Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To move us all in with my mum?

132 replies

DoingJustFine · 16/08/2022 16:31

My lovely dad recently died, very unexpectedly. Mum (83, frail, forgetful) is now living alone in the huge family house.

I live literally round the corner with DH, and my two teenagers. I bought our house but we have horrible neighbours and I've wanted to move for a while. We couldn't afford it as DH is still on the mortgage with his ex and we'd have to pay loads of stamp duty. He's in the process of sorting this out but it's glacial.

I think the sensible thing is us to move in with my mum. She'd love it. I'd love it. She'll be safe, I can run the house and take care of everything.

DH isn't keen as my mum smokes and the house smells like cigarettes.

My sibling (lives miles away, very rich) isn't keen as I suspect they'd prefer the family house to be sold and the money split between us all.

Our Dad's ashes are going to be sprinkled in the garden (as he requested) so I hate the thought of another family trampling all over him.

AIBU to just move us in? Even until DH has sorted his mortgage issue, or mum needs a care home?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LadyLapsang · 23/08/2022 19:29

@Rachie1973 I would imagine they established the trust to avoid paying excess inheritance tax, but the tax situation has changed over the years. If OP’s mum needs care and the house belongs to her it would have to be used to pay some or all of her care, if needed. Placing it in a trust may mean they succeed in protecting it from sale to pay for care and minimise tax although I would expect the situation would be scrutinised.

MnPrem · 19/08/2022 16:06

That’s a much better idea, she can burn you all to death! And your DH can live in nicotine stained fug beforehand. Lovely. Lucky old him! Aren’t you the star life partner.

toomuchlaundry · 19/08/2022 09:18

Retirement flats are usually still for people who can live independently. They may have a warden but some only work normal office hours during the week and don’t live in. You then have emergency call buttons for the rest of the time. So if your mum is getting very frail you might need to find a complex that offers more help

Rachie1973 · 19/08/2022 09:05

As an aside I’d be furious if my DH tied OUR property into trusts etc that removed all of my choices! As his ŵife I expect to inherit my home cleanly and vice versa!

djdkdkddkek · 19/08/2022 08:52

DoingJustFine · 18/08/2022 17:42

It’s also all about how her husband hates smoking but no word on whether her mun Would even want to quit

Thanks for your post, which I think I deciphered correctly.

No, mum would never quit smoking. But while I was there today I found EIGHT cigarette burns on the sofa blanket, plus six more on the carpet. I can't tell how old they are, but she hasn't had the blanket that long.

I've banned her from putting the ash tray on the sofa, for fear she's going to set herself on fire. It's terrifying.

But I'd better not move in and look after her, or anything, as you've all told me. Far better I let her burn to death.

Ah give over

its more that you’ve decided that your husbands aversion to smoking is the only inconvenience in this situation

CookieSue222 · 18/08/2022 18:28

I cannot comment on the rights and wrongs of house swaps and smoking issues.
What I do understand is that you are in an awful situation, caught between your Mum and your family.
Having been in a similar position myself I can only offer you my sympathy. No one can understand your situation unless they have been there (been there twice). I hope you are able to sort things out. 💐

Mischance · 18/08/2022 18:26

Three reasons not to do it:


  1. OH does not want to - are you planning to leave him behind?

  2. You are taking your family into a smoker's house - are you aware of the risks of passive smoking?

  3. You will lack security - as soon as your Mum dies you will be under pressure to move out so the profits can be split.

DDivaStar · 18/08/2022 18:21

DoingJustFine · 18/08/2022 17:42

It’s also all about how her husband hates smoking but no word on whether her mun Would even want to quit

Thanks for your post, which I think I deciphered correctly.

No, mum would never quit smoking. But while I was there today I found EIGHT cigarette burns on the sofa blanket, plus six more on the carpet. I can't tell how old they are, but she hasn't had the blanket that long.

I've banned her from putting the ash tray on the sofa, for fear she's going to set herself on fire. It's terrifying.

But I'd better not move in and look after her, or anything, as you've all told me. Far better I let her burn to death.

Even moving in wouldn't stop the burn issue you can't be watching her every minute. Moving in would put you and your family at greater risk of passive smoking and potentially being in a house fire.

Have you checked her fire alarms lately?

DDivaStar · 18/08/2022 18:16

I was with you until you said she smokes. No wag would I, my H or my daughter be living with a smoker.

Yogagirl72 · 18/08/2022 18:16

I couldn’t live with a smoker. I also could not live with my MIL.

AhNowTed · 18/08/2022 18:14

"Mum actually fancies a warden-controlled flat."

There's your answer right there.

everywoman682 · 18/08/2022 18:09

Better she sells her huge house and moves into some sort of warden-assisted, sheltered accommodation, as she's said she's happy to do.

I think it's entirely unreasonable to expect the rest of your family to live in a house where the owner is smoking (a lot, it sounds like!) in every room. I wouldn't be able to put up with it: I don't blame your dh from feeling exactly the same. It could also put your family at risk too if she's this dangerous with discarded fags and ash. It's not like you can be there 24/7 - as you say, you have your own career and other stuff to get on with

DoingJustFine · 18/08/2022 17:42

It’s also all about how her husband hates smoking but no word on whether her mun Would even want to quit

Thanks for your post, which I think I deciphered correctly.

No, mum would never quit smoking. But while I was there today I found EIGHT cigarette burns on the sofa blanket, plus six more on the carpet. I can't tell how old they are, but she hasn't had the blanket that long.

I've banned her from putting the ash tray on the sofa, for fear she's going to set herself on fire. It's terrifying.

But I'd better not move in and look after her, or anything, as you've all told me. Far better I let her burn to death.

OP posts:
DoingJustFine · 18/08/2022 17:38

For now I think your idea to work from your mum’s is a really good one

Thank you! It's taking up all my time otherwise. I've been found to mum's every day this week and my own life is falling behind a bit. It's hard fitting in mum, my kids, DH, then my own career, friends, interests...

I really miss Dad. He was amazing.

Thank you all again!

OP posts:
NiqueNique · 17/08/2022 18:38

First of all, I’m sorry you’ve lost your dad. Flowers And I don’t think you sound grabby, I understand that you’re the one who’s tasked with support/organisation/admin/help for your mum now that your dad isn’t here.

For now I think your idea to work from your mum’s is a really good one - you can be there daily to keep her company and help her adjust, make sure she has a good meal, get her set for the evening and then go home and see your husband and children. You’ll be able to keep an eye on how she’s getting on without it becoming another daily event/chore/demand on your time, your mind will be at ease, and you’ll not feel always on edge worrying about her. Maybe make a rule that you’ll be at home with your family at weekends, though - just to keep things from tipping too much.

djdkdkddkek · 17/08/2022 18:12

doilookremotelyinterested · 16/08/2022 17:11

What's horrible about it? The sister will (assuming the will splits it 50-50) be entitled to half but OP is aiming to move in and make it home because she doesn't like where she's living now. I can't see her agreeing to a quick sale as she'll want to stay there. From the sister's point of view that's grabby however you want to look at it.

It’s also all about how her husband hates smoking but no word on whether her mun Would even want to quit or live with someone who will judge her for smoking

yes smoking isn’t great, but she’s elderly, quite frail from all accounts and has people trying to move into her “mansion” so to be scolded for smoking seems really… ugh

AhNowTed · 17/08/2022 13:46

@everywoman682 good post.

And as an aside, I'm a smoker. Outside only. Even I couldn't tolerate smoking in the house.

everywoman682 · 17/08/2022 13:06

I'm sorry you're feeling so low. Hats off to you as well for not taking offence and appreciating how the situation looks from other perspectives.

The main issue here is that you're unhappy with your own living situation- so try to separate that from your mother's. You have bad neighbours and your dh is still disentangling himself from the financial situation with his ex. Both of which I can see are stresses- particularly the bad neighbour as there's no switching off from that.

But like others have said, you'd only be exchanging one difficult situation for another! At some point you would need to move out of your mother's house and if you've spent money on redecorating then that'll be even harder. It sounds like your mother is quite up for downsizing, going to a warden assisted place or similar so let her do that. I wouldn't step out of the housing market because in the longer term property is always the best investment. It just looked like as a 'quick fix' you could be tempted to all move into your mothers and then you'd have the issue of smoking - and don't underestimate that, I absolutely could not live in a house where someone smokes in every room. I think it could also feel difficult for your dh living in a house where essentially you have no say- because at the end of the day, it's your mothers name on the deeds, not yours. Then at some point, possibly years down the line, you'd be in the position of having to sell anyway, as your sister would be entitled to half the estate.

When the chips are down its always tempting to find a swift 'escape route' but this really isn't the answer. I would be looking to move house yourselves into your own space where you have control.

DoingJustFine · 17/08/2022 12:47

Sorry, that ended a bit bleakly!

We won't make any decisions till we've had the will deciphered, and taken mum to look at some different options (flats, retirement villages, etc) so she can make a more informed choice.

Thank you all again.

OP posts:
DoingJustFine · 17/08/2022 12:38

Thank you all again for all your posts. Even reading the ones saying I sound grabby is useful, as it helps me see what I look like to my sibling (and forces me to do some soul searching).

It's not a mansion - just a big family house.

I really am all over the place st the moment. I don't know what to do. I just went to the hairdresser and cried while they washed my hair! It's all crap.

OP posts:
Harridan1981 · 17/08/2022 10:07

I don't think you sound at all grabby. You sound like you are grieving and worried and a bit lost.

Take some time. Work from there during the day to see your mum and help her settle. Get the will and probate sorted and take it from there.

DivaBeliever · 17/08/2022 09:35

What a difficult situation. It's clear you're concerned about your Mum and frustrated by your own living situation so moving in seems an obvious solution - apart from the smoking !!

But you really need to clarify the terms of the trust, as you may not have the options you are contemplating. One common scenario - although I stress, it may not be the terms of yours - is that the house is held in trust, giving your mother a life time interest, but on her passing, it passes to the children, and the trustees (which will have been appointed by your Dad) are responsible for sorting out what happens, which will have been outlined in the terms of the trust.

A solicitor, who deals with trusts, will be able to explain the terms of your trust to you. I would prioritise this before exhausting yourself contemplating possible scenarios.

Blowthemandown · 17/08/2022 09:20

@DoingJustFine probate is not usually difficult. I did it for DH when MIL died. It’s detailed but not rocket science. So you could make that happen more quickly maybe. Smoking would be a no for me. But more important, whether relatives do nothing care-wise or not, it would be better to sell up and divide the proceeds etc. I think the issues with your DH not resolving things so you can move are what really needs sorting so you can move regardless of what happens with your Mum. Otherwise it’s almost enabling him not to sort things, if you provide some way round it. But I don’t think moving in with your Mum is the answer.

everywoman682 · 17/08/2022 09:16

Agree with pp, this sounds very much like you're wanting to get your hands on your mother's property, and dressing it up as a 'convenience' for everyone.

Your dh understandably doesn't want to live in a smoke filled house. It would be entirely unreasonable to expect him to live somewhere he's unhappy.

Your mother is keen to live in a warden-assisted, sheltered type of property so best thing would be for her to sell up and do that. The 'mansion' she's rolling around in is hers, not yours, so that's the obvious thing to do.

Your sibling can't help the fact she lives a hundred or more miles away. Sounds like you hold it against her simply because you stayed on the doorstep of your parents.

Your motivation for moving seems to be that you've got bad neighbours. I get that that can be stressful, but that's a separate issue from your mum, so don't use that as a convenient excuse to move your family somewhere your dh isn't happy with.

Finally although I can see this seems like the solution for you at the moment, it'll come back to bite you because you'll step out of the property market which is always a bad idea. Even though house prices are levelling off and may even drop a bit, property is always a good long term investment and it won't do you any favours. Particularly if you end up spending out on a property which isn't yours, decorating etc

That's the bottom line: the house belongs to your mother. When she passes, it will be part of her estate. It's not yours.

LadyLapsang · 17/08/2022 09:11

I know of two families where the elderly surviving spouse moved in with their daughter and family post bereavement. Both were frail and not expected to live many years. They gained a new lease of life and lived until their mid 90s and over 100 respectively - over two decades of increasing caring although neither had dementia and both were relatively fit for their age when they had the care and support they needed. In both cases there was only a tiny property and no real wealth to argue over and the elderly person moved into the large family home of the daughter. The thing that struck me is your use of bold in the opening text of huge in relation to your mother’s home.

Have you thought about what would happen if you all moved in, then your mum decided she was happy with the set up and didn’t want to go into sheltered accommodation or a care home? What if she then broke her hip, had a stroke or developed dementia? It is hard enough getting care for your parents when they live alone, you try getting care from the NHS if the person lives with a household of adults. What would happen to your mum if you became disabled or predeceased her - would your DH step up as carer? All these issues are before you throw the trust in the mix, not to mention your sibling. If this is about you genuinely wanting to care for your mum, then maybe buy a bigger house and she can move in and pay a small amount towards an annex, with the rest of her wealth protected for her ongoing care and for your sibling in the trust.

Swipe left for the next trending thread