Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why so many women put up with this shit

344 replies

Stylishkidintheriot · 16/08/2022 12:33

www.theguardian.com/money/2022/aug/15/how-to-achieve-an-equal-split-of-household-chores-kate-mangino#comment-158160830

I don’t get it: I really don’t. Not in this day and age.

if a man isn’t pulling his weight, why the fuck would you stay in a relationship or have children with him?

OP posts:
PewterHeart · 16/08/2022 23:01

G5000 · 16/08/2022 22:30

I don't want to be misconstrued as believing that every woman wants to be a SAHM and every man wants to work every waking moment of the day... but there is a trend, when you equal out every other societal influence

You can't remove the influence of the society if your claim is that people make more 'traditional' choices in more egalitarian societies. And there are barely any SAHMs in Scandinavia - peculiar, if this is something women allegedly in those societies are gravitating towards.

Like I said before I don't think that every woman in Scandinavia is a SAHM, I reckon I've financially perhaps that isn't possible because the cost of living is so high, but they do gravitate to more people focussed roles in the workplace (traditionally feminine)

ProbablyPossiblyPerhaps · 16/08/2022 22:38

This article isn't bad www.bbc.com/worklife/article/20220511-why-women-file-for-divorce-more-than-men

G5000 · 16/08/2022 22:37

And to get back to the topic, yes of course it's the society as well. I've lived all over and if most of the men barely lift a finger, your expectations are not that high either. A friend of mine in Switzerland (still stuck in 50s as feminism is concerned) was just told off by her MIL, as according to MIL, her poor son should not be doing any housework. Friend also works full time. And the general expectation in the UK is pretty similar to that. "Oh he's so good, even ironed his own shirts and is babysitting kids so I can clean the house!"
I do not know any man in Scandinavia who would think he's the king of the castle and can't possibly do any laundry, or any woman who would be happy to accept this.

G5000 · 16/08/2022 22:30

I don't want to be misconstrued as believing that every woman wants to be a SAHM and every man wants to work every waking moment of the day... but there is a trend, when you equal out every other societal influence

You can't remove the influence of the society if your claim is that people make more 'traditional' choices in more egalitarian societies. And there are barely any SAHMs in Scandinavia - peculiar, if this is something women allegedly in those societies are gravitating towards.

Scottishskifun · 16/08/2022 22:28

I have friends like this who make excuses for their husbands never lifting a finger, never giving them downtime and think it's acceptable for them to be exhausted looking after children whilst their husband has a lie in at the weekend because he's tired even though both sides work.

I've given up saying anything but I've also stopped offering to assist with children when they are tired as it's enabling their DHs behaviour. It's not nice to see friends so down beaten but until they stop taking this kind of crap their DHs won't change.

Topgub · 16/08/2022 22:22

@PewterHeart

Its not possible to remove the sexist influences on our choices. Even the more egalitarian societies aren't actually that equal

We live, globally, in patriarchal societies.

The fact you use radical feminist like an insult says you don't really respect my choices either so...

ProbablyPossiblyPerhaps · 16/08/2022 22:20

Stichintimesavesstapling has it 100%

Also extends to the workplace glass ceiling.

Men who produce a baby should be legally obligated to take 9 months (maternity leave minus the physical recovery/ initial breastfeeding establishment) regardless of any - any - other considerations.

Only then is there even faint hope of equality regarding the reproductive load.

HesterShaw1 · 16/08/2022 22:06

With my ex, a lot of it was his total refusal/inability to credit anything he didn't do himself as even existing e.g woman/wifework was Just. Not. A. Thing. It was my imagination.

Or he claimed not to realise or notice things needed doing.

I fully admit we got off on the wrong foot with me being eager to create a lovely nest. Having come from a traditional household where my dad's learned helplessness, I just thought that was normal. I was pretty young - never again. If I ever move in with anyone else this will be a conversation we have in advance

avocadotofu · 16/08/2022 22:05

Phineyj · 16/08/2022 21:40

If it is just "innate" female/male differences, then it is strange that other developed countries around the world vary so much in terms of female participation in the labour force, the gender pay gap, the types of job women do etc.

There's a strong cultural element and in the UK that's massively exacerbated by our childcare and housing being so expensive. Every decision is riskier when it's so expensive to make a mistake.

I personally had no idea how sexist the UK was until I had a DC. It had never really impinged on me before.

I absolutely think it's this. I have been totally amazed by what a sexist society we live in since having a child.

cansu · 16/08/2022 22:01

I think a lot of people on mumsnet do not recognise the financial realities of life. Many women work in low paid part time roles. They have caring responsibilities. They do not have the cash to get a solicitor and get rid of someone. They may not have a supportive family who will help them financially through a separation. Therefore it will sometimes take a lot before someone puts themselves in a precarious situation. This is normal life. Why do well off people in the public eye leave their spouses and get divorced more frequently? Answer because they can.

Homewardbound2022 · 16/08/2022 21:56

An ex moved in with me temporarily for 3/4 weeks. When he had his own place he was forever mopping floors and cleaning and proclaimed that everyone should clean up after themselves and take pride in cleanliness.
Staying at my place though, I thought his arms had been amputated, didn't do a tap.😂

PewterHeart · 16/08/2022 21:56

Topgub · 16/08/2022 21:48

@PewterHeart

You're reading an awful lot into a few short sentences.

I havent said any of the things you're saying I think.

I dont have to respect your choices and I don't care if you respect mine.

Regardless of motivation, the choice to be a sahm promotes sexist ideals like women are innately better suited to nurturing and being home makers.

So no, I don't respect it.

If I've misunderstood you then I apologise... however with what you have said, I don't think I'm far off the mark. Feel free to prove me wrong - but nothing you've said makes me think that you truly believe in equality of womens choices, because you cannot even respect another woman's decision, you can only acknowledge that you can't change their mind for them... a far cry from the former

PewterHeart · 16/08/2022 21:55

G5000 · 16/08/2022 21:47

men and women become even more different in an equal society, women fall naturally into more traditionally feminine roles, and men to the masculine.

Really, more female builders and male nurses in Saudi Arabia than Sweden?

It's always good to take a super extreme example of a society that bears little resemblance to any western society because of religious difference when taking about specifically secular societal impacts and outcomes...

PewterHeart · 16/08/2022 21:52

Phineyj · 16/08/2022 21:40

If it is just "innate" female/male differences, then it is strange that other developed countries around the world vary so much in terms of female participation in the labour force, the gender pay gap, the types of job women do etc.

There's a strong cultural element and in the UK that's massively exacerbated by our childcare and housing being so expensive. Every decision is riskier when it's so expensive to make a mistake.

I personally had no idea how sexist the UK was until I had a DC. It had never really impinged on me before.

In many countries that are considered egalitarian icons (eg throughout Scandinavia) the women tended to fall into more feminine roles and the men to masculine. That doesn't mean that women were all SAHM, but it might mean they took more roles as teachers and nurses rather than engineers and bricklayers. And again, that's not 100% because there's always outliers. As there are many many differences between even the most developed countries it's difficult to know exactly what might be impacting choices etc... but it has been studied that when given an even choice, woman choose more "people-y" and caring roles and men choose more "thing-y" and analytical roles. I don't want to be misconstrued as believing that every woman wants to be a SAHM and every man wants to work every waking moment of the day... but there is a trend, when you equal out every other societal influence (if that's the right phrase - I'm very tired haha), in what choices they make.

Topgub · 16/08/2022 21:48

@PewterHeart

You're reading an awful lot into a few short sentences.

I havent said any of the things you're saying I think.

I dont have to respect your choices and I don't care if you respect mine.

Regardless of motivation, the choice to be a sahm promotes sexist ideals like women are innately better suited to nurturing and being home makers.

So no, I don't respect it.

G5000 · 16/08/2022 21:47

men and women become even more different in an equal society, women fall naturally into more traditionally feminine roles, and men to the masculine.

Really, more female builders and male nurses in Saudi Arabia than Sweden?

PewterHeart · 16/08/2022 21:42

Topgub · 16/08/2022 21:38

@PewterHeart

Lol at the idea it's me with the narrow world view whilyou spout even more sexist nonsense.

Funnily enough I've managed to raise my children and have a career, just like their dad.

Good for you! If that's what you want to do then go for it. I'm genuinely pleased for you and have respect for your choices and apparent success in achieving your goals.

I'm saying you have a narrow world view because you don't seem to be able to have the same admiration and respect for women who choose something different, despite if it come naturally to them and it is their preferred lifestyle.

My world view is not narrow or sexist because I accept that everyone is different, but that means that there are plenty of women, like my sister and me who would prefer to be SAHMs (regardless of ability to do so). Whereas you seem to think that any women who think that are suffering internal oppression of some sort, which is ridiculous and just radical feminist brainwashing.

Phineyj · 16/08/2022 21:40

If it is just "innate" female/male differences, then it is strange that other developed countries around the world vary so much in terms of female participation in the labour force, the gender pay gap, the types of job women do etc.

There's a strong cultural element and in the UK that's massively exacerbated by our childcare and housing being so expensive. Every decision is riskier when it's so expensive to make a mistake.

I personally had no idea how sexist the UK was until I had a DC. It had never really impinged on me before.

Topgub · 16/08/2022 21:38

@PewterHeart

Lol at the idea it's me with the narrow world view whilyou spout even more sexist nonsense.

Funnily enough I've managed to raise my children and have a career, just like their dad.

PewterHeart · 16/08/2022 21:34

@Topgub you're choosing to view it as sexist because you have a narrow world view. Never mind that scientifically speaking most women and men have different temperaments and gravitate towards certain roles, which is also reflected in the type of work men and women tend to go into, it must be sexism. If that were true, the more egalitarian a society is, the more similar men and women would be in terms of life choices. Actually its the opposite. Men and women become even more different in an equal society, women fall naturally into more traditionally feminine roles, and men to the masculine. That's not 100% of people of course, there will be outliers and exceptions - I imagine you would consider yourself one of them.
However if it is just the natural way of things that most women tend to be more nurturing and like to be around people in their jobs, more so than the majority of their male counterparts, then how is that sexist? Sexism implies oppression, whereas for many it is a choice or a natural tendency. My sister for example is the breadwinner in her house, and her husband takes more time off with the kids and does more traditionally feminine chores around the house... my sister would rather it were the other way around, she would love to be a SAHM but it's not financially feasible for them. It's not because she has some internalised sexism - it's because she values time raising her children more than having a career. Many many women feel this way. Your dismissal of that as purely a symptom of societal sexism is just simply wrong.

TheLeadbetterLife · 16/08/2022 21:23

felulageller · 16/08/2022 20:49

I think it is a class thing.

If you are poor you often have more pressure to move in together quickly to save money.

Or one of you is coming to the end of a private rental. Or one of you still officially lives with DPs and just moves in gradually rather than with intent.

Under these circumstances there is less room to lay down ground rules. So wifework lands on the woman.

I find gen z women much less liberated than gen xers. By a long way...

I can’t see at all why this scenario should naturally lead to the domestic drudgery landing on the woman. Or what class has to with it. Very few young people can afford to live alone.

FinallyHere · 16/08/2022 21:01

I agree with @ComtesseDeSpair that before having children, it's easy enough to move on if you get stuck with someone who won't do their share of the chores. Before DC, you can earn enough to support yourself and avoid being dependent on another salary.

Once DC are added into the mix, it's just not so simple. It's fair enough to say 'it's your turn' for eg waking in the night but if one of you are on maternity leave and the other is working it can seem to make sense for the SAHP (even just for maternity leave) picks up more household chores.

No suggestion that that is correct, but it does seem to be when things start to change. Granted, NAMALT My lovely DSS positively delights in getting home and doing things for and with his DTs. But if your partner does start to let things slide, I understand that it might seem easier to just do it yourself as quicker than using up your energy in pushing for things to be more equal.

It's also not really possible to just leave a crying child til 'he' notices it the way it is possible if you really want to, to ignore washing up left in sink or washing festering in a machine.

Then you find your earning power is impacted so for a quiet life (and reflecting what many others do) you just get in and pick up the slack.

Growing up at the end of the '70's I genuinely thought we had cracked this equality thing. My mostly child free friends would agree. I'm so sorry to discover on MN just how many women have one way or another found themselves carrying more of the grunt household activities.

Yeah, and lots of social conditioning encourages women to consider romance / relationship the key focus of their lives, so they suck up the less attractive elements such as being expected to carry more than their share of chores while men are conditioned to expect to earn more and feel somehow entitled to a free ride on the chores front in return.

Without children, just ditch him. Once you have responsibilities, it gets trickier.

felulageller · 16/08/2022 20:49

I think it is a class thing.

If you are poor you often have more pressure to move in together quickly to save money.

Or one of you is coming to the end of a private rental. Or one of you still officially lives with DPs and just moves in gradually rather than with intent.

Under these circumstances there is less room to lay down ground rules. So wifework lands on the woman.

I find gen z women much less liberated than gen xers. By a long way...

Malad · 16/08/2022 20:43

I think many are just blinded by love and can’t see the faults. They are mostly all evident before marriage as most people live together for some time before getting married nowadays. Despite how shit some of these men are, the women still marry them and have kids with them.

Topgub · 16/08/2022 20:34

@PewterHeart

You can choose.

I'm not stopping you.

I can choose to judge you for being sexist

On a societal level men working and women doing all the housework and childcare is absolutely sexist

Its bound by sexist ideals and gendered stereotypes which hamper everyone

But yeah, you as an individual can choose what you like.