Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the police aren't fit for purpose

285 replies

countingsheep5678 · 16/08/2022 11:29

I am not talking about individuals who put their lives on the line, I'm talking about how police constabularies are run up and down the country.

I have experienced three quite horrible anti social incidents in the 'safe' area of Hertfordshire where I live! One a group of boys threatened to throw my toddler in the river and another a man threatened to smash my 'ducking' car in because I asked him to move a bag out of the road!

I want to speak to a local police officer to explain my concerns and ask if there would be more officers on the street and what they are doing about the anti social behaviour in the area. I managed to speak to someone who took all my details and said they'd pass it onto a safer neighbourhood team.

I asked when I would hear back... he couldn't tell me. I asked if I could speak to someone more senior as I wanted some reassurance quite soon, he said I would have to make a complaint if I wanted to speak to someone more senior. I asked if I could have the number of the safer neighbourhood team... they don't have a number. So essentially, unless I call 999 there and then there are no local police officers you can talk and engage with. I was also astounded by the lack of empathy the police officer I spoke to had. When you've been on the receiving end of horrible situations you want to feel reassured. I have got off the phone feeling more concerned about the safety of our neighbourhood than ever.

Just by luck I have seen my local safer neighbourhood police team are holding a surgery tomorrow... but surely we deserve better from the police? We need more open, direct access to them? Am I alone in thinking this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
11
Felix125 · 21/08/2022 15:53

Snowraingain
I agree - there should have been someone available, but inevitably we run out of resources.

You then have to way up diverting someone from one job to that one - and we all might be on jobs that we just can't divert from. As stillvicarinatutu listed before, hospital guards, mental health cases, custody queues with prisoners, safeguarding vulnerable victims etc etc

We have to weigh up weather a wing mirror is more important than a life.

Snowraingain · 21/08/2022 15:04

Sadly I only have bad examples. I think the police do their best and I don’t blame them

Another experience for me was when we were woken up my a commotion. Some man was going along the road ripping the side mirrors off cars and kicking in the sides of cars. He did about five in the time it took my oh to get his trousers and trainers on and out the front door. Oh ran after him with my neighbour and caught him. My oh is pretty fit and strong so this bloke wasn’t going anywhere. Neighbour called the police. No one came. The call handler was very nice but said there was no one and wouldn’t be anyone and to let him go.
He had damaged a total of nine cars.

Felix125 · 21/08/2022 11:51

Its the same old scenario - receive a good service and you tell no one, receive a bad service and you tell the world

I'm still interested in how people who are against the police service would like to see it run - baring in mind the resources and procedures we have. What changes would they make if they were in charge and what effect do they think it would have?

quietnightmare · 21/08/2022 10:20

Summergarden · 21/08/2022 08:22

I must admit that since the Sarah Everard case my confidence and trust in the police has plummeted. I still find it hard to get my head around the fact that a poor young woman was murdered by someone in uniform that we should be able to trust.

Plus then there was the case soon after of the poor black ladies who were murdered in a London park and when the police arrived, one of the officers sent photos of the corpses to his friends in a WhatsApp group, with words of contempt that it was their fault anyway because they had broken lockdown rules (when they actually hadn’t).

I’m sure I read another similar case a few days ago too.

I used to hold the police in such high regard and trusted that they were doing the right thing. I’m sure some are, but not all.

Have you lost faith in doctors because of Harold shipman or teachers/teaching assistants because of Maxine carr, I doubt it! For all the negative incidents we here about the police they are undoubtedly trumped by the amount of good and solid policing that just doesn't even get mentioned to the public

Vincitveritas · 21/08/2022 09:14

stillvicarinatutu · 20/08/2022 22:36

The police (of which I one ) are not fit for purpose anymore.

Because it's a service .
Because there aren't enough of us
Because we're doing the job of mental health teams and social services
Because we don't have the time
Because we don't have the resources
Because it's run by fucking imbeciles
That's the truth . The front line tries. We really do try .

Hit the nail on the head.👌

VladmirsPoutine · 21/08/2022 08:25

Plus then there was the case soon after of the poor black ladies who were murdered in a London park and when the police arrived, one of the officers sent photos of the corpses to his friends in a WhatsApp group, with words of contempt that it was their fault anyway because they had broken lockdown rules (when they actually hadn’t).

Bibaa Henry and Nicole Smallman. To be defaced in death! By the police no less! I honestly think the police are worse than some of the criminals they purport to 'protect' us from.

Summergarden · 21/08/2022 08:22

I must admit that since the Sarah Everard case my confidence and trust in the police has plummeted. I still find it hard to get my head around the fact that a poor young woman was murdered by someone in uniform that we should be able to trust.

Plus then there was the case soon after of the poor black ladies who were murdered in a London park and when the police arrived, one of the officers sent photos of the corpses to his friends in a WhatsApp group, with words of contempt that it was their fault anyway because they had broken lockdown rules (when they actually hadn’t).

I’m sure I read another similar case a few days ago too.

I used to hold the police in such high regard and trusted that they were doing the right thing. I’m sure some are, but not all.

Snowraingain · 21/08/2022 07:38

My OH’s van was stolen. A friend happened to see it next to a breakers yard. By the time we got there it was in the yard - we could see the top of it but there was no way into the yard. The police didn’t have anyone to come! It was right there they were committing a crime right there.
A few days later we got a call from the council (the van has his company name and phone number on it) saying we needed to move the dumped van. It was now outside the breakers yard completely stripped! Literally outside.
The police never called us back.

Yesterday when I was walking my dog I saw a two foot long machete stuck into the ground behind a bush. I called 101 and they said that was of interest but no one would come.

TellySavalashairbrush · 21/08/2022 07:36

Many of these responses make my blood boil. I do agree with the poster who states that the front liners are doing their best but are under resourced and let down by crap management . My dd is a police officer and it is awful to hear the amount of abuse she gets, just trying to do her job. She has been kicked, spat at and throttled, is regularly called a racist (she definitely isn’t) all while trying to help others. It’s a thankless task.

SaintHelena · 21/08/2022 07:14

Almost half of murder victims - as well as suspects - were black despite the ethnic group accounting for just 13% of London's population.
White people in London make up 60% of the population, but only account for 35% of murder victims and 24% of murder suspects.

news.sky.com/story/black-murder-victims-and-suspects-london-v-uk-11443656 2018 article
So half of murder suspects are black, might explain the reason for more tasering

loislovesstewie · 21/08/2022 06:56

My husband died suddenly earlier in the year. As it was a sudden death the police attended, at one point there were 4 of them in my house. They couldn't have behaved better, they were kind, sympathetic and understanding. Just to give an example of good policing.

stillvicarinatutu · 21/08/2022 01:03

Right .
If you work as a police officer in a white
Community the criminals will be white .
If you work in a predominantly Asian community the criminals will be predominantly Asian .
If you work in a predominantly black community the criminals will be predominantly black.

That's not racist . That's demographics. Crime doesn't just happen to one particular race .

Last week one of sgts tasered a white murderer. It's not because he was white . It's cos he murdered a man in cold blood .

What ar people not getting? Criminals can be of any demographic and any colour . White black Asian Chinese , Slovak , Romanian , polish , - any demographic. What would you like police to do ?
Not taser black people? White people? Slovak people ? Autistic people? If someone is armed or offering violence they are gonna get tasered whatever colour they happen to be !

VladmirsPoutine · 21/08/2022 00:22

If the met police was regularly armed like say in America, we'd be having to step over black bodies on our way to get lunch from Pret, it would be that bad.

www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2021/aug/25/black-people-more-likely-to-be-tasered-for-longer-police-watchdog-finds

stillvicarinatutu · 21/08/2022 00:14

White people are also stopped if they match a description of someone who has committed a crime. It doesn't mean they are guilty. It means they COULD be a suspect - they'll be stopped , questioned and let on they're way . Same as anyone . That's the job - stop people who may have been involved in a criminal act and ask questions. It doesn't matter what colour they are if they fit the description of someone who has comm a crime . If they're not involved they'll be left to go on their way . If they are suspected they'll be arrested. Even that doesn't mean guilt - you can arrest on suspicion of an offence - to obtain evidence by questioning- or not . Arresting someone doesn't automatically mean guilt . But the police have to stop people and question them - we'd never bloody get to the bottom of anything otherwise . We have to talk to people to ascertain what's happened. That's not a cultural or race issue - I work in a predominantly white and Asian community- I can't avoid stopping Asian people just because they're Asian ! If they fit a description of someone who committed a crime I'm gonna question them! Same as if they were black , white , brown , or sky blue pink with yellow dots on .
That's how police catch criminals. That thing g you all think we're rubbish at !!!

stillvicarinatutu · 21/08/2022 00:03

VladmirsPoutine · 20/08/2022 23:54

The police is institutionally racist. That's not mere opinion. The police being afraid of being called racist is a bit like worrying you'll get wet in the shower.

No they are not . I have friends of colour and mixed race and Asian .
The police are not institutionally racist . That's what people peddle because they don't like it when a criminal is Asian or mixed race or of colour . The colour of your skin is not a get out of jail free card . Your behaviour is what the police will deal with - not what colour you are .
To say otherwise is simply racism in reverse . So we should turn a blind eye when a criminal is of colour ? Or Asian ? Or missed race ? Criminality is not restricted to one race or colour . The police deal with criminality. Not a colour .

VladmirsPoutine · 21/08/2022 00:02

I no longer have any faith in the police.

No longer does one of my nephews. He was running towards Victoria station (to catch imminent train departure), grabbed by two officers, and questioned by another what he was running away from. Him, breathless, pointing at the station says "my train", another officer arrives and tells him not to move and asks what he's carrying in his bag. Curiously in his bag was his laptop and tepid bottle of water. Oddly enough the result wasn't just a missed train; he was left with a nice hefty dose of anxiety to deal with. When the police ask him about himself, I've told him not to tell them he is/was studying law because no doubt a few grams of coke will turn up in his backpack once they take him to the station.

VladmirsPoutine · 20/08/2022 23:54

The police is institutionally racist. That's not mere opinion. The police being afraid of being called racist is a bit like worrying you'll get wet in the shower.

Lolliepoppie · 20/08/2022 23:53

I was burgled for the second time in a week. The non emergency call handler (after a 40 minute wait to get through) said “that must be annoying” and declined to send anyone out to investigate.

My home felt alien and unsafe. Irreplaceable family mementoes were taken. I still sleep with the light on 3 years later. I no longer have any faith in the police.

stillvicarinatutu · 20/08/2022 23:47

VladmirsPoutine · 20/08/2022 23:42

Plus social media . No wonder the police have to tread carefully in some instances.

Just on this point, I've said this before and I genuinely think smartphones are in the top 10 best inventions in the history of inventions. I'm not being even slightly facetious or hyperbolic. That we can now live record what has been happening for decades is frankly amazing. Imagine just how many lives the police ruined before we were able to whip out our smartphones? Just how many black men and boys' lives utterly destroyed? The phones certainly help keep them in check. Whenever I see a black boy being questioned I get my phone out before I've even gone over. When the police stopped me curiously wondering if the car was mine because it's expensive I made a point of switching on my in-car monitor Smile

Bollocks .

You will get a snapshot of what's happening without any knowledge as to why .
This is exactly why the scandals happened in Rotherham and Oldham 🙈 because people were so scared of being called racists they allowed crimes to happen simy
Because the perpetrators were Asian or of colour . Crime doesn't just happen to one race . Crime isn't just committed by one race . The police are so
Up against this shit now because people do whip the phone out without any knowledge of why that person is being arrested or searched or detained . What are police (me !) meant to do ? Ignore crime being committed because of the colour of a persons skin ?

VladmirsPoutine · 20/08/2022 23:42

Plus social media . No wonder the police have to tread carefully in some instances.

Just on this point, I've said this before and I genuinely think smartphones are in the top 10 best inventions in the history of inventions. I'm not being even slightly facetious or hyperbolic. That we can now live record what has been happening for decades is frankly amazing. Imagine just how many lives the police ruined before we were able to whip out our smartphones? Just how many black men and boys' lives utterly destroyed? The phones certainly help keep them in check. Whenever I see a black boy being questioned I get my phone out before I've even gone over. When the police stopped me curiously wondering if the car was mine because it's expensive I made a point of switching on my in-car monitor Smile

deepathinka · 20/08/2022 23:37

This country is slowly breaking down

stillvicarinatutu · 20/08/2022 23:15

What truly pisses me off is when I see burglaries sit on the active queue for days .
Csi go . But no cops are free . We just have no one free to go . Our active queue is regularly over 100 incidents . And there might be 10 cops to deal with that if you're lucky . Throw in a murder scene and a prisoner or 3 and there's no cops left . So those calls for someone kicking a dog , or a neighbour dispute , or a suspicious car or kids smoking weed in a park - forget it . There just aren't the resources to deal with it . We're too busy looking for kids that have walked out of a care home in front of the staff who can't stop them , or looking for a hospital patient who walked out in front of security but they didn't stop them , or sitting prisoners in custody because they've plugged their heroin stash up their arse , or sitting mental health patients in the 136 suite because the on call psychiatric doctor can't get there for 3 hours. Or sitting murder scenes because there's no one else to do it . Ir dealing with prisoners in the cells . Or sitting on cannabis factories for 12 hours with its food or drink or a loo break .
It's shit . The jobs fucked . Gone are the days you could actually a difference by patrolling and catching criminals . Now we just respond after the event . Because there simply aren't enough cops to police effectively.

DdraigGoch · 20/08/2022 23:11

As for the sprinter - maybe he should have stopped, he probably does see a police car and sigh because he knows they'll pull him over for no reason. Why on earth does the Met have the resources to pull over "black people in flash cars" and victimise women who attended the Sarah Everard vigil, but not actually deal with all the stabbings going on in London?

On the first occasion that he was pulled over, wasn't he weaving all over the road?

deepathinka · 20/08/2022 23:02

stillvicarinatutu · 20/08/2022 22:36

The police (of which I one ) are not fit for purpose anymore.

Because it's a service .
Because there aren't enough of us
Because we're doing the job of mental health teams and social services
Because we don't have the time
Because we don't have the resources
Because it's run by fucking imbeciles
That's the truth . The front line tries. We really do try .

Well this is what happens when there is a suing culture . Plus social media . No wonder the police have to tread carefully in some instances.

stillvicarinatutu · 20/08/2022 22:36

The police (of which I one ) are not fit for purpose anymore.

Because it's a service .
Because there aren't enough of us
Because we're doing the job of mental health teams and social services
Because we don't have the time
Because we don't have the resources
Because it's run by fucking imbeciles
That's the truth . The front line tries. We really do try .