Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Outgoing employee on interview panel?

37 replies

Troyes76 · 17/08/2022 15:05

Posting here for traffic!

I volunteer for a local charity, and our administrator is leaving, so we are about to interview for a new administrator (paid role)
The administrator who is leaving is adamant that she should be on the interview panel for the new administrator (ie the person who will take over her role)

To me, this sounds wrong - surely if you're leaving then you shouldn't be involved? I've looked on the ACAS and TUC websites but can't find anything - does anyone know the answer to this? Thanks!

OP posts:
SettingsO · 17/08/2022 15:20

Do you trust her judgement? If so then its fine. If not, then don't let her.

Auntieobem · 17/08/2022 15:19

While her involvement might be useful, she cannot insist on being part of the panel. Being adamant she should be on the panel is very odd - what reasons does she give?

Exasperatednow · 17/08/2022 15:17

It depends. Why are they leaving? What were they like as a role? Do you think the role needs some change?
Why do they want to be on the panel? Do they have a set view of how it should be done?

SparklyLeprechaun · 17/08/2022 15:17

I've interviewed for my replacement before, what's the problem? I didn't have the final say on the hire, but I was the one best placed to say if these people had the necessary qualities/knowledge to do my job.

Triffid1 · 17/08/2022 15:16

My instinct is to say that having the departing person on the panel can be quite helpful in terms of properly assessing skills and also to answer questions. However, that person would not have any meaningful role in actual decision making - ie they would advise the hiring panel but not actually have a vote as such.

But her insistence is a bit odd. Why is she leaving? Are you confident that she's not trying to sabotage and/or get a friend/colleague into the job by insisting that she is part of the process?

GeekyThings · 17/08/2022 15:16

It's unusual, although there isn't any law against it. But I would err on the side of saying no, as she's leaving, so she shouldn't really be put in a position where she has any say over new hires - she won't be working there anymore, it isn't really her place to do that.

As an administrative role I'd say making sure the new hire gets on with existing staff remaining would be more useful. Most interviews now tend to have 3 people involved, usually one person from HR, the manager in charge of the hire or someone who deals with capabilities, and then one other person who will either be directly responsible day to day for the potential employee, or will be working with them frequently. Stick with that kind of format and it should be easy to pick people to do the interview.

Vapeyvapevape · 17/08/2022 15:14

It will give the interviewees an opportunity to ask questions about the role and get answers from the horse's mouth. Better than asking panel members who have no in-depth knowledge of the job.

FangsForTheMemory · 17/08/2022 15:10

If she's leaving it's none of her business!

HangOnToYourself · 17/08/2022 15:10

I have supported recruitment for my replacements and also had team members who were being replaced support me on interviews. No issues with HR so I dont see the problem

Randomness12 · 17/08/2022 15:09

Generally a massive no unless it’s for something like maternity cover and the person is coming back. Just say no. It’ll be awkward for the candidates to see/compare to who they are potentially succeeding

sillysmiles · 17/08/2022 15:09

It could depend - if you need to hire someone with specific expertise that only the outgoing person has, then it would make sense for them to be on the panel to assess the level of in-depth specialist knowledge.
But without that, then no, I would think it is more important that the person who will be working with them are on the panel.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 17/08/2022 15:07

I have often thought that it would make a pleasant change to be interviewed or recruited by somebody who actually understands the job (and whether the candidate is utterly bullshitting, which is most definitely a thing).

Why not give it a go?