Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask my kids to watch my toddler in the garden coke 10 minutes

156 replies

sadandlonely2022 · 16/08/2022 14:09

So I asked me 15 and 16 year old daughters to watch my 3 year old in the back garden whilst I sort lunch and the 15 what old trashed the living room because she said 'why me' and started whining at the fact I asked her to do something, i took the iPad away and she kicked off trashing the living room. Then I asked my 16 year old she pulls her face and said she's 'getting dressed even though she was already decently dressed ' half an hour later o just go tell her to forget it coz she's obv won't help, she went mad because apparently she's 'getting dressed'
All I asked for was 10 minutes help
My older kids never get dressed to go out and that means me and my toddler and 6 year old son are stuck in all day coz my 10 years old can't be arsed either. I'm sick of it I can't just walk pit and leave the 10 year old alone at home to go out.

They said 'it's my child' so why should they help, whilst I have to clean wash clothes and make meal all day like a slave and get nothing back

Feel like walking away my life is awful and pointless and I am actually start to regret having kids

OP posts:
ohisay · 16/08/2022 16:07

The fact that 'can you keep an eye on 3yo for me while I make us all lunch' turned in to a room trashing shouting match says there is way more going on!
No, they don't have to look after their sibling, they don't have to do anything.
But respectful, polite children don't destroy rooms because they've been asked for a few minutes of their time.
As others have said, a family is a team!
Reading replies, it seems like there's no middle ground - children should either do absolutely NOTHING in the family home and be treated like hotel guests or should lose everything they posess because none of it is theirs anyway.
There most definitely is a middle ground, and at a calm point in the house, I think you need to find it- as a family!

SaltySeaWitch · 16/08/2022 16:06

Oh god I get how draining and exhausting kids can be. I’ve been at the end of my tether more than once today with my two (toddlers) so I’d imagine more, with a spread of ages, is even worse!

Whilst the teens have been unhelpful and disrespectful, is there a reason you can’t just bung 3yo in front of paw patrol for 20 mins to make lunch? Or give him some chalk to doodle by the back door?

Teens ought to be doing their own lunches/laundry etc. so knock that on the head if they can’t be bothered to help you out!

With the 10yo, assuming neurotypical, I probably would just leave them at home and pop to the park for an hour or so. They’ll soon learn that they miss out.

Hopeandlove · 16/08/2022 16:05

Take their phones and tablets and an electronic devices and lock them in the boot of your car. Change the internet password immediately and Netflix Disney etc

dont they ducking dare speak to their mother. It’s their home and a 15 year old is capable of looking after a 3 year old for an hour never mind ten minutes. I’d be bloody calling my best friend for reinforcements and laying down the law. Trashing stuff they can bloody clear it up and that’s not punishment that’s just putting it back.

jobs every morning and if they don’t like it they can piss off to their fathers

mam0918 · 16/08/2022 16:05

user478965227857 · 16/08/2022 15:57

They don't have to.

Their sibling isn't their responsibility.

sitting with my grandfather and helping him drink when thirsty etc... after his stroke wasnt my 'responsability' but I did it without question.

Sitting with my grandma when she got dementia and couldnt be left alone wasn't my 'responsability' but I did it without question.

Its what decent families do for each other, honestly I dispair for some people being so heartless to their loved ones no wonder the worlds gone to shit with 'main character' entitlement being so rife.

Dweetfidilove · 16/08/2022 16:04

Watching your sibling for ten minutes is not childcare; it's being a useful, helpful member of a household!

I don't know how you got here, but Lord only knows what I'd do with a child who trashed my house.

Keep the devices - no point giving them back now to avoid further resistance. Going forward, only do as much as is required to keep them alive. They will figure the rest out and hopefully learn to be less selfish and horrible in the process.

Stand up for yourself or they're going to make you regret everything.

Eon · 16/08/2022 16:04

So you mean to tell me her older children can't watch her toddler for 10 mins whilst she makes lunch for them to gobble on? Miss me with that BS please.

OP You needs to set some very thick boundaries now! No phones or tablets, stop with all the lunch making and cleaning up after them etc, if they're starving they can sort out their own food since they wanna be so useless.

user478965227857 · 16/08/2022 15:57

menopause59 · 16/08/2022 15:32

I also can't believe the people that are saying the older ones don't have to look after the toddler.

You are a family you all work together and help each other out, I am from a large family and we all had jobs to do around the house and if I was asked to look after my younger siblings it would never of entered my head to refuse

They don't have to.

Their sibling isn't their responsibility.

crosstalk · 16/08/2022 15:53

Stop making sandwiches or doing their laundry. Take away internet if you can and don't need it. No, they are not to blame for having to share with 3 younger ones but they're on a hiding to nothing if they can't look after themselves. Start getting them involved in running the house. It'll help them when they're students/have one of their own to manage. And use the time saved to take the younger kids out somewhere.

mam0918 · 16/08/2022 15:50

At 16 I didnt even live at home (neither did over half of my friends), you have zero obligation to be babying a 16 year old (regardless of what some privilaged middle mumsnets say while clutch their pearls about how will little Timothy afford a house if he doesnt live with us for free until well into his 20s/30s).

As for the 15 year old, punishment... Im not sure what punishment would be best (but a start would be being forced to tidy it even if you have to stand over her as she does it, and pay for anything broken) but you can not trash the house. If I had done that I would have been 6 foot under.

Yes they didnt choose to have 6 kids but so what? even if you only had 2 they would have to act cohiesively as a family, my teen cried when he found out I was pregnant and HATED it. yet now he automatically go to his sister to look after her if he sees no ones with her in that moment (nipped to the toilet etc...) never had to ask him to do anything.

If they where RAISING the baby (night feeds, nappy changes, been left alone with the all the time etc...) thats wildly different but watching a sibling play for 10 minutes while your parents in the kitchen cooking your dinner is not a crazy expectation.

As for the 10 year old, they dont want to get up and dressed you make them... otherwise most preteen boys would slob about unhygenic, underessed and unsocial they dont because their parents do let them.

Dirtylittleroses · 16/08/2022 15:50

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 16/08/2022 15:47

Is the garden safe and enclosed? Is the kitchen next to the garden? I'd be content letting a 3yo play in a secure back garden while I prep lunch in the kitchen.

Their actions today are ridiculous - I'd stop funding phones, social lives etc and tell them to sort their own lunches.

Make meals for you the 3,6&10yos and then take them out to the park. If the 15/16yos hadn't sorted the house out on my return I'd be laying down exactly how long it will be until they get their devices back. And I'd last longer than them!

Unlikely as they will just leave as soon as they can. And not look back

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 16/08/2022 15:47

Is the garden safe and enclosed? Is the kitchen next to the garden? I'd be content letting a 3yo play in a secure back garden while I prep lunch in the kitchen.

Their actions today are ridiculous - I'd stop funding phones, social lives etc and tell them to sort their own lunches.

Make meals for you the 3,6&10yos and then take them out to the park. If the 15/16yos hadn't sorted the house out on my return I'd be laying down exactly how long it will be until they get their devices back. And I'd last longer than them!

ErmIDontKnow · 16/08/2022 15:46

We aren't talking about looking after the younger ones while mum goes and works a full shift, it's ten minutes while she sorted lunch

Exactly this. Its 10 minutes of their time, it's hardly a big deal is it. All the posters saying they wouldnt ask their older children to "look after" their younger siblings are full of crap. Your telling me you wouldnt ask an older sibling to watch a younger sibling for TEN MINUTES whilst you made lunch? Give over

I'd send them to their dads OP. No way would I be putting up with one of them trashing my front room. Send the older 3 to their dads for a week or so

Butteryflakycrust83 · 16/08/2022 15:45

Stop doing things for them.

Seriously.

Stop it.

Dirtylittleroses · 16/08/2022 15:45

SoSoSusan · 16/08/2022 14:43

I took the iPad away and she kicked off trashing the living room

A 15 year old? What did you do?

I know this is likely to be unpopular (illegal blah blah) but I'll be honest. If my 14 or 12 year old started doing this (I'm assuming 'trashed' means throwing stuff around or breaking things) then he'd be feeling the back of my hand sharpish. And I say that as someone who doesn't hit their kids at all. But if you want to behave like a feral animal, you can damn well be treated like one.

After my initial reaction I can only imagine the punishment I'd give for such disgusting behaviour would be at least a fortnight of being completely grounded and every single bit of tech removed.

It's sounds like your dc treat you like dirt because you let them and have done for so long this type of behaviour has been normalised. Stop letting them behave like animals, lose your fucking shit and come down on them like a tonne of bricks would be my advice.

This is horrific, that’d you’d assault your own children.

op please ignore this person advising you to choose violence.

2bazookas · 16/08/2022 15:45

When I was 15, my widowed mother worked full time and new baby brother was in day care nursery. When I got home from school my task was to collect the baby from nursery , make his bottle, feed change and look after him until DM got home. If she was very late I bathed him and put him to bed. Mother (and I) had absolute trust and confidence in my childcare skills because she'd taught me herself from when he was born.

123becauseicouldntthinkofone · 16/08/2022 15:44

Change the internet password until they have done what you have asked, 10 minutes is not unreasonable at all. To keep them in a routine of internet access and doing what asked i would give all 3 one chore a day to do and until all 3 have completed that task NO ONE gets the internet then they will need to start policing each other instead of you doing it....good luck OP x

Bananarama21 · 16/08/2022 15:44

You've had 5 kids that's a personal choice. Are they all to different dads? You said their dad's left? It sounds chaotic but typical self-indulgent behaviour of a teenager. Obviously kicking off is not on and should be punished. Being 1 of 5 kids and one parent must the very hard especially when you want to do your own things and been asked to care for a sibling.

MrsTerryPratchett · 16/08/2022 15:44

All the comments about this one incident are missing that this is your life right now. The family has struggled since dad left and one consequences isn't going to fix that. You are going to have to do a lot of work to get your family back on track and you don't have a lot of time because of the ages.

First thing I'd do is stop the transactional stuff. I cook lunch so you babysit. No. It's designed to induce guilt and guilt makes teenagers avoidant. Buy some parenting books, go to classes, work out ways to help your children grow up well. It's very difficult but putting in a huge effort to change things now will help in the future.

sunsetsandsandybeaches · 16/08/2022 15:42

menopause59 · 16/08/2022 15:32

I also can't believe the people that are saying the older ones don't have to look after the toddler.

You are a family you all work together and help each other out, I am from a large family and we all had jobs to do around the house and if I was asked to look after my younger siblings it would never of entered my head to refuse

I think the point people are making is that the teens never asked to have multiple younger siblings, so they shouldn't be roped into doing the care for them.

Of course they should do housework - dishes, cooking, laundry, emptying the bins, stripping/making beds etc, but I would argue that care for siblings is the responsibility of the parents who chose to have them to start with.

Dirtylittleroses · 16/08/2022 15:42

you have five kids? I think it’s clear they don’t wish to look after their younger siblings, and to be fair I agree with them in that, they shouldn’t have to, at all, but they should also behave respectfully and be able to say no and that’s it.

Purpleforthewin · 16/08/2022 15:40

I don't expect my teenagers to look after my toddler but I do expect them to do something to help and include it as a choice then they often do picking watching younger sibling as the easier option.

Witchofthenorth · 16/08/2022 15:39

We aren't talking about looking after the younger ones while mum goes and works a full shift, it's ten minutes while she sorted lunch. I don't see anything wrong with that. But I accept I may be in the minority.
For what it's worth, I fully expected my older ones to help out with the younger and yes I have had my eldest son when he was 16 look after his younger siblings one day when regular childcare fell through when I needed to work.
It didn't enter his mind to say no, all the kids knew that everyone had to pull their weight to make the house run.

Usually though, if they were minding their siblings it was to allow me to pop to the shops quickly or let me get dinner organised.

Each to their own though.

InsertPunHere · 16/08/2022 15:35

Turn off the router.

butterflied · 16/08/2022 15:34

They shouldn't be used for childcare, but at 15 and 16 they can do their own washing and their own lunch etc.

Prokupatuscrakedatus · 16/08/2022 15:33

"§ 1619 - Services in home and business
As long as the child belongs to the parental household and is brought up or maintained by the parents, it is obliged to render services to the parents in their household and business in a manner appropriate to their strength and position in life.” – Civil Code (BGB, Germany)