Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why so many women put up with this shit

344 replies

Stylishkidintheriot · 16/08/2022 12:33

www.theguardian.com/money/2022/aug/15/how-to-achieve-an-equal-split-of-household-chores-kate-mangino#comment-158160830

I don’t get it: I really don’t. Not in this day and age.

if a man isn’t pulling his weight, why the fuck would you stay in a relationship or have children with him?

OP posts:
Almondsandraisins · 17/08/2022 10:08

PewterHeart · 17/08/2022 09:48

Lol I exaggerated obviously he would figure it out eventually but he'd probably end up with scratchy or weirdly soft clothes for a while... probably shrink some as well (he's shrunk one of my jumpers before which is a big part of why I do it because I actually check labels lol). Good to know you're still worrying about what me and my husband do though x

I can't imagine anything less sexy than a man who is more incompetent than the average 14 year old child

Unless his job doesn't involve computers, machinery or technology of any kind, and he doesn't have a phone or any gadgets then he can use a washing machine, he is choosing to do it badly to force you to do it.

You may be happy with your set up, he should be fucking happy with your set up, but I couldn't be happy with a set up with a man who didn't respect me to this extent.

Topgub · 17/08/2022 10:07

And the usual nonsense of women thinking they're actually coaxing and persuading men into doing any of ot by showing them how valuable it is to do it all

Fucking nonsense

G5000 · 17/08/2022 10:02

Good to know you're still worrying about what me and my husband do though x

Sorry to disappoint, I didn't even notice who the poster was. Just that this kind of attitude is part of the reason why women accept to do the lion's share, because husbands 'literally' cannot do laundry, literally cannot see dirt, can't possibly remember family birthdays or what time their kids weekly afterschool activities are. All nature. Women have an innate ability to clean toilets.

ComtesseDeSpair · 17/08/2022 09:56

Thing is, I accept that some couples want to live with “traditional” set roles. I don’t understand it, but I accept it might work for some people. But I don’t see why that has to also tandem and the broader dynamic become diluted with this weird infantilisation of men by claiming things like that they aren’t capable of using a washing machine. The things were only invented a few decades ago, so clearly humankind didn’t evolve as a species with only the female half developing the innate DNA for working a washing machine. If your husband doesn’t do laundry then just say that he doesn’t do laundry because he’s never bothered to learn because he sees it as a woman’s job and has always banked on having a woman around who will do it for him. If you’re proud of your housewife role, why pretend that he can’t rather than that he won’t?

PewterHeart · 17/08/2022 09:48

G5000 · 17/08/2022 08:50

However, I do all the laundry (my husband literally couldn't)

Literally can't use washing machine? Why? Disabled and can't reach the washing machine buttons? Hm probably not if he's able to do all the heavy lifting..
So if he lived alone, he would use disposable paper gowns only?

Lol I exaggerated obviously he would figure it out eventually but he'd probably end up with scratchy or weirdly soft clothes for a while... probably shrink some as well (he's shrunk one of my jumpers before which is a big part of why I do it because I actually check labels lol). Good to know you're still worrying about what me and my husband do though x

G5000 · 17/08/2022 09:45

I know, it’s amazing isn’t it, that we don’t have a crisis of men post-divorce wandering the streets like unwashed zombies in filthy, tattered rags which they dragged from the bottom of the laundry basket six months ago and have been wearing ever since.

What is even more amazing is that somehow they managed to do their laundry before marriage - as I don't think there's much demand on the market for unwashed zombies. Unless of course mummy did it for a grown man, which should be a warning sign.

ComtesseDeSpair · 17/08/2022 09:41

G5000 · 17/08/2022 08:50

However, I do all the laundry (my husband literally couldn't)

Literally can't use washing machine? Why? Disabled and can't reach the washing machine buttons? Hm probably not if he's able to do all the heavy lifting..
So if he lived alone, he would use disposable paper gowns only?

I know, it’s amazing isn’t it, that we don’t have a crisis of men post-divorce wandering the streets like unwashed zombies in filthy, tattered rags which they dragged from the bottom of the laundry basket six months ago and have been wearing ever since. Oddly enough, they seem to develop the mental capacity to load a washing machine within days.

Northbynorthbreast · 17/08/2022 09:07

DillonPanthersTexas · 16/08/2022 16:15

A man that stays at home, does housework and looks after the kids is also a hard working SAHP, a cocklodger is a totally different animal.

I agree, although I generally find though that stay at home dads are often assumed to be some kind of failure insofar as only taking on the primary caring role because they were unable to secure a decent job as opposed to the couple having a serious chat about what arrangement is best for them and their kids. Let's be honest, there is still a stigma around this, no woman has said "what I am really looking for is a man who would prefer to be a stay at home dad looking after the kids and doing all the domestic chores while I work full time as the main earner"

I did exactly that!! I knew that I wanted a very proactive parenting partner who would help me fly in my work…

G5000 · 17/08/2022 08:50

However, I do all the laundry (my husband literally couldn't)

Literally can't use washing machine? Why? Disabled and can't reach the washing machine buttons? Hm probably not if he's able to do all the heavy lifting..
So if he lived alone, he would use disposable paper gowns only?

Bubblebubblebah · 17/08/2022 08:43

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 16/08/2022 23:53

I read an article the other day that suggests more and more men are being "left on the shelf" (as it were) due to the fact that women are now in a position to be a lot more selective about who they partner with, and subsequently, how and when they leave the relationship when it doesn't work.

It said that men (namalt) are basically ill-equipped to provide what the modern woman requires in an equal relationship. Hopefully, over time, men (namalt) will naturally evolve to become better at providing towards a balanced, non-1950s style household. This takes time, and today's women are pretty much the last generation of women who will stand for this, as the culture of what we expect of our husbands and boyfriends is (rightly) changing.

Women on the whole do not need men. Therefore darwinism would suggest that in order to retain their species, men must evolve and the fair and decent ones will prevail.

The thing is though. Why are they so ill-equipped. It's not like some natural unchangable state, is it. Parents everywhere always beam (well not always, I am sure parents of kids setting corner shops on fore don't but you know what I mean) about how great they brought up their kids.
Yet we have over submissive women and men who can't workout a hoover.
I do think lots of it is nurture. My brother and I had to swap chores at home all the time so we did everything. While he is moody and bit pessimistic type, which is his nature, his nurture ensured he can put a wash on, deep clean, DIY, cook and does it as a baisc part of life.

I often wonder about how some of these other man grew up. I am talking man in early 30s, not some long gone by times (don't even, I like to feel young).

tiger2691 · 17/08/2022 08:24

Plenty of young men / fathers out and about round here, on the buses with children, in pushchairs and buggy's, the children mostly seem content and the fathers dont shout and rant at them, like some mothers do. So much negativity on mn about men and over intellectualising of topics. Life is hard for everyone, whether you have a willy or fanny, all this point scoring lark, does my head in.

daisychain01 · 17/08/2022 05:39

Hopefully, over time, men (namalt) will naturally evolve to become better at providing towards a balanced, non-1950s style household.

and the reason this is taking soooo long to evolve is because....?

yup, men have always had a vested interest in keeping the status quo. In organisations, home life, education, every aspect of society. The only power women can exert is in relationships, deciding not to put up with misogyny.

Instead they far too often let men off the hook.

Killer quote from another thread, a woman cleaning up her partner's sick from too much drink "oh, but he's lovely when he isn't being a selfish arse" - ffs lovely???

FangsForTheMemory · 17/08/2022 00:06

I think a lot of men expect to look after them the way their mothers did.

WinterDeWinter · 16/08/2022 23:57

It's not until the relentless drudgery of children that you realise that they're not just a bit less fussy than you.

Topgub · 16/08/2022 23:57

@Lucidas

Yeah.

I habent said child rearing or childcare is worthless

You can rear children and do lots if childcare and work.

Having a sahm excludes men from doing more childcare.

So how does that help to encourage them to value it more?

Being a sahd has less negative societal impacts but I dont respect that choice much either.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 16/08/2022 23:53

I read an article the other day that suggests more and more men are being "left on the shelf" (as it were) due to the fact that women are now in a position to be a lot more selective about who they partner with, and subsequently, how and when they leave the relationship when it doesn't work.

It said that men (namalt) are basically ill-equipped to provide what the modern woman requires in an equal relationship. Hopefully, over time, men (namalt) will naturally evolve to become better at providing towards a balanced, non-1950s style household. This takes time, and today's women are pretty much the last generation of women who will stand for this, as the culture of what we expect of our husbands and boyfriends is (rightly) changing.

Women on the whole do not need men. Therefore darwinism would suggest that in order to retain their species, men must evolve and the fair and decent ones will prevail.

Lucidas · 16/08/2022 23:48

The irony for posters like Topgub is that the more you lambast the SAHM model, the more you affirm that the domain of ‘child-rearing’ is effectively valueless, the more you then deter men from participating in it. It’s why childcare workers, predominantly young women, are grotesquely underpaid. Think about it: if childcare in any form is so lacking in worth, why would men do more of it? You’re sending a clear signal that this is an undesirable pursuit for women, yet somehow you want men to participate in it more? That makes no sense. People are drawn to high value activities, however valie is defined.

It stands to reason then that we get more men to participate in caring work, by enhancing its value, not diminishing it.

latetothefisting · 16/08/2022 23:47

butterflied · 16/08/2022 13:23

It's mostly this, I think. It's so depressing. Being single and childfree by choice I get asked often, "aren't you lonely?"

Not ever enough to put up with this crap. I also don't understand the women, who keep having kids with these men. Surely you knew from the first how shit he is.

Yes agree with this. I'm happily single but was at a wedding last month and the number of people who asked why I wasn't with anyone...apparently this was more interesting than my job, my hobbies, my family....anything else about me! And sometimes it can be bloody hard being single - financially, emotionally, etc. It's interesting that research shows that single women without children are the happiest subgroup, and also live longer!

Whereas married men are happier than single men! Yet a single man isn't pitied in the same way a single, childless woman is....

TheLeadbetterLife · 16/08/2022 23:45

@PewterHeart you don't find people using matriarchal negatively because there aren't any matriarchal societies, and likely never have been.

It's extremely unscientific to draw conclusions about the innate behaviours of men and women based on any current civilisation. You'd have to go back at least tens of thousands of years to find a human civilisation untainted by patriarchal dominance. The closest we possibly have are modern hunter gatherer societies, and many of them are remarkably egalitarian (and child-rearing tends to be done collectively rather than in nuclear families, so let's not pretend there's anything natural about that structure).

There are very sound scientific theories about the reasons all human society is patriarchal, and they have nothing to do with cooking, cleaning, nurturing, or being a SAHM. It's much more likely to be to rooted in sexual dimorphism, and males exploiting female labour by exerting their physical dominance.

Topgub · 16/08/2022 23:31

@PewterHeart

It wasn't a personal remark, directed at you.

It was a statement/description of global societies. The difference is clear.

I didnt say everything was because of sexism. It heavily influences most choices. Thats inescapable.

I have no interest in respecting all choices made by women.

Lots of women make lots of terrible choices absolutely not worthy of respect.

There's nothing respect worthy about choosing to be a sahm imo. It's a lifestyle choice that has a negative impact on wider society.

I dont respect the choice to be a hedge fund manager or a tory mp either if that helps?

PewterHeart · 16/08/2022 23:24

Topgub · 16/08/2022 23:15

@PewterHeart

I havent uses patriarchal as an insult though. Its very odd you're claiming I have.

You definitely have used radical feminist as an insult.

You clearly judge women you view to be 'too' feminist

So what you actually mean by dont be so judgemental is dont judge me! I can judge. But you can't judge me.

The problem with pretending that sexism doesn't exist and that women just naturally choose not to be equal is pretty obvious I'd have thought.

Much like pretending racism doesn't exist is problematic.

I'm not sure how else I'm supposed to be taking your use of the word patriarchal... you're using it to describe a type of society which you clearly don't think is fair... so should I assume you think that patriarchy is a good thing then, no?

And labelling everything sexist doesn't make it so.

I don't think I have any right to judge someone. I said I try not to do that but I know I fall short of the mark regularly. Clearly you believe I'm being judgmental of you and so I apologise for having presented my arguments in such a way that this is how it reads. Truly my intentions were not to judge.

I simply want to point out that not everything is because of sexism, not every woman wants to have a career, women have a choice which includes the choice of being a SAHM and all choices (both personal and professional) by women should be respected, not just the ones you agree with. I truly do respect women who choose a career and motherhood at the same time - I literally couldn't do it! But I don't want to be sneered at or called a victim of a sexist society or some similar accusation because of my choice. I would like to be treated with and given the same respect that the same person would give a woman who chose to have a career as well.

Topgub · 16/08/2022 23:15

@PewterHeart

I havent uses patriarchal as an insult though. Its very odd you're claiming I have.

You definitely have used radical feminist as an insult.

You clearly judge women you view to be 'too' feminist

So what you actually mean by dont be so judgemental is dont judge me! I can judge. But you can't judge me.

The problem with pretending that sexism doesn't exist and that women just naturally choose not to be equal is pretty obvious I'd have thought.

Much like pretending racism doesn't exist is problematic.

PewterHeart · 16/08/2022 23:07

cherish123 · 16/08/2022 23:06

The % each spouse does should depend on who works more or less. If you work similar hours, you should split it equally. I do more as I work part-time. My DH thinks I do things that don't actually need done. When he retires (he hopes to before me), I will expect him to do all or most.

I get OP saying women (or men) should not stand for a lazy spouse. However, it's a bit extreme to break up children's stable home lives.

I think this is a fair way to look at it all tbh!

cherish123 · 16/08/2022 23:06

The % each spouse does should depend on who works more or less. If you work similar hours, you should split it equally. I do more as I work part-time. My DH thinks I do things that don't actually need done. When he retires (he hopes to before me), I will expect him to do all or most.

I get OP saying women (or men) should not stand for a lazy spouse. However, it's a bit extreme to break up children's stable home lives.

PewterHeart · 16/08/2022 23:05

Topgub · 16/08/2022 22:22

@PewterHeart

Its not possible to remove the sexist influences on our choices. Even the more egalitarian societies aren't actually that equal

We live, globally, in patriarchal societies.

The fact you use radical feminist like an insult says you don't really respect my choices either so...

I suppose that my using of radical feminist as an insult is similar to your use of patriarchal as an insult. Would matriarchal be equally as bad in your view, or is it just men that are the problem? I don't see why difference is synonymous with inequality. I don't see anything wrong with men and women just being different (on average). Obviously not condoning any actual oppression - but if given the same choices and on average different decisions are made and it seems to correlate within the sexes... what is wrong with that... I just don't understand the moral judgement on simple life choices.

Swipe left for the next trending thread