Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the police aren't fit for purpose

285 replies

countingsheep5678 · 16/08/2022 11:29

I am not talking about individuals who put their lives on the line, I'm talking about how police constabularies are run up and down the country.

I have experienced three quite horrible anti social incidents in the 'safe' area of Hertfordshire where I live! One a group of boys threatened to throw my toddler in the river and another a man threatened to smash my 'ducking' car in because I asked him to move a bag out of the road!

I want to speak to a local police officer to explain my concerns and ask if there would be more officers on the street and what they are doing about the anti social behaviour in the area. I managed to speak to someone who took all my details and said they'd pass it onto a safer neighbourhood team.

I asked when I would hear back... he couldn't tell me. I asked if I could speak to someone more senior as I wanted some reassurance quite soon, he said I would have to make a complaint if I wanted to speak to someone more senior. I asked if I could have the number of the safer neighbourhood team... they don't have a number. So essentially, unless I call 999 there and then there are no local police officers you can talk and engage with. I was also astounded by the lack of empathy the police officer I spoke to had. When you've been on the receiving end of horrible situations you want to feel reassured. I have got off the phone feeling more concerned about the safety of our neighbourhood than ever.

Just by luck I have seen my local safer neighbourhood police team are holding a surgery tomorrow... but surely we deserve better from the police? We need more open, direct access to them? Am I alone in thinking this?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Anewdayanewdawn · 16/08/2022 12:11

They are rubbish in our area. Had a few incidents including a break in and without CCTV the police said there was nothing to investigate. Burglars even left cans of beer they had drunk, finger prints and marks all over the place.
lazy, disinterested, and constantly using excuses for why they can’t be bothered to actually deal with crime.

Georgeskitchen · 16/08/2022 12:10

There is a big recruitment drive going on at the moment. Apparently they are halfway to their target of 20,000 new police officers on the beat by 2023.
Although in the experience of the close family member who has just been given a start date, they dont seem to be in too much of a hurry.
The recruitment process has taken about 6 months!!
What the government should be looking at is the courts and the sometimes frankly pathetic sentences being given for some quite nasty and violent crimes.
Also need to put a stop to this ridiculous "none crime hate incident " malarkey.
If someone is offended by something they dont agree with the police should tell them to grow a pair of bollocks, build a bridge and get over themselves instead of pandering to them!!

Dotjones · 16/08/2022 12:09

The police are in an impossible position. A police force which investigate every complaint thoroughly will be accused of being heavy handed, not using their common sense and a whole lot more. They'll be told they're only investigating a particular allegation because they're racist/sexist/homophobic/transphobic. A police force that thoroughly investigate everything will inevitably put a lot of time and resources into non-crimes and exaggerated (or straightforward made-up) incidents. Therefore they will be wasting resources.

What people seem to want is a police force that thoroughly investigates every actual crime but instantly dismisses the false allegations. It's understandable that people want that, but clearly impossible.

If we gave the police the ability to investigate everything then an awful lot of people would be upset. Every speeding driver, every cyclist who goes through a red light, everyone who has ever downloaded a copyrighted file from the internet (even once), everyone who'd had a bad day and made some ill-thought out joke on social media than someone took offence with - all these people would be dealing with the police and be threatened with a criminal conviction.

I doubt there are many people who've never breached some minor law or other. A properly funded police force will bring a police state.

MintJulia · 16/08/2022 12:09

I live in Hampshire and contact details for our local team are published in the parish mag and on their web site. I can see who is our local rural pcso, their email address & number, and the team email address.

Our nearest police station is 18 miles away, we get a lot of rural crime, so the police rely on the public to email them about vans parked up where they shouldn't be at 2am, hare coursing, farm thefts, drug dealing etc.

Not sure they would discuss policy though. They're busy doing the best they can with limited resources.

countingsheep5678 · 16/08/2022 12:09

@queenMab99 I am! But I don't think a once every sixth month surgery is good enough! I expect more!

OP posts:
countingsheep5678 · 16/08/2022 12:08

@IfIHadAHeart totally understand! But I should be able to speak directly to a police office, any time of the day, about my concerns! Is there anyway, as a police office, you can implement change from within? The system needs to work better and it doesn't! I understand it must be infuriating to work in but it's even more infuriating when the police are nowhere to be seen and anti social behaviour is just allowed to run rife!

OP posts:
IfIHadAHeart · 16/08/2022 12:05

I’m afraid there just aren’t enough of us. As for “hiding behind desks” our force has massively cut back room staff so that budget can be used to have the appearance of having more front line officers. But who do you think is fulfilling those admin tasks now? Yep, front line officers. I would love to “get out from behind my desk” more often, however not keeping up to date with paperwork is one of the things we are measured on and hauled over the coals about.

In addition to that, a massive proportion of my time is taken up attending calls that other agencies would be far better placed to deal with, mostly mental health jobs. And every single one of those jobs causes more paperwork, safeguarding referrals etc.

There are bad eggs in every job but the majority of us want to be out there making a difference; it’s why we joined and the part of the job we enjoy. Unfortunately it’s not that simple.

queenMab99 · 16/08/2022 12:05

I think you could class neighbourhood police surgeries as direct access, why don't you try going to one of those?

niceandsimple · 16/08/2022 12:04

My area used to have a police station and 2 community hubs within walking distance of my house. I used to regularly see police officers. When I see police now, it's an event. I call my children over to the window to see. And I live on the high street.
As an aside in 2010 I had a burglary, when I was home alone as a teenager, in the middle of the day on a Saturday - a chancer who saw we had scaffolding up. The police didn't cross my mind. At all. The only thing I thought was the street - it's safer on the street.

Goldpaw · 16/08/2022 12:04

The police have always been useless and unhelpful in my experience, and I agree with @Badbadbunny that it goes back to the 80s at least. They haven't suddenly become rubbish.

TotalRhubarb · 16/08/2022 12:03

Johnnysgirl · 16/08/2022 11:53

I thought it was quite a reasonable question, actually.

Me too.

I mentioned funding in my post, which is clearly a big factor. But institutional culture and priorities are just as instrumental.

It may well be that ‘clearing up’ inconsequential non-crimes, like somebody saying something on Twitter somebody else doesn’t like, is an easy gig for them that helps their stats look good. But the public they’re meant to serve want them to actually be effective in clearing up and preventing actual crimes that impact peoples’ lives.

The conviction rates for burglaries and rapes, to name just two crimes, are risible. That’s what they should be measured on, but they’ve stopped bothering even to investigate them. There’s a de facto licence to rape and burgle in this country right now. The chances of being caught and convicted are virtually nil. Hence OP not getting anywhere.

FOJN · 16/08/2022 12:02

PollyRockets · 16/08/2022 11:40

Do you really not understand the difference in time to investigate an online crime where there is easy to access evidence vs a burglary where they are so unlikely to be successful in finding who did it?

One takes a few hours tops and has near enough 100% success rate, the other can take weeks and with little chance of actually getting anywhere

Really? Serious crimes are more effort to investigate than hurt feelings and there is a lower chance of success so let's prioritise low hanging fruit?

Not sure you're qualified to be accusing others of making silly comments.

Jessica60 · 16/08/2022 12:01

Major underfunding for years. Low morale.

the80sweregreat · 16/08/2022 12:00

Every time we've had anything to do with the police it's been a bit shambolic tbh
' here is a crime number '
Or knocking days later after reporting anything
Or not following anything up.
Yet if I did anything wrong or go two inches over a yellow box by mistake ( because you can't move forwards enough or misjudged it) and here is a 65 quid fine
Quick enough with anything like that of course

balalake · 16/08/2022 12:00

YANBU, others have pointed out the main reasons.

PuttingOnMyBestBra · 16/08/2022 11:59

I was thinkingthe same @countingsheep5678 , we need more people like @Badbadbunny
I bet its frustrating for those good officers who see the despair people are facing everyday too

countingsheep5678 · 16/08/2022 11:56

@Badbadbunny how utterly depressing! I take it you're not in the police now? I wish you were... policing needs more people like you xxxx

OP posts:
Johnnysgirl · 16/08/2022 11:53

PollyRockets · 16/08/2022 11:38

What a silly comment

I thought it was quite a reasonable question, actually.

Badbadbunny · 16/08/2022 11:51

You're not wrong, but it's been decades in the making. I was a special constable in the late 1980s and was aghast at just how lazy many of the police officers were and even back then, how they would only do things that could "tick their boxes". Proactivity was basically zero! They'd only do something if they really had to. I did quite a few "overnight" shifts, mostly with regular constables, but sometimes with another special or even on my own. I hated working with the regulars because they'd just park up to have a smoke several times over the shift, or go home/to friend's houses for brews, unless they were actively being given jobs to attend. When I worked on my own or with other specials, we'd walk the back alleys, check shop doors etc (old fashioned policing), and just by walking around, we'd find crimes - in the early hours when it's all silent, you can hear glass breaking from several streets away, and that's how I arrested several burglars, seen running away from the direction of the broken glass. By contrast I was once on foot patrol with a regular at a similar time, heard breaking glass, and he just carried on, I thought he'd not heard it and mentioned it, but he just said "we'll wait to see if anyone reports it".

countingsheep5678 · 16/08/2022 11:49

@womaninatightspot so frustrating! Sorry but hiding behind desks is not on!

OP posts:
womaninatightspot · 16/08/2022 11:46

In the town where I work they’ve shut down the police station and moved them into a section of council offices with a separate door. There’s no longer a counter so you can’t speak to anyone. Just a yellow phone outside so you can call. Nearest police station with a counter is over half hour drive. They never come out on foot apart from to buy food. Teenagers vandalising public square directly outside without a care.

countingsheep5678 · 16/08/2022 11:44

I get the cuts! But I just think it is run appallingly! Surely with my complaint I should have been able to call our safer neighbourhood team directly! Not phone one person to push a bit of a paper to another person and not even tell me how long I would have to wait for a call back! So awfully inefficient! If police forces were run like businesses I swear it would be much better. Also, too many people behind desks and not enough visible police out and about. They manage to find enough police to patrol around the Houses of Parliament but the rest of us plebs are left to deal with disgusting anti social behaviour. I felt safer living in London than where I live now. Thanks for ranting along with me xxx

OP posts:
MistyGreenAndBlue · 16/08/2022 11:44

PollyRockets · 16/08/2022 11:40

Do you really not understand the difference in time to investigate an online crime where there is easy to access evidence vs a burglary where they are so unlikely to be successful in finding who did it?

One takes a few hours tops and has near enough 100% success rate, the other can take weeks and with little chance of actually getting anywhere

So? What's your point?

And really? Online crime?
Offending someone on Twitter is NOT a crime and is, therefore, non of the police's business anyway.

the80sweregreat · 16/08/2022 11:43

What has the current opposition party got to do with police cuts and now being a service rather than an actual force?
It's definitely got worse over the years and I'm sorry you had this experience.
I lost faith in them years ago. Like most public services they are broken and most do not care either. It's become the norm now not to expect too much from them.

PollyRockets · 16/08/2022 11:41

@whentheraincame

Considering I also support the police questioning and arresting those who post offensively online why would i have issue with Labour doing this?

If they did I'd actively support them