Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the police aren't fit for purpose

285 replies

countingsheep5678 · 16/08/2022 11:29

I am not talking about individuals who put their lives on the line, I'm talking about how police constabularies are run up and down the country.

I have experienced three quite horrible anti social incidents in the 'safe' area of Hertfordshire where I live! One a group of boys threatened to throw my toddler in the river and another a man threatened to smash my 'ducking' car in because I asked him to move a bag out of the road!

I want to speak to a local police officer to explain my concerns and ask if there would be more officers on the street and what they are doing about the anti social behaviour in the area. I managed to speak to someone who took all my details and said they'd pass it onto a safer neighbourhood team.

I asked when I would hear back... he couldn't tell me. I asked if I could speak to someone more senior as I wanted some reassurance quite soon, he said I would have to make a complaint if I wanted to speak to someone more senior. I asked if I could have the number of the safer neighbourhood team... they don't have a number. So essentially, unless I call 999 there and then there are no local police officers you can talk and engage with. I was also astounded by the lack of empathy the police officer I spoke to had. When you've been on the receiving end of horrible situations you want to feel reassured. I have got off the phone feeling more concerned about the safety of our neighbourhood than ever.

Just by luck I have seen my local safer neighbourhood police team are holding a surgery tomorrow... but surely we deserve better from the police? We need more open, direct access to them? Am I alone in thinking this?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
stillvicarinatutu · 18/08/2022 01:37

Courts are a huge letdown .

For context - this month my force remanded a very very dangerous individual whose behaviour was escalating.

Remanded Friday . Court Monday . Court bailed this person . The following day they committed the most horrendous murder in cold blood . Facebook was full of people decrying police . But it wasn't the police . Police had remanded to court saying the behaviour was escalating to dangerous levels . A magistrate decided not . Magistrates have absolutely no legal training . They are just upstanding members of society. That's why I hate magistrates court and prefer crown court - at least there they all have legal training and know what their doing .
So gets released by court Monday .
Tuesday kills someone . Yeah now he'll be remanded for life - cps lawyer recommends whole life tariff . But someone had to die for that to happen . And that wasn't the fault of the police and yet plastered all over fb ....police are shit . Police knew . Police should have .....

DdraigGoch · 18/08/2022 01:15

Just seen yet another couple of scumbags laughing outside court because a judge has let them off with a non-custodial sentence.

This is where the problem lies. Recidivists need locking up for a decent length of time, if nothing else to give some respite to their long-suffering fellow citizens.

quietnightmare · 18/08/2022 00:16

The comments on here are ridiculous. The police aren't the problem and all those whinging about them they will be the first you call when you need help. The problem is criminals, how about all the idiots committing crimes stop doing that or is that too simple

stillvicarinatutu · 18/08/2022 00:06

Oh and the other issue ....

Police call handlers . Now I love ours . Work with them often . But it's run like a customer service call centre . So like today . I got a job whereby a woman phoned police because she was annoyed that the previous owner of the house had forgotten to update their address details for "boohoo" clothing and she had received 2 parcels for previous occupant. 2 parcels in 2 years. And she wanted police to tell the previous owner it was "unacceptable!"
And the call handlers said yes madam, course madam , 3 bags full madam and put a job on the active queue for an officer to do just that .

That officer happened to be me . And that caller was bitterly disappointed when I basically told her that this is not an offence , no crime had occurred, it is not a police matter , and how did she expect me to find said previous occupant in any case ? What the hell has a job like that got to do with police ?!! Police deal with criminality. We aren't some customer service rep for pissed off people who got accidental post !
But because that call handler had put a job on and said police would be in touch her expectations were that I'd deal with it for her . Well news flash - it's not a police matter . She was entitled and rude . 2 parcels in 2 years - it not like she was getting a parcel a week . And that job was out on for an officer to deal with . If officers answered the phones , and had some discretion to tell people essentially to get a grip - then we might actually be able to deal with crime . Not customer service gripes with royal mail. 🤷🏻‍♀️

TotalRhubarb · 18/08/2022 00:02

Felix125 · 17/08/2022 22:02

Womblesgash
Agree exactly - if a car makes off from police, the only way its going to stop is by crashing or stropping of its own accord. Its obviously looks like its not going to stop of its own accord - so the police can't just wait until it crashes.

We have to put something in place to stop it - best way to do this is by boxing the car in and bringing it to a controlled stop. You need at least 4-5 cop cars to do this safely

That's why it took 7 officers to stop him on this occasion. That's 7 officers pulled away from other things for someone who just didn't want to stop.

I can well imagine the media making mischief, for a story, and your explanation of what happens if somebody fails to stop, and why, makes sense.

Do we know why they tried to stop him in the first place? Was it justified? He seems very much of the opinion that it was a 'driving a flash car whilst black' pull.

For context, living in London in the Met jurisdiction, I see people driving while on the phone every day. To be fair, there aren't that many patrol cars visible any more, but even so, I have never seen the cops pull anyone over for doing that. Have a few times seen people drive erratically, swerve, skid over a stop line etc while a cop car or van is passing and felt sure the officers would pull them over, but they've just sailed past!

stillvicarinatutu · 17/08/2022 23:47

Felix125 · 17/08/2022 16:44

I think the focus on police has changed. Its now more preventing and managing threat, harm & risk.

For example
Incidents of domestic abuse which once were 'sorted' quite quickly by police years ago, now take several hours to do. The victim needs to be risk assessed and safe guarded - as with the offender. Rolling arrest attempts have to be completed etc etc....

Now this is a good thing, that we are taking such things more serious and safeguarding victims - but it will tie the officers up for most of the shift. And this type of incident will always trump a shed being broken into, or kids playing football in the street and shouting abuse - which will go on the back burner

Very quickly you will lose all the available cops of the shift to this - or guarding people at hospitals or mental health institutions

Ditto for incidents of missing from homes, people in mental health crisis, ambulances using police for the ones they can't get to as we are first aid trained.

Then you have the case files - which have become more & more bureaucratic - everything has to be redacted, BWV has to be uploaded and edited/redacted - so if a cop has their BWV (Body Worn Video) on for a 2 hour incident, they are going to have to find at least 2 hours (and more) to go through it all and edit/redact it. And the case file is important, otherwise the case doesn't get to court

I could go on and on about the stuff which is affecting police and the service we deliver - but once these new protocols & procedures are introduced, its very hard to go back over to how it use to be.

Absolutely this 100% .
It's tiring . And for us oldies - learning how to upload bwv and redact , no one trains you on the stuff you need daily , most you get in a mandatory online course that bores you half to death and you only get time to even look at it on a night shift at 4am when your eyes and brain have all but stopped working.
I manage the active queue now- and I make decisions daily that are above my pay grade . There are just too many jobs on the box for too few cops to get to . Throw in a murder (happens very often )and you soon run out of cops. It's relentless and unsustainable.

Felix125 · 17/08/2022 22:02

Womblesgash
Agree exactly - if a car makes off from police, the only way its going to stop is by crashing or stropping of its own accord. Its obviously looks like its not going to stop of its own accord - so the police can't just wait until it crashes.

We have to put something in place to stop it - best way to do this is by boxing the car in and bringing it to a controlled stop. You need at least 4-5 cop cars to do this safely

That's why it took 7 officers to stop him on this occasion. That's 7 officers pulled away from other things for someone who just didn't want to stop.

Felix125 · 17/08/2022 21:56

Isaidnoalready
I don't know about individual cases, but there are so many questions to ask here

How old was the child - were they interviewed?
What did the suspect say in his interview?

Did both accounts given mean that the witness could not add anything to the investigation?
Was there another reason why the witness was not used?
Was there forensic evidence that negated the case?
Did CPS drop the case without the requirement of the witness under their guidance?

Sexual assault on a child would have gone to CPS for a charging decision - probably why bail was extended twice. I'm pretty certain that CPS would have asked for a statement from the witness if it was needed before the case was dropped.

You need to go back to the OIC to get a full explanation as to why the case was dropped. You can also challenge the decision given by CPS and ask them for an explanation. This is the victim's right.

Womblesgash · 17/08/2022 21:51

That article about the athlete is exactly my point from earlier how people only get to hear one side of things and there are other things going on

samg76 you say why bother? As the article says the car didn’t stop at first so Officers will be very suspicious why that is…for example there could be drugs or weapons being hidden before it stops which DOES happen.

Also anyone wondering why 7 cop cars including firearms officers arrived…..its very probable that as the car didn’t stop at first police have to be prepared that it may continue to not stop and a pursuit could take place which carries an obvious major risk to other traffic and pedestrians so if that happens they need more resources there to deal with it like getting stingers there etc..

Firearms Officers are also more specially trained in dealing with vehicle pursuits than average cops too

Isaidnoalready · 17/08/2022 21:45

An allegation of sexual assault on a minor child needed to be investigated there was an alleged incident at a certain date a certain time with a witness willing to speak to the police man was arrested investigation begins bail extended twice witness never spoken too statements never taken case dropped due to lack of evidence, evidence freely offered but never looked at

Felix125 · 17/08/2022 19:57

samG76
Because people using their phone whilst driving kill people. Google the Bowburn Lorry crash - recent incident near us which killed 3 people and wrecked the lives of countless others (family & friends) - all because he was on his phone.

Armed police & traffic police tend to share roles & vehicles - ie traffic cops will be ARV cops too

If we can find his phone, the evidence will be there - phone logs etc. Or we can apply to use his account to show his phone was active at the material time.

Offences are always offences - COVID or otherwise. And we don't chase people because 'they hack us off'. If you're referring to de santos, he overtook the police car trying to stop him - what did you expect the police to do from that point?

WalkingOnTheCracks · 17/08/2022 19:49

with Covid it became a police discretion whether anything was or wasn't an offence,

What?

so obviously they went after people who had hacked them off for other reasons.

What?

So people lost even more respect

What?

Isn’t there some kind of algorithm to instantly delete weapons-grade nonsense?

samG76 · 17/08/2022 19:40

There was a piece yesterday about an athlete (de Santos?) who complained around racial harassment when his car was stopped by armed police who said they had been "concerned he may have been using his phone". Quite apart from whether armed police are really necessary for this, presumably he would have put his phone away by the time to spoke to him, so why bother? Or if they had actual evidence they could have sent him a FPN.

Many years ago it was probably easier to work out whether things were crimes or not (with some grey areas, obviously). But especially with Covid it became a police discretion whether anything was or wasn't an offence, so obviously they went after people who had hacked them off for other reasons. So people lost even more respect for them, and the cycle continues....

Valeriekat · 17/08/2022 19:21

PollyRockets · 16/08/2022 11:38

What a silly comment

Their job is not to make friends with people who might (with good reason) hate them.

Felix125 · 17/08/2022 16:46

I was thinking of posting on the AMA pages - 'I'm a cop, ask me anything'.

Not sure how it would go down though and what time I would have to reply to everyone

Felix125 · 17/08/2022 16:44

I think the focus on police has changed. Its now more preventing and managing threat, harm & risk.

For example
Incidents of domestic abuse which once were 'sorted' quite quickly by police years ago, now take several hours to do. The victim needs to be risk assessed and safe guarded - as with the offender. Rolling arrest attempts have to be completed etc etc....

Now this is a good thing, that we are taking such things more serious and safeguarding victims - but it will tie the officers up for most of the shift. And this type of incident will always trump a shed being broken into, or kids playing football in the street and shouting abuse - which will go on the back burner

Very quickly you will lose all the available cops of the shift to this - or guarding people at hospitals or mental health institutions

Ditto for incidents of missing from homes, people in mental health crisis, ambulances using police for the ones they can't get to as we are first aid trained.

Then you have the case files - which have become more & more bureaucratic - everything has to be redacted, BWV has to be uploaded and edited/redacted - so if a cop has their BWV (Body Worn Video) on for a 2 hour incident, they are going to have to find at least 2 hours (and more) to go through it all and edit/redact it. And the case file is important, otherwise the case doesn't get to court

I could go on and on about the stuff which is affecting police and the service we deliver - but once these new protocols & procedures are introduced, its very hard to go back over to how it use to be.

BelfastsChild · 17/08/2022 11:50

Yes there is some shit going on in the Met and PSNI
There have been calls for the last two years for PSNI Chief Constable Simon Byrne to step down, not least over his own and his officers' handling of the disappearance and death of young Noah Donohoe and this. Byrne was previously in the Met so perhaps that is where he learnt some of his conduct. TW for graphic description in image:

To think the police aren't fit for purpose
Vincitveritas · 17/08/2022 11:20

@WalkingOnTheCracks Thanks😆Which parts are unhinged exactly? And what is wrong with the military overseeing large crowded events? It happens during royal ceremonies for example. I don't mean they need to be armed to the teeth and firing tear gas left right and centre.

DdraigGoch · 17/08/2022 11:11

The government want more statistics than ever. Funnily enough like the NHS it's management and too many senior officers contributing to waste of time and dredging money. Too many chiefs and not enough Indians.

We're seeing the same on the railways. The government are insisting on a sign off for every piece of expenditure over £500 so the clerical staff are horrendously overworked - it costs more than that in the time it takes to fill out their spreadsheet in whatever format they want it in this week.

Meanwhile the DfT employs 50 civil servants to man-mark Avanti alone. That's 50 civil servants who aren't doing anything productive, just monitoring one "private" operator. Duplicate that for all of the operating companies in England which aren't devolved and the bureaucracy is incredibly bloated. Micromanagement to the nth degree.

Contrast that with BR which despite being officially nationalised had a considerable amount of independence. It was given an annual sum of money by the Treasury and left to get on with the job.

Sir Humphrey would have been proud.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 17/08/2022 11:09

@Vincitveritas

Parades/marches/concerts etc should be attended by the military

Well, the opening sentence gave us a clue as to how unhinged the rest of the post was likely to be, and you didn't disappoint.

Vincitveritas · 17/08/2022 10:53

Parades/marches/concerts etc should be attended by the military and the many hours of work spent on welfare checks and the like should be left to Social Services. Not going to happen though as they're also chronically underfunded! Every profession will have it's share of idiots, but I think unfortunately there may be a higher proportion in the Police Service due to the nature of the job. However, a few bad apples shouldn't spoil the barrel.

Also, parents need to take far more responsibility for the behaviour of their children. There's a majority on Mumsnet who feel they shouldn't discipline their children at all, even 'time out' seems controversial. How do they expect a child to grow up to be a good, law abiding citizen if there's absolutely no consequences for bad behaviour? Children need firm boundaries and strong leadership. As a PP said, there's so many feral teenagers these days, whose parents have no clue that they're terrorising old ladies at the bus depot or vandalising the local park while high on Spice - or worse, don't care.

Canada seems to have a much better way of doing things and we should definitely take a leaf out of their book.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 17/08/2022 10:27

brianixon · 16/08/2022 13:06

Police will not improve whilst they are run by Sergeants or senior ranks with attitudes they learned as Sergeants.
They need purposely trained Officers. In a similar way to the separate training of military.
Which we and most countries have got almost right.

As someone who comes from a family of coppers, of whom two rose to the highest ranks having started on the beat, I completely disagree with this.

One of the strengths of the police force is that the people at the top have done all the jobs on the way up.

Those who reach the top don't have 'attitudes learned as sergeants' otherwise they'd still be sergeants. What they do have, though, is an understanding of what it takes to be a sergeant.

My dad, born during the Second World War, just about the straightest bloke you could ever meet, and, by the end of his career, very near the top of his Force, was firmly opposed to National Service, and would disagree with you about the benefits of a military approach.

"I've had plenty of ex-military blokes come into the job, and all they ever seem to have learned in the Army is how to get away with doing close to bugger-all."

Also, I've never met a copper who didn't acknowledge that there are plenty of lazy, sexist, dim coppers. Just as I've never met a lawyer, doctor or teacher who didn't acknowledge that there are plenty of arseholes in their profession.

They're underfunded, it's true. But also, they are directed. As a senior copper of my acquaintance said, "You tend to get the police force the government thinks you want."

Vincitveritas · 17/08/2022 10:21

@Womblesgash That's the whole point though, it's so badly run that the entire system is collapsing. Police Officers shouldn't be doing hours of endless paperwork, that needs to be delegated to specific admin staff. People with mental health difficulties should be dealt with by medical staff with training in that area. Police should be combating criminal activity - that is their function.

Womblesgash · 17/08/2022 09:29

Most of the general public have no idea what is involved in being a police officer these days….how so much time is taken up with doing admin, GDPR, files to CPS, people in custody, safeguarding, data quality etc..the list goes on and on

And yes there are bad cops but the majority work very very hard and for little praise or thanks.

What really impacts the public perception of the police is how they are reported in the media and the press. There are always 2 sides to every story but so much anti-police stuff gets written these days and people lap it up without knowing the full facts. But hey, easy to bash the Police just like people do with teachers etc..

felulageller · 17/08/2022 09:11

I've seen the police be outrageously incompetent (as all other public services!) But have also seen where time is wasted due to other service deficiencies:

  • time sitting in court waiting rooms (can be all day and then never even get called!!)
  • teen runaways (children's homes aren't allowed to lock their doors at night like a family would so teens are allowed to run off and care homes have to report all of these to the police, even when everyone knows where they are/ who with/ what doing)
  • endless meetings regarding above teens
  • attending domestic abuse call outs when the perpetrator has a long history (don't let him out of jail just to reoffend/ go back home!)
  • welfare checks when families refuse to open their door to social workers
  • malicious calls (can we not issue fines for these?)
  • mental health/ suicidal ideation - need quicker access to MH services for kids and adults
  • they ignore cannabis use even though it's a gateway drug and causes no end of mental health and child welfare issues.

-they will pursue a child neglect charge if a child is home alone but do nothing for 'real' neglect. No criminal conviction leaves the perpetrator free to repeat causing more long term issues.

  • the forms for welfare/ non crime issues are several pages long, can take weeks to be written and just repeat info already known.