Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To be a surrogate

137 replies

tobelrn · 16/08/2022 21:05

My DP and I have been together 2.5 years, my brother and his wife have been together for 11 years. For multiple reasons, they cannot have a baby naturally together.

Me and DP are very close, we always have been and I have a really lovely relationship with my sister in law.

I have always said from when they told me the news, I would be a surrogate if the time ever came. I have children from a previous relationship so I am aware what pregnancy/labour/post natal has in store. I am late 20s if it makes any difference.

Well it seems like the time is coming and we're starting to have more in depth conversations about it, and again, I have reassured them that it is absolutely something I will do if it's means they have a chance of having their own child together.

Well, DP is very unhappy about this. He thinks I'm being very selfish not taking his feelings into consideration. He thinks that while I'm pregnant, it have a massive impact on our lives.
He thinks he should get just as much say in the matter as I do, he thinks he needs to have a sit down with my brother and have "strong words" as to why it shouldn't happen and he will make it known that he does not support the idea.

I have told him he is being ludicrous, it is something I offered to them before we even knew full scale of their struggles and before I even knew DP.

DP and I both have children from previous relationships so can't possibly begin to understand the heartache DB and SIL have went through. The strain on my body being a surrogate would be no different from giving our children a sibling.

As for affecting our lives, due to us both working and having children, our lives won't be that much affected. He admitted himself that we have around 3 nights out a year and I'm really not a big drinker at all, especially compared to him, so I wouldn't miss this. And he could always have a night out with his friend group instead. My work wouldn't be that much affected either until the time of pregnancy when baby could come at any time. I also have a lovely employer who would be very accommodating to maternity leave and I would only need to take a couple of weeks after having the baby. I also have ample savings should things not quite go to plan so it's not as if I would be relying on him for financial help.

So, AIBU to go ahead and help my DB and SIL and to ignore his opinion or should I take the side of my DP and let down my brother?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 17/08/2022 23:11

This excerpt from @CliantheLang li k sums up why all surrogacy should be banned:

”The potential for abuse is too great. Women should not be encouraged to endanger their emotional and physical health and safety for other people’s ‘need’ to have babies. Women matter. Women should not be encouraged to put ourselves second, and to risk our lives for other people.”

RedToothBrush · 17/08/2022 16:31

PollyRockets · 16/08/2022 22:01

Posters on here are so disingenuous

If they cared about existing children the posts asking whether people should have a second/third/fourth child would be full of the same types of reply, but they never are

Posters need to accept they have an issue with surrogacy and stop hiding behind the very weak 'but what if you have complications'

The same could be said for anyone having additional children - but it never is.

Except surrogate pregnancies are higher risk. And thats relevant.

What happens if the OP is disables or dies? If in a relationship, when you agree to get pregnant there is a natural person to pick up the pieces.

In this situation its less clear. Say the OP was unable to work, then who covers the financial hardship? The partner living with her or the brother?

Its one thing to lose a mother having a sibling. Its a bit different to lose one to an uncle. And then them maybe ending up taking custody of the OPs children.

Its very much more complex.

MrsTerryPratchett · 17/08/2022 14:55

PurpleDaisies · 17/08/2022 08:58

What do you think of all the replies @tobelrn ?

I think I know. One post on a very very contentious topic? Not come back?

CliantheLang · 17/08/2022 13:55

PollyRockets · 16/08/2022 21:47

Be wary OP, AIBU is very anti surrogacy so it will colour posters views on this unfortunately

Gee, I can't imagine why...

I'll just leave this here: nordicmodelnow.org/2020/01/29/i-was-an-altruistic-surrogate-and-am-now-against-all-surrogacy/

RampantIvy · 17/08/2022 13:51

I guess he could say "it's your body, and you can do what you like with it, but don't expect me to support you"

Bubbleapop · 17/08/2022 13:40

takealettermsjones · 17/08/2022 13:22

I get where you're coming from. I'm not saying it's equally his say, just that I'm shocked at people saying he gets no say at all. If it were me, I'd want to know what my partner thought, because I love and care about him. If I made a decision that I knew would hurt him, that would be a problem for me. So I don't think it should be as simple as "I do what I want, and you can decide whether to leave me or not".

Re. having words with the brother, I completely agree it's not the best idea, I'm just saying that I think I can see how it could have happened - if he feels that his concerns are not being listened to.

I do get what you're saying but realistically he doesn't get a say. It's her body. He doesn't have a say over what she does with it. Of course that may mean OP needs to decide whether she wants to prioritise her partner or her brother and SIL but no, he doesn't get a say over her doing this or not.

As you say, in a relationship I'd expect to listen to my partner's concerns about something like this and discuss them with him but ultimately he wouldn't have a say over whether I went ahead or not because we're talking about my own body. You can't get more personal that that really.

I could tell my husband I was going to get a skull tattooed on my face tomorrow and I'm sure he'd have oppositions! But he wouldn't get to have a SAY over whether I do it or not. He'd voice his objections I'm sure but ultimately the say is mine not his because it's my face. Now that could lead to the end of my marriage, which is possibly what the OP may have to deal with but it's still my say not his.

Crayfishforyou · 17/08/2022 13:33

What are his fears exactly? Is he unhappy about picking up some slack whilst you are pregnant? Something going wrong? Health reasons?
The truth is it, would impact on your lives together for a while so he would have to be on board. If his reasoning against it is from a selfish ‘I want my life as it is’ standpoint, I would tell him to feck off.
I have a friend who did three surrogacies for people. I think she is a very strong, caring, magical person and I am in awe of her.
It took her longer than a couple of weeks to recover afterwards though, don’t sugarcoat recovery because you want to do this, think realistically about all the things that could happen

picklemewalnuts · 17/08/2022 13:24

I'm generally anti surrogacy- it's usually an abuse of power, involving a sense of entitlement over another woman's body.

However in this case, you sound really close to the couple.

There are a few things to consider, some of which your DP *should be part of:
What will the ongoing relationship with the baby and your family be?
What if you become ill or are injured- how your earnings, your children will be impacted.
Do you and the parents agree with how you live during the pregnancy- will they be policing the brie!

Some of this your DP is involved in, some of it he may feel protective of you about.

However what you've said sounds more like he feels his assest (your body) is being loaned out without his agreement, and that sense of ownership is not acceptable in a relationship. I'd end it on that basis.

takealettermsjones · 17/08/2022 13:22

Bubbleapop · 17/08/2022 13:10

Of course he can have an opinion like anyone here can too. But it's not equally his say when we're talking about someone else's body. Ultimately the decision is OPs and the decision he has the right to make is whether to stay or not.

I don't think he has any right to have strong words with her brother. That just feels like infantilising OP as if she can't make the "right" decision for herself so he needs to step in. It's OPs body and OPs brother.

I get where you're coming from. I'm not saying it's equally his say, just that I'm shocked at people saying he gets no say at all. If it were me, I'd want to know what my partner thought, because I love and care about him. If I made a decision that I knew would hurt him, that would be a problem for me. So I don't think it should be as simple as "I do what I want, and you can decide whether to leave me or not".

Re. having words with the brother, I completely agree it's not the best idea, I'm just saying that I think I can see how it could have happened - if he feels that his concerns are not being listened to.

Bubbleapop · 17/08/2022 13:10

takealettermsjones · 17/08/2022 12:55

I'm also baffled by people saying the DP doesn't get a say. It affects him, their life, and their existing children. I'm not saying his opinion is more important than OP's in any way, but he is entitled to have one.

Don't know whether this is the case, but I could imagine the suggestion of talking to the DB coming from a feeling of panic that he's not having his concerns heard.

Of course he can have an opinion like anyone here can too. But it's not equally his say when we're talking about someone else's body. Ultimately the decision is OPs and the decision he has the right to make is whether to stay or not.

I don't think he has any right to have strong words with her brother. That just feels like infantilising OP as if she can't make the "right" decision for herself so he needs to step in. It's OPs body and OPs brother.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 17/08/2022 13:10

I'm a little unclear on what he thinks the negative impact "on your lives" would be. If it's just inconvenience, not being able to drink, him having to pull his weight a bit more for 9 months I would consider my future with him regardless, as that sounds pretty selfish.

If he has genuine worries about your health/ wellbeing it's maybe different.

Anothernamechangeplease · 17/08/2022 13:07

He doesn't have the right to dictate what you should do with your own body, nor does he have the right to interfere in your relationships with your wider family.

He does have the right to decide that he doesn't want to stay with a partner who chooses to act as a surrogate. It might turn out to be a dealbreaker for him, and that's fair enough. You can't dictate how he should feel about your choices.

What it comes down to, ultimately, is which relationship you want to prioritise. If it comes to it, are you prepared to sacrifice the relationship that you have with your DP in order to help your brother and SIL? There is no right or wrong answer here - only what is right or wrong for you personally.

LookingOverHereAllNight · 17/08/2022 13:02

I think your partner does get a say if you see a future with him. It will affect him too. You don’t know how the pregnancy will go of how you will feel giving away the child. It’s also dreadfully unfair to create a baby that’s intended to be taken from their mum and you are their mum, the one that carried them. It’s never in the best interests of the child, only adults, but no one has a right to have a child. You may think it’s kind but I don’t think it is.

Revolvingwhore · 17/08/2022 12:59

PollyRockets · 16/08/2022 21:45

Your body your choice

Tell your 'D'P to keep his nose out

I couldn't be with someone as opinionated on something like this

Who does he think he is wanting to confront your brother about it

That's just callous, when there are other people massively affected. A stupid and ignorant comment - do you have people you can about, or are is it just 'fuck them' when you decide stuff?

takealettermsjones · 17/08/2022 12:55

I'm also baffled by people saying the DP doesn't get a say. It affects him, their life, and their existing children. I'm not saying his opinion is more important than OP's in any way, but he is entitled to have one.

Don't know whether this is the case, but I could imagine the suggestion of talking to the DB coming from a feeling of panic that he's not having his concerns heard.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 17/08/2022 12:44

doodlywoodlydingdong · 17/08/2022 11:55

Why would you intentionally create a baby, only to remove it from the only mother it knows as soon as it's born? It doesn't care about biology, to that baby the woman that carried it is is mother... it recognises her voice, taste, smell, heartbeat and that baby only wants HER. Surrogacy is people trafficking. I don't care if it's voluntary, paid etc. you don't get to just " give away" people Willy nilly. It's just horrendous.

This sums up so well exactly why I’m anti-surrogacy. It’s all about the bio parents and no one ever considers the impact on the baby. Separation anxiety may not be obvious in new norms but it’s very real and that baby is very much expecting the person who carried them to be their mother.

I have researched this topic excessively and I only know of ONE family who got it ‘right’. My friend was a surrogate for her sister. They all had a really healthy attitude towards it whereby my friend was centered, and then both her and the baby when he was born. My friend went to antenatal appointments alone, made decisions about the birth alone, her sister and BIL were not at the birth (my friend had her wife with her), they called them afterwards and they came at visiting time. Then my friend breastfeed and stayed in their home for about 2 months so they could gradually transition the baby to his bio parents and also onto formula. A very slow, steady process and now she’s a doting Aunty and they have told the little boy (IIRC he’s 6 now) all about it from the off. When she lived with them they gave her space and respect and topped her wages up as she took 3 month maternity leave etc. it’s basically the best way to do surrogacy - but I bet similar stories are negligible

BloodAndFire · 17/08/2022 12:31

RampantIvy · 16/08/2022 23:16

Posters lining up on here to say 'what about your existing children' never do the same on 'should I have another baby' threads

Oh yes they do. I have seen this quoted on many of those threads.

I was going to say the same thing. Not only have I seen it said on here, but many of my friends in real life have mentioned it as a reason for not trying for further children. It's also a significant reason that I chose not to 'roll the dice again' - because I wouldn't want to risk my existing children being left without a mother (or a mother who was severely disabled).

Eskarina1 · 17/08/2022 12:12

I would say you're not being unreasonable but as with any choice he gets to decide whether he wants to be around for it.

However, him wanting a "strong word " with your brother is a massive overstep.

This is a discussion about your body and what you do with it. He can have an opinion within the relationship but he has zero right to impose it or to strong arm other people.

doodlywoodlydingdong · 17/08/2022 11:55

Why would you intentionally create a baby, only to remove it from the only mother it knows as soon as it's born? It doesn't care about biology, to that baby the woman that carried it is is mother... it recognises her voice, taste, smell, heartbeat and that baby only wants HER. Surrogacy is people trafficking. I don't care if it's voluntary, paid etc. you don't get to just " give away" people Willy nilly. It's just horrendous.

Quincythequince · 17/08/2022 11:50

I think it’s absolutely crazy that you think your partner shouldn’t have an opinion here.

If you’re adamant that you’re going to do it, that’s up to you. But he has every right to comment on it- this will affect his life too.

So generous, and yet actually quite selfish at the same time.

PollyRockets · 17/08/2022 11:30

GermanFrench22 · 16/08/2022 23:44

I think it's worth remembering that pre eclampsia is more common if the egg is not your own.

You might find the article below interesting. It's by a woman who was an altruistic surrogate for her brother.

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2013/apr/27/secret-diary-of-a-surrogate-mother

The risks associated with donor eggs are conflated with the fact most recipients of donor eggs are older women

The studies into this done mitigate for age unfortunately

Teder · 17/08/2022 10:50

Nobody has a right to decide what you do with your body, not your partner nor your brother. You are entitled to change your mind and you are equally entitled to go ahead.

Your partner’s attitude is controlling. However, I do think you are being naive in not acknowledging the huge impact this will have on your family. I am not saying don’t go ahead but do consider it and then you can look for ways to
mitigate it. 🙂

As a side note, there is no way you should need to resort to using your savings. Your brother should be ensuring your financial security, for
example if you had a life changing pregnancy or birth complication that means your capacity to work is reduced.

PurpleDaisies · 17/08/2022 08:58

What do you think of all the replies @tobelrn ?

3amAndImStillAwake · 17/08/2022 07:25

Your DP is reasonable to have an opinion, and is reasonable to say it will affect him - of course it will. He would also be reasonable to end the relationship, in the sense that anyone can end a relationship whenever they want. He's massively unreasonable to say he is going to sit down with your brother (so the two men can sort it out between themselves and let you know what they decide??), and to say he has equal say in the decision. But it's a big thing, it's not realistic to expect him to not have any opinion on it.

The other thing in your post which stood out to me was you saying you have your own savings to use if necessary. If it were me, I'd expect my brother to cover reasonable costs - maternity clothes, lost earnings for sickness and maternity leave etc.

PainPainGoAwayToday · 17/08/2022 00:34

Of course your DP doesn’t get a say in what you do with your body. But I think you’re being very naive to think a pregnancy won’t impact him at all. You’ll be growing and carrying a whole person. You’ll be tired, grumpy and possibly sick for months. Then that’ll improve (hopefully!) just in time for you to get massive and not be able to do many of the things you normally can. Your sleep will be affected. Your sex life will be affected. Your ability to look after your own kids and house will be limited. Of course people do it, all the time, sometimes alone, but if you have a DP (do you live together?), they’d usually pick up at least some of the chores to help you out. If he didn’t, he would be a massive arsehole. If he did- he’s being affected. It’ll affect the things you can and things you want to do. You could be too tired for dates, too sick for meals, too big for long walks. Then the birth comes and he has to know you’re going through all that and he isn’t there. You could have hospital stays, stitches, bleeding, prolapses. Birth can take months to recover from. There’s no sex for 6 weeks (and that’s if it all goes well!) and afterwards your body is changed forever. Not his body, not his choice, but he’s allowed to be against it. He’s allowed his opinion and he’s allowed to leave before during or after the pregnancy if he doesn’t like what’s happening. He could walk away at any time and I'm not sure many people would blame him.

His ex may have been a nightmare when pregnant. Had PND. Struggled after the births. Been on bedrest. Maybe he can’t face it again. Or maybe he could if it was your baby (his and yours) but he can’t face it all again for someone else.

Of course none of that matters as it is your body and 100% your choice but it’s silly to say your pregnancy won’t affect your partner, because it will, in so many ways. Make your own choice but it’s likely to be choosing between being a surrogate or having your partner… x