Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What's it really like for a child with 50/50 custody mum and dad?

260 replies

rejectshampoodemandtherealpoo · 17/08/2022 16:03

I can only ask for experience. I was brought up by a single parent with little involvement from the other. So I have no idea what it would be like to be shared.

What's it like for those of you who grew up with an arrangement like this where you live between two houses?

I want to know if it's overall good or bad. Just out of interest as I got thinking about this. Thankfully I don't have to consider it for my child but I am very curious.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
nevynevster · 28/05/2023 11:42

I've done this for years with my two. Week on/off. Things that have helped:

  • Big commitment to move their stuff especially when they were little (this included toys) .. so I'd take a big suitcase over every week with their stuff in it
  • we live very near each other, a short walk, so that makes school/friends etc all the same distance
  • we both went out of the way to sort any forgotten items (sometimes late at night or first thing in the morning), we tried to make it a parent problem not a kid's one
  • shared calendar and lots of organisation to make sure no balls were dropped in the transitions
  • buying doubles of lots of key items so they're never short

So I think by and large it has worked. There have been moments when the kids have hated it and said they hated the hassle. They've also, as teens, exploited it at school .. saying they've left homework in the other house when they just forgot to do it! But I think all arrangements have their pros and cons so, for example transitioning for weekends also has its downsides.

Anyway, now kids are older I've suggested several times moving to different arrangements and they've declined, saying they'd miss me/their dad if they didn't swap every week. So that's the best endorsement I guess !

Flittingaboutagain · 27/05/2023 20:09

Mum2023 · 27/05/2023 12:44

Courts are forcing my kids 10 & 7 to have 50/50 with dad kids have always lived with me and had long weekends with dad with 50% spilt holidays he now has had a baby is living in a small apartment how on earth will
this work for my kids I’m so heartbroken tomcat court would allow that to happen after all this time, my youngest has already told me she doesn’t want to do it but she is 7 and won’t like it, I’ve got SS to coming to support me transitioning them my heart is broken, I have a final court date coming up cafcass has given there recommendations this will not only destroy me but my kids too. My ex is abusive and controlling and now I will torment me even more. I’m so scared of him.

I'm so sorry. How awful.

Mum2023 · 27/05/2023 16:36

Thank you it’s this awful system I’d always say to anyone now stay in an abusive relationship even if they cheat stay in there because this system does t support you it’s now all for dads all for tock boxes. How can kids adapt when they are use to living with me ? Emotionally mentally? How can anyone say kids adapt in real life they don’t hence so many kids are in a bad state mentally and emotionally it’s our system we allow to destroy our kids and there futures then blame the parents for it.

Tandora · 27/05/2023 15:22

Mum2023 · 27/05/2023 12:44

Courts are forcing my kids 10 & 7 to have 50/50 with dad kids have always lived with me and had long weekends with dad with 50% spilt holidays he now has had a baby is living in a small apartment how on earth will
this work for my kids I’m so heartbroken tomcat court would allow that to happen after all this time, my youngest has already told me she doesn’t want to do it but she is 7 and won’t like it, I’ve got SS to coming to support me transitioning them my heart is broken, I have a final court date coming up cafcass has given there recommendations this will not only destroy me but my kids too. My ex is abusive and controlling and now I will torment me even more. I’m so scared of him.

@Mum2023 im so so sorry to hear you are in this situation. Have the children not had any opportunity to express their wishes? I don’t have a lot of experience here but didn’t want to read and run xxx

Mum2023 · 27/05/2023 12:44

Courts are forcing my kids 10 & 7 to have 50/50 with dad kids have always lived with me and had long weekends with dad with 50% spilt holidays he now has had a baby is living in a small apartment how on earth will
this work for my kids I’m so heartbroken tomcat court would allow that to happen after all this time, my youngest has already told me she doesn’t want to do it but she is 7 and won’t like it, I’ve got SS to coming to support me transitioning them my heart is broken, I have a final court date coming up cafcass has given there recommendations this will not only destroy me but my kids too. My ex is abusive and controlling and now I will torment me even more. I’m so scared of him.

Nordicrain · 25/04/2023 11:40

My personal experience is I really disliked it and as soon as I was older I chose to spend more time at one parent's house and ended up living there all the time (visiting the other parent as and when - which wasn't good for our relationship as that parent felt very rejected). I hated the moving back and forth, I hated missing out all the time, I hated having to their transport all my day to day possessions or be without them. No specific issues, I just felt really unsettled.

This was in scandinavia too.

Thereisnolight · 25/04/2023 11:37

Tandora · 21/08/2022 14:31

following this thread: particularly interested in the experiences of children.

I know, right?
The children don’t seem to appreciate 50:50 as much as the adults do.
I don’t know what the answer is. Very sad all round.
But almost always made worse by blending families!

Hotcrossbunnowplease · 25/04/2023 07:46

I’m close to a situation with 50/50 for one child, parents can’t stand each other and only communicate via solicitors. (I’m not one of their partners). From what I can see the child is miserable, he’s 6. The dad has great intentions and loves his child so much but he can’t see the bigger picture. Mum works long hours and could ask the dad to help by having him for tea then dropping home but she won’t. I think at some point it will blow up.

Thislife55555 · 25/04/2023 07:42

I also think from there should be some form
Of safeguards implemented to protect children in cases where the parents split, like an informal advocate should be asking how they feel about their setup to garner from them only if they are happy or not and why and this should help them to make the best way forward for them but of course this comes down to cost and this isn't deemed imp kids jjsy had to put up and get on with what their parents decide which is sad, kids essentially don't have a voice until they work out that they do, I dread to think the poor kids forced in to a family deal that not really best for them as they can't communicate that themselves or effectively! The system isn't doing enough to protect children in this regard ar all! We provide safeguards for the elderly living in controlled environments when people lose their capacity they have the right to an advocate why should children in these also everyday situations not be afforded the same rights?!!

Thislife55555 · 25/04/2023 07:33

@PowerPack I abs think the issue here is the fact you never feel like you can fully live your life as you're limited! I remember prior to when I got to age 8 when I lived perm wirh one parent I would be at mums in the wk formed my friendships at school and kids back then locally could play out I for couole hrs so I found my local friends at school and we met up Mon to Fri evenings but by the wknd it was sorru I'll see you next wk so what happened was they started forming better closer bonds with other kids who were there all the time and it was awful' same thing at my dads, saw these local
Kids at wknds then didn't see them again until the following wknd. As a child forming friendships is not jjsy that but it's the start to finding out who you are, working out your own character and that's so important! It's also about feeling part of a friendship circle which is vital for school life as a child that's what it feels is so imp! I was just lucky mum won my case as dad has a bad track record as walked out when I was born and I was with mum until 3 when he decided he wanted contact again and his busy shift role wouldn't have worked either.

My OH believed intensely that 50/50 is best but I don't agree, I lived like that and even had it been every other wk it's the same odds, I needed a perm home, it wasn't my fault they split up but for dad he wanted what was best for him and I chose what was best for me!

I think tbh there likely isn't a best option but we have to as parents do what is best for our children and as hard as this is to accept i truly believe the child knows what makes them happiest and whatever that is that's what has to happen, if that means parents stay together and make best of a bad situaion keeping their mouths shut and taking care in the best way for the kids I think we have a duty to do that as we brought the poor kid in to the world we owe it to them to do what's best for them, not for us and ruin their childhood.

My childhood from age 8 then became rhe happiest time of my life, I finally was in one place where I felt at home,y social life expanded hugely, I became more confident, happier, settled developed in to the person I am today. I felt like I belonged somewhere and it was home. Dad found it very difficult but he was never int from the start and I knew that from an early age I really did, he of course chnaged his mind as time went on but decision day taught me again he only wanted what was best for him, I was lucky I made it very clear it wasn't going to work that way, I went to court and remained steadfast.

Had I had to live with him or remain as it was god knows how my life would have turned out! I dread to think and the thing is as a child you only see you in your own world and you think this is only happening to you, it feels very isolating as you think everyone other kid is living a normal life esp if the ones you know are and you're not, I can absolutely see this having a negative mental impact on children.

So sad all round, I think the best way forward is what is solely best for your children, and you have to do your best for them whichever way that is and bite the bullet for their sake, if we love them we need to do what's best for them not for us.

Thislife55555 · 25/04/2023 07:14

I had to do this until I was 8 then was forced by my dad to make a choice of who to stay with perm as he was moving to another area and I chose my mum. I never felt like I really belonged in either household, particularly my dads as hed walked out initially first few yrs of my life and I never felt a bond to him, he'd met a new woman too, just felt very uncomfortable. I became luckily very attached to my step father and when decision day came it was awful, truely awful, I was also slyly guilt tripped by my step mother in to choosing them with you'd have your own room with us but you'll have to share at your mums, so you see how much stuff you're dad buys for you! I remember thinking (age 8) what more to me and thank god it was
My step dad and the friends I only saw in the wk at my mums who I missed at wknds as wasn't there, I couldn't have a life this way,
All wk I was with mum it felt like my home then I was carted off to dads who I felt I didn't know and make it worse he was so much older than my mum so in my view practically ancient, I chose my mum and my life changed for the better rapidly! The relief when my first sat
Came and I said to my wk day friend yes I can play out this wknd &'every other, I could
Finally create my own life! Dad fought against MY very strong decision for years, hated him for it, abs no regard for me, I was just so relieved mum and SF helped me to stay with them as I think it would have been so so hard forming a life for myself in that setup and they lived 5 mins from eachother so god knows how kids feel in split homes in further distances

romance123 · 30/08/2022 08:02

That's really good advice @sassyclassyandsmartassy

sassyclassyandsmartassy · 21/08/2022 20:12

We don’t 50:50. My DH ex was very difficult to start with even though nobody else as involved and she kicked him out and she was married to her new DH and there were no issues with abuse of any kind.

Access to his son was supervised visits for 2 hours a time at her mothers 3 times a week. We have worked to change this over time up to every other weekend now and one week of the holidays and are speaking to her about another week of a different school holiday and 2 BHols each year now (he is now 11 and I have been on the scene 9.5 years). I can’t help but feel that it would have been better for SS to have had a set routine from the get go and would have saved him a lot of unnecessary change over this time, but it is what it is in relationship breakdowns.

That aside we do now have every other weekend and have just taken him on his first flight to go on a foreign holiday with is for a week which, whilst he missed them and we had a couple of hours upset on one day, overall went very well all things considered (I refer to my earlier comment of how things like this wouldn’t be such a ‘change’ for him if there had been more consistency of routine early on).

Anyway, my point. We don’t live close enough for 50:50 (30 min drive away), I feel that, overall, it does him good to have consistency during the school week for his education, but, with two step siblings in his primary home, he is vocal about how he enjoys a break from them EOWE. We don’t ship a lot of stuff back and forward, preferring to promote to him that his stuff is ‘his’ so he has stuff at both homes. It hasn’t always been an easy relationship between parents, mum still likes to try and exert ‘control’ but I try hard a lot of the time to bridge the gap which I think, overall, works. Both parents do work hard to ensure any tension isn’t something he is exposed to at all and we all work hard to promote the other house in front of him and he’s settled in the arrangement overall now.

We recently moved to a new build and as he was involved throughout the build process I think he is even more happy here and refers to it also as ‘home’ as he feels he’s been involved in the process.

I am sad at how things started and I do think it could have been made easier for him if he’d had consistency from the beginning of a routine between the houses, but, overall, the arrangement now works really well for all concerned and, overall, communication between the adults to assure this for him has become easier which is key!

I think 50:50 could work if parents lived in walking distance of one another and parented well together though, but I think the key to shared parenting is different homes is that all adults need to learn to put their own feelings to one side and really genuinely consider what works for their children and their emotional well-being overall throughout the years.

RhubarbMoon · 21/08/2022 15:15

I packed up on a Friday after school and got driven to my mum's or she'd pick me up, then spend two nights there, come back Sunday evening. Not every weekend though - thank God!

RhubarbMoon · 21/08/2022 15:12

But if it's one night in the week and every other weekend

Scrap the one night in the week. I didn't have that as a kid. It was just EOW. But then my mum lived too far away to get me to school in the week, when she has two other kids to get to school in her own area. One night in the week sounds awful because you have to change for just one night? But then, as an adult, I hate things like going away "just for a night" because it doesn't seem worth it to me.

RhubarbMoon · 21/08/2022 15:02

The best scenario I heard of was there being a house and two flats

Who can afford a house and two flats? This would only work for substantially well-off parents.

Tandora · 21/08/2022 14:31

following this thread: particularly interested in the experiences of children.

Rosewaterblossom · 21/08/2022 14:29

50/50 works for us.. however, we live 2 - 3 miles away from each other, school is in the middle of where we each live, we have great communication and co parent well. We have no qualms of going to school events together or sitting in eachothers houses for a zoom parents evening. If there's any sort of grudge/animosity there or you live much further apart, it might not work as well.

Bigchezemakeme · 21/08/2022 14:17

The best scenario I heard of was there being a house and two flats, with the child remaining in the house and the parents taking turns to live there with them and being the ones to move back and forth. If that sounds too exhausting, imagine that that is what you're asking the kids to do

but it’s not really is it. Adults run a home with all that entails, children don’t have all that admin - or really any admin. Even legally it’s hard for adults as what is their legal address for insurance, for schooling etc etc etc

Bigchezemakeme · 21/08/2022 14:12

@Diamondinthesolesofhershoes doesn’t sound like a good dad in any sense. Or a great guy. He’s a dick that only wants to parent his child once a fortnight. That’s why your poor son doesn’t want to go, his dad doesn’t want him

Pinkyxx · 21/08/2022 12:43

This narrative of ''50:50 is bad” brigade'' being selfish controlling mothers is incredibly disingenuous and inflammatory. Children are not homogenous therefore there can be no 'one size fits all'. While 50/50 may function fine for some children & some families, it doesn't for all of them. Maybe some are happy to force what they feel is ''fair'' to them on their children irrespective of whether it works for the children or not, personally, I'm not prepared to put my (or anyone else's) wants ahead of what my child needs. If 50/50 works for your child then I applaud you for making it work for your children, but kindly don't judge, make assumptions as to my intent or disparage me because my child needs something different.

Each family should do what is right for their children, not espouse this notion that only one way is right and fair.

Bioandstepmum · 21/08/2022 10:15

PrimarilyParented · 17/08/2022 17:06

I think that both parents have an equal right to see their children and fundamentally if it’s a 60:40 split or an 80:20 split as opposed to 50:50 it’s still going to be tricky for the kids and the parents.

Basically the problem is that kids hate it when their parents split up and hate it even more if they feel one parent had then abandoned them (moved away or only seeing them every other weekend).

honestly I think if both parents love and care for their kids anything less that 50:50 is absolutely heartbreaking for them (50:50 is bad enough) and I think it is for the kids too as they will miss the parent they don’t see so much.

I also think there is a real a plus to 50:50 in terms of counterbalancing the negatives of the other home (such as noise, siblings, unhealthy diet etc.) that are not child safeguarding concerns but do mean children want a change.

also, I think a lot of the “50:50 is bad” brigade are mothers who want their kids all the time (understandably) and who want the kids to only have one home and to have full control over that because they don’t recognise/accept that the kids should always have two homes as they have separated parents and don’t only “belong” to one family/home even if they’re there 80% of the time.

This ☝️

Oopsiedaisyy · 21/08/2022 07:30

We do 50 50, have done for three years, kids now 8 and 13. Daughter is very organised, and has two of most things at both houses, our boy travels light.

They seem ok with the set up, its not ideal for anyone, but we live close, and we are amicable so organise between us. We both have partners, although my kids have yet to spend time with mine.

Diamondinthesolesofhershoes · 21/08/2022 07:09

mummykayles · 20/08/2022 15:58

My eldest is 10. He lives with me and has seen his dad every other weekend since he started full time school. I am always asking if dad wants him any extra (school holidays etc) or to pick him up for a few hours after school in the week - but it is always a no thankyou on dad's part.
My son would absolutely hate 50/50 as he doesn't enjoy going. I almost have to force him to go every other weekend and I always get "why are you making me go??" from him. He wants to be at home, with all his things and his friends nearby and his home comforts.
He has never felt comfortable at his dads for whatever reason. I know for a fact he isn't at ease or his true self while he's there. He doesn't see his dad's as home, just somewhere he goes to visit. I should add that his dad is lovely and a good dad (in my opinion) and we are on good terms. DS would just rather be at home and it has always been that way.

Doesn't sound like a great dad

HeckyPeck · 21/08/2022 00:09

CloudCatz · 19/08/2022 19:07

All the issues re feeling like you live out of a suitcase etc still exist with 80:20 etc, but that also has the downside of a more distant relationship with one of your parents.

Well, no, because with 80:20 you only live out of a suitcase (if you do) for 20% of time, not all the time, and only have to move EOW. I'd take a more distant relationship with one parent over having to move every week any day.

But if it's one night in the week and every other weekend then you'd still be moving between houses every week on the weekday and twice in the same week on the weekend ones.

I preferred only have to change once a week on a Saturday with the way my parents did 50:50 as a week on, week off.

Before that it was pack up and change house Wed pm, pack up and change back Thurs pm & again for a night at the weekend. Much more annoying & disruptive.