Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why so many women put up with this shit

344 replies

Stylishkidintheriot · 16/08/2022 12:33

www.theguardian.com/money/2022/aug/15/how-to-achieve-an-equal-split-of-household-chores-kate-mangino#comment-158160830

I don’t get it: I really don’t. Not in this day and age.

if a man isn’t pulling his weight, why the fuck would you stay in a relationship or have children with him?

OP posts:
Topgub · 17/08/2022 17:52

@PewterHeart

The trends we find in medicine are the same as the trends we find elsewhere.

Despite more female medical students there are many maby more male consultants

And despite nursing being a majority female workforce, there are many many more male managers

You'd probably argue that's natural because men are better equipped to take on leadership roles and really, women are all just wishing they were at home doing the washing.

I'd argue its because our society is deeply sexist and women need to fight back.

Bubblebubblebah · 17/08/2022 17:50

Classicblunder · 17/08/2022 17:43

Professions like medicine used to be male dominated and considered all masculine and sciencey. Now they are female dominated, they are nurturing and people focussed.

Being a vicar used to be a manly leadership thing, now loads of women do it, it's a nurturing thing..

Correct me if I am wrong.

Interestingly USSR had more female doctors than male ones. Personal anecdote, about 2/3 of doctors I encountered in my life in former satelite country were women. Even more interestingly! It still didn't mean that men weren't considered better and deserving more respect🙄

Orangello · 17/08/2022 17:49

Unless you're in an arranged marriage, it's not just luck and lottery. I mean sure there's some luck involved that you don't stumble on a narcissistic sociopath who can deceive you until it's too late. But in most cases, people show you who they are, we just don't want to believe it or think they will change or that it's not such a big deal.

PewterHeart · 17/08/2022 17:49

I apologise for that - I don’t know why I failed to speak my view accurately. I was tired and I have been emotional so probably not being clearheaded and thinking about the right words to use. Especially when these forums are so fast paced I feel I have to just get it all written and posted as fast as possible, so I’m not as careful with my word choice… Hopefully I’ve explained myself better now and you can forgive my past misspeaking… or not, it’s your prerogative!

Topgub · 17/08/2022 17:48

And the opposite with tec/it which were initially dominated/created by women and are now dominated by men

Women don't naturally fall into nurturing roles any more than men naturally fall into leadership roles.

They're funnelled into them

PewterHeart · 17/08/2022 17:47

@Classicblunder yes I suppose there is a level of perspective shift that could taint the views of the profession. I think it’s great that there is a more nurturing expectation of medicine now rather than it being cold hearted though! So good change I think. But maybe if we look closer salt the fields of medicine we could find trends there, paediatrician vs oncology vs neurology perhaps? I’m not sure! Would be interesting though.

Topgub · 17/08/2022 17:45

@PewterHeart

Yeah, that's really not how you first put it across.

PewterHeart · 17/08/2022 17:43

@tiggergoesbounce i know! I’m such a procrastinator with big projects which is why we are going to at least try and get the room cleared before I get too round 😂 luckily the room was freshly painted a lovely neutral colour before we moved in, so thankfully I don’t have to do that (I always think I’m gonna like painting a room right up until I start and I get bored very quickly) but once the room is cleared all I need to do is fill it with baby furniture (and then provide the baby 😂)! And thanks again for your kind words!

Classicblunder · 17/08/2022 17:43

PewterHeart · 17/08/2022 17:38

@Topgub I think maybe I mustn’t have been speaking accurately. I can’t be bothered to go back and check exactly what I said as it’s pages ago… but to try and clarify - I only meant that I feel like what would traditionally be the “feminine” role is what suits me. And regarding other women I never meant to imply that they all want to be SAHMs… more that many women in general seem to fall into more feminine “people focussed” roles even looking at the workplace (nursing, teaching, daycare, medicine, People/HR teams etc). Now that’s not to say all women at all, but it’s just what I’ve seen in various statistics etc. I’m no expert though so I could be completely wrong (and if I am then fair enough I’m happy to be wrong)!

Professions like medicine used to be male dominated and considered all masculine and sciencey. Now they are female dominated, they are nurturing and people focussed.

Being a vicar used to be a manly leadership thing, now loads of women do it, it's a nurturing thing..

ohfook · 17/08/2022 17:43

In my experience it doesn't happen overnight. When you both work and have few other responsibilities, things are fairly equal. In terms of relationships I've seen around me (and my own) the change starts when you have children. Over maternity leave in particular when the mum is off work so picks up most responsibilities around the house in the interests of 'fairness' and then once you return to work it's a real battle getting things in an equal setting again - especially if once you return to work you're part time so your partner becomes the one with the 'important job'.

My advice to anyone on maternity leave is start as you mean to go on in terms of division of household responsibilities.

PewterHeart · 17/08/2022 17:38

@Topgub I think maybe I mustn’t have been speaking accurately. I can’t be bothered to go back and check exactly what I said as it’s pages ago… but to try and clarify - I only meant that I feel like what would traditionally be the “feminine” role is what suits me. And regarding other women I never meant to imply that they all want to be SAHMs… more that many women in general seem to fall into more feminine “people focussed” roles even looking at the workplace (nursing, teaching, daycare, medicine, People/HR teams etc). Now that’s not to say all women at all, but it’s just what I’ve seen in various statistics etc. I’m no expert though so I could be completely wrong (and if I am then fair enough I’m happy to be wrong)!

Topgub · 17/08/2022 17:22

@Popeyeandolive

Its possible if both parents do an equal share.

Also THE point of the thread

Popeyeandolive · 17/08/2022 17:15

Yes but not meeting the needs of BOTH parents. That's THE point of the thread.

Topgub · 17/08/2022 16:58

@Popeyeandolive

Well, that's kind of the point of the thread?

I didnt say loads of men were doing their share. They're clearly not.

They should be though.

Most families have both parents working.

Which means most families are meeting their kids needs while working

Popeyeandolive · 17/08/2022 16:52

Part time

tiggergoesbounce · 17/08/2022 16:52

Ah I understand, I shall try not to be discouraged!

Yes really dont be, just see some posters for what they are.
Its bad practice on here to use the search to search other users names, but in some cases you really will get their number if you are new. You will see the same bile being regurgitated time and time again. So please just ignore them. Literally.

But less of thats, MN can be really helpful on the parenting board once your baby is here, they can give some great advice and they can be really supportive if there are things you are maybe a little unsure of or need reassurance on.

And thank you very much, we are really excited! Clearing out the spare room ready for a nursery 🤩

I still remember swearing we would be those people with everything sorted months before, yet there i was, about 34 weeks pregnant up ladders painting Blush.

Popeyeandolive · 17/08/2022 16:51

And of you go past time your career stalls. For most people in most careers. So disproportionately impacts women.

Popeyeandolive · 17/08/2022 16:49

It only is if the working person/people are supported to do so to the same level.

So men generally get completely supported to do so by their wives (it's rare for a reversal in the UK)

Women have variable levels of support.

We all know that.

Support isn't just childcare. If the home work isn't equal then it soon becomes untenable for a woman working full time. I'm well aware plenty of single mums manage it. But let's not pretend it isn't very hard for them. Why should a working mum with a partner with children have to take on an unequal load and be tired stressed and with less free time if not necessary. We all know this is the reality. Most of us can barely think of anyone this isn't the reality for if we're really honest. Daddy sharing pickups and making tea isn't 50/50. I don't buy loads of men doing equal. Never seen it. And I know a lot of women, families and work in an area that brings me into contact with more.

Topgub · 17/08/2022 16:39

It is absolutely possible to raise children in a happy home while meeting their needs and to have a career/work.

I dont see why we have to pretend its not.

Popeyeandolive · 17/08/2022 16:37

@PewterHeart
I don't think many people disagree that children need a home with their needs met. That having them in wrap around childcare etc is far from ideal and home cooked meals are the best.
But the reality is that women give up things to do this with a promise from their DH in return to be supported financially and emotionally. And then when the DH doesn't do this, circumstances change, he leaves and so on, they're screwed
Also a lot of us don't feel like we went to university and have brains in our heads to be treated like the 'forman' of the house and have to manage everything boring. Apart from anything else it's exhausting, lonely and often thankless. It's the world's biggest turn off too. Who wants sex with a lazy man-child.
It doesnt mean we don't want to do everything for our children. In fact the reason why most of us do it/did it for so long is because we don't want our children to miss out or suffer, and we are in a situation financially of no choice. It also takes a long time to realise.

But I'm sure you know this!

Topgub · 17/08/2022 16:37

@PewterHeart

That's fair enough except earlier in the thread you were fairly adamant that feeling like that was because you were a woman and that most women naturally feel like that

Your inability to cope with work isn't down to your sex.

I suppose you should count yourself lucky that at your age you've managed to find an oh willing to bank roll you.

I hope for your sake that doesn't change

PewterHeart · 17/08/2022 16:32

tiggergoesbounce · 17/08/2022 16:29

@PewterHeart its absolutely fine. I hate to see the usual suspects goading and "misunderstanding" on purpose.
If you take a step back, you will see they do it on every single thread, and when they start getting ignored they @ people and get all goady.

This thread is no exception i see.

Please dont step away from the forum, we need as many level headed posters as possible Grin and most posters, although they may not agree with your point of view, they are usually, respectful and are open to a decent discussion, its the very few who cant comprehend people making different choices so want to drag others down. Don't let them, it just highlights their failings, not yours.

Oh and congrats on the pregnancy Flowers

Ah I understand, I shall try not to be discouraged!

And thank you very much, we are really excited! Clearing out the spare room ready for a nursery 🤩

PewterHeart · 17/08/2022 16:30

@Topgub okay I think I understand you better now. I think that’s a reasonable opinion to have, it’s just not a solution that works for me. I seriously absolutely do not want a job or a career. I’m not interested in earning money or getting a promotion or any status I might get from having a good job/career. To me it doesn’t seem worth the effort and stress. A happy, clean, warm, inviting home and raising happy and healthy children does seem worth any stress and effort it takes, so I’m focussed on that. And I’m honestly not saying that if a woman has a career it’s pointless - not at all! It absolutely is worth it as long as the woman believes it is worth it. Imagine having to do a job you hate, that wouldn’t really feel worth it to you, right (aside from monetary gain)? To me that is literally all jobs (I’ve tried many, including being self employed) even the job where I worked only 10 hours per week at a prestigious private school where everyone was sweet as pie and the benefits were great was too much stress and effort and even though I was getting paid etc I didn’t really feel like it was worth it in my soul, yknow? I wasn’t really doing anything worthwhile to me. I understand that’s not everyone’s cup of tea or opinion but it genuinely is mine. I’m happier out of the work force and I look forward to being a SAHM. I wish you well and I hope you’re able to achieve and maintain your ideal balance of relationship! 😊

tiggergoesbounce · 17/08/2022 16:29

@PewterHeart its absolutely fine. I hate to see the usual suspects goading and "misunderstanding" on purpose.
If you take a step back, you will see they do it on every single thread, and when they start getting ignored they @ people and get all goady.

This thread is no exception i see.

Please dont step away from the forum, we need as many level headed posters as possible Grin and most posters, although they may not agree with your point of view, they are usually, respectful and are open to a decent discussion, its the very few who cant comprehend people making different choices so want to drag others down. Don't let them, it just highlights their failings, not yours.

Oh and congrats on the pregnancy Flowers

foxster22 · 17/08/2022 16:23

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Swipe left for the next trending thread