Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the police aren't fit for purpose

285 replies

countingsheep5678 · 16/08/2022 11:29

I am not talking about individuals who put their lives on the line, I'm talking about how police constabularies are run up and down the country.

I have experienced three quite horrible anti social incidents in the 'safe' area of Hertfordshire where I live! One a group of boys threatened to throw my toddler in the river and another a man threatened to smash my 'ducking' car in because I asked him to move a bag out of the road!

I want to speak to a local police officer to explain my concerns and ask if there would be more officers on the street and what they are doing about the anti social behaviour in the area. I managed to speak to someone who took all my details and said they'd pass it onto a safer neighbourhood team.

I asked when I would hear back... he couldn't tell me. I asked if I could speak to someone more senior as I wanted some reassurance quite soon, he said I would have to make a complaint if I wanted to speak to someone more senior. I asked if I could have the number of the safer neighbourhood team... they don't have a number. So essentially, unless I call 999 there and then there are no local police officers you can talk and engage with. I was also astounded by the lack of empathy the police officer I spoke to had. When you've been on the receiving end of horrible situations you want to feel reassured. I have got off the phone feeling more concerned about the safety of our neighbourhood than ever.

Just by luck I have seen my local safer neighbourhood police team are holding a surgery tomorrow... but surely we deserve better from the police? We need more open, direct access to them? Am I alone in thinking this?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
TooBigForMyBoots · 16/08/2022 14:39

JuvenileEmu · 16/08/2022 14:38

So why do they waste so much time monitoring twitter?

Because Tory MPs report people on Twitter?

JuvenileEmu · 16/08/2022 14:38

Magicpaintbrush · 16/08/2022 13:31

They are completely overworked and treated like shit by the government - frequently pulled out of their day jobs to cover other stuff like Aid - etc There aren't enough of them. They are trying to deliver a good service on a shoe string budget because of cuts and they just can't. Do you have any idea how much time and paperwork is involved in answering one complaint? Loads, absolutely loads. And that in itself is vicious circle. It's like robbing Peter to pay Paul in terms of time every single day - there is never enough of anything to go around whether it's people or resources. A big organisation needs money to operate - when it keeps being cut and cut and cut this is what you get.

So why do they waste so much time monitoring twitter?

BluebellsareBlue · 16/08/2022 14:35

@HistoryKitty well said!!
@countingsheep5678 I'm retired now but I spent a lot of my service in child abuse, some of these cases took months to bring right there with weeks and weeks of paperwork.

I was also a community officer for a while and you maybe didn't see me because I was noting crime after crimes after crime and dealing with cases like yours so either looking though intel or out making enquiries.

I have NEVER his behind a desk, I led proactive teams, worked late nearly every evening to the detriment of my family so that I could provide a service to the people that needed it.

The hiding behind desks comment had pissed me off no end. There are decent hardworking officers out there who are bombarded by cuts, at court on days off, working hard to solve crime, taking the work home with them mentally, personally I still wake up at night thinking about the children who suffered horrific abuse, the children who were lost to sids whose parents I had to hold whilst they screamed, and then an hour later I had to attend a shoplifter and deal with that. I won't ever forget these things that I have seen or people that have passed whilst I held bits of their body together to try and stop them bleeding out, the parents I had to tell that their child was gone from some attack, jumping into a harbour to save a drowning teen.
Five years I've been retired and I don't think these scenes will ever leave me.
So no, we are not hiding behind desks!

BasiliskStare · 16/08/2022 14:33

@loislovesstewie 💐

loislovesstewie · 16/08/2022 14:25

Over 30 years ago, I worked as a call handler in a police control room. The thinking was that a civilian (me) doing the job freed up actual coppers, then SOCO was made into a civilian career for the same reason. I spent a lot of my time sending police officers to jobs which involved people with serious mental health issues and/or learning disabilities who were either breaking the law and committing criminal acts or were causing nuisance to others or their families. Proper funding of those services would have had a huge impact on what we had to deal with. Then there were hoax calls, how funny to call the police when you are bored! People killing themselves in gruesome ways, sudden deaths, all have to be attended by the police.
Instead of actually funding the police properly, we have PCSO's ( yes I did comment on that thread too and thought the PCSO was well out of line) , we have underfunded services generally so that impacts on what the police can do, but if everyone was asked to pay an extra £100 per year council tax to fund those services would you? Most would not want to, but just pass the buck and ask those in the public sector to work harder.

I spent all of my working life in the public sector, I worked my socks off and still got bollocked regularly by my customers who thought that I spent my time drinking tea and going to meetings. Sometimes I think there was no understanding that meetings were very much necessary to my job. And as for having a holiday or days off, the thinking was that I just shouldn't do so! The surprise from customers when I told them that I didn't work weekends! Apparently I was supposed to be chained to my desk.
I've never worked in any private enterprise and have no clue what any of those jobs entail, so for me to comment on those who do would be pointless. And often when people joined us who had worked in the private sector, they couldn't cope with the abuse and the level of responsibility that even lowly local authority workers have.
Sorry this has become a rant but generally from my experience, most in the public sector generally are trying their best and are trying to behave reasonably with often ,unreasonable customers . If we, as a society, want a decent service, then we should cough up and vote for those would achieve that.
Hope it makes sense.

DdraigGoch · 16/08/2022 14:16

PollyRockets · 16/08/2022 11:40

Do you really not understand the difference in time to investigate an online crime where there is easy to access evidence vs a burglary where they are so unlikely to be successful in finding who did it?

One takes a few hours tops and has near enough 100% success rate, the other can take weeks and with little chance of actually getting anywhere

Ah, so if we prioritise those trivial "crimes" (some of which aren't even crimes, but "incidents") that are easy to solve, rather than the ones that actually put fear into people, we can make the clear-up rate look better (on paper at least) and the Superintendent can get his promotion.

I think that it was known as an "administrative detection" back in the mid-2000s. Not sure what the practice is called now.

Yeah, I'm aware of how the state works. Pen-pushers are set targets and they look to achieve those targets, even if that's only technically rather than dealing with the actual problem. Just like "solving" a shortage of hospital beds by wedging five beds into a bay that's only designed and equipped to fit four. Meets the central target and there's no target for people who couldn't be resuscitated because there wasn't room to do it or the equipment wasn't close enough to the nearest socket/oxygen outlet to be plugged in. Just bully whistleblowers and the problem is solved.

countingsheep5678 · 16/08/2022 14:13

@HistoryKitty totally agree! When they brought in 'care in the community' without any real impact on the individual, the social services and the public it was catastrophic! I remember living in London and every morning a very unwell man would have to get a bus (I don't know where to)! He was clearly extremely mentally unwell and would scream to the top of his lungs on the bus, I felt sorry for him as he sounded terrified, I felt sorry for the children and other adults on the bus who weren't expecting him as they were terrified! He needed a carer to look after him... I imagine the police had to help him many times! I am so over this Pisa poor government underfunding and fucking everything up! Probably should have worded my original post like that than taking direct aim at the police!

OP posts:
peskyginge · 16/08/2022 14:07

Yes it needs change but most of that revolves around funding and pay. The police service has been eroded endlessly and people are leaving in their droves.
The expectations of the public are well beyond what is actually achievable. Recording standards state that whatever the public says has happened has to be investigated until it can be proven otherwise - which means hours and hours of time wasted on low level rubbish. The volume is overwhelming and as I said before the wider criminal justice system is not able to deal. On the flip side policing approach to violent crime, safeguarding and DV (I know some will disagree re DV but every allegation is investigated agin though the volume is off the scale) has improved. Often these types of crimes also take a lot of officer time - I know a crime scene recently that took 17 officers that didn’t even touch the detail of the investigation. Where do these officers come from????
Currently policing can only deal with the most serious matters because there are not enough officers - also we are being sent to ambulance calls, missing people often from care, mental health - self harm/crisis/welfare, social services - welfare for children/police protection. So while it’s not right someone was abusive to you as pervious posters have pointed out you have the service you voted for and listen too closely to the negative propaganda spewed on MSM. Personally I am an officer and I think policing in the UK as it has been known is over and can never be recovered, similarly to nursing, teaching. As I said people are completely blind to how are public services are being destroyed (and the cunning mantra is poor leadership/staff when really unless you have magicians who can magic something from nothing) and will wake up too late.

HistoryKitty · 16/08/2022 14:04

No you are totally right, it isn't fit for purpose at all. And maybe some of that fault lies with its senior management. But most of it lies with the Government, wider criminal justice system, MSM and to some extent, the general public.

The public do deserve better. The Police Officers also deserve better. But its not going to get better. Its only going to get worse. Chronic underfunding and the current cost of living crisis means all our public services, already under significant strain, are on the verge of taking a nose dive off a cliff. The Police are already picking up the slack for a lot of these services, which in turn is impacting on their performance. I doubt they're going to be able to continue to do that for much longer given the situation the country is in.

sst1234 · 16/08/2022 14:00

You are being unreasonable OP. The police are there to dress up and attend pride events. They are there to deal with non-crime hate incidents. They are there to put videos on tik tok. Let’s not be too harsh and expect them to….police.

the80sweregreat · 16/08/2022 14:00

They are underfunded, but like most big organizations those at the very top are paid eye watering amounts plus a great pension too
Maybe pay less money for them?
It's always the same with these public services
The CEOs of most councils or social services earn six figures but the council tax and services are mostly rubbish too , expensive. We never get what we pay for out of our taxes yet we all just put up with it.

OneTC · 16/08/2022 13:56

PollyRockets · 16/08/2022 13:52

Ones a specific crime that has evidence the other harassment at best with a low success rate of any form of arrest let alone conviction

Rape has a shocking conviction rate, shall we bump that even further down the list of priorities?

Johnnysgirl · 16/08/2022 13:54

PollyRockets · 16/08/2022 13:52

Ones a specific crime that has evidence the other harassment at best with a low success rate of any form of arrest let alone conviction

You are obsessed.

queenrollo · 16/08/2022 13:53

I will add that I was disappointed in my recent experience because I have always stood up for the police. I have several family members and friends who are really good Police staff. I've had a lot of ACAB types in my social circles for years and always challenged their view.
As you say OP it is the system that is broken, and letting down some really good people who are working a job that carries great risk and little public support.

I live in a rural area which is very understaffed and underfunded, more so than many other areas. We actually have a really good PCC but he hasn't got a magic wand.

PollyRockets · 16/08/2022 13:52

OneTC · 16/08/2022 13:31

Threatening to chuck your kid in the river is probably more offensive to most people than someone digging them out online

Ones a specific crime that has evidence the other harassment at best with a low success rate of any form of arrest let alone conviction

countingsheep5678 · 16/08/2022 13:49

@peskyginge can I ask why I am out of touch for saying the police is not fit for purpose? I am well aware of lack of funding but this highlights even more that it is isn't fit for purpose!

OP posts:
peskyginge · 16/08/2022 13:46

These types of posts just show how out of touch people are with the chronic underfunding of public services. This isn’t about not being bothered it’s about prioritising time. Most police time is spent picking up the chaos of other public services that literally can not function which usually involve vulnerable people which will take priority over most other things sadly.
The negative media has also skewed public opinion, the police are not full of sexist, racists people. And it’s the same police who have locked up those officers who deserve to be. But equally why would any officer in this day and age be pro active - it just results in edited MSM footage and officers having to be investigated by the useless IOPC for years for only doing their job.
finally you will find that it is not the police who don’t investigate your crime it is the wider criminal justice system (also completely broken) which will say it’s not in the public interest to continue - unfortunately crime like burglary are non violent (agree that they are actually very distressing) and therefore won’t end up in prison or with any real punishment. This is not the choice of the police.
If you can do a better job join the police, work the awful shifts for awful pay! Be spat at, hit, threatened daily, stroppy complaints for not being nice enough when you have just seen a child stabbed to death!

countingsheep5678 · 16/08/2022 13:44

@Suetwo it does scare me the neglect some of these teenagers must have suffered to be so vile! I read these awful cases of abuse that go unnoticed because of another stretched service (the social services) and wonder what actually is the government doing with our money?

* Just a general comment please don't think I am bashing all police officers because I am not. The man I spoke to Today had no people skills but I am crisitising the running of the organisation as a whole not individual officers who work bloody hard for little gain*

OP posts:
HistoryKitty · 16/08/2022 13:41

cormorant5 · 16/08/2022 13:14

'You think the police officers are hiding behind desks? Is that what you think they are doing ?? This just goes to prove that the public have absolutely NO idea what an officer does. I'm flabbergasted'

Well if you don't come out when we ask for you and then you try and change our thoughts for Twitter comments' what are we to think?

Maybe you should think.

Consider maybe police work also entails paperwork and a lengthy amount at that. Its not uncommon for a shoplift to take up eight hours of writing. Apply that concept to when an independent investigation is required. Once upon a time, Police could arrest and hand over to investigation teams to progress. That is not the case anymore. Officers have to deal with their own arrests and subsequent investigations (unless its an investigation that can be handed to a specialist department) whilst all the while having to respond to 999 calls that are continuously coming in.

Meanwhile they have to spend the majority of their time dealing with the absolute worst society has to offer, working a dangerous job, seeing awful things that most wouldn't be able to cope with emotionally and are having to watch their profession dragged through the mud because of a few bad apples.

Not defending the bad ones but every profession has them sadly. I still visit my GP despite Harold Shipman, Benjamin Geen, Beverly Allit, Lucy Letby, Barbara Salisbury, Colin Norris, Victorino Chua, etc. We are still happy to send our kids to nursery and school despite Vanessa George, Jayden McCarthy, Nisha Rani, Paul Wilson, Clare Cartwright and Thomas Clark.
Not surprised if their empathy and morale are through the floor at this point. Evidenced by their poor retention of officers right now. The Met have more people leaving then they are recruiting.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 16/08/2022 13:41

No, we want police to properly respond to and investigate crimes that matter. Like rape, burglary, assault, murder etc. NOT pissball about visiting and intimidating people who’ve tweeted an opinion others don’t like. Or copyright infringements or the like.

This.

Tanfastic · 16/08/2022 13:38

I'm a bit conflicted because dh is a retired police officer and worked really hard but found it very difficult in the latter years due to all the cuts that were made, replacing officers with pcso's etc and all the red tape and paperwork, it wasn't what he signed up for in the end and couldn't wait to retire.

I think it's another one of those services that needs a massive overhaul.

We've had to involve the police in a handful of things over the past few years and have found it hit and miss about whether they were "any good" or not.

If you have a hit and run don't even bother ringing them, happened to me recently and they wrote me a polite email advising me that although it was a road traffic offence to crash into someone's car and drive off it wasn't punishable by the police and just let the insurance company deal with it. In other words they just don't have the resources.

Another time dh intervened in a fight in the local pub when he was off duty got knocked almost unconscious by a single punch, a black eye etc as when he fell to the ground they kicked him in the head, the police wouldn't even arrest the culprit even though he was there in front of him but that was because he was waiting for back up which arrived too late. Luckily dh complained (as he knew the sergeant) they had cctv and found him through a bit if investigating.

Another time we were being harassed by a bunch of teenagers causing some issues outside our house and the police came round and looked at our cctv and went to the school and the school spoke to the parents.

So from my point of view it's hit and miss but it definitely isn't fit for purpose anymore.

Suetwo · 16/08/2022 13:38

The police officers I've met have all been pretty decent people. On the whole, I have been impressed. Be wary of constantly bashing them. If you do, the best will leave.

If you really want to reduce crime and build a better society, you must stop the worst people from having kids. I know that sounds extreme, but it's the truth. You must also deport criminals who came here illegally. So long as you allow ignorant, vicious, anti-social chavs to have as many kids as they like, so long as you allow illegal immigrants who've raped or robbed to keep delaying deportation, you'll just have to put up with violence and crime. Simple as that. There is a limit to what the police can do.

countingsheep5678 · 16/08/2022 13:37

@Magicpaintbrush as I said it's not fit for purpose!

OP posts:
strawberryshortcake1 · 16/08/2022 13:37

My law abiding husband who is asthmatic and diabetic was arrested in handcuffs from our home, at the height of lockdown, and chucked in a cell for 8 hours, for theft of an A4 paper sign our neighbours put on a bank of land between our homes. I returned A4 to the arresting officer. Someone round the corner had a campervan stolen and couldn't raise any interest from the police. Consequently we are extremely cynical and our faith in the police in our area is totally trashed.

TooBigForMyBoots · 16/08/2022 13:35

YANBU @countingsheep5678. Utterly unfit for purpose. But then after 12 years of Tory incompetence, chaos and corruption, nothing works in the UK anymore 😠