Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the police aren't fit for purpose

285 replies

countingsheep5678 · 16/08/2022 11:29

I am not talking about individuals who put their lives on the line, I'm talking about how police constabularies are run up and down the country.

I have experienced three quite horrible anti social incidents in the 'safe' area of Hertfordshire where I live! One a group of boys threatened to throw my toddler in the river and another a man threatened to smash my 'ducking' car in because I asked him to move a bag out of the road!

I want to speak to a local police officer to explain my concerns and ask if there would be more officers on the street and what they are doing about the anti social behaviour in the area. I managed to speak to someone who took all my details and said they'd pass it onto a safer neighbourhood team.

I asked when I would hear back... he couldn't tell me. I asked if I could speak to someone more senior as I wanted some reassurance quite soon, he said I would have to make a complaint if I wanted to speak to someone more senior. I asked if I could have the number of the safer neighbourhood team... they don't have a number. So essentially, unless I call 999 there and then there are no local police officers you can talk and engage with. I was also astounded by the lack of empathy the police officer I spoke to had. When you've been on the receiving end of horrible situations you want to feel reassured. I have got off the phone feeling more concerned about the safety of our neighbourhood than ever.

Just by luck I have seen my local safer neighbourhood police team are holding a surgery tomorrow... but surely we deserve better from the police? We need more open, direct access to them? Am I alone in thinking this?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
DdraigGoch · 16/08/2022 21:28

SaintHelena · 16/08/2022 13:32

Show me a public service in Britain that is adequately funded.

The House of Commons.

DdraigGoch · 16/08/2022 21:08

PollyRockets · 16/08/2022 12:34

@FOJN

Never said it was right

But am merely asking the posters who think it's ridiculous the police moan about cuts but can investigate what they consider minor crimes to engage their brains

They have limited hours in the day, why spend all of those investigating something that will most likely go no where, and with burglary insurance often covers the losses for the victims, whereas you could successfully investigate a handful of smaller issues with evidence.

Insurance might cover most of the value of what was lost but it won't do anything about the sense of violation that you get, knowing that your home isn't the safe space you thought it was.

What will do something about that? Criminals knowing that there is a very real chance of being caught, prosecuted, and ending up behind bars for a substantial length of time. Therefore making them reconsider whether it's worth doing in the first place.

VladmirsPoutine · 16/08/2022 21:07

Of course they aren't. They never have been. I find it bemusing that so many people are finding out what some people have known their whole lives. You'd have better luck jumping off the Eiffel tower and flapping your arms in an attempt to fly than finding a good, hard-working police officer.

DdraigGoch · 16/08/2022 20:58

I’m afraid there just aren’t enough of us. As for “hiding behind desks” our force has massively cut back room staff so that budget can be used to have the appearance of having more front line officers. But who do you think is fulfilling those admin tasks now? Yep, front line officers. I would love to “get out from behind my desk” more often, however not keeping up to date with paperwork is one of the things we are measured on and hauled over the coals about.

Are those admin tasks even necessary? How often do you find yourself filling in forms for your force and the CPS which essentially duplicate the information in one another; or which include information that is not strictly necessary and would be included in the statements if it were? How long do you spend on hold to CPS Direct for minor crimes that used to be dealt with by police solicitors?

Obviously I understand that these are out of your control, and that the power to do away with paperwork lies with ACPO ranks, the CPS and the Home Office.

In Canada, an officer will be back on the streets within an hour of bringing a prisoner in. How long does it take you? I've heard figures around the six hour mark before. In fact, for minor stuff the Canadians will deal with it on the street and just bail the person on the spot to appear in court on Monday.

SummerLovin123 · 16/08/2022 17:29

Well yes. The Police are MASSIVELY underfunded by our incompetent government.

MamaWingsIt · 16/08/2022 17:28

IfIHadAHeart · 16/08/2022 12:05

I’m afraid there just aren’t enough of us. As for “hiding behind desks” our force has massively cut back room staff so that budget can be used to have the appearance of having more front line officers. But who do you think is fulfilling those admin tasks now? Yep, front line officers. I would love to “get out from behind my desk” more often, however not keeping up to date with paperwork is one of the things we are measured on and hauled over the coals about.

In addition to that, a massive proportion of my time is taken up attending calls that other agencies would be far better placed to deal with, mostly mental health jobs. And every single one of those jobs causes more paperwork, safeguarding referrals etc.

There are bad eggs in every job but the majority of us want to be out there making a difference; it’s why we joined and the part of the job we enjoy. Unfortunately it’s not that simple.

This!!!

Thank you for what you do 😊 DH is in the same position as you, having a lot less time with us/young DC too due to being kept on jobs a lot longer than the shift is.

MamaWingsIt · 16/08/2022 17:26

DH is a PC.

He works hard, puts up with all sorts of shit and comes home some days/nights over 3 or 4 hours late because he isn't lazy and is doing the job he loves and is paid to do. We sacrifice so much as a family with young DC for him to still be able to do this job and he is very good at it.

DS is a detective and also does the same, if not more, given the nature of her job.

I think what my point is, they aren't all lazy before people start tarnishing them all with the same brush.

stillvicarinatutu · 16/08/2022 17:18

It's me again !

Police officer . SNT don't have a direct line because they'd spend most of they're day on the phone to people instead of being out on patrol or dealing with crime .
What happens is when you report something for the snt to look at it will go to a tasking queue . The tasking queue is often very busy with over 50 incidents to pick up . When I was a snt cop there was me and one pcso for the area I had responsibility for .
That was only 3 years ago .

Someone will get in touch - but it may take a while . We pick up the tasking queue in between warrants , days of targeted action , dealing with prisoners for shoplifting etc .
We need funding . And more officers. And more cars. And basic equipment. When I was on response I had to scrape the ice off the windscreen with the cars log book . No scrapers . No nothing . It's depressing.

CornishTiger · 16/08/2022 17:09

You can feedback in Hertfordshire to neighbourhoods team here.

www.herts.police.uk/advice/advice-and-information/wsi/watch-schemes-initiatives/echo/echo-community-feedback/

However in our area you can email in too and i find them really helpful.

Thelittleweasel · 16/08/2022 17:03

@countingsheep5678

How dreadful but you had the suggestion to "make a complaint". Find out the name of a local inspector and write a letter [not an e-mail etc] to that named individual saying what you feel is wrong. If you get no answer or action then follow it up. Clearly mark the letter "COMPLAINT" as so often they simply say "you did not make a formal complaint"

Tomhardyshadabath · 16/08/2022 16:48

Twelve years of major funding cuts. The majority of officers and staff are committed, decent, hard-working people, who cannot provide the service that they would like to because the service is dying on its arse. I'm not sure why everyone accepts that a desperate funding situation in the NHS has a direct correlation to the problems on the front line but can't make that connection with the police service. It's exactly the same problem.

countingsheep5678 · 16/08/2022 16:12

@oldbill93 thanks for your amazing response! I wish people like you were in charge of making the big decisions and could impact how the police is run! It feels like the people that should be in charge never are and the people at the top don't really have a clue! As I've said, there and thousands of amazing people working in the police but as an organisation it is not run in a way that gives credit to its hardworking staff or the public! The fact they got rid of all their admin staff and put it on to the police tells you everything you need to know!

OP posts:
daisyjgrey · 16/08/2022 15:57

I always think of the police the way I think of men.

Some (maybe most) police officers are good as individuals, as a collective, shit.

AndreaC74 · 16/08/2022 15:52

sst1234 · 16/08/2022 14:00

You are being unreasonable OP. The police are there to dress up and attend pride events. They are there to deal with non-crime hate incidents. They are there to put videos on tik tok. Let’s not be too harsh and expect them to….police.

The Police come under the Home Office, answerable to the Home Sec, if they really are sat around doing SFA, whose fault is that?

The Home Office (the Department) is the lead government department for crime, the police, drugs policy, immigration and passports, and counter terrorism. It has four priorities: cut crime; reduce immigration; prevent terrorism; and promote growth by keeping the UK safe

Who closed down almost all the public police stations? who cut numbers by 22000 ?

Aside, funny isn't that all the institution's that used to function (of sorts) Railways, Utilities, NHS, Roads... are now all deemed to be "Not Fit for Purpose"

The latest one identified by Truss and Sunak is her Majesties Government.

peskyginge · 16/08/2022 15:46

shootfromthehip145 - press charges for what? Serious ASB?? What is the actual criminal offence it’s not clear from your post.

shootfromthehip145 · 16/08/2022 15:29

From my last two dealings with the police they are as useless as a chocolate fire guard and don't give me its the we lack resources rubbish.

Last one I had some serious anti-social behavior and I had it all on CCTV and recorded they know exactly who it was and what they did. I was in fear for my life they turned up 8 hrs. later. We provided a statement and video evidence and in the end I asked them to leave my home, the officers refused to accept I wanted to press charges and take it further.

Very condescending they contently repeated we know best we will just have a word with the offender. I wanted to purse the matter as it has happened multiple times, it got until the point we were arguing with the police in my own front room and they were refusing to take it further as they knew best. In the end i got a call to say they had closed the case and I found out they never even visited the offender.

This has happened a couple of times, they are not interested. Lazy, lazy, lazy!

oldbill93 · 16/08/2022 15:26

Have NC'd for this post as am a police officer with over 25 years experience and sadly agree with your frustration as I feel it too.
When I joined we attended every shed break, burglary , theft and public order. However then we could finalise it / write it off with an entry in our pocket book or a paper crime report.
Now everything is computerised and measured. Officers spend hours updating crimes on their laptops, writing files for the CPS - years ago we had admin support staff who would do all those things so we could be out dealing with the public.
The police also pick up all the jobs other agencies can't get to / won't do. A lot of time is spent dealing with people with mental health problems/ attending calls that ambulance should go to/ welfare calls that social services should attend. We do it all.
Morale is rock bottom. However I recently spent the weekend with CID overseeing a serious sexual assault enquiry and everyone worked so hard on it. The victim could not have had a better service so it's unfair to say we don't care because we do. There just aren't enough of us.

Isaidnoalready · 16/08/2022 15:25

Ex husband regularly threatened to kill me hurt me make my life hell sorry call us back if he hits you call back ex is stalking financially abusing and coercive control ahhh but has he hit you? no? Can't do anything until he does just don't answer the phone just ignore what he says/does to the kids just ignore it unless you have proof 🤷 like all the texts saying I'm going to die the vandalism on my car that voukd have been fatal just ignore it all your clearly still alive whats the issue

Athenajm80 · 16/08/2022 15:20

I've had a couple of bad experiences of the police, but way more positive ones. As others have said, their hands are tied by stupid amounts of paperwork and the CPS deciding that there is no point in charging. Add into that mix a justice system which sadly isn't seen as a deterrent by many, and what feels like an increasing number of feral idiots who have no fear, and seem to spend their time committing crime, taking drugs, and breeding.

The police have come out to my area a few times over the years for various things, and when I've chatted to them, they will freely admit that they know who did it, but that it's often nigh on impossible to get the CPS to choose to prosecute based on the evidence (this is for things like car crime). It must be so frustrating for the police to do all the work, KNOW who the little scrote is, but then know he'll get away with it.

As for being able to contact your local community team, we have PACT meetings round here that I think are once a month. On the local police force website is an list of the PACT officers and their contact details, including an email. I'm not sure if that's a national thing or just my local force.

tiggergoesbounce · 16/08/2022 15:09

PollyRockets · 16/08/2022 11:30

We definitely deserve better

Unfortunately people keep voting for the opposite

This sums it up perfectly.

BluebellsareBlue · 16/08/2022 15:02

uhtredbebbanburg · 16/08/2022 14:56

I unfortunately had dealings with police Scotland yesterday and I have to say they were amazing. My vulnerable teen was missing for 11 hours and 2 officers stayed with me while they liaised with their Sergeant, tech side, boots on the pavement and the constabulary she was eventually found in. There was no judgement, and constant communication. I have them lots of tea and biscuits and my other 2 DCs wanted to watch a film with them. They didn’t eat a proper meal though it was offered.

Thank you!! Although I'm retired and we are one force now it's good to hear you had a good experience. Also I'm sorry that you had such a worrying time DaffodilFlowers

uhtredbebbanburg · 16/08/2022 14:56

I unfortunately had dealings with police Scotland yesterday and I have to say they were amazing. My vulnerable teen was missing for 11 hours and 2 officers stayed with me while they liaised with their Sergeant, tech side, boots on the pavement and the constabulary she was eventually found in. There was no judgement, and constant communication. I have them lots of tea and biscuits and my other 2 DCs wanted to watch a film with them. They didn’t eat a proper meal though it was offered.

hattie43 · 16/08/2022 14:51

Our local town and villages are becoming worse and worse for crime and anti social behaviour and unless the residents do something to sort it like neighbour watch groups out after dark I can't see anything changing .

CB1993 · 16/08/2022 14:49

@Georgeskitchen

'What the government should be looking at is the courts and the sometimes frankly pathetic sentences being given for some quite nasty and violent crimes.
Also need to put a stop to this ridiculous "none crime hate incident " malarkey.
If someone is offended by something they dont agree with the police should tell them to grow a pair of bollocks, build a bridge and get over themselves instead of pandering to them!!'

I could not agree more with this above!

I think part of the issue with the police (aside from lacking of funding & recruitment) is very low morale because of what a PP posted above. I have seen examples of where a member of public physically assaults a police officer or spits at them and the lack of sentencing/punishment from the CPS is absolutely disgusting. How are these criminals (especially youths of today who know get zero punishment so do whatever they want) meant to have any respect for police when the public can do something as callous as assault a police officer and get next to no punishment, there is no deterrent!

I commend the police and have huge respect for what they do, the majority of them will be doing their best with very little resources.

I agree with OP to an extent. There is flaws in the system. I don't believe individual officers are to blame. Intervention needs to come from higher up and rolled out across the board for consistency rather than one rule for one force & different for others.

ForfuckssakeEXHstopbeingatwat · 16/08/2022 14:42

Just want to say I've had two minor burglaries from an outbuilding and both times the police came round,, looked at the scene and second time sent forensics round to do a full sweep for evidence and DNA, and sent a separate officer round to take a statement. They aren't overly hopeful of catching or convicting anyone but I cannot fault their response. I also had two lengthy calls from them over a case of bullying at school where my DS had been threatened. School contacted police who spoke to me and went round to have a chat with the teenage bully. I won't say which force as outing but not in the SE.