Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for the good points to having a boy?

261 replies

Greentartanbow01 · 17/08/2022 15:11

Please could I have measured responses, I absolutely know that ultimately a healthy baby is all that matters.

I’m due a c section with my first baby next week. We don’t know the sex.

It took us a long time to get here and we never thought we’d be able to have a child, I’ve had a pretty rough pregnancy- diagnosed with many different things and had threatened first and second trimester miscarriage, plus pre-term 3rd trimester labour. Am so relieved and pleased to have made it to the gestation I am now.

In all honesty though, because of all the drama throughout this pregnancy, I haven’t really stopped and thought about the baby at the end of it 😳

In my head, the whole way through it’s been a girl. In every daydream that I’ve dared let myself have, it’s been a girl. I’ve always imagined myself with a daughter, never a son. I’m much better with girls than I am boys when I’m around other people’s children and I’m going to be honest here and say that I do have a gender preference and that is for a girl.

DH genuinely doesn’t have a preference and I believe him.

Please don’t get me wrong, I’m terrified of the baby not being healthy and I know that a healthy baby is the ultimate goal, sex really doesn’t matter and I know I’ll love my baby whatever, but I know if it’s a boy, it is probably going to take me a few hours to get my head around and mange the ‘disappointment’ (if that would be the word) in all honesty.

Part of the reason I’m less keen on having a boy is because of the saying that I keep seeing trotted out on here, about a daughter being a wife but a son only being a son until he finds a wife. In all honesty, that’s definitely been the case with me and my sibling, DB just doesn’t have the relationship with my mother that I do. They’re close enough but he sees a lot more of his wife’s mother/ family and tbh it’s pretty much the same for most males that I know.

Could posters please reassure me that that isn’t always the case and tell me why they love having a son/ sons?

OP posts:
Moonface123 · 17/08/2022 16:04

Shame we have to continuosly keep justifying whats so great re having a boy on here.
Notice all the feminists are very quiet on this topic, God forbid OP questioned having a girl, that would be completey different story, but as they are so fond of telling us, its a Mans world after all, never mind huge percentage of Mums being deeply disapointed at gender reveal.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 17/08/2022 16:03

MissyB1 · 17/08/2022 15:36

It says a lot about how we view boys in our society that OP has to ask this question.

Yes, I sometimes feel people on MN don’t like little boys and it makes me sad for them!

Butteryflakycrust83 · 17/08/2022 16:03

And I agree - find the sex out now!

Butteryflakycrust83 · 17/08/2022 16:03

I think we often lean towards preference of a daughter because that is what we can directly relate our own experience to. I can envisage a daughter because I AM one.

It often has nothing to do with gender stereotypes.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 17/08/2022 16:02

TBH OP, even though I have one of each I’m not going to answer your original question.

What I am going to do is to tell you that you whatever sexist stereotype you have of a what a boy and a girl means - leave it at the door. There’s nothing a girl could give you that a boy couldn’t. Unless you’re talking about very superficial stuff like pretty dresses and ringleting hair - which would be fine on a boy but would probably get judgement from others - boys and girls are the same. Your child is whoever you make them. My DD lives in black clothes, a baseball cap and is forever carrying round a football. My son’s favourite shoes are unicorns boots from the ‘girls’ section Clark’s. They won’t turn into whatever stereotype you have in mind I’m afraid.

badgerstink · 17/08/2022 16:02

I love being mum to my boy. He probably will be the death of me but I wouldn't change him for the world

Sartre · 17/08/2022 16:00

I have two girls and three boys. So far my DS’s have been much, much easier to handle. I know people always claim boys are a handful but this hasn’t been my experience at all. All three of my DS’s are quiet and gentle (eldest is 12, youngest 2) whereas DD’s (10 and 11) are a totally different kettle of fish. They had the most violent tantrums as toddlers and even up till the age of 6 I’d say. They still have loud outbursts now occasionally although have settled down a lot. They have lots of dramatic fall outs with friends at school a lot and everything is always the end of the world, this definitely never happened with DS. I find them much harder to deal with than I’ve ever found my DS’s.

It’s totally anecdotal and I’m sure plenty of people found the opposite to be true although I do know my friend had a similar experience and has always found her DS much easier than DD. Anyway, boys are great basically and you will just love your baby regardless of sex!

Flittingaboutagain · 17/08/2022 15:59

I understand OP. I read up on it and there is research that there are differences in parent-child relationships between the sexes. If you want to know you can search this topic in the results from research such as the Family Exchange Studies. However, just because there are population level statistics, doesn't mean at an individual level you and your future child (son) may not have just as close a relationship as some of the posters here.

StillMissV · 17/08/2022 15:58

Ugzbugz · 17/08/2022 15:54

I cannot tell you how many threads there are on the disappointment of having a son. Never a girl.

Yet we fight for equality etc.

@ugzbugz yes, but often with legitimate reason - I am one of three girls, raised by my mum and am myself a woman in a very female orientated work place with a lot of female friends. Raising a boy was totally uncharted territory for me and I thought a girl would be easier! Nothing to do with anything insidious!

Bluebells12 · 17/08/2022 15:58
  • Sons tend to adore their mothers very intensely.
  • Sons have less emotional drama around age 6-12 when the girls are exploring power struggles and either being, or struggling with, the ‘mean girl’. At school, boys are more interested in who’s fastest/strongest than emotional power struggles, and boys get over arguments faster.
  • Boys have less infections (utis etc) and are easier to potty train👌
  • As boys grow they are fantastic for carrying heavy objects and reaching high shelves 🤣
  • That saying about “daughter for life” is nonsense. Have you never met a woman who doesn’t get on with her mum? There are just as many men who are close to their mums.
StillMissV · 17/08/2022 15:57

@ugzbugz yes, but often with legitimate reason - I am one of three girls, raised by my mum and am myself a woman in a very female orientated work place with a lot of female friends. Raising a boy was totally uncharted territory for me and I thought a girl would be easier! Nothing to do with anything insidious!

bloomety · 17/08/2022 15:56

Dalaidramailama · 17/08/2022 15:49

@SuperCamp

Think it depends on the mother’s attitude. I hope my boys remain close to me in adulthood. I do not wish to be “number one”. Of course his wife will be (and should be) number one so to speak. There will be no competition in adulthood certainly not by me anyway. Some women are too needy and probably do push their sons away.

I feel this view is based on the fact the woman often runs the household and makes decisions about holidays, childcare etc. if you bring your son up to be an equal partner who thinks women and men should equally pull their weight in a relationship and equally take responsibility for deciding what the family does, then a wife won’t replace you as their mother, she’ll be his partner and he won’t feel ashamed for being a “mummy’s boy” which is a horrible sexist term. You don’t get mummy’s girls so why is it seen as bad if a man is close to his mum? It’s time we take responsibility to change our language and expectations of “male behaviour”.

HappinesDependsOnYou · 17/08/2022 15:55

I find it depressing people are so harsh on baby boys. My brother in law phones his mum every week and almost every man I have worked with has supported their mums through struggles and always check in whilst my sisters and I rarely do with out mum. It's not out of unkindness it's just the way we were brought up. Teach your kids you are approachable and there for them and supportive, let them find their place in the world and put in effort to keep a relationship and you have just as much chance as you would of a daughter maintaining a great adult relationship. Welcome any daughter or son in law also!

theveg · 17/08/2022 15:55

I have 2 ds and I have lost count of the times today that each of them has just come up to me for a cuddle and said "love you mum". Just in one day. They are beautiful, funny, and I feel like I've done stuff with them I might never have done if I'd had a daughter. It has pushed me out of a comfort zone for sure but I wouldn't change it.

addler · 17/08/2022 15:55

I adore my son. Sometimes I look at him and can feel how much I love him physically, in my chest. He comes up to us and holds our faces in his hands and kisses us. He loves looking after his toy baby doll and pushing it around in his buggy. He is obsessed with all things that go at the moment. And he loves his toy kitchen.

On the adult side- my parents have two girls and a boy. They are much closer to my brother, they have a wonderful relationship and get on so well with his wife, they both stay at my parents' house regularly when they're in their city for work.

I'm 30 weeks pregnant with my second and we aren't finding out the sex again, the only reason I'd prefer a girl this time is that I find them easier to name Grin

Ugzbugz · 17/08/2022 15:54

I cannot tell you how many threads there are on the disappointment of having a son. Never a girl.

Yet we fight for equality etc.

Yousee · 17/08/2022 15:54

When that baby that you've been waiting for so long is placed on your chest for the first time you are sooooo not going to be caring what's between it's legs. You are going to be marvelling at how fucking fantastic you are for producing the most beautiful, wonderful baby ever born.
I'm due DS3 next month and have been a little peeved at the pitying looks and pinched "oh another boy" comments to be honest.
DS1 is the sweetest, funniest child, DS2 was stillborn and is my perfect, handsome angel and I'm so excited to find out who DS3 is and what he's all about. Just as I would be if he was a girl.
As an aside. My DBro dumped his last GF for slagging off our DM (who she'd only met in the passing but apparently DM didn't fall to her knees and worship at her feet) which he lamented as the GF was a 10 (he said 🤨) but he couldn't tolerate that sort of attitude to DM. So its not a given that some woman will just steal your boy away!

ChagSameachDoreen · 17/08/2022 15:53

MissyB1 · 17/08/2022 15:36

It says a lot about how we view boys in our society that OP has to ask this question.

And yet society is still hugely misogynistic and skewed to the advantage of males.

hellosunshineagainx · 17/08/2022 15:53

When I was pregnant I wanted a girl but found out about boy and honestly he is the most wonderful thing to exist on the planet. So much so that I am pregnant again and hoping for another boy 🥰 You will adore them whatever the sex

quiteathome · 17/08/2022 15:53

I have one of each and they are both awesome.

Finawelesca · 17/08/2022 15:53

Mine are both boys and 19 and 16. Even though Ds is at uni we are in contact almost daily about anything and everything. When home we watch stuff together, meal prep dinner, listen to music and sing to it. We chat about the news or his mates and their lives/problems etc. He tells me he is grateful that he likes both his parents as people, not just parents.

The 16 year old is just as good but spends a bit less time with me. However, he is chatty, respectful, funny, just like his brother. Watches tv shows with us too. We spend time together as a family, have a family dinner every night. Now that it is summer holidays we lunch together with Dh who is working from home.

Both children are kind and thoughtful. This has nothing to do with their sex. I totally understand your disappointment. When I was younger I envisioned my life to have a boy and a girl but I had a miracle first baby after fertility issues so I was grateful for whatever I could carry to term.

Damnautocorrect · 17/08/2022 15:53

This makes me so sad
honestly, boys are great!
mines soft, sensitive, wouldn’t hurt a fly- literally wouldn’t hurt one. Was not rough and tumble,not football mad, he was enquiring and gentle as a toddler.
mines a teen now has a good mix of male and female friends. Gets on with life, has a brilliant sense of humour and is and always has been great company.
this genuinely makes me sad that your concerned.

some children are little arseholes. It’s not gender specific. Teach them empathy and respect for the world and others no matter what and they won’t go far wrong.

good luck with the rest of your pregnancy.

Eliode2000 · 17/08/2022 15:52

i have met the sweetest loveliest boys. they are awesome

KyaClark · 17/08/2022 15:51

I have two boys. I admit I was disappointed I didn't have a girl, and I am sad that I'll never have a daughter, but -

I am everyone's favourite person

Constant cuddles

I'm very well looked after

It's really just nice and I'm very lucky.

Arthursmom · 17/08/2022 15:50

I also thought I was having a girl but wasn't exactly disappointed I had a boy. Can't imagine it any other way now, to the point where if I have another I'd hope for another boy. He is so fun! Creative and has definite interests. He builds things and is fascinated by machinery and cars and neenaws. I find him fascinating and we are as close as we could possibly be. He is almost 2. I'm sure you won't be disappointed OP.