Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why so many women put up with this shit

344 replies

Stylishkidintheriot · 16/08/2022 12:33

www.theguardian.com/money/2022/aug/15/how-to-achieve-an-equal-split-of-household-chores-kate-mangino#comment-158160830

I don’t get it: I really don’t. Not in this day and age.

if a man isn’t pulling his weight, why the fuck would you stay in a relationship or have children with him?

OP posts:
Topgub · 16/08/2022 14:45

@Lockheart

Why would she have been our the workplace for 20 years?!

Lockheart · 16/08/2022 14:43

Neondevelitionist · 16/08/2022 14:41

Also staying in a dismal marriage "for nice holidays" - christ almighty. Have some dignity.

Too much talk of finances here. Being stuck with a man for his big manly salary. Get a proper job and live off your own big salary. Look at the dickheaded mediocre men on big pay packets. It's all there for you too.

This is easy to say if you're in your 20s with no dependents. Not so easy for a woman in her mid-40s who has been out of the workplace for 20 years with children to look after.

Astrabees · 16/08/2022 14:42

Don't people agree these things before they live together? DH and i agreed equal split of income and an bonuses like insurance policy pay outs and inheritances, equal division of chores ( and no ironing for each other ever). We also agreed no salt in the cooking and no instant coffee, plus a stock of 8 bottles in the wine rack minimum. I think we did quite well bearing in mind we were engaged within a fortnight of meeting. 38 years later I can confirm it has made for domestic harmony.

Neondevelitionist · 16/08/2022 14:41

Also staying in a dismal marriage "for nice holidays" - christ almighty. Have some dignity.

Too much talk of finances here. Being stuck with a man for his big manly salary. Get a proper job and live off your own big salary. Look at the dickheaded mediocre men on big pay packets. It's all there for you too.

MorrisZapp · 16/08/2022 14:41

Dotjones · 16/08/2022 14:16

It's a mistake to assume that so many women "put up" with this.

You're starting from the point that everything in a relationship should be equal. This sounds fine on the face of it, but the relationships that work best are often ones where partners bring different abilities to the table. It doesn't have to be the case that each partner must earn exactly the same as the other, so it's illogical to assume that other things have to be exactly equal.

I mean, if you want something to be split exactly equally, that's fine, you should communicate that with your partner and you're free to leave the relationship if they have a different perspective.

Some women actually like being a SAHM for example, and some men are happy to work and support their partner in being a SAHM. By the logic that everything should be 50/50, each partner should work 2.5 days per week and bring home the same salary. But that might not be what either person wants?

That's not what this thread is about though. Loads of couples happily decide that one of them will do the bulk of the housework. This thread is about men who should be doing more, and whose wives despair of their laziness or ineptitude.

BadNomad · 16/08/2022 14:40

Lockheart · 16/08/2022 14:38

In your opinion. People ascribe different levels of importance to different things. Being happy overall in a relationship consists of many threads. If shared housework is crucially important to you then yes, it would seem like giving up. If shared housework doesn't matter to you or if you rate other things more highly, then perhaps not.

Everyone has their own preferences and boundaries and everyone is different.

Where is the compromise? You want him to do housework. He doesn't want to do housework. So you do all the housework. I'm not seeing the compromise. He got what he wanted. You gave up wanting what you wanted.

User8273738273737 · 16/08/2022 14:40

MorrisZapp · 16/08/2022 13:26

From looking at the families I know, I think often it's the woman who wants a baby, or to add to the family. The man is less sure, or worried about the practicalities. By the time the woman has talked the man round, it's too difficult to then say 'oh and you'll be fkn knackered for ten years because that's what family life is like'. He expects that because she was so keen to have them, she'll do the bulk of the work.

I'm a big fan of observing people when they show you who they are. They won't try harder with a second or third child, or a puppy.

@MorrisZapp
exactly - believe people when they tell you or show you who they are. Don’t go for the version of the person/or events that you would prefer.

I was very unwell for almost a year not long into starting my relationship with my OH. He was very supportive and caring, bent backwards to help me get the care I needed - this was during the worst of the pandemic, when the NHS was practically for COVID only - looked after me and all the things I couldn’t do because I was so unwell.

fast forward, I’m now 9 months pregnant and he has, again, been supportive, caring, and I have no fears about what kind of father he will be or the future of our relationship in terms of equality

Neondevelitionist · 16/08/2022 14:39

WeSent500Ravens · 16/08/2022 13:48

Not ever enough to put up with this crap. I also don't understand the women, who keep having kids with these men. Surely you knew from the first how shit he is

It is the kids I feel sorry for. You aren't allowed to say that on MN because you get jumped for "victim blaming" but I do wonder why anybody would continue to breed with some of the specimens you read about on here. Yet they do and are encouraged to do so. Go for it hun, you won't regret baby no. 4. Okaaaaaaaay.....

What was that one at the start of the holidays who shat all up the stairs and made his wife clean it up? Or the ones who hit their children. Or the ones who point out other women and say "she's fit and you're a cow."

It's not just chores. Some of the "normal" behaviour reported here under a title of "oo my diddy dumpling did a wee boo boo" is frightening. Because if you think shitting on the stairs or belting a toddler is "oo I'm not sure, am I over-reacting and being a bitch like he says I am?" worthy, how much else have you been letting slide.

No one's saying it's women's 'fault', but educating half the population that you don't have to put up with being called names, treated like shit, told you're a useless bitch and you'll never find anyone better can't hurt in the long run.

Lockheart · 16/08/2022 14:38

BadNomad · 16/08/2022 14:34

It's a compromise, like most things in long relationships and families.

That isn't a compromise. That is surrendering. Giving up.

In your opinion. People ascribe different levels of importance to different things. Being happy overall in a relationship consists of many threads. If shared housework is crucially important to you then yes, it would seem like giving up. If shared housework doesn't matter to you or if you rate other things more highly, then perhaps not.

Everyone has their own preferences and boundaries and everyone is different.

Topgub · 16/08/2022 14:37

@NewBlueGoo

I havent said any of those things

I'm saying women shouldn't accept it from the start.

Also, you kind of appear to be suggesting that it's worth it for financial security.

Fuck that.

Make your own financial security

BadNomad · 16/08/2022 14:34

It's a compromise, like most things in long relationships and families.

That isn't a compromise. That is surrendering. Giving up.

NewBlueGoo · 16/08/2022 14:32

@Topgub

It is naive to say women are 'putting up with it' as though they are fondly indulging male entitlement because they agree with it, or don't know any better, or whatever. Most women I know try EVERY SINGLE DAY to negotiate a better balance of household labour. Some are just biding their time until they are in a position to leave without massively financially compromising themselves and their children.

Some have decided that for the time being it is just easier to crack on with what they are doing than have constant arguments with someone they love, whose company they enjoy, and with whom they have shared all their most important memories for over half their lives. That is a choice people are entitled to make. It's a compromise, like most things in long relationships and families.

It's not as simple (for most people) as saying 'if you do not do exactly 50% of everything, I will stop caring about you, stop accepting care from you, disrupt our kids' lives, disrupt all sorts of relationships within the wider extended family, and make us all poorer in the midst of a huge cost of living crisis.'

Topgub · 16/08/2022 14:28

@Dotjones

You're starting from the point that everything in a relationship should be equal.

You aren't?

Maybe that's the problem.

Bubblebubblebah · 16/08/2022 14:23

Dotjones · 16/08/2022 14:16

It's a mistake to assume that so many women "put up" with this.

You're starting from the point that everything in a relationship should be equal. This sounds fine on the face of it, but the relationships that work best are often ones where partners bring different abilities to the table. It doesn't have to be the case that each partner must earn exactly the same as the other, so it's illogical to assume that other things have to be exactly equal.

I mean, if you want something to be split exactly equally, that's fine, you should communicate that with your partner and you're free to leave the relationship if they have a different perspective.

Some women actually like being a SAHM for example, and some men are happy to work and support their partner in being a SAHM. By the logic that everything should be 50/50, each partner should work 2.5 days per week and bring home the same salary. But that might not be what either person wants?

Equal doesn't have to mean 50-50 on everything.
It can mean one person does more of cleaning while other dows more of gardening or diy. It becomes unequal when the gardening is 30 min job a week while cleaning is 6 hours (random time examples) and partner 2 says "well I did my share". One person works more hours, the other does some more housework.

What is the problem is when someone does nothing or bare minimum and it's left to the other partner who already has massive load.

HotWashCycle · 16/08/2022 14:18

Thanks to a previous MN thread, I am reading Fair Play - its all about getting away from the idea of woman as the home organiser who has her head full of a thousand things that need to be followed up and done, and the man maybe doing a bit to "help". The aim is for both to have more time to do their own thing, and more headspace by willingly taking on a whole task each, and the other trusting them to do it properly.

Bubblebubblebah · 16/08/2022 14:17

Women are not responsible for policing lazy man. Women are responsible for own lives and what they will accept in their lives. It's not any extra job...

Women also do have the power to procreate eith only suitable partners. We have minimum of 10 easily accessible types of contraception with great levels of success... The power is very much with us if we want it.

When they freedom to do so without possibility of prison or death of course....

Dotjones · 16/08/2022 14:16

It's a mistake to assume that so many women "put up" with this.

You're starting from the point that everything in a relationship should be equal. This sounds fine on the face of it, but the relationships that work best are often ones where partners bring different abilities to the table. It doesn't have to be the case that each partner must earn exactly the same as the other, so it's illogical to assume that other things have to be exactly equal.

I mean, if you want something to be split exactly equally, that's fine, you should communicate that with your partner and you're free to leave the relationship if they have a different perspective.

Some women actually like being a SAHM for example, and some men are happy to work and support their partner in being a SAHM. By the logic that everything should be 50/50, each partner should work 2.5 days per week and bring home the same salary. But that might not be what either person wants?

NewBlueGoo · 16/08/2022 14:15

I mean, are we actually curious to know the many and various reasons why women stay with men in these situations? Or is 'why do women put up with this;' just one of those rhetorical questions, opening up the floor to have a pop at women we think are desperate or unambitious or unenlightened or stupid or ignorant or otherwise beneath us? I just hate the sneeriness of these posts.

Topgub · 16/08/2022 14:15

@NewBlueGoo

But they are putting up with it

Its not internalised mysoginy to acknowledge that.

They aren't responsible for men's behaviour. Only what they are willing to tolerate

NewBlueGoo · 16/08/2022 14:12

Of course it's not comparable, but you also can't say that women are 'putting up with it' - as though this is yet another bit of emotional labour women are responsible for: policing the lazy men in their lives / ensuring they only procreate with a perfect specimen of equitable masculinity like my Tarquin.

I don't disagree that it's shit. I do despair of the internalised misogyny that leads women to (seemingly gleefully and very smugly) hold other women responsible for the failings of their partners, or criticise them for not breaking up a family and potentially putting themselves in penury because Tarquin doesn't do exactly half of the washing up.

Bubblebubblebah · 16/08/2022 14:07

When I said English, I mean the ones doscussed here since it's predominantly English people here. Not that all English man are shit😁

Bubblebubblebah · 16/08/2022 14:06

NewBlueGoo · 16/08/2022 14:02

@Topgub how will casting aspersions on women's intelligence / strength of character help?

The idea that people are only shits because the people around them 'put up with it' is really un-nuanced. Those Afghan women should really put their foot down and insist the Taliban behave reasonably. Or leave! There are plenty of nice regimes around if you have the gumption and self-worth not to settle.

You can't compare shit english man with Taliban rule ffs.

Topgub · 16/08/2022 14:06

@NewBlueGoo

I dont think it's comparable to the taliban

But nothing will change unless women demand change. Men aren't only shits because women put up with it.

But its a big part of the reason.

Dalaidramailama · 16/08/2022 14:05

My husband does so much round the house. Hoovering, cleaning, washing, the beds. You name if he does it. I stick to the cooking mainly. Works for us as it’s 50/50.

I have no idea why he’s so domesticated. Working class backgrounds and his mum once told me “a woman’s work is never done” erm I think you’ll find it is. Maybe my husband just knew he wasn’t going to be able to the take the piss. My friends husbands are all manbabies.

NewBlueGoo · 16/08/2022 14:02

@Topgub how will casting aspersions on women's intelligence / strength of character help?

The idea that people are only shits because the people around them 'put up with it' is really un-nuanced. Those Afghan women should really put their foot down and insist the Taliban behave reasonably. Or leave! There are plenty of nice regimes around if you have the gumption and self-worth not to settle.

Swipe left for the next trending thread