Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to get a 'worse but bigger car' for the sake of DD2 not having an isofix base?

41 replies

Sausagechipsandbean · 16/08/2022 08:55

I have a 2012 Seat Ibiza. It's been reliable for us and has just past it's MOT. We own it outright. It's not any great shakes but it's perfectly acceptable.
I am pregnant, due in October and we have a DD who is 2. Money is tight but luckily we have everything we need for baby practically already as we kept everything of DDs and know this little one is a girl too. We have a Maxi Cosi car seat for DD and an isofix base which she's always had; we still have the newborn car seat she was in until she was about 9 months before we moved her to the next size up (pebble). The problem is the isofix itself; because of the way the leg sits it pushes the passenger seat forward pretty much as far as it will go. Neither DH or I would be able to drive if the driver's seat was pushed that far forward so my suggestion to DH was we buy DD a new car seat that can go behind the driver's seat without an isofix (the Pebble can't be strapped in without the isofix) and new baby has the current set up with the isofix.
DH wants to try and sell the car and buy a bigger car so we can buy a new isofix for baby and have both children with an isofix. My car is not worth much; it's good for us but realistically it's maybe worth £1500 if that so to buy a bigger can from what we can see currently we would have to get an older car with higher mileage to accommodate this.
Is it really so bad to take DD who will be 2 years 7 months when baby is here out of an isofix. Surely millions of children use car seats without an isofix and are perfectly safe. And for the sake of keeping a car that at least we know is good enough for what we need now is surely better than getting a 'worse' car just to accommodate the child seat?

OP posts:
GlitteryGreen · 16/08/2022 09:22

I was actually advised by someone at a car seat company to use the base for the first seat and then just get one with a built-in base for the next stage as it's just as safe and better value for money.

Sausagechipsandbean · 16/08/2022 09:20

@tooearlyortoolate thank you, I didn't know car seats like that were an option, I'll have a Google. That may be the compromise we need.

OP posts:
Mummysgonetobed · 16/08/2022 09:20

Isofix doesn’t necessarily make the install safer, it’s just an easier method and therefore less room for human error, which could make a seat unsafe.

i absolutely wouldn’t change a car just for isofix. You might find you want a larger car down the line but I’d just be buying a decent belted seat for your 2 year old (I’m a fan of Joie seats myself!)

EverydayIsPJday · 16/08/2022 09:18

I'd change the car based on space. I had a fiesta I ADORED but got rid when ds2 was 5 weeks old and ds1 was 2yrs 4 months because it was a nightmare trying to squeeze everything in. There are scooters, bikes, balls, more shopping bags etc that have to go somewhere. I used to have to shove them in the footwell as I'd run out of space. I now have a zafira I loathe tbh but I don't even blink when I have to put buggy and shopping in.

Sausagechipsandbean · 16/08/2022 09:17

The car has plenty of boot space so I'm not worried about having enough space for weekends away which are honestly extremely rare events anyway and will be for the foreseeable future. Yes, it is uncomfortable for us at the moment compared to if we had more leg room but it's not bothersome enough that I think it's worth downgrading the car altogether and the majority of the time, if we're all going somewhere together DH drives so I'm the one in the passenger seat so it's not really DHs problem that the passenger seat is uncomfortable.

OP posts:
NannyR · 16/08/2022 09:16

A car seat fitted with isofix isn't necessarily safer than one fitted securely and correctly with a seatbelt, isofix is just an easier, fail safe way of fitting a car seat correctly. If you are confident that you can fit a belted seat correctly it will be just as safe.

mattressspring · 16/08/2022 09:14

I wouldn't compromise on mechanical safety just to have an isofix, no. That's not to say all > 10 year old cars are unsafe, but for the money you are talking you are going to have limited choice which basically pushes you into the more risky motors. I know some people get absolutely bargains and run them for years but there is no guarantee and more people have bought a £1.5k car which has run into more expense than haven't. Keep the car you have, nobody needs a bigger car for 2 children either. The strange thing for having a huge car for 2 kids and a 7 swather for 3 isn't necessary. A small family car is adequate, you just have to compromise on the fitting of your care seat and the size of your pram.

toomanyhobbies · 16/08/2022 09:14

There are lots of car seats that have the isofix (the arms that slide between the seat and the back and clip on to the little ring thingys) that don’t have the big bases with a leg. Have you looked at those?

Louise0701 · 16/08/2022 09:13

You will need a bigger car with 2 children. You won’t fit a pram plus luggage into an ibiza nor would you get a pram + bike / scooter I imagine.

Longtimeposternc · 16/08/2022 09:10

“If we look at all data, crash test, real life usage, and habits, Isofix is far safer than installing a car seat with seat belt. With Isofix, virtually no mistakes are made, something which can not be said about seat belt installs”

Longtimeposternc · 16/08/2022 09:10

I think isofix bases are safer so I would do the same

tooearlyortoolate · 16/08/2022 09:10

We have a cuggl car seat which has isofix built in and no base. You can use it with or without the isofix which means it's easily swapped about with friends and grandparents cars if needed. Cheaper than a new car!

JellyBellybutton · 16/08/2022 09:09

Yes he's being ridiculous. My kids dont have isofix seats because although my car has it, our van doesn't and we need to be able to swap between. Just research belted car seats properly and choose one you're happy with.

Tohaveandtohold · 16/08/2022 09:08

A bigger car that’s £1500 will not be worth it at all, it’ll be old, high mileage and I can bet will be having lots of issues. Except if you’ll be adding more money to buy something worthwhile. At least you know the history of your Small car and you can rely on it.
I personally will buy a normal car seat without an Isofix for dd1 to seat behind you and use the isofix at the passenger side for the baby.

Tigofigo · 16/08/2022 09:06

You can get non isofix extended rear facing seats, BeSafe is a good brand.

But I agree with pp who said you might find you want a bigger car anyway, we go camping and couldn't do without our big estate car now!

ShadowPuppets · 16/08/2022 09:02

Surely the benefit of a bigger car - aside from the isofix issue - is that it’ll be more comfortable for longer journeys and also more space for luggage? We have a newborn and a 2 year old and upgraded car size when we knew newborn was on the way. Yes, we could have got the two car seats in the Fiesta (no isofix) but we’d have never got the double buggy, a travelcot, and enough stuff for a weekend away into the boot… gone are the days where we could go away for the weekend with one overnight bag 😁

Re Isofix, I think strap in car seats are perfectly safe but when looking at replacing the car I was really reassured by the presence of Isofix. It doesn’t sound very comfy for the passenger to be pushed all the way forward anyway? But I guess it depends how often you do long journeys.