Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if the second child is always worse?

87 replies

sevenoh · 17/08/2022 07:24

Morning all,

I currently have an 19 month old toddler and honestly he's been a dream baby - he's slept through the night from 12 weeks old, barely cried whilst teething, happy to entertain himself, he's actually still in bed now from half 7 last night (will probably wake up between 7.30-8) etc I mean now he's coming up to two he can throw a cracking tantrum but he's been a pretty easy baby and I know I'm very lucky.

However, when he turns 22 months old we'll be having a baby girl and the amount of people who describe the situation as "brave" is really making me nervous like I understand all babies are different but people are saying things like oh the second is always worse, she'll never sleep, she'll do this, that and the other and basically I'm giving birth to a tiny satan Grin (joking).

Although saying that with my first everyone said I'll never sleep again, I'll never get any free time etc you know all the horrifying things people say to new parents.

So I was just wondering is it really always the case that the second one is "worse" than the first one or is it just all babies are different no matter what order they are born in?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ihatebojo · 17/08/2022 17:34

People are arses at times. I have no idea why they say such things.
I have 14 months between my DC1&2, and heard this a lot.

I heard similar with DC3&4, who are also very close in age. I had all 4 in 6 years.

ALL OF THEM WITHOUT FAIL WERE LOVELY BABIES.

I also get lots of comments when we are out about how lovely and polite they are, and the oldest is 13 now.

Enjoy your children! I loved having a little tribe and they are all good friends.

Ringmaster27 · 17/08/2022 16:50

@dandelionthistle I’d agree. I had 16 months between dcs 1&2, and found the first year with one toddler and one baby easier than the next few years of two toddlers 😳🤯

MrsTerryPratchett · 17/08/2022 15:05

Shock not chock!

MrsTerryPratchett · 17/08/2022 15:04

It's a very good example of a statistical concept known as reversion to the mean.

Most babies aren't perfect sleepers/'dream babies'. And since most aren't, your first is out of the average. Most of the time, most things are closer to the mean (average). So most people with dream babies will get a more typical baby next time. There's also the chance of getting a really poor sleeper. That means most of the people with a dream first baby will tell you second babies are dreadful because they got a shock.

Also an example of people attributing good to themselves and bad to chance. They BELIEVE their parenting caused the good sleep so the second who doesn't is a terrible chock (and there's clearly something wrong because they are so great!).

SuperCamp · 17/08/2022 14:58

Gilmorehill · 17/08/2022 11:33

I detest the way people find the need to make comments to expectant and new mothers. It’s like they want to undermine them or make them feel anxious. There are no rules to whether a first or second or third baby is easier or more difficult. However I felt more confident second time round, which helped a lot.

I know!

I don't know why loads of people are giving examples - as if such a ridiculous idea was credible. How on earth could it be true, scientifically? Half a second's thought reveals that anecdotally it is just nonsense.

BakewellGin1 · 17/08/2022 11:33

My first was colicky, never slept, screamed constantly... Slept through the night for the first time age 2.5. However he was well behaved, followed instructions and played nicely.

Second slept fabulously, was a perfect textbook baby... Now aged 3 is wild, opinionated, independent, daredevil.

Both are fun, loving and polite. But as far opposite extremes ha ha.

Gilmorehill · 17/08/2022 11:33

I detest the way people find the need to make comments to expectant and new mothers. It’s like they want to undermine them or make them feel anxious. There are no rules to whether a first or second or third baby is easier or more difficult. However I felt more confident second time round, which helped a lot.

SidSparrow · 17/08/2022 11:30

In some ways my 2nd was easier, and in other ways not so. The thing that made it difficult was going from one child to two! Holy moly, nothing could have prepared me for that. We were also a 22month age gap. Can't be that bad as we're now TTC no. 3 (or I am stark raving mad - v. possible)

But, I wouldn't change it for the world. My two are best buddies.

notanatural2018 · 17/08/2022 11:24

My second was way easier than my first. There's also the fact "you know what you're doing" with a second. And.... They're all different!

dottiedodah · 17/08/2022 11:07

My second was a really easy baby.The Midwife joked that he had "read all the books" as he fed and slept almost on the dot! Take no notice ,it really surprises me how many doom mongers there are saying shit like this .No idea why but it sucks!

RudsyFarmer · 17/08/2022 11:07

My second was and is a nightmare but I honestly don’t think that proves any theory. I’m trying to think of the families I know and I can’t think of any of them that have difficult second children.

mast0650 · 17/08/2022 11:07

Also, as others have said, babies just vary so if you had a particularly easy going one first time round then there is a high chance the next one will be harder work. Definitely don't count on your second baby being like the first.

SpringRainbow · 17/08/2022 11:06

My youngest is so much more chilled and easy going. Seriously, they just get on with things. They have their moments but for the most part it’s a breeze.

With my eldest, well, everything is just so “difficult”.

mast0650 · 17/08/2022 11:04

Our second baby was infinitely "easier" than our first i.e. self settled, slept through etc. If anything, I would said it was generally true that second babies are easier, though this is totally unscientific. If it is true, I imagine it is to do with parents being more confident second time round and not jumping at every sound or movement as they just don't have time. But of course two children is harder work than one, regardless of how easy they are.

Our age-gap was (unintentionally) 16-17 months. It was pretty full on but there are advantages too, especially as they get old. 22 month gap is not exceptionally small or "brave"!

cucumberegg · 17/08/2022 11:03

My first was like yours. Absolute dream. Life didn't change, she just fell in to place. Had a second with a 14 month age gap and it was the worst thing I've ever done. I'm out of the other side now but I was bordering suicidal it was so hard. Honestly it was horrendous. I can see how in the long run it will be amazing the close gap but fuck me those first 12 month were without any shadow of a doubt the worst 12 months of my life.

IcedOatLatte · 17/08/2022 10:59

The issue here appears to be with the people you know, why would having a second child be "brave" and why do they think that there's some kind of universal rule that applies to birth order?

Personally I'd be ignoring these people, they seem a little odd

At the risk of stating the obvious there's no way to predict what a baby will be like, me telling you that my 2nd child for example was no bother isn't going to have any affect on your 2nd child.

mindutopia · 17/08/2022 10:52

All babies are different. Sounds like you possibly had an easier one to start, so you may find the second one more challenging. I think it may also be the age gap people are responding to. 2 under 2 is tricky. I had 5 years between mine and even that had it's challenges, but I think was all around probably easier due to older one having more independence and the affordability of childcare.

I had a friend in my NCT group. Of the 5 of us, she was the only one with an 'easy' baby. The rest of us were completely on our knees and overwhelmed. And she just breezed on through, baby took a bottle of breast milk from her dh at 7pm, slept through, so she was well rested, and baby was super chill. She was very smug about it, telling everyone who would listen how she had her routine and she knew what she was doing and if everyone else would just do the same, we'd all have easy babies. She was the first of us to have a 2nd. Ran into her on a day out and she was completely frazzled and exhausted and overwhelmed. Turned out her 'routine' didn't work with the second one and she was struggling like we all did the first time around.

That said, my 2nd was much easier than my first. You also know what you're doing in a different sort of way.

GG1986 · 17/08/2022 10:52

My 1st was/is a nightmare, they are now 6! Due 2nd at the end of the year, so if they are worse then I am screwed!

SpiritedAway22 · 17/08/2022 10:47

My second was easier as a baby/toddler.

But oh my god, now they're older..... the tables have definitely switched! My eldest is a dream compared to my youngest. 😂

Podgedodge · 17/08/2022 10:46

My second was a better sleeper I think, if I can’t remember, she must have been ok! Neither were perfect, they were different from the womb, but having two close together is great fun, and I would be back there again in a heartbeat!

User8273738273737 · 17/08/2022 10:45

ClingyClingy · 17/08/2022 07:37

25 months apart. First baby was also an easy baby and lovely toddler. Always slept, always eaten, plays on his own and although tantrums and gets upset, can navigate his way out of it with some help.

Baby 2 (now six months). Was an even calmer baby. Always smiling, rarely cries, happy to go with the flow. Sleeps well with one wake up-not as well as dc1 but still better than average.

Complete bollox that number 2 is the worst.

@ClingyClingy what is your secret??
from someone who is 39+6 weeks pregnant 😂

JasperHale · 17/08/2022 10:42

My both were amazing sleepers, both easy as babies, DS quite energetic, DD (2nd) a dream to have. Calm, collected, just great. So no, second child is not always worse.

3amAndImStillAwake · 17/08/2022 10:19

DD2 is 3 months old and like a revelation compared to DD1. DD1 howled like a banshee the second she was put down for the first 6 months of her life. Having a baby I can put in a bouncer and chat away to while I cook dinner/have a quick tidy up/go for a wee/get dressed is magical in comparison.

MotherOfCrocodiles · 17/08/2022 10:18

Of course not but if your first was a dream baby, regression to the mean suggests your second won't be as good

BadGranny · 17/08/2022 10:07

I had 15 months between the first two.

You learn about parenting and get used to how to handle child 1. You learn what works and what doesn’t and because it’s the first one, that’s fixed in your mind as ‘the way to handle a baby’. Child 2 doesn’t behave or react the same as child 1, so when you use your experience of child 1 to deal with stuff, it doesn’t work. That may make it seem worse. You just need to remember that child 2 is a whole new person. You have to learn what works for child 2 the same way you did when you had child 1. Some things will be easier, some harder.

After the first few months, parenting child 2 is often easier because you are a more confident parent the second time around, so it’s all a bit less stressful. For example, if child 1 was even a bit off colour, I’d rush him to the GP. With child 2, it was more a case of ‘if he hasn’t got a temperature or rash, he’ll probably get over it’. With child 1, I was checking every milestone to make sure he was at least ‘average’, but with child 2, it was more like ‘if he’s not crawling yet, that’s a plus because I don’t have eyes in the back of my head’.

Swipe left for the next trending thread