Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if the second child is always worse?

87 replies

sevenoh · 17/08/2022 07:24

Morning all,

I currently have an 19 month old toddler and honestly he's been a dream baby - he's slept through the night from 12 weeks old, barely cried whilst teething, happy to entertain himself, he's actually still in bed now from half 7 last night (will probably wake up between 7.30-8) etc I mean now he's coming up to two he can throw a cracking tantrum but he's been a pretty easy baby and I know I'm very lucky.

However, when he turns 22 months old we'll be having a baby girl and the amount of people who describe the situation as "brave" is really making me nervous like I understand all babies are different but people are saying things like oh the second is always worse, she'll never sleep, she'll do this, that and the other and basically I'm giving birth to a tiny satan Grin (joking).

Although saying that with my first everyone said I'll never sleep again, I'll never get any free time etc you know all the horrifying things people say to new parents.

So I was just wondering is it really always the case that the second one is "worse" than the first one or is it just all babies are different no matter what order they are born in?

OP posts:
WhenDovesFly · 17/08/2022 08:20

Every child is different and has their own good and not-so-good points.

My first baby slept for England. I'd put her down for a nap and had to check she was still alive 3 hours later and rouse her. However, she was awful to feed. Wouldn't breastfeed and when I switched to bottles I was lucky to get 1-2oz at most down her at a time. Still picky eater now in her early 20s. She was painfully shy and introverted as a child up until she reached her late teens.

Second DD was a different story. Put her down for a nap and 2 minutes later - ping! Wide awake and ready to go! She went straight from crawling to climbing and I had to have eyes in the back of my head. DD2 was the opposite to DD1 with regard to feeding - I struggled to get her to stop breastfeeding, and she'll try anything food wise. Very loving, caring and outgoing.

I suppose I did find DD2 a little bit of a shock after DD1, as I'd had it so easy sleep wise, but I wouldn't classify either one as being better or worse than the other.

Amichelle84 · 17/08/2022 08:20

I really thought I would never be graced with 2 dream babies and that the 2nd would surely be a devil child but actually he's just as lovely.

mrsbitaly · 17/08/2022 08:17

It genuinely depends on each baby not which order. But in my case my second daughter was more confident strong willed and harder to manage than my first. I hate saying that as she's still only 2.5 years old and it's just a difficult age for them but she most certainly keeps us on our feet and can pull off the most amazing tantrums 🤣 Please don't let it put you off or make you worried they are all individual and I absolutely adore my firecracker

Ragged · 17/08/2022 08:17

2nd was my very best sleeper.
I found adusting to 1st the hardest, but none of mine were terrible sleepers themselves. Just me who doesn't sleep.

Matilda1981 · 17/08/2022 08:13

My first was horrific, second and absolute dream, third was easy too and the fourth was an arsehole!
BUT 1 and 4 were dream toddlers and 2 and 3 were pretty hardcore 🤣. Mine are all girls so can’t compare girls vs boys!

MsChatterbox · 17/08/2022 08:11

My second was easier but my first was mental

alrightfella · 17/08/2022 08:10

I'm sure second babies are usually better as you are more confident as parents. I was so much more relaxed about everything second time round and I didn't have all those fears in the early days about doing stuff wrong.

Second time round I found it easier to understand what ds needed, I also got into a routine better purely because life had to carry on as normal for 3yr old dd.

First time round I spent an awful lot of time in my pjs on the sofa. Second time round dd had to be at preschool, or tumble tots or we'd be meeting friends in the park so ds just came along too. Once DJ went back to work after two weeks, I just picked up dd's routine again just with a baby added in. He had reflux though which could be a bit stressful feeding when out! But you just get on with it and i always had a bag of spare clothes for all of us!

Yumyumgin · 17/08/2022 08:04

I speak for all 2nd born children, we are absolute delights 😁

Eixample · 17/08/2022 07:59

People just love to tarnish your joy any way they can. We have half your age gap but the second is easier simply because you know what you are doing and you avoid some of the sleep mistakes. The second has to be a little more free range because of your divided attention and that often helps too. My first was a fairly easy baby and my second was really a dream baby. Less compliant when older, though, that seems to be a second child thing.

sevenoh · 17/08/2022 07:59

Thank you for your replies for far everyone! Feeling a bit better haha

I agree that the comment about being brave is the age gap although I'm not too worried about it just because DS is quite independent and can feed and entertain himself. I'm also hoping because he's too young to understand I might avoid the sibling jealousy and he'll just accept the change and they'll be close and as they get older it'll be a bit easier as hopefully they'll like similar things in the sense of if we went to playgroup they'd both enjoy that etc

I've said to DH that I don't want to put labels on a tiny baby already (self fulfilling prophesy and all that) and that we'll just get what we're given and will have to deal with it in the best way we can.

I think with her being due in three months it's starting to feel very real and I panicked a little bit!

OP posts:
MrsToothyBitch · 17/08/2022 07:54

I think it depends on who you get tbh and it doesn't mean they'll stay that way. DP is the eldest and was apparently quite challenging in many ways until about 3.5 Then he completed all the surgery he needed on his eye and his poor, painful ears and became a much happier, better behaved child. His sister was DC2 and had no such drama; evidently slotted in nicely and was sunny natured as a baby and toddler. She now causes more chaos and problems than anyone. Similarly my dad is the older brother but my uncle was apparently comparably much more easy going from a very early age. I don't think my dad was a "difficult" baby but my uncle was just easier- and a more relaxed, personality in general too. As charming as my dad is, he has a more serious streak than my uncle did. Both turned out fine!

On the flipside, my ex's mum admitted that if she'd had her DS2 first, she might not have had more! She only has the 2. Her DS1 -my ex- had lulled her into a false sense of security by being a very mellow, easy baby. He has stayed that chilled to this day but both her boys are lovely!

Milkand2sugarsplease · 17/08/2022 07:50

First was a very "high needs" baby. Cried constantly for 18m, woke angry from every sleep he had, literally nothing pleased him.

Second time round - people said "you never get 2 the same"

They were right, he's even harder! Grin
I love him dearly but at 14m he's definitely still a glass half empty kinda kid!!

You get what you get and you get through - some days great, others you just get through and look forward to bed!! Good luck.

dandelionthistle · 17/08/2022 07:49

I hate the language of describing children as better/worse/dream/nightmare based on how inconvenient they are to us. </po-faced>

My gap is bigger, but my DC2 was much easier than my DC1 as a baby and toddler. Some of that was just temperament, some was me being more experienced and relaxed, some was that I just didn't have the headspace to overthink and so she just slotted in and we all benefited. I think that's a more typical story than not. But I have certainly known a few families with easy firstborns who were shocked by their more wakeful, grumpy or rambunctious second children!

My DC1 was a "high needs" baby and toddler but mellowed with age. DC2 was a cheerful and agreeable baby and toddler but is growing into her determination at 4 🤣 They're all different. I find having two generally easier than having one though, and I feel that our family is complete now and fits well together.

redskyatnight · 17/08/2022 07:45

I agree "brave" will be because of the small age gap.

My second child was like your current one, but my first child was a nightmare.

I also know a substantial number of people with hard work first children who never go on and have a second, so I guess statistically it's more likely that the second child will be worse than the first :)

Motherofalegend · 17/08/2022 07:45

We were told this too. However? It’s not the kids, it’s the circumstance. You’re bringing another dependent person into the family. Depending on age gap, you could be incredibly knackered and not have the same amount of time you did with the first.

my second pushes it as he watches his brother. Thinks he can do the same, despite the four year age gap!

1984Winston · 17/08/2022 07:44

My second was far easier than my first, they are individuals you just don't know what they are going to be like

MangoBiscuit · 17/08/2022 07:43

FWIW, I found the addition of DD2 a far easier transition than going from no DC to 1.

mumonthehill · 17/08/2022 07:43

first ds was a dream baby, slept and was so easy. He turned into a very difficult teenager and it has been tricky. Second ds was a nightmare at sleeping, did not sleep through until he was 5, however he had been a lovely, easy teenager. So you just never know!!

Notlosinganyweight · 17/08/2022 07:42

Notlosinganyweight · 17/08/2022 07:39

My second was far worse. He's reduced me to tears many times. Still a lovely boy in many ways, but strong willed, didn't sleep, had colic, tantrums are spectacular, didnt settle in any nursery unless it was one of those that throws the doors to the back garden open all day. He has been hard work. He has had hearing issues and he is always on the go and has very delayed speech too. I think he possibly has an intellectual disability too, but getting any kind of help confirming this is difficult. It's like it doesn't exist.

My first wasn't easy either and didn't sleep and has been fussy with food, but as long as his confidence grows he will be fine.

I'm terrified of my youngest starting school due to being so behind developmentally and he really isn't ready. I hope things change in the next year. The good things about him is you don't need to draw up a business proposal to get him to eat fruit and veg.

I must add to this though that my 2nd was my OHs 4th baby. So that says it all really. He does agree that he was the most difficult by a long way too though.

MangoBiscuit · 17/08/2022 07:41

My 2nd was far more laid back, still is in many ways. She had colic and silent reflux though, so until we got that sorted sleep was non-existant. They're differennt people, so were different babies. I think the only trend you can mostly rely on is that second babies startle less when toys go flying, or bigger kids run past. Just because they get used to being bumped/hugged/climbed over while in utero.

Throwawaytoday · 17/08/2022 07:40

DH and I call this Competitive Misery.

Parents of one child can't help but tell you how you'll ruin your life when your first is born.

Parents of two can't help but tell you how the second is so much worse.

Ignore.

RosiePosie80 · 17/08/2022 07:40

we had a similar age gap and my second baby was easier than my first in every way.

I think people just feel the need to say something- anything- even if it’s nonsense. I’ve never heard anyone say second babies are harder and it’s not my experience. I think it’s more common that the second baby is easier because they have to fit in with an established routine.

Notlosinganyweight · 17/08/2022 07:39

My second was far worse. He's reduced me to tears many times. Still a lovely boy in many ways, but strong willed, didn't sleep, had colic, tantrums are spectacular, didnt settle in any nursery unless it was one of those that throws the doors to the back garden open all day. He has been hard work. He has had hearing issues and he is always on the go and has very delayed speech too. I think he possibly has an intellectual disability too, but getting any kind of help confirming this is difficult. It's like it doesn't exist.

My first wasn't easy either and didn't sleep and has been fussy with food, but as long as his confidence grows he will be fine.

I'm terrified of my youngest starting school due to being so behind developmentally and he really isn't ready. I hope things change in the next year. The good things about him is you don't need to draw up a business proposal to get him to eat fruit and veg.

Vallmo47 · 17/08/2022 07:37

Unless the world is psychic, no they will have no idea what your second baby is like. In my personal experience? Yes. But I’ve never claimed that’s the case for everyone. It does make sense that it’s harder though - you have memories of a time your 100% focus could be on your baby. Now that’s not going to be possible this time around, you need to multitask. Your easy going first will likely get jealous and fight for the full time attention they used to get also.
I guess my point is that even if you have an easy going second baby, it will seem harder than first time because you are needed more.

I wouldn’t change anything and even the hard times pass. I love watching my two interact through the ages, it was worth it. Congrats and good luck!

ClingyClingy · 17/08/2022 07:37

25 months apart. First baby was also an easy baby and lovely toddler. Always slept, always eaten, plays on his own and although tantrums and gets upset, can navigate his way out of it with some help.

Baby 2 (now six months). Was an even calmer baby. Always smiling, rarely cries, happy to go with the flow. Sleeps well with one wake up-not as well as dc1 but still better than average.

Complete bollox that number 2 is the worst.