Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for the good points to having a boy?

261 replies

Greentartanbow01 · 17/08/2022 15:11

Please could I have measured responses, I absolutely know that ultimately a healthy baby is all that matters.

I’m due a c section with my first baby next week. We don’t know the sex.

It took us a long time to get here and we never thought we’d be able to have a child, I’ve had a pretty rough pregnancy- diagnosed with many different things and had threatened first and second trimester miscarriage, plus pre-term 3rd trimester labour. Am so relieved and pleased to have made it to the gestation I am now.

In all honesty though, because of all the drama throughout this pregnancy, I haven’t really stopped and thought about the baby at the end of it 😳

In my head, the whole way through it’s been a girl. In every daydream that I’ve dared let myself have, it’s been a girl. I’ve always imagined myself with a daughter, never a son. I’m much better with girls than I am boys when I’m around other people’s children and I’m going to be honest here and say that I do have a gender preference and that is for a girl.

DH genuinely doesn’t have a preference and I believe him.

Please don’t get me wrong, I’m terrified of the baby not being healthy and I know that a healthy baby is the ultimate goal, sex really doesn’t matter and I know I’ll love my baby whatever, but I know if it’s a boy, it is probably going to take me a few hours to get my head around and mange the ‘disappointment’ (if that would be the word) in all honesty.

Part of the reason I’m less keen on having a boy is because of the saying that I keep seeing trotted out on here, about a daughter being a wife but a son only being a son until he finds a wife. In all honesty, that’s definitely been the case with me and my sibling, DB just doesn’t have the relationship with my mother that I do. They’re close enough but he sees a lot more of his wife’s mother/ family and tbh it’s pretty much the same for most males that I know.

Could posters please reassure me that that isn’t always the case and tell me why they love having a son/ sons?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CurlyGirlMumma · 14/02/2023 14:19

I understand where your coming from with the wife/son comment. I fully believe that it's the way a boy is raised. In particular the male influences. How his dad treats you and his mothers for example. How he prioritises the ladies in his life, will predict how he will be with you when he finds a wife.

My dad wasn't around much. He didn't facilitate much contact with his mum. And my brother doesn't speak to my mum.

Isis1981uk · 14/02/2023 12:53

I had a boy first (then a girl) and the bond I have with my son is incredible - boys really do love their mums, and he is still very huggy and affectionate now he's nearly 12. I see a lot of my personality in him and we have a real laugh together. On a practical side, he slept 12 hrs a night early on, ate everything, hardly ever cried, and was generally a lot easier than my daughter!

GahArgh · 14/02/2023 12:44

It's all down to you, OP. I have one of each. I really wanted the second to be another boy because I had such a lovely time with DS that I was worried I wouldn't know what to do with a girl.

My DS is now a young teen. He is excellent company, still cuddles me and sometimes holds my hand, cooks and bakes, is pretty level-headed. He doesn't divulge his every thought like his younger sister, but then I doubt she'll still be doing that in a few years' time.

My manager still regularly hangs out with her adult son, sometimes also with his girlfriend. I hope to be the same.

I am not close to my mum because she's not someone I particularly want to be close to. My highest priority in life is to have the kind of relationship with my DC that means they still enjoy my company when I'm not just their financial support!

I hope the rest of the pregnancy and birth go smoothly for you.

Nevermind31 · 14/02/2023 12:19

How about you’ll start daydreaming about a son in advance?
there are lots that can be said about boys, but that might not apply to your child.same as not all girls are the same.
mu brother and his wife (together and individually) are spending a lot of time with my parents - with hers, not so much.
it all depends on you.
best of luck!!!

WhereIsMumHiding3 · 14/02/2023 12:19

Oh sorry you had a girl! Whoops!

Anyway glad you are happy !

WhereIsMumHiding3 · 14/02/2023 12:18

Greentartanbow01 · 14/02/2023 10:13

OP back again.

I can confirm I had a girl! I can’t lie, I was relieved when they said congratulations, it’s a girl! But, knowing the absolute love I have for her now, I KNOW I’d have loved the baby just as much if it were a boy, would I be worried about the future slightly, maybe but I’d have embraced having a boy as I’d have just loved the baby.

Congratulations OP!!

Yes , glad to hear you realised, you'd love your baby whatever gender

Good luck with the happy changing (put a wet wipe over his w*lly when you change happy, pee in the eye is no fun Grin" and be careful as boys tend to make bigger movements so your far more likely to get poked in the eye or head butted by a lively growing boy baby than a girl baby (I swear I needed American football style protective gear!) but that may just be my DCs personalities and strength.

WhereIsMumHiding3 · 14/02/2023 12:15

Sorry this

far easier albeit active and kicked

Was meant to say far easier and lively

WhereIsMumHiding3 · 14/02/2023 12:14

I have two girls and one boy

I don't think it divides out as that old wives tale says as it very much depends on the individuals regardless of their gender. My cousins with both sons and daughters including married ones also are very close to their grown married boys. As long as you welcome and respect the partners in their lives- which is key i think.

The girls are very different to each other. Can't say I'm close at all to my middle girl who's now a new adult and at Uni for years, although we were extremely close until she hit teenage years.

My youngest DD still a teen is very close to me...

I'm very close to my son, eldest, aways have been even though he's a grown adult living away from home. He is independent as the eldest but has always been very close to his old mum (me!) and I can't see that changing.

In terms of who is hardest to bring up, my boy was harder as a toddler but far easier albeit active and kicked aged 5 onwards. My girls were easier as toddlers but boy oh boy wait til they hit teenage years! It's an emotional roller coaster with teen girls and complex friendship dramas they have! Give me a teenage boy who mumbles and maybe doesn't shower as much as he should for a couple years any day over the "I hate you mum you're ruining my life!!" (When they are doing something very Ill thought out and unsafe) My boys answer is always "fair nuff mum, what do I need to do to make it ok for you?" And he does it!! That might be an order of birth thing but I suspect it's their personalities and hormones.

mucky123 · 14/02/2023 12:12

I had first 2 girls and then a boy. My boy is just beautiful, he loves me so much, he is funny, sweet, interested intently in weird things and I just want to smile everytime I see him. Its easy to parent him whereas I find with the girls there is a lot more angst (although on paper they are better behaved). I don't have a preference as to gender but I can confirm there are lots of lovely things about having a boy.

Mummy2mybear · 14/02/2023 11:57

Congratulations OP 💐 amazing for you x

TheOrigRights · 14/02/2023 10:48

Everyone always wants a girl errr no.

I suggest you get a scan done before baby arrives I suggest you read the thread, or at least the OP's posts!

Remmy123 · 14/02/2023 10:41

Everyone always wants a girl - pretty dresses / close to their mums/ mother and daughter days out etc

yes that can be the case but most of my mates with girls it's not like that at all!!

I have sons all different personalities

I won't tell you what is good about them because you will find out for yourself.

a mother loves thier baby no matter what it's irrelevant what sex they are.

these threads are silly really

I suggest you get a scan done before baby arrives

Abhannmor · 14/02/2023 10:33

Congratulations 🎊!

VestaTilley · 14/02/2023 10:31

It’s sex, not gender.

You treat them exactly the same. I take my son to ballet and we do arts and crafts. You don’t pigeonhole them- and you never, ever let them know you regret not having a child of the opposite sex.

I find your post to be deeply distasteful.

Hello12345678910 · 14/02/2023 10:29

I wanted a girl. Desperately desperately wanted a girl.. I got a boy.. we found out gender at 18 weeks at a private scan
I cried alot, other people also seemed weirdly disappointed (colleagues) though I had never mentioned I wanted a girl

Once he was here though honestly it's not made the blindest bit of difference - he's 9 months old and I love him more than anything - obviously I can't tell you on future years - but I'm not a girly girl myself so that doesn't overly worry me.

Agree with a previous poster though, if I were you I'd get a private scan and see what baby is.. if you think you may be disappointed at a boy it'll give you time to get over it now. Don't spoil it for yourself when baby arrives... its the best thing in the world

harrassedmumto3 · 14/02/2023 10:26

Oh, I've just seen you had a girl!! Many congratulations! Flowers
Wish I'd seen this before posting now Grin

harrassedmumto3 · 14/02/2023 10:22

I have 3 girls (two of whom are teens) and my sister has 3 boys (similar ages).
The boys were physically more challenging when they were little, with bags of energy, and needed to be run off at the park. Mine were happy indoors, playing or doing arts & crafts.
The tide has truly turned now Grin Her boys are much easier as teens, whereas it's the most difficult time of my parenting experience to date. I love my girls but they are so emotionally draining. Also, they're not affectionate at all.
I also work with challenging teens! The boys are more laidback, in my experience.
There are definite advantages to boys!

Greentartanbow01 · 14/02/2023 10:13

OP back again.

I can confirm I had a girl! I can’t lie, I was relieved when they said congratulations, it’s a girl! But, knowing the absolute love I have for her now, I KNOW I’d have loved the baby just as much if it were a boy, would I be worried about the future slightly, maybe but I’d have embraced having a boy as I’d have just loved the baby.

OP posts:
GretnaGreenIsLovely · 13/02/2023 19:18

I have two boys. I'll admit I wanted DS2 to be a girl! But now I have boys, and will not be having more so will never have a girl, I actually love it! Boys are great fun! I'm learning all about football and swimming and planes and cars despite trying my hardest to get them into pink and nail polish!! It's been a fun journey and I love it!

I'm v close to both my boys and think I always will be. I do think it's a different relationship, but it's a great one! I don't think I'll lose my boys when (if) they marry! I'm sure they'll always call and be happy for a few meet ups! I can't wait to see where their lives take them!! And .. who knows .. maybe they will marry women I can get to know and hang out with!

I understand where you are coming from OP, but boys are great! They really are!! And as far as I can tell from my friends with girls they r a hec of a lot easier to manage and their friendships way less complex, especially in primary school!! ;)

SleepingStandingUp · 13/02/2023 19:05

Livemenot · 13/02/2023 18:12

@Greentartanbow01 , I am in a similar position. I have always wanted a girl as I have heard and seen girls tend to be closer to their families when they are adults. I have seen sons visiting their wives’ parents and relatives much more often. Sons usually don’t give as much attention to their mums.

I have given birth to a son, he is going to be 3 years old and he is lovely. I love him as much as I would have loved a daughter. I am just selfishly worried that I am raising him for another family when he gets married - his wife’s parents and relatives.

How does your husband treat his mom and family? I think its about modelling. I have 3 boys, we see DHs Mom (widow) once or twice a week, we see my own once. HE gets her mothers day, birthday and Christmas cards and presents. He and his brother go over and help her when she needs it. DH fixes her PC.

My boys will grow up knowing its normal to be close to your parents I adulthood

Livemenot · 13/02/2023 18:12

@Greentartanbow01 , I am in a similar position. I have always wanted a girl as I have heard and seen girls tend to be closer to their families when they are adults. I have seen sons visiting their wives’ parents and relatives much more often. Sons usually don’t give as much attention to their mums.

I have given birth to a son, he is going to be 3 years old and he is lovely. I love him as much as I would have loved a daughter. I am just selfishly worried that I am raising him for another family when he gets married - his wife’s parents and relatives.

GretaVanFleet · 18/08/2022 21:51

We never found out what we were having either time and have one of each, DD then DS two completely different babies, children and adults. Both bring us so much joy. I wanted two children, I didn’t have any thoughts about wanting a girl or a boy. DH did talk about wanting a son and I would say to him - would you rather a healthy girl or a boy with a medical problem - he said that I had a fair point. He was thrilled when our daughter was born and again our son. Our DD says DS is our favourite and DS insists DD is our favourite. I’m so proud of both of them, they both give the best hugs and I have learned so much from them. Whether you have a son or daughter you are blessed, enjoy every moment because before you know it they’re getting ready to leave home. Watch some gender reveal videos on TikTok or YouTube, I’ve never seen a negative reaction and I’m sure if the confetti cloud had been the alternative colour the reaction would have been the same. It doesn’t matter what you have you’ll love your child regardless as you’ve already pointed out. I wish you all the best.

AliTheMinx · 18/08/2022 20:09

I didn't have any preference on sex, but I adore my son. He's incredible. Loving, loyal, fun, kind, caring - and very funny. He's 10 and the best company. I didn't have any experience of boys, but when it's your son you just get it. There are some things he does which are more aligned to my husband's interests, but that's fine. Good luck, OP!

AliBaliBears · 18/08/2022 19:46

They're all individuals you'd be better off wishing for a baby that sleeps well than a specific sex.
**
This is so very very true.

My partner wanted to find out sex at 20wks so we did. I wouldn't have bothered as made no difference to me. We didn't tell anyone else and I never once referred to the baby as anything other than 'the baby' until he was born. For the first few weeks I was so tired I kept mixing up he/she when talking about him as his sex was honestly the last thing on my mind. He was just a baby of the non-sleeping type 😂
**

YouSetTheTone · 18/08/2022 19:24

I have three sons and by the time I was pregnant with the third I was actually more nervous of having a girl than a boy (although obviously I’d have got over it fast!!)
I love my three sons so much, they are all so different in character yet all so loving, thoughtful, curious, affectionate and exciting to be around. My brother is just as close to my mum as my sister and I and equally we’re just as close to my dad as he is.
A lot of the mums in my eldest son’s class seem to be struggling with their daughters now as opposed to the ones with boys. I know this will balance out eventually but I think both sexes have their periods of pulling away and being more challenging.