and a stable home life better for kids than instability. Kids have to come first, even (!) when that means things aren’t ideal for the parents. A lot of parents lie to themselves that by putting themselves first that means they’re putting their kids first cos they’re happier. There’s some truth to that, but my god is it a convenient ‘get out of jail free’ card to prioritise yourself first and tell yourself it’s for your kids.

Swipe left for the next trending thread