Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What's it really like for a child with 50/50 custody mum and dad?

260 replies

rejectshampoodemandtherealpoo · 17/08/2022 16:03

I can only ask for experience. I was brought up by a single parent with little involvement from the other. So I have no idea what it would be like to be shared.

What's it like for those of you who grew up with an arrangement like this where you live between two houses?

I want to know if it's overall good or bad. Just out of interest as I got thinking about this. Thankfully I don't have to consider it for my child but I am very curious.

OP posts:
SlipperyLizard · 17/08/2022 17:22

My parents divorced when I was a toddler, my dad wasn’t really interested (which causes its own issues!), so we only saw him sporadically, but I think 50/50 would have been awful for me.

I would have hated moving each week & not feeling anywhere was “home”, and would have been anxious about each switch.

I expect it can work, but I doubt that it does work in the majority of cases.

ariesalien · 17/08/2022 17:21

@Getoff why would it be what's best for me? Surely could be argued that people pushing for 50/50 could be considering what's best for them as it gives them as much time to themselves as possible?
I just stated I wouldn't personally want my kids to be switching and changing between two homes and the kids I grew up with who did hated the arrangement.

50/50 may work really well in some cases and I'm not denying that but I personally think children should maintain one secure 'home' despite a split that wasn't their fault. (This is no judgement to those that decide otherwise for other circumstances, just what stance I would personally take with my own DC!)

rejectshampoodemandtherealpoo · 17/08/2022 17:15

CookPassBabtridge · 17/08/2022 16:42

Sorry, but it's an individual thing. Me and ex are both awesome parents and equally loved by the kids, equally hands on and involved. Anything other than 50:50 would be awful. The kids are really happy and swap every few days, it helps that me and ex are best friends and hang out at each others houses.
Not only would ex miss them, and kids miss him.. it puts too much responsibility on me and he would have more spare time.
Which would lead to resentment.
I just think it's awful that usually the dad sees them much less often!

If the dad is less bothered and kids prefer mum then I can see why other arrangements work.

It's great you're friends. It's how you view it I guess because I would want more time with the kids not more free time.

OP posts:
Snuggleworm · 17/08/2022 17:14

50/50 cause major trauma for the child in my opinion.

We did it and it was ok until she was 12 and then that is when all the problems arose. We did not co parent very well at all. We barely spoke, the child was not allowed to speak about her time in our house when she was with her dad.
At the age of 14 my DD decided she did not want to stay in her dads overnight and this caused huge trauma for her as he guilt tripped her for years as a result she no has control issues, very low self esteem, has struggled through all her teenage years and now has what we believe to be an eating sidisorder.
If I could turn back the clock I would have never ever allowed it to happen as it did not benefit her at all.

loveireland · 17/08/2022 17:14

Jamaisy82 · 17/08/2022 16:31

My partner shares 50/50 with his little girl. One week on one week off. She is 5 now and in the holidays also goes away to her grandmas down the country in the holidays for a week. I think it must be very confusing for her and no actual home. I brought up my son on my own and he's only ever been with me and he's well behaved and only really knows one home. I can't imagine being away from my young child a week or more at a time but because they don't live close it has to happen. Her behaviour isn't the best. Must be hard but often no choice.

How does school work?

orbitalcrisis · 17/08/2022 17:12

We used to be with my mother Monday to Friday, then weekends with my father. I would have preferred it one week on, one week off. They lived walking distance from each other so it worked well. After having seen both my parents every day for my whole life up until then, it would have been very upsetting not to see them both regularly.

Personally, I loved it. Two Christmases, two holidays in the summer. Great!

PowerPack · 17/08/2022 17:11

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 17/08/2022 17:07

In scandinavia it is the norm. Much more so than here anyway.

My experience (as the child, and in a scandinavian country) was not great though. Despite no specific issues as such.

Gosh that's interesting. Scandinavian countries have some of the highest teen suicide rates in Europe, which again could be for any number of reasons, but it is interesting alongside the research we did

gogohmm · 17/08/2022 17:10

My friends teens have access to both parents houses whenever they want rather than set days - they have a family diary they say where they are eating. Houses are under 5 mins walk away. Y works well and kids are very well adjusted plus matter of fact about it including when mum or dad says they need space for a night/weekend (code for dating!)

melodypondisasuperhero · 17/08/2022 17:10

My parents split when I was 5 and if they hadn’t done 50/50 I guess I would have been with my mum mainly - from an outside point of view she probably had the more suitable home situation. By the time I got to around 10/11 I hated being at my mums, the way she and her husband treated me was awful but again, from an outside point of view she would probably have been the more “suitable” one - married, two more kids, large home whereas my dad was single, much smaller home, worked less predictable hours. If my mum had decided she wanted me full time and taken it to court I don’t think it’s impossible she would have won but I shudder to think how much worse my childhood would have been.

So I’m probably massively biased but from my experience 50/50 as the starting point is a good thing.

maddiemookins16mum · 17/08/2022 17:09

It sounds exhausting for the kids (and sometimes done for the benefit of the parents and not the child). I say this as the Aunt of a 11 year old who never spends a week in her own bed before swapping to another one who really just wants to stay with her Mum (and she is my brothers child).

rejectshampoodemandtherealpoo · 17/08/2022 17:08

Doyoumind · 17/08/2022 16:25

I'm not sure the courts do favour 50:50. I think it depends on the age of the children and the setup before a split.

I don't believe it works. I know my dc wouldn't want it and the eow and one weeknight arrangement works for them.

They do if the parents can't agree and the principle is that the children have equal right to time with both parents.

OP posts:
Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 17/08/2022 17:07

rejectshampoodemandtherealpoo · 17/08/2022 17:05

I'd love to know what you mean. Which countries?

In scandinavia it is the norm. Much more so than here anyway.

My experience (as the child, and in a scandinavian country) was not great though. Despite no specific issues as such.

AdamRyan · 17/08/2022 17:06

CookPassBabtridge · 17/08/2022 16:42

Sorry, but it's an individual thing. Me and ex are both awesome parents and equally loved by the kids, equally hands on and involved. Anything other than 50:50 would be awful. The kids are really happy and swap every few days, it helps that me and ex are best friends and hang out at each others houses.
Not only would ex miss them, and kids miss him.. it puts too much responsibility on me and he would have more spare time.
Which would lead to resentment.
I just think it's awful that usually the dad sees them much less often!

If the dad is less bothered and kids prefer mum then I can see why other arrangements work.

Same
My kids would be upset with anything other than 50/50

PrimarilyParented · 17/08/2022 17:06

I think that both parents have an equal right to see their children and fundamentally if it’s a 60:40 split or an 80:20 split as opposed to 50:50 it’s still going to be tricky for the kids and the parents.

Basically the problem is that kids hate it when their parents split up and hate it even more if they feel one parent had then abandoned them (moved away or only seeing them every other weekend).

honestly I think if both parents love and care for their kids anything less that 50:50 is absolutely heartbreaking for them (50:50 is bad enough) and I think it is for the kids too as they will miss the parent they don’t see so much.

I also think there is a real a plus to 50:50 in terms of counterbalancing the negatives of the other home (such as noise, siblings, unhealthy diet etc.) that are not child safeguarding concerns but do mean children want a change.

also, I think a lot of the “50:50 is bad” brigade are mothers who want their kids all the time (understandably) and who want the kids to only have one home and to have full control over that because they don’t recognise/accept that the kids should always have two homes as they have separated parents and don’t only “belong” to one family/home even if they’re there 80% of the time.

rejectshampoodemandtherealpoo · 17/08/2022 17:05

helpfulperson · 17/08/2022 16:24

There have been parents on here from countries where this has been the norm for many years who are much more positive about it than MN generally.

I'd love to know what you mean. Which countries?

OP posts:
CrapBucket · 17/08/2022 17:05

My ex insisted he would do 50/50... in a surprise to no one except him, it failed miserably.

We are now at 'every other weekend and once mid week' arrangement. DC are teens and don't like moving stuff about, so they rarely actually end up going to their dads.

I have no idea what is best for the kids overall. For their dad not to be a selfish wanker probably.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 17/08/2022 17:03

It depends on the parents and kids. Obviously. The better communication the better.

BUT my experience (teen when parents seperated) was I HATED it. I hated having 2 main homes, I hated bringing all the stuff I wanted back and forth, I hate missing out on things happening in either household. I felt split all the time and it was unsettling to always be moving. I gradually ended up living with my dad more or less full time which really hurt my mum and ended up with us falling out and not talking for a long time. Most people I know ended up spending more time with one parent/ in one home once they were old enough to decide themselves.

I do think 50:50 is more about creating an illusion of fairness between the parents than it is necessarily considering the best interests of the child. Most adults wouldn't like their lives and possessions divided across two homes, and having to constantly go back and forth, so I am not sure why we would expect children to like it.

LookingOverHereAllNight · 17/08/2022 17:01

When both parents genuinely prioritise their kids, communicate well and live relatively near each other, it can work I think. When they don’t, it can be really awful for the kids. One of my friends and her ex really do it well, they even go for meals as a family and have days out together. The kids love it and although they would prefer mum and dad to be together, it’s the next best thing. Their dad had a new partner and she’s really lovely. He’s a really nice bloke though so I’m not surprised he’s chosen such a nice partner. I tell them they should write a book on how to get parenting spot on in a split. 😂

FlyingSaucerss · 17/08/2022 17:00

It would be my ideal set up but my ex would never have been interested unfortunately

Greyskiesaregonnaclearup · 17/08/2022 16:57

I have my DD 50/50. Against my wishes for lots of reasons, I fought it for years but the UK courts do absolutely see it now as the 'norm'. But DD's dad is abusive and saw it as the only way to avoid the CMS. It doesn't work for us as he counter parents at every opportunity. DD doesn't get to do hobbies outside of school, as every fortnight it clashes with time at her dads, who doesn't want her doing anything. It's not been a positive experience for us, but although DD is old enough that the court would consider her feelings, she's too afraid to raise it with her dad.

I do have friends with 50/50 setups that work though. It needs to come from a place where there isn't conflict between parents (the UK courts have a rose tinted view where all parents co-parent happily which just isn't the case).

Getoff · 17/08/2022 16:55

I've always said to DP that if we split, I won't do 50:50.

So if for some reason you had to choose between 50:50 and only having your children every other weekend, you'd choose the latter?

Just wondering if by fortunate coincidence what you think is best for the children also happens to be best for you.

PowerPack · 17/08/2022 16:55

I know shared arrangements are popular now, but I'm not convinced they're in the inerest of the child.

A few years ago we had a horrible spell in our county where we had far too many teenagers committing suicide. Schools felt they were facing critism about the pressure children were under/bullying etc and did a piece of work to try and find out what was happening and how these awful deaths could be prevented.

It was only a small sample, although also far too large and research wasn't scientific, but the only things they all, every single one, had in common was that they had previously self harmed (although some a long time ago) and they had homelives where parents had split but both parents were still very much around/shared residency. Not all 50/50, but significant time spent with both parents.

Other than that the children were a real mix of sporty or not, academically gifted, average and struggling, popular and bullied, affluent, average, deprived. We couldn't find anything else in common.

Now obviously lots of children live in these situations without coming to such tragic harm and correlation doesn't equal cause etc, but I really feel strongly that that information is worth further research. People don't want to hear it though, everyone wants to believe "fair" is best, but who's it fair/best for?

I know I'd be unsettled if I was going to a different home on different days and that's without the pull of different parents. I'm sure lots manage to create home where that doesn't happen, but most children must feel it to some extent?

Darhon · 17/08/2022 16:53

I’ve done it with mid to late teens. But the kids were nested so we moved in and out. Hate it now 2 years on because the moving every week is awful and would rather have my own property and the kids to decide where they want to be most of the time. Also, whilst I thought 50:50 and nesting was ideal, one kid feels in the middle of it and I’m not sure it’s worked that well in the end for that child.

SweatyChamoisPad · 17/08/2022 16:50

My boyfriend's kids are 50/50 (we don't live together and have no plans to). His girls are teenagers and like the set up because Mum has moved her new partner in, and he has kids who visit regularly. They like their space and peace and quiet at their dads - they seem to think of it as a bit of a refuge.

Revolvingwhore · 17/08/2022 16:47

rejectshampoodemandtherealpoo · 17/08/2022 16:03

I can only ask for experience. I was brought up by a single parent with little involvement from the other. So I have no idea what it would be like to be shared.

What's it like for those of you who grew up with an arrangement like this where you live between two houses?

I want to know if it's overall good or bad. Just out of interest as I got thinking about this. Thankfully I don't have to consider it for my child but I am very curious.

I've always thought adults are lying to themselves when they say their kids are perfectly happy with any custody arrangements and that they work well, when they've split up. Realistically what kid wants to dick about from house to another? Its a triumph of resilience - doesnt mean it's good.

I'm sure I'll be unpopular for saying so.

Swipe left for the next trending thread