Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To be a surrogate

137 replies

tobelrn · 16/08/2022 21:05

My DP and I have been together 2.5 years, my brother and his wife have been together for 11 years. For multiple reasons, they cannot have a baby naturally together.

Me and DP are very close, we always have been and I have a really lovely relationship with my sister in law.

I have always said from when they told me the news, I would be a surrogate if the time ever came. I have children from a previous relationship so I am aware what pregnancy/labour/post natal has in store. I am late 20s if it makes any difference.

Well it seems like the time is coming and we're starting to have more in depth conversations about it, and again, I have reassured them that it is absolutely something I will do if it's means they have a chance of having their own child together.

Well, DP is very unhappy about this. He thinks I'm being very selfish not taking his feelings into consideration. He thinks that while I'm pregnant, it have a massive impact on our lives.
He thinks he should get just as much say in the matter as I do, he thinks he needs to have a sit down with my brother and have "strong words" as to why it shouldn't happen and he will make it known that he does not support the idea.

I have told him he is being ludicrous, it is something I offered to them before we even knew full scale of their struggles and before I even knew DP.

DP and I both have children from previous relationships so can't possibly begin to understand the heartache DB and SIL have went through. The strain on my body being a surrogate would be no different from giving our children a sibling.

As for affecting our lives, due to us both working and having children, our lives won't be that much affected. He admitted himself that we have around 3 nights out a year and I'm really not a big drinker at all, especially compared to him, so I wouldn't miss this. And he could always have a night out with his friend group instead. My work wouldn't be that much affected either until the time of pregnancy when baby could come at any time. I also have a lovely employer who would be very accommodating to maternity leave and I would only need to take a couple of weeks after having the baby. I also have ample savings should things not quite go to plan so it's not as if I would be relying on him for financial help.

So, AIBU to go ahead and help my DB and SIL and to ignore his opinion or should I take the side of my DP and let down my brother?

OP posts:
GermanFrench22 · 16/08/2022 23:44

I think it's worth remembering that pre eclampsia is more common if the egg is not your own.

You might find the article below interesting. It's by a woman who was an altruistic surrogate for her brother.

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2013/apr/27/secret-diary-of-a-surrogate-mother

PurpleDaisies · 16/08/2022 23:44

The impact on a serious relationship is a totally valid reason to change her mind about the surrogacy offer.

PurpleDaisies · 16/08/2022 23:38

pumpkinpie01 · 16/08/2022 23:13

@CanIbeAlonepls you have literally put what I was going to. @tobelrn you must have had so many heartbreaking chats with your db and sil over the years regarding their infertility you can't let them down because your bf of 2 years doesn't like it . Not his body and tbh I don't like the fact he intends to speak to your brother about it - so out of order !

Of course the op can let them down. She can change her mind for any reason she chooses. Of course that could be devastating news but this absolutely isn’t a decision that can be set in stone years before without any further consideration.

KimberleyClark · 16/08/2022 23:31

Relationship, not marriage sorry.

KimberleyClark · 16/08/2022 23:30

The well-being of the children you chose to have should come before your brother.

And so should your marriage.

5zeds · 16/08/2022 23:30

It’s naive to believe every pregnancy is equal. Your body will be massively impacted as will your life for several years. I’m assuming you would attempt ivf. Would you risk multiples?

ChagSameachDoreen · 16/08/2022 23:30

Don't do it. You aren't rent-a-womb.

RampantIvy · 16/08/2022 23:16

Posters lining up on here to say 'what about your existing children' never do the same on 'should I have another baby' threads

Oh yes they do. I have seen this quoted on many of those threads.

pumpkinpie01 · 16/08/2022 23:13

@CanIbeAlonepls you have literally put what I was going to. @tobelrn you must have had so many heartbreaking chats with your db and sil over the years regarding their infertility you can't let them down because your bf of 2 years doesn't like it . Not his body and tbh I don't like the fact he intends to speak to your brother about it - so out of order !

Pallisers · 16/08/2022 23:10

shreddednips · 16/08/2022 22:53

It's up to you whether you want to be a surrogate for your DB. Your DP doesn't get a 'say' as it's not his body, but it would be perfectly reasonable for him to decide it was a dealbreaker. It's a major thing you're considering doing, and I think it will almost certainly have an impact on your relationship. In his shoes, I would be incredibly worried about the potential for things to go wrong/the distress you might experience when you had to hand the baby over and what the long-term impacts of that would be on your family unit.

I think he's going too far wanting to sit your brother down- he needs to accept that all he can do is decide his own boundaries, communicate them to you and then accept whatever your decision is. It sounds like his boundary is likely to be that he leaves if you go ahead, so I suppose all you can do is weigh up the importance of your relationship/family setup vs. being a surrogate for your brother.

Best of luck whatever you decide.

I think this is a great post.

I'm not a fan of surrogacy in general but feel less strongly about family surrogace but if you do this, please get some proper counselling/whatever before making the decision. Not "its a wonderful thing you are doing" counselling but a proper deep look at all the possible consequences - including the physical effects on you and the psycological effects on you and your children. I was a perfectly healthy woman in my late 20s and I came very very close to dying in childbirth. My recovery took at least 3 months. I knew a woman who died giving birth to her fourth child - every other delivery perfectly standard. it is rare but it is still in the risk profile. pregnancy and childbirth are not risk free. What happens if the baby has issues? Are you ok if they ask you to terminate? What if you want to terminate because circumstances drastically change - are they ok with that? What if the baby is born with significant issues? how will that affect your relationship. how will you explain it to your children. How will you feel if you end up with pre-eclampsia or incontinence or any of the other many things that are risks - no not definites - but still risks.

I don't think you and your brother and his wife sitting down and chatting will really get to all of the issues that might arise - you need someone with some expertise.

5zeds · 16/08/2022 22:56

How many children have you given birth to @tobelrn ?

Do you want children with your DP?

Does he?

Honestly I wouldn’t if your partner isn’t on board but I’d also be pissed off at the “having words” etc. is he normally like that or has this really joltedhim?

Bluebells12 · 16/08/2022 22:56

It’s a wonderful thing to do for someone.

I understand your DP’s concerns that it would affect his life, yes it would be a little inconvenient to him. He’s being startlingly selfish though, it’s a small inconvenience to him, but life changing for the parents-to-be.

My biggest concern is that your DP seems to think he gets a vote / a voice in the conversation with the parents-to-be. This is your decision. DP can tell you how he feels, and advise against it, but if you decide to do it he should try to help you in your choice, just as he should with any other choice you may make.

I bet it’s something stupid about him not wanting another man’s baby inside you 🙄

JubileeTrifle · 16/08/2022 22:55

I just wanted to say it also must be emotionally quite hard to watch your partner through pregnancy without their being a baby at the end for him as well.
My friend didn’t want more children necessarily, but the fact she had babies for other people was hard (they didn’t share children).

shreddednips · 16/08/2022 22:53

It's up to you whether you want to be a surrogate for your DB. Your DP doesn't get a 'say' as it's not his body, but it would be perfectly reasonable for him to decide it was a dealbreaker. It's a major thing you're considering doing, and I think it will almost certainly have an impact on your relationship. In his shoes, I would be incredibly worried about the potential for things to go wrong/the distress you might experience when you had to hand the baby over and what the long-term impacts of that would be on your family unit.

I think he's going too far wanting to sit your brother down- he needs to accept that all he can do is decide his own boundaries, communicate them to you and then accept whatever your decision is. It sounds like his boundary is likely to be that he leaves if you go ahead, so I suppose all you can do is weigh up the importance of your relationship/family setup vs. being a surrogate for your brother.

Best of luck whatever you decide.

CrossStichQueen · 16/08/2022 22:52

Of course many thanks.

ImaniMumsnet · 16/08/2022 22:52

HI @CrossStichQueen , happy to discuss the reasons for the deletions, please could you send us an email?

CrossStichQueen · 16/08/2022 22:50

How was it Polly?

PollyRockets · 16/08/2022 22:49

CrossStichQueen · 16/08/2022 22:48

I see my post has been deleted and I will be asking MNHQ how it broke guidelines given it was not abusive or a personal attack.

It was both.

CrossStichQueen · 16/08/2022 22:48

I see my post has been deleted and I will be asking MNHQ how it broke guidelines given it was not abusive or a personal attack.

iolaus · 16/08/2022 22:48

At the end of the day it's your body and you have the right to make the final decision

However I do think you are being naive over how much a surrogate pregnancy would impact on your partner as well

TheUsualChaos · 16/08/2022 22:46

Where has OP gone while everyone is busy arguing...

CanIbeAlonepls · 16/08/2022 22:45

Basically you can disagree with surrogacy in general (my personal opinion) whilst also disagreeing it's equally OPs partners decision.

PollyRockets · 16/08/2022 22:45

CrossStichQueen · 16/08/2022 22:40

She actually didn't ask for your opinion on surrogacy did she? And yet you couldn't wait to share it.
Generally to agree or disagree with the OP or her DP will mean you share their opinion so yes others will voice their own opinion in support of choosing either the OP or DPs side just as you and Polly have.

You feel the need to shut down any posters that don't agree with you it will be just you and your mate Polly on the thread soon.

There is a reason your first comment has been deleted on this thread.

CanIbeAlonepls · 16/08/2022 22:43

CrossStichQueen · 16/08/2022 22:40

She actually didn't ask for your opinion on surrogacy did she? And yet you couldn't wait to share it.
Generally to agree or disagree with the OP or her DP will mean you share their opinion so yes others will voice their own opinion in support of choosing either the OP or DPs side just as you and Polly have.

You feel the need to shut down any posters that don't agree with you it will be just you and your mate Polly on the thread soon.

You're entirely wrong about my opinion on surrogacy actually. But as I said in my first comment I have no intention on making it a point on this thread because it's not actually what OP asked is it? She's a big girl, she doesn't need you to tell her how selfish you think surrogacy is. She didn't ask you for your opinion on surrogacy and your comment didn't actually provide anything by way of meaningful advice about the actual situation she asked about. You just couldn't wait to make your stance on surrogacy known rather than respond to the actual question.

CanIbeAlonepls · 16/08/2022 22:41

JubileeTrifle · 16/08/2022 22:39

I do know someone who left his wife when she was a surrogate for the second time. The first time was already arranged when he had met her so it went ahead. the second time was for strangers so not the same. But he did say it broke the trust between them and he didn’t want to support another pregnancy for someone else.

And that's what the partner can do if this is a deal breaker for him. That's his rights in all of this. To leave if he doesn't like it and feels he can't support it. Not to dictate what OP does and intervene on her behalf as if she's incapable of making an informed decision about her own body and her own family.

Swipe left for the next trending thread