Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

August babies shouldn't be allowed to move down a year

972 replies

SapphosRock · 17/08/2022 07:53

My DD has a late August birthday, she is 6 nearly 7 and about to go into Year 3.

A friend in her class (let's call her Lucy) has an early August birthday but was allowed to move down a year. She is already 8.

No special needs, her mum just decided she would prefer her DD to be the oldest in the class rather than one of the youngest.

This has impacted my DD in a few ways. She is good at sports but being the youngest means she doesn't often win. On Sports Day Lucy came first in the year 2 running race. My DD came 4th so missed out on a medal.

Lucy had a sleepover for her 8th birthday and invited the girls in DD's class. Most went but I didn't think DD was ready for a sleepover as she's still only 6 so she missed out on a fun party.

Lucy got the biggest speaking part in the Christmas play as she is the most confident and articulate.

AIBU and precious to think Lucy should have been kept in the correct year group?

OP posts:
SapphosRock · 17/08/2022 11:36

For all manner of reasons listed in this thread. Not emotionally ready. Still having an afternoon nap. SEN (plenty of autistic and ADHD girls are very bright and come across as very confident, but may struggle at school in other ways). Parents being deployed abroad for a year. That’s just a few.

I did explain in the OP that none of this applies to Lucy. Her mum just wanted her to be the oldest.

I know this because her mum told me.

OP posts:
WalkingOnTheCracks · 17/08/2022 11:35

OhPleaseJustLast · 17/08/2022 11:20

Would anyone with a 1st September child send them to school a year early, making them the youngest I the year above, just in case they disadvantaged the youngest children in their own year by being the oldest...?

Given the chance I almost certainly would have sent at least one of my September borns the year before I was allowed to, because he was totally ready and bored out of his mind at pre school. The other was also academically ready, but perhaps not emotionally.

Likewise. Our 1st Sept kid was completely ready to start school at the same time as her cousin who was born three days earlier.

I quite like the idea of a month-either-way system of some sort.

Lourdes12 · 17/08/2022 11:33

We start school at 7 in Sweden and have 3 month summer holiday

twentySixx · 17/08/2022 11:33

My dd is late aug birthday I want to defer her but I’m not sure about the process does anyone know would she be allowed to do 2 years at school nursery or would her nursery start be deferred too as they only take one intake in sep each year so she can either go at just 3 or just 4 ?

OhPleaseJustLast · 17/08/2022 11:33

DazzlePaintedBattlePants · 17/08/2022 11:24

If it’s not a complete why didn’t Lucy start in her correct year?

For all manner of reasons listed in this thread. Not emotionally ready. Still having an afternoon nap. SEN (plenty of autistic and ADHD girls are very bright and come across as very confident, but may struggle at school in other ways). Parents being deployed abroad for a year. That’s just a few.

THNG5 · 17/08/2022 11:31

RunningSME · 17/08/2022 09:00

The issue is quite frankly 13-year-olds will try and shag anything that moves at school and their peer group will be your 11-year-old.

I cannot believe you just wrote that. Do you have a 13 year old??? If this is your view of the world, I feel sorry for you.

MrsRobinsonsHandprints · 17/08/2022 11:29

And the very idea that all 13 year old boys want nothing more than to have sex with your 11 year old is still weird.

In fairness it was another poster that said that but the difference between an 11 year old and a 13 year old is immense. I think it wouldn't be fair on either of them. Plus senior school is tough, there will be questions and teasing about why the 13 year old is kept back, why he is friends with and 11 year old.

And as this continues through the years, a 16 year old dating someone in his class that is 14, a 17 year old doing his GCSEs with 15 year olds.

RubbishRobotFromTheDawnOfTime · 17/08/2022 11:29

SapphosRock · 17/08/2022 08:05

But someone born in September will be 12 months older than her and in the 'correct' year group. One month isn't going to make much difference really is it.

I would have zero issues if Lucy was born in September as someone has to be the oldest and someone the youngest.

This makes no sense. It’s only one month’s difference! You could have deferred your daughter too if you thought she wasn’t ready.

oakleaffy · 17/08/2022 11:28

@SapphosRock
In retrospect I wish I’d kept DS back a year.
for boys especially, being nearly a year younger physically makes a big difference.
It IS more advantageous to be the oldest and tallest in one’s year, for sure.

theadultsaretalking · 17/08/2022 11:28

My eldest is August born and when deciding between two educational systems (British or European), we chose the European one purely because the intake age is from January to December.

My daughter is already the smallest and the shyest in her class as it is, if she was the youngest - she would really struggle to be seen or heard. So I think it's great to have this option to postpone for a year.

babbez · 17/08/2022 11:25

OhPleaseJustLast · 17/08/2022 11:20

Would anyone with a 1st September child send them to school a year early, making them the youngest I the year above, just in case they disadvantaged the youngest children in their own year by being the oldest...?

Given the chance I almost certainly would have sent at least one of my September borns the year before I was allowed to, because he was totally ready and bored out of his mind at pre school. The other was also academically ready, but perhaps not emotionally.

I also thought about whether I'd do this for my child, however the point is that you're still considering your own child, not wider societal fairness, so you can't blame the parents who keep theirs back. Few are willing to gamble their own children's future, we all do what we think is best

DazzlePaintedBattlePants · 17/08/2022 11:25

Competition obviously!

DazzlePaintedBattlePants · 17/08/2022 11:24

ForfuckssakeEXHstopbeingatwat · 17/08/2022 11:02

It's only unfair if you see school as a competition. If it's about each child accessing it at an appropriate level for them, it makes perfect sense and arguably yes, could be offered to all students, so those who are super ready could go a year early etc. Those saying it should be the same for everyone are going entirely contrary to the principle of "every child matters" . Shall we just abandon all differentiation and acknowledgment of different pace and style of learning so they are all given the exact same work, help and support, regardless of what they actually need?

If it’s not a complete why didn’t Lucy start in her correct year?

WhereAreMyAirpods · 17/08/2022 11:22

MrsRobinsonsHandprints · 17/08/2022 10:40

I disagree. A child who turns 13 on 1st April is in a class with a child that is 11 until the 31st August.

I think that is a big deal.

In Scotland, anyone whose child whose birthday is between the school start in August and the following 28th Feb has the right to request deferral, but it's not automatic. Jan/Feb birthdays there are no questions asked but for Aug-December children there is a whole separate issue around Councils not wanting to fund pre-school for another year so parents are either faced with funding that themselves, or going down the route of ed psych reports and so on. Very few Aug-Dec birthdays are deferred. Many more Jan/Feb birthdays are deferred.

In England the system is different in that parents of summer borns must say WHY they want their child deferred - jan/feb birthdays in Scotland do not need to do this. Your scenario of a boy born 1st April being deferred purely on the basis of sharp-elbowed parents who want him to be way older, and then that 1st April boy preying on a girl whose birthday is end August is unrealistic in the same way that there are vanishingly few Oct/Nov/Dec children deferred in Scotland.

It is going to be the parents of the children whose birthdays in England are in the "summer holiday" period who MAY want to take advantage of this. The 25 July - 31 August cohort. And it's a choice for the parents, some will take advantage, some won't.

And the very idea that all 13 year old boys want nothing more than to have sex with your 11 year old is still weird.

OhPleaseJustLast · 17/08/2022 11:20

Would anyone with a 1st September child send them to school a year early, making them the youngest I the year above, just in case they disadvantaged the youngest children in their own year by being the oldest...?

Given the chance I almost certainly would have sent at least one of my September borns the year before I was allowed to, because he was totally ready and bored out of his mind at pre school. The other was also academically ready, but perhaps not emotionally.

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 17/08/2022 11:20

Lucy had a sleepover for her 8th birthday and invited the girls in DD's class. Most went but I didn't think DD was ready for a sleepover as she's still only 6 so she missed out on a fun party.

This is the most bizarre part of the thread. Your daughter ‘missed out on a fun party’ because you didn’t let her go! How is it the fault of the other child? Should her mother have checked in advance whether each and every parent approved of the birthday activity?

Maybe what will REALLY disadvantage your daughter in life is not sharing her primary school class with someone a month too old, but reaching adulthood and realising not everything and everyone will adjust to suit her needs, just because her mommy says so.

MrsRobinsonsHandprints · 17/08/2022 11:19

Lucy’s parents thought when they realised she would be going through school with children 11 months

But now there are children going to school with other children who are nearly 17 months older.

When should the cut off be? Let's have a free for all and let everyone choose what year their child attends.

Changechangychange · 17/08/2022 11:17

oddoneoutalways · 17/08/2022 08:23

I think if you can hold them back, you should also be able to push them forward. If not, the cut off should be the cut off and that's it.

My child is going to be the oldest in her year group by far. She misses the cut off by ONE DAY. This is a child who is more than ready for Reception, more so that many of the children who are only weeks older than her and moving up whilst she's still got another year at playgroup to go. She'll already be 5 when she starts Reception next year.

Mine is a second child, she regularly plays with children older than her very happily. She's already writing her name, ours and other words, doing simple sums, and blending letters to read simple words. She joins in with her older sisters spelling practice from school, asking me to make her her own version (only simple worlds like Bat, Cat, Mat etc). She can use the toilet, change her own clothes/shoes, do things like open a yoghurt independently, knows how to follow the routine at playgroup/sit on the carpet nicely/raise her hand for things etc and has no problem mixing with a range of children. She's very confident.

I can't move her forwards. She has another year at playgroup which she attends three days a week and she is going to be so frustrated this coming school year. She's cross because her friends are moving to reception without her and she's being left at playgroup with children some of whom are nearly a year younger than her which at this age is a big gap. Some of them are only just turning 3 and are still in nappies.

I'm not fussed from a childcare perspective either - I'm a SAHM so it means I get an extra year having some time to do nice things with her solo on the days she's at home which is a bonus. I'm not putting her into playgroup an extra day, she's going to start getting bored there as it is, as good as they are! So I've found a forest school to take her to (with me) one day a week to give her some extra things to do and more socialising opportunities.

Before I had a child who was as capable as her I'd have said I'd always prefer for mine to be the oldest in the year rather than the youngest. Now, if I had a choice - for her, not me - I'd send her to Reception in September if I could. She'd benefit far more from starting this year than spending another year at playgroup.

It's not on that it doesn't work both ways! When I was a child there were three intakes a year, my brother started school the January after he turned 5 at the Christmas. Worked better!

Yep we had that when I was a child - I had a January birthday and started after Easter. I did mean that I missed out on two terms of Reception though, we moved up to Year 1 in September along with everyone else. So I might have well have started the previous September.

Chillow · 17/08/2022 11:17

It’s an interesting point, OP. I was the youngest in my class but also the brightest.

I have done well but maybe I would have done even better if I hadn’t been the youngest? Who knows.

viques · 17/08/2022 11:16

SapphosRock · 17/08/2022 08:00

Okay I am clearly U!

Just though it was a tad unfair my DD is expected to work / perform at the same level as a girl 13 months older than her.

But that is exactly what Lucy’s parents thought when they realised she would be going through school with children 11 months older! They are giving her a chance to build confidence, achieve academically , emotionally and physically, and it seems to be paying off. The difference does even out eventually, at four years old a year of age represents a quarter of your entire experience so you have had a quarter less exposure to language, you are a quarter less emotionally experienced, physically your body and muscles are a quarter less developed and competent, at eight it represents an eighth of your experience and so on, by the time you are 12 the differences are negligible.

miserablecat · 17/08/2022 11:16

The opportunity is there for anyone with a child who is in the youngest portion of the year. Some parents might be unaware, others might not be able to take advantage from a financial or practical point of view, but I can't see how it's pushy or sharp elbowed to take an opportunity offered, that you believe is a benefit your child .
In reality most people would take opportunities offered if they thought they were advantageous to their own child. They are not taking anything from anyone else, or asking for special treatment for their child.

Would anyone with a 1st September child send them to school a year early, making them the youngest I the year above, just in case they disadvantaged the youngest children in their own year by being the oldest...?

Essexgalttc · 17/08/2022 11:11

@SapphosRock
You are not being unreasonable

The cut off at our school when I was younger was 28th August

You couldn’t just move your child down a year, or up a year.

I am a May birthday and I had friends who were August birthdays. We definitely were slightly slower or not as academic as our almost a year older friends in the same class.

My friends are school teachers, I asked them this question and they agree there is some level of difference (not all cases of course. Sometimes there can be a 8 year old more advanced or smarter than a 10 year old)

13 months is quite a gap. Usually the max is 11/12

What matters most is stop worrying about her friend in her class and worry about her own personal development for the age your DD is. Do not compare her to other children. We are always going to have someone smarter than us or not as smart as us.

OhPleaseJustLast · 17/08/2022 11:07

Astrabees · 17/08/2022 10:59

I'm interested in this theme whenever it comes up. I was born at the end of August and was always the youngest in my year. I passed my 11+ a year early , so i had just turned 10 when I went to secondary school, took my O levels at 14 and my A levels at 16. There were several of us in my class like this, mostly born in the summer. I don't think we honestly felt any different to the others, maybe I pushed boundaries for freedom a bit early and the only time I really felt I was missing out was when the others got to be 17 and could learn to drive and I couldn't. I'm still good friends with my old schoolfriends, especially the oldest in my year who is nearly 3 years older than me (she got kept down a year at some point) At that time parents wanted to push their children a bit and it seemed to work, none of the younger ones in my class seemed to struggle.

Me too. I’m undoubtedly biased because I am a September born who moved to secondary school a year early, and therefore had friends in my year who were 18 months or so older than me. It made zero difference. I was top of my year and went to Oxbridge. Had I been made to stay on at primary school an extra year - as Lucy will be - I would have been bored out of mind.

I also have two September born children who would both have been ready for school at 4, but were 5 by the time they started. Yes, they are doing well academically, but since the youngest could already read at 4, I’m confident that would have been the case anyway. The eldest is the smallest in his year and is definitely not winning any medals at sports day, nor are they by any means the most confident in their class.

This is all anecdata. But logically, I think if you accept it’s ok for there to be 11 months and 30 days between children in a year group, then I don’t see what difference a couple of months makes.

Tink1989 · 17/08/2022 11:07

If you didn't make decision for your daughter as you said then why are you moaning when someone else has for theirs, I would probably do the same

fyn · 17/08/2022 11:07

You absolutely don’t know the circumstances though. We are going to delay our June born child because my husbands posting will be up in either the November or December. We think it would be more beneficial for her to wait until the next year rather than start her at her first school then pull her out two months later. I genuinely couldn’t care less whether other parents would be upset that their child might be a year younger. We all do what is best for our children.

Swipe left for the next trending thread