Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for the good points to having a boy?

261 replies

Greentartanbow01 · 17/08/2022 15:11

Please could I have measured responses, I absolutely know that ultimately a healthy baby is all that matters.

I’m due a c section with my first baby next week. We don’t know the sex.

It took us a long time to get here and we never thought we’d be able to have a child, I’ve had a pretty rough pregnancy- diagnosed with many different things and had threatened first and second trimester miscarriage, plus pre-term 3rd trimester labour. Am so relieved and pleased to have made it to the gestation I am now.

In all honesty though, because of all the drama throughout this pregnancy, I haven’t really stopped and thought about the baby at the end of it 😳

In my head, the whole way through it’s been a girl. In every daydream that I’ve dared let myself have, it’s been a girl. I’ve always imagined myself with a daughter, never a son. I’m much better with girls than I am boys when I’m around other people’s children and I’m going to be honest here and say that I do have a gender preference and that is for a girl.

DH genuinely doesn’t have a preference and I believe him.

Please don’t get me wrong, I’m terrified of the baby not being healthy and I know that a healthy baby is the ultimate goal, sex really doesn’t matter and I know I’ll love my baby whatever, but I know if it’s a boy, it is probably going to take me a few hours to get my head around and mange the ‘disappointment’ (if that would be the word) in all honesty.

Part of the reason I’m less keen on having a boy is because of the saying that I keep seeing trotted out on here, about a daughter being a wife but a son only being a son until he finds a wife. In all honesty, that’s definitely been the case with me and my sibling, DB just doesn’t have the relationship with my mother that I do. They’re close enough but he sees a lot more of his wife’s mother/ family and tbh it’s pretty much the same for most males that I know.

Could posters please reassure me that that isn’t always the case and tell me why they love having a son/ sons?

OP posts:
CheshireCat1 · 17/08/2022 16:56

I have three grown sons, they all have their own homes now with their partners. Their partners are lovely and arrange lots of outings with me, theatre, meals holidays with all the family. We go to each other’s houses lots and have a great time. So basically I’ve got three sons and also have three daughters.
They are all the joy of my life and I’m so lucky, my daughter in laws tell everyone that they’ve got the best mother in law in the world.
When you have your baby they will be the one that you’ve dreamed of having regardless of sex.

Mummy2mybear · 17/08/2022 16:55

I have a girl and a boy I secretly wanted two girls when I found out i was expecting my second, I had this idea in my mind of two sister's but I am so blessed, my boy is wonderful and they are all amazing in own way's when your beautiful baby is born you won't care about the gender I can't comment on the older milestones as my two are still primary age but I do know that I would not have swapped my boy for all the girl's in the world. You will understand when you hold your beautiful baby congratulations OP enjoy every moment xx

smileandsing · 17/08/2022 16:55

I have a boy, he is the best! I genuinely didn't mind whether I had a boy or a girl, and I don't really understand why people do. But you do so all I can tell you is once the baby arrives nothing else matters but them. The relationship you foster with your child from the start will lay the foundations for the relationship you have with them in future. That is not defined by the babies sex.
As far as differences between the sexes go, I can't really comment, but every child is different so no one can really tell you. I do know that if you have a boy and decide that he should do boy stuff with his dad, not you (as I've seen many mum's do) then don't be surprised if your relationship is not as close with him as that with his dad.

Don't buy into the tripe that is a 'daughter's a daughter for all her life, a son's a son until you ditch him because he takes a wife'. The only person who I've ever heard say that irl is MIL, and we haven't seen her for years because I think she truly believes it. I will never feel that way about DS.

speakout · 17/08/2022 16:54

I wouldn’t know what to do with a girl- Lacey247

Seriously?

What are the specific things you do with a baby boy?

BlackKittyMama · 17/08/2022 16:54

I voted YANBU because they are completely valid worries to have and it’s normal to have a preference.

However! It’s certainly not always the case. My partner is very close with his family in general and actually we see his mum far more than we see mine. He’s always been particularly close with his mum. She will also be having more of an “active” grandma role once our baby is born.

AryaStarkWolf · 17/08/2022 16:54

BeardyButton · 17/08/2022 16:46

I get where you are coming from.... But I do wonder if we don t socialise boys into this. At the start, my son would come home with tales of woe too. Im not entirely convinced that anything has changed or that he isnt as upset.... but somehow he has become convinced that he doesn't talk about that sort of thing because he is a big boy. Whoever filled his little head w that cr£p, I don t know.

I don't want to generalise of course but in my experience my son came home with stories of sneaky, mean boys in the friendship groups as well, what I did notice though (which I always pointed out as well) was when my daughter came home with stories like that my DH would always make a comment about girls being bitchy or whatever where as if my son came home with a story like that my DH would make a comment specifically about that boy, if you know what I mean.? And I don't even think he did it consciously, it's like something ingrained in people that girls are sneaky or mean by nature but if a boy is he's individually responsible for that behaviour

Miriam101 · 17/08/2022 16:53

You've taken one ridiculous patriarchal saying, added in an individual's experience and come up with a nonsensical generalisation- and all you're going to get here is generalisations in return.

For every man who abandoned his mum you'll find a man who still lives with her; for every man who was much closer to his father you'll find one who was devoted to his mother. Who knows? Your little boy- if that's what he is- may one day decide he wants to live his life as a woman.

All you can do as a parent is appreciate and nurture the individual you have been blessed with. And I feel very sorry for the little baby born to a mother who's disappointed in him even before he's uttered his first cry.

On a practical level, I agree with the poster who suggested getting a private scan to find out the sex now, to give yourself some time to process this before the birth.

Lacey247 · 17/08/2022 16:50

I absolutely LOVE having a boy. I wouldn’t know what to do with a girl and I am due my second boy soon. My son is so loving and sweet and such a mummy’s boy. His dad loves that we didn’t have a daughter as he loves doing ‘boy’ stuff with him. I don’t think girls are necessarily closer to their mums just because they are girls. I think the bond you have with your children will be there or not regardless of their gender

Isis1981uk · 17/08/2022 16:47

I had a boy first (then a girl) and my experience is that he was easier (slept more, ate well, rarely cried etc) than my daughter, but also that boys ADORE their mummas! He's so affectionate (even at 11 & about to start secondary school) & cuddly, and thinks I'm the most wonderful person ever!

BeardyButton · 17/08/2022 16:46

Genevieva · 17/08/2022 16:39

Socially boys are a lot easier. Girls are a nightmare the amount of stress brought home because friends have fallen out with each other is unbelievable. My son has never had these issues. Boys just muck in together, don't worry about who is friends with whom... Honestly, you will meet your baby and fall in love whether it is a boy or a girl. You will get swept up in their interests as their little personality unfolds. Congratulations on your pregnancy and good luck with everything to come.

I get where you are coming from.... But I do wonder if we don t socialise boys into this. At the start, my son would come home with tales of woe too. Im not entirely convinced that anything has changed or that he isnt as upset.... but somehow he has become convinced that he doesn't talk about that sort of thing because he is a big boy. Whoever filled his little head w that cr£p, I don t know.

AryaStarkWolf · 17/08/2022 16:46

Pushmepullu · 17/08/2022 16:36

Boys are more loving and don’t scream.

What a stupid statement.

My two - boy & girl are both loving and my daughter doesn't/didn't scream ffs

neverbeenskiing · 17/08/2022 16:46

I agree with the pp saying get a private scan asap so if it is a boy you can come to terms with your "disappointment" before the baby arrives.

MIL assumed DH would be a girl for some reason and was "shocked" when he turned out not to be. She spent his early childhood making her disappointment blatantly obvious. Then his sister came along and he went from being a disappointment to being invisible. That's why they're not close now, not because of this "a son is only a son until he finds a wife" bollocks. Had MIL found out his sex and been forced to deal with it during her pregnancy instead of conveniently ignoring the reality that there was only a 50/50 chance of her getting what she wanted it would have been better for all concerned I reckon.

NotQuiteUsual · 17/08/2022 16:45

Babies are wonderful little sleep stealers, boy or girl. Daughters are delightful and Sons are wonderful. There's very little difference between the two truthfully. It's all about the child's personality, my son is my easiest child. But his personality is very empathetic and gentle, which makes it easy to have a discussions rather than arguements.

But basically you're allowed to feel how you feel when you find out the sex. Because despite what people can say about gender disappointment, it's not something to be ashamed of. Before you know the sex you have the possibility of a son or a daughter and knowing the sex means one of those potential children no longer exists. It's ok to be a bit sad about that.

You'll love your child just as much regardless. I knew my in gut my third was another son, well she wasn't. It was absolutely fine in the moment and the surprise that she was a girl was actually lovely. It's not often you get such huge surprises in life.

GretaVanFleet · 17/08/2022 16:44

Gender disappointment. I’d never heard of it before this thread and I’m surprised how many people have said they had this. To think any parent’s first thought when they’ve just given birth or had their scan is disappointment is really quite sad.

LookingOverHereAllNight · 17/08/2022 16:43

Pushmepullu · 17/08/2022 16:36

Boys are more loving and don’t scream.

My boy and girl are equally as loving. My boy screamed as a baby and toddler. Is he not a boy? 🤦🏻‍♀️ People just make shit up.

LovinglifeAF · 17/08/2022 16:43

And they both still like hugs

Yabbadubba · 17/08/2022 16:43

@Greentartanbow01 i would also say that if you have a daughter you risk becoming extremely disappointed with her - you clearly have high expectations of being very close to her - If you’re close to your mum it will be natural for you to think you’ll therefore be close to your daughter. But you might not be. She might prefer her mother in law, and her son steals your daughter, rather than your saying.

GinUnicorn · 17/08/2022 16:43

I was disappointed with a boy too but he is
just the most lovely cuddly little person. He’s every bit as unique and wonderful as my daughter. I think it’s the stereotypes that really are the issue. I was scared about raising a boy because of all the talk of rough and tumble but the reality is lovely.

LovinglifeAF · 17/08/2022 16:42

I’ve got 2 boys, they are brilliant.

my eldest is 16 and he’s just a terrific young man - clever, hardworking, gentle and kind

the youngest is 13 and cracks me up, he’s so funny and kind hearted

BeardyButton · 17/08/2022 16:41

I have a boy. If I had another, I d want a boy. Isn't it strange? I mean I think my preference is probably irrational too. But - My boy is extremely cuddly. He is outdoorsey and fun. He is funny. He doesn't care what he is wearing. He likes very active play (think wrestling, which can get a bit... ). But Im sure there are plenty of girls like that too! I guess the cliche is that as girls grow they turn into friends or something?

Also - I know I don t have to worry about the sort of crap I encountered as a child/young adolescent. Catcalling. Being sexualised by older men. Creepy comments etc etc etc. That is a BIG plus of having a boy.The dangers of misogyny are much less (though not zero of course - and I do have to worry about bringing him up not to be involved in it).

ANewNameANewDay · 17/08/2022 16:41

God can't we just be grateful for healthy babies? Particularly if it's taken you a while to get one? Why on earth would you be disappointed just because your child comes out with a penis? Absolutely weird and desperately sad that there is so much disappointment for baby boys.

Just enjoy your baby and your journey into motherhood.

Yabbadubba · 17/08/2022 16:40

@Greentartanbow01 I haven’t read through the replies, but my god - how awful of you - you can’t be serious? Why on earth did you bother trying for a child if you didn’t want a boy?? So many people would do anything to be in your position and would not care

I wouldn’t compare your brother’s relationship with your parents or your partners relationshop with his parents (both bad by the sounds of it).

considering you have made such a huge generalisation , I will make one too:

little girls are bossy, far too independent, they snatch, take control - I could go on. I would much rather be in a room of little boys toddling around than little girls. They do not love back like little boys do. Little boys are are so kind, gentle, offer the most wonderful hugs and kisses. Girls have many more issues at school with friends. Boys just get on with it.

mother / daughter relationships whilst can often be good, can also be very fractious. A mother / son relationship is not as fragile.

I accept this is a generalisation, but you’ve made one too.

The whole a man goes off with his wife thing - for heavens sake get real. Your son might not get married, and if it does he might not end up with a wife. You must be a terrible daughter in law to have taken your son away from his parents!

Genevieva · 17/08/2022 16:39

Socially boys are a lot easier. Girls are a nightmare the amount of stress brought home because friends have fallen out with each other is unbelievable. My son has never had these issues. Boys just muck in together, don't worry about who is friends with whom... Honestly, you will meet your baby and fall in love whether it is a boy or a girl. You will get swept up in their interests as their little personality unfolds. Congratulations on your pregnancy and good luck with everything to come.

Pushmepullu · 17/08/2022 16:37

Oh, and what you see is what you get.

knittingaddict · 17/08/2022 16:36

My experience is that boys are very affectionate and loving. Certainly at their current ages - junior school.