Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Moving a child away from the bottom of the slide

106 replies

amamma · 17/08/2022 14:12

I was on the playground with my DD. There was a little boy who I moved out of the way a couple of times, because he was standing at the bottom of the slide and others were coming down. I did ask him to move, but he didn't, so I gently moved him.

I also did the same to my DD a few times.

Is that OK ? I'm paranoid it's super out of line. The mum was nearby but she was sitting down chatting, so she didn't see that he could have been hurt by another child coming down. She saw me do it and didn't seem do mind. I absolutely wouldn't mind if another adult did that to my children.

Opinions ?

OP posts:
mam0918 · 17/08/2022 16:31

TheOrigRights · 17/08/2022 15:12

and I presume you are closely supervising him then.

If I saw an unsupervised child about to get hurt I would move them. I guess subconsciously I'd make my own risk assessment : chances of toddler getting hurt by incoming child down slide = 97% vs chances of causing serious injury to toddler due to invisible disability = vanishingly small (thankfully).

mam0918 - are you suggesting people shouldn't move a child in danger?

Im saying people shouldnt assume anything, this entire thead is people assuming about somthing that was an assumption in the first place.

OP does not know this child, childs mother or anything about the situation but CLEARLY has an anxiety disorder. Just from the irratic overthinking of this post and they way she writes I would take the actual 'risk' of the situation with a big pinch of salt.

Also for the record I am also disabled, yes I watch my DS like a hawk but no I can not physically chase him around picking him up. He has never been at risk or got hurt and no one else has ever took it upon themselves to man handle him out of the way of their kids - thats not how the world works.

The view that the risk of a child you dont know being disabled is 'vanishingly small' is ignorant and abilist.

Livpool · 17/08/2022 16:30

FlyingSaucerss · 17/08/2022 14:14

I wouldn’t have moved him. In this situation I tell dd to play on something else

Exactly!

I saw a child get kicked quite forcefully on the back last week when they sat at the bottom of the slide for too long. The other child showed them to move then said they were coming down.

You did the right thing OP

dandelionthistle · 17/08/2022 16:14

I would have done as you did, and if you had done that to my child I'd have been grateful.

I would have been annoyed at having to effectively look after someone else's child though so I'd be quietly hoping my DC moved to another bit of the playground soon!

Cant get my head around either actively encouraging my DC to move away rather than deal with the child directly, or deliberately standing by and letting the child get hurt.

V grateful mine are now largely big enough to navigate the playground without close supervision, so this sort of thing rarely falls to me to intervene. But obvs if I'm the closest adult I feel obliged to.

Brefugee · 17/08/2022 16:10

haha - i also mentioned a few other things i might do too - so you understand the use of hyperbole right?
That was the last thing after things like asking who he was with and actually, you know moving him out of the way.

Sorry if it wasn't clear i wouldn't actually do it.

Again: you are determined to be a wet lettuce. That's up to you. Me? I'd move the child, physically and ask him who he was with. Because I think the current fear around either touching a stranger's child, or having a stranger touch your child in these circumstances is totally batshit

Zippy1510 · 17/08/2022 16:09

I tend to tell children they need to move and if it doesn't work use my arm/body to block them either going up slides or lingering at the bottom. I once had to lift a child who went charging up a slide whilst a much larger child was already on their way down. I couldn't care less if it angers their parents, they should be supervising.

FlyingSaucerss · 17/08/2022 16:06

Brefugee · 17/08/2022 16:01

Like I said, sending your child down to hurt them is much better isn’t it 🙄

you are so bloody determined to misunderstand. Whatever. I hope your DD loves being dragged off things because other parents don't supervise their kids and you're too much of a wet lettuce to move them.

I'd send my DD down and if she knocked the boy over, he'd soon learn not to stand in the way again.

what have I misunderstood? it’s here clearly for you since you have such difficult reading.

Izzabellasasperella · 17/08/2022 16:06

drpet49 · 17/08/2022 14:42

“I'd send my DD down and if she knocked the boy over, he'd soon learn not to stand in the way again.”

^Me too

So you would deliberately upset and hurt (maybe seriously) a little boy AND your own child!?
That is all sorts of wrong in my world.

QueSyrahSyrah · 17/08/2022 16:05

I'd do the same, but saying that I once jumped in to move a tiny toddling baby out of the way of getting nutted by a bigger kids zip wire at an indoor play and the Mother came over and snatched him away with the kind of look I'd expect to get if I'd tried to set him alight.

I took it that she was embarrassed / frightened by her lack of attention and chose to direct it at me 🤷🏻‍♀️

Brefugee · 17/08/2022 16:01

Like I said, sending your child down to hurt them is much better isn’t it 🙄

you are so bloody determined to misunderstand. Whatever. I hope your DD loves being dragged off things because other parents don't supervise their kids and you're too much of a wet lettuce to move them.

FallOutPloy · 17/08/2022 16:01

I would pick him up and move him if there were actually another child on the way down the slide. Otherwise I'd kind of "shepherd" him away trying not to actually touch him. We're probably all a bit too scared of situations like this though tbh.

Also, parents who can't be arsed with supervising their own children should really understand that someone else is very likely to have to step in 🙄

OldTinHat · 17/08/2022 15:58

I would have said 'careful standing there, you might get knocked over' in the same way I bellowed at a woman on Sunday who was standing on a cliff edge with a great big crack almost running from her feet to the beach. (I was on the beach and didn't fancy wearing a tourist as a hat!)

Nothing wrong in looking out for people, whether guiding them physically or verbally if it means putting them out of harms way. We're too scared of doing the wrong thing when trying to help imo.

FlyingSaucerss · 17/08/2022 15:58

Brefugee · 17/08/2022 15:57

No they didn't @FlyingSaucerss . They have called out, roundly and soundly, pretty much everyone who said they'd not interfere and if the child got hurt tough tits.

But you were going to another batshit extreme of not letting your dd use a slide because a kid was a) unsupervised and b) unaware of how playparks work (ie you don't stand at the end of the slide, or walk too closely to swings). Which is an extreme and incomprehensible aversion to simply kindly guiding the (unsupervised) child out of the way so the playground can be used for it's intended purpose. You and the "he gets what's coming to him" are the ridiculous, imo, extreme positions.

Like I said, sending your child down to hurt them is much better isn’t it 🙄

10HailMarys · 17/08/2022 15:57

Steering a small child out of harm's way at a playground is a perfectly normal thing to do.

Christ, from some of the responses on here, you'd think you'd picked him up by one leg and lobbed him into a bin.

Brefugee · 17/08/2022 15:57

No they didn't @FlyingSaucerss . They have called out, roundly and soundly, pretty much everyone who said they'd not interfere and if the child got hurt tough tits.

But you were going to another batshit extreme of not letting your dd use a slide because a kid was a) unsupervised and b) unaware of how playparks work (ie you don't stand at the end of the slide, or walk too closely to swings). Which is an extreme and incomprehensible aversion to simply kindly guiding the (unsupervised) child out of the way so the playground can be used for it's intended purpose. You and the "he gets what's coming to him" are the ridiculous, imo, extreme positions.

ChagSameachDoreen · 17/08/2022 15:55

A swift kick, job done.

FlyingSaucerss · 17/08/2022 15:54

Well I said I would distract my child and tell them to go on something else and had so many posters jump on me for that yet so many of them ignored the ones who would send theirs down to deliberately hurt the child 🤦🏻 Yeh because that’s so much better?!

dumptruck · 17/08/2022 15:52

Under what other circumstances would you choose to injure a child? A shove on a escalator, with a shopping trolley, with your car in a carpark? Because in the first scenario it's you that's decided to injure the child. Would you injure an adult who is disabled, if their carer wasn't watching them? What about if they go close to the swing?

@Ponoka7 I would never do this, I do as op did or move away.

However!

Pp are not advocating injuring a child. Their principle is to ignore their child going down the slide, the same way the boys mum ignored him. Ie. Let nature take its course, not shove a child down an escalator.

Flittingaboutagain · 17/08/2022 15:49

I'd send my DD down and if she knocked the boy over, he'd soon learn not to stand in the way again.”
^Me too

  • I can't believe these nasty replies. Sometimes kids make mistakes and it's quite evil to punish them just because their parent is distracted.
Flittingaboutagain · 17/08/2022 15:47

So I'd ask the child to move, call-out "whose child is this ? You wanna move them" And if no one replied or looked up I'd move them

^ this is what I do too.

Tiani4 · 17/08/2022 15:45

*if you moved my child!!

Please don't love my child! Gosh that was an unfortunate auto incorrect!! 😱😱

Tiani4 · 17/08/2022 15:44

I'd be glad you loved my child if I wasn't watching them and moving them myself

It's very annoying when an unsupervised young child stands at bottom of slide keeping others waiting at time and both children will get injured if they go down

So I'd ask the child to move, call-out "whose child is this ? You wanna move them" And if no one replied or looked up I'd move them

Longdistance · 17/08/2022 15:34

I would’ve left him there, after a few kicks in the head I’m sure he’ll move.

Dajeeling · 17/08/2022 15:33

Absolutely fine. If they have an objection to this then they should be supervising him more carefully.

I say this as a mum to 3 autistic children- the youngest loves to climb up slides and eat bark from the ground. Hence why I can’t sit and just ignore him when we go to the park.

Sally99 · 17/08/2022 15:33

I would have gently moved him. If someone moved my child out of harms way I'd be grateful

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 17/08/2022 15:32

I’d def. move a child out of the way if its parent was too busy nattering/on their phone, to see that it needed to move. After asking the child first, of course. Would it be better for the child to be knocked over by another child coming down? Maybe a bigger, heavier one?

Swipe left for the next trending thread