Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be confused about social services

427 replies

whentheraincame · 15/08/2022 19:06

Bit of a long one but it's something I have thought about a long time. There's two narratives:

SS don't do enough; don't act to remove children in obvious danger (happens sometimes of course)

SS are overzealous; remove children from loving homes (going to happen at times, right?)

there was a show over ten years ago called I Want my Baby Back and it was absolutely heartbreaking and admittedly it terrified me. Basically hairline fractures were found in children and parents were blamed for abuse. The argument was (I forget details and could never watch again) from some doctors that these were the result of Vitamin D deficiency (which let's face it, was endemic a while back and in the news loads)

So the argument was those children were wrongly removed. One mother cried "I want my baby" and honestly it's never left me. I'll have a cry about this later as I always do if I think too much about a child being removed from a loving mum.

So my question is if anyone has proper insight. I'm scared of SS in general. Although I actually had involvement with them myself when I left an abusive ex and they came to check I was not going to go back, nothing further happened once they met me - so proof they are fine I guess.

But I remember seeing a lady on the news, well spoken, and saying SS need to return her children who were removed. I had a friend tell me in work once that a friend with undiagnosed autism got the children removed due an incident where one got hurt by the other (which happens. these things happen, children do get hurt and it's often an accident that couldn't be prevented)

I guess I just don't want to see SS as evil child snatchers, and want insight into how they operate in reality and what actually gets children removed from parents' care?

OP posts:
Cassimin · 17/08/2022 10:21

SnowWhitesSM · Today 08:00
Foster carer - lovingly cooks nutritious food.
Foster dc - doesn't eat the food and feels funny about it. Can't explain why.
Foster carer - this is what you're eating, look how hard I worked to cooked this, eat up your veg it's so good for you. You want to grow big and strong don't you.
Foster dc - yuk I hate your food. May or may not throw food.
Foster carer upset. Fdc upset.

I think you’ve been reading Tracey Beaker

Cassimin · 17/08/2022 10:16

SnowWhitesSM
thanks , smug and I talk a load of bollocks.
If you are a social worker you certainly are a very judgemental one.
i don’t sit and lecture our fc about the food I prepare, I prepare it. If they eat it great if not they have something else. Fc was 3 when then came, they didn’t know food was unhealthy.
I didn’t say parents turned up with alcohol I said drinks, meaning they could have brought one for child while they were in the shop.
i (and they) wanted to have days outside of the contact centre, surely an afternoon at the swimming baths and a maccies is better than an hour in a small dismal room in a contact centre, especially if the intention is returning the child to their parents.
im not saying every fcarer is like me, I obviously don’t know what goes on in their houses. All of the carers I know care for the fc very well. Maybe birds of a feather flock together?
If you’ve had bad experience of fcarers and you are a social worker you should report them. We have regular visits from our Childrens and our own Sw, often unannounced, if they’ve got a problem and think we are ‘shitty’ they should report it. We have to be re registered each year when we go to panel, we need reports from school, SWs, everyone involved with the child, if we’re shitty they should report it.
we have lac reviews every 6 months where everyone around the child, including the child attend, if we are shitty someone should report it.
If everyone does their job properly there should be no shitty foster carers.
Im putting my view across, sorry if you don’t like it, as I wouldn’t like to think that if someone’s child needs, for whatever reason( they could have no support and need to spend time in hospital) that the fcarer is treating their child badly and ‘slagging them off’
As you probably know there is a national shortage of foster carers and I know many excellent ones who have left, the ones I know go into it with the best intentions, hoping to help the child and their family, never setting them up to fail. We try to maintain a good relationship with parents, ‘mums not well at the moment so I’m looking after you’ is what we said to this particular child. Unfortunately some parents see us as the enemy and when people on here who work with us are saying it too it doesn’t help.
So in a nutshell, next time you work with a ‘shitty’ foster carer, report, if you and all your colleagues do this there will be no more ‘ shitty’ foster carers.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 17/08/2022 08:25

Cassimin · 16/08/2022 18:29

when2become3
sorry I just saw your post.
I can honestly say that all the children I have cared for and those of other carers have had a lot of contact.
I did supervised contact for one of my children.
I took them on days out, activities paid for meals, only for parents not to turn up lots of times.
imagine having to take the poor child home when this has happened.

@Cassimin Ok, I see you provide foster care? You will be seeing it from a side of poorly treated children who deserve so much more. And I guess you must experience some kind of confirmation bias - I assume you feel you are doing a good thing for those children (you are), which doesn't really stack up as well if those children are removed from their parents for no good reason.

Clearly there are lots of terrible parents in the world. Where the children 100% ought to get removed. What we just can't forget is accountability and due process for those parents where a mistake has been made by a SW (either a genuine mistake or due to poor or biased decision making). And these things do happen, that's all I am saying. Denying it is ridiculous. And it shouldn't be ignored as a non-issue that is fixed by simply handing the kids back with an "oops" because that the vast majority of cases aren't that. That is all I am saying.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 17/08/2022 08:18

Cassimin · 16/08/2022 17:55

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer
i think highly educated family barristers can have the wool pulled over their eyes just as highly educated social workers can.
I also think that highly educated people should not be advising people not to take their children to hospital just incase social services swoop in and snatch their child from them.
i also didn’t say any parents were evil, unfortunately some parents no matter how hard they try, cannot provide good enough care for a child. This is often not their fault, they too are a product of their upbringing.
I have also previously said that if a Sw is neglectful in any way they should be dealt with in an appropriate way, if necessary legally.
My attitude is from my experience and that of many of my friends who are also foster carers.
some of the children brought into our care are past the point of no return.
I also have family who work with young adults who after leaving the care system have reconnected with their families, often this is not a good experience for them.
Heartbreaking.

@Cassimin Sure.

His comment was a little tongue in cheek (and obviously, for the SW looking to jump, we take our children for medical treatment when they require it). But that was his scathing impression due to years of working in that field. That it is not rare for parents to have their children taken away for no real reason at all, and then having to spend weeks, months etc fighting to get them back.

Of course he could have had the wool pulled over his eyes. I just think it's odd that's the conclusion you jump to immediately. And his experiences follow a court process where these things are investigated and the evidence is looked at in full. Not just him sitting in a room with the parents, taking their work for it and going "oh they took your kids for no reason? Those mean SWs!". Give the legal process (which clearly exists to have some level of accountability where these often is none - too bad parents have to spend thousands accessing justice) some credit. It might not be great (family courts are a whole other story), but it's better than allowing an individual to make devastating decisions unchecked.

SaintHelena · 17/08/2022 08:14

Why didn't the woman who had her baby taken away have another baby?

Human rights, the right to family life - everyone can have babies. Good and bad.

SnowWhitesSM · 17/08/2022 08:00

Foster carer - lovingly cooks nutritious food.
Foster dc - doesn't eat the food and feels funny about it. Can't explain why.
Foster carer - this is what you're eating, look how hard I worked to cooked this, eat up your veg it's so good for you. You want to grow big and strong don't you.
Foster dc - yuk I hate your food. May or may not throw food.
Foster carer upset. Fdc upset.

Dc was caught in a huge loyalty bind. Has to deal with the feeling that mum didn't care enough to make food and will justify it that mums way is the better way. Now fc is upset with them so they also feel unstable. Lot's of big emotions. Another traumatic experience in the life of care. You must know this @Cassimin this is basic training. Your healthy food can cause many issues even if it's technically the right thing to do.

SnowWhitesSM · 17/08/2022 07:50

What are you differing on @Cassimin as you've just spoken about yourself and yes you do come across smug like another poster said. Are you saying every FC is like you?

Boundaries are a funny thing, I'd argue that trying to make the parents part of the family was a overstep in boundaries. You set them up to fail (inadvertently and I'm sure with good intentions) by trying to have them so close, Arguing for parents to see dc outside of a contact centre when they turn up with drink is a poor boundary overstep on your part and could have led to something bad happening. You also could have added to your foster childrens feelings of rejection from parents and probably did. That's emotionally worse than the dc eating 'unhealthy' food and not having a bedtime imo. They weren't able to look after their dc and you shouldn't have those dc in another position of rejection.

Neverfullycharged · 17/08/2022 04:14

But @Cassimin , @SnowWhitesSM isn’t talking about you, and I do think it’s really important to not defend the specific when people are talking about the general.

Cassimin · 16/08/2022 23:46

SnowWhitesSM
beg to differ, you do not know our circumstances all of our child’s needs are met. I have ensured our child has had all the therapies they need, I’ve taken them to counselling, camhs, occupational therapy, speech therapy, none of which they had previously.
I have never slagged off their parents, in fact I had a really good relationship with them for years. We tried to make them part of our family, I argued with Sw to get supervised contact with them so they weren’t stuck in a boring contact centre. We had days out, meals out I helped them out with money. I knew they’d had a bad start in their lives and this was why they couldn’t care for their child.
many times we turned up at a meeting place only for them not to. I would ring them, they would ignore me. This became more frequent until it was too traumatic for our f child and Sw stepped in and cancelled contact. They have never given a birthday or Christmas card never mind a present yet would turn up with drinks and cigarettes for themselves.
boundaries are not just about bedtimes, they are developing a healthy diet, not roaming the streets at night, going to school etc.
If you’ve had experience with shitty foster carers I’m sorry but that’s no reason to say I’m talking bollocks.
The foster carer is not the only person involved in the child’s life so if they are failing it should be picked up by the others and acted upon.
as you have dealt with shitty foster carers and shitty Sw I’ve also dealt with shitty parents.

SnowWhitesSM · 16/08/2022 23:12

@Cassimin that's bollocks. Foster care does not meet all dcs needs. Boundaries do not create well behaved looked after children. Boundaries do create feelings of safety in line with other therapeutic methods but these dc aren't behaving because suddenly they have a bedtime.

Often dc are traumatised from early life and from removal of family AND from being in the new foster carers home. They then act really good to control their world. There's usually a honeymoon period (that's pretty standard) and then lots more settling in. There are absolutely terrible foster carers out there. Foster carers can also continue the loyalty binds the dc have and they usually slag the SW and birth family off to the looked after child.

I've personal and professional experience with some really shitty foster carers. Just like social workers, just like all humans in the world really.

Cassimin · 16/08/2022 22:57

Sunnyqueen
Parents are not supposed to talk about their children being removed as it identifies the children. Parents on Facebook giving out private info is not on, completely goes against the privacy of the child.
On one hand you are saying children are left with parents who are inadequate on the other they are traumatised by being removed so what is the solution.
As for smug foster carers saying the behaviours have changed 6 months down the line I think that’s very unfair. Often the behaviours do change, the children have structure, boundary’s all their needs are being met. They feel safe.
Some children never recover, whether this is because they’ve been removed from their parents or it’s because of the things they’ve been exposed to we will never know.
Im not sure where you get your info on finances from but I can assure you I would get more money in a 9-5 minimum wage job, sick pay and holiday pay than I do now.
As any parent knows caring is a 24 hour job 365 days a year, you can’t stop at 5, go for nights out when you want, book a weekend away, foster care is the same.
We have a foster child,been with us over 10 years, they are very much part of our family and treated no different to our birth children. They know this is their home and they will stay as long as they want. They certainly aren’t a cash cow and I’m insulted that you feel that way. You don’t know everyone’s circumstances

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 16/08/2022 22:19

SnowWhitesSM · 16/08/2022 21:43

It's my LA rather than that previous supervisor. Even in our supervision notes we have a section (like the johoris window) of what we don't know. So in that window it might say - we don't know if mum is back with her violent partner. We don't know mum isn't still using class A drugs etc. Even if you as the worker completely believes mum and completely believes that your YP is safe at her house. We have a real culture of responsibility, covering your back and ticking boxes. It doesn't make for good social work and we're not a bad LA. Lots of great initiatives, lots of amazing reunification work and we're investing and have new preventive teams working alongside exploitation.

What a weird section to have - and obvious. Of course you don’t know if they’re still abusing drugs etc! What bureaucratic drivel.

Sunnyqueen · 16/08/2022 22:17

At some point you have to question why parents who've had children removed are being subjected to gagging orders? If everything's above board why?
The problem is epidemic yet completely secret, that the entire system is rotten from the inside out.
3 mothers stories just in my town that I know
A. Newborn baby died due to neglect over a class a drug fueled weekend - still has her other children.
B. Known prostitute drunknly punched her 2yo boy in the face twice in the middle of town 20 odd witnesses loads of cctv, definitely reported - still has her children.
C. Children stayed out at grandma's for the night. Partner/father come home drunk, row ensues punches mother in the face. Mum does what we are all supposed to do, chucks him out, doesn't allow unsupervised contact and reports it to the police. Social hand custody to father stating that Mother should seek counselling so she doesn't alienate children from their father.

How the fuck is anyone supposed to know where any case stands when there is just zero consistency constantly?
And all the Foster parents smug cos 6 months a year down the line traumatised children's behavior has improved. Consider the fact the kid was only traumatised and had behaviour issues because they were stolen from loving parents and dumped with strangers who just see them as a cash cow. Pretty sure that would create problems in the most well rounded child.

LostForWordsagain · 16/08/2022 21:43

Oblomov22 · 16/08/2022 20:40

I know 3 local families where SS tried to remove children. All related to health conditions that weren't believed. Threatened parents that they had every intention of making sure dc would be adopted. It's only because retired social workers helped that they avoided it.

MN'ers never believe SS have ulterior motives. But you know that it happens. Dirty doctors kill and dirty policeman - killing Sarah Everard. But MN'ers can't accept dirty or misguided sw'ers accept.

Lots of parents (me included) experience this.
there seems to be a list of ‘red flag conditions’ as ALL the familiar I know who went through similar had children with one or more of the following and were fighting for support / ehcp/ treatment
-ASD
-SEN
-PoTs
-allergies
-digestive issues
-feeding problems / failure to thrive
eating disorder
-EDS
-ME

In at least half the cases a parent also had ASD as well.

Something is wrong with the system

SnowWhitesSM · 16/08/2022 21:43

It's my LA rather than that previous supervisor. Even in our supervision notes we have a section (like the johoris window) of what we don't know. So in that window it might say - we don't know if mum is back with her violent partner. We don't know mum isn't still using class A drugs etc. Even if you as the worker completely believes mum and completely believes that your YP is safe at her house. We have a real culture of responsibility, covering your back and ticking boxes. It doesn't make for good social work and we're not a bad LA. Lots of great initiatives, lots of amazing reunification work and we're investing and have new preventive teams working alongside exploitation.

when2become3 · 16/08/2022 20:41

Oblomov22 · 16/08/2022 20:40

I know 3 local families where SS tried to remove children. All related to health conditions that weren't believed. Threatened parents that they had every intention of making sure dc would be adopted. It's only because retired social workers helped that they avoided it.

MN'ers never believe SS have ulterior motives. But you know that it happens. Dirty doctors kill and dirty policeman - killing Sarah Everard. But MN'ers can't accept dirty or misguided sw'ers accept.

This!!

Oblomov22 · 16/08/2022 20:40

I know 3 local families where SS tried to remove children. All related to health conditions that weren't believed. Threatened parents that they had every intention of making sure dc would be adopted. It's only because retired social workers helped that they avoided it.

MN'ers never believe SS have ulterior motives. But you know that it happens. Dirty doctors kill and dirty policeman - killing Sarah Everard. But MN'ers can't accept dirty or misguided sw'ers accept.

Jellycatspyjamas · 16/08/2022 20:34

I was taught years ago by my supervisor to never write I have no concerns as this could come back on me if something happened.

Thats truly shit advice, if there are no concerns that’s what you record and if something did happen you point to the fact that all was ok in your observations of parent and child interaction. You can’t be responsible for something you don’t see. Apart from anything else it’s fundamentally dishonest and calls into question every concern and assessment you make because if you can lie in one case, whose to say you haven’t lied in others.

I’m not blaming you for following her lead, but that kind of instruction is something social workers should be challenging.

Neverfullycharged · 16/08/2022 20:33

Neverfullycharged there are thousands of adopters out there which will have similar stories

I didn’t ask if there were thousands of adopters out there with similar stories, although they are hardly going to be told ‘actually, we do think that the birth parents got a raw deal but never mind’, are they? Hmm

I asked if you disbelieve the women on this thread.

Jellycatspyjamas · 16/08/2022 20:29

She was right but still nothing was done to make right the things they did.

What did you want to happen that would make things right? The social worker was sacked (and as a consequence would lose her registration - so wouldn’t be practicing again, rightly). What could they have done that would have made it right for you?

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 16/08/2022 20:25

SnowWhitesSM · 16/08/2022 20:21

It's weird the faux worries. I was taught years ago by my supervisor to never write I have no concerns as this could come back on me if something happened. I have to write previous concerns, previous irrelevant information in care plans and even things like - FC reports that mum made an inappropriate joke at contact and I have to ask my YP if it's true or not and write it out that although I believe it to be a joke it might not be a joke. That wouldn't disappear as we'd have to 'cover our backs' if it turned out it was true. We fo have a culture a fear in our profession, people that think we look after each other are wrong. Complaints get made and social workers are sacked. It's not like the police!

Like I've repeatedly said - a radical overhaul is needed. I wish more people would write to their MPs and ask for better social care.

This is exactly why people are terrified - making up concerns just in case it comes back on you is damaging should the child’s case go to court.

Its also the reason I essentially started to give one word answers whenever speaking to SWs and giving away absolutely nothing. If you talk, they will use your words against you

SnowWhitesSM · 16/08/2022 20:21

It's weird the faux worries. I was taught years ago by my supervisor to never write I have no concerns as this could come back on me if something happened. I have to write previous concerns, previous irrelevant information in care plans and even things like - FC reports that mum made an inappropriate joke at contact and I have to ask my YP if it's true or not and write it out that although I believe it to be a joke it might not be a joke. That wouldn't disappear as we'd have to 'cover our backs' if it turned out it was true. We fo have a culture a fear in our profession, people that think we look after each other are wrong. Complaints get made and social workers are sacked. It's not like the police!

Like I've repeatedly said - a radical overhaul is needed. I wish more people would write to their MPs and ask for better social care.

ihateexcel · 16/08/2022 20:13

@Neverfullycharged there are thousands of adopters out there which will have similar stories.

Neverfullycharged · 16/08/2022 20:04

@ihateexcel but you are talking about one case where you believe the right call was made.

Do you disbelieve @LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet ? And others on this thread?

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 16/08/2022 19:59

calmlakes · 16/08/2022 19:29

"This is exactly the kind of attitude in SWs I despise. Dehumanising oarents - it does fucking matter that you take children away no matter what you plan to do with them. Saying “oh we will probably return them” doesn’t make a shit of difference.

Then again I’ve seen you post before and I get the impression you think every parent you have a referral for is a bad parent who doesn’t deserve kids, is untrustworthy, will lie and manipulate, right?"

Of course taking children away from their parents matters, both to the children, parents, wider family and often the community.

I do maintain that there is a difference between doing this for reasons of social engineering, removing children for adoption, and for reasons of suspected significant harm. One is at heart child focused the other isn't.
That doesn't mean that there aren't significant levels of distress caused to both children and families.

I don't know any social worker who thinks every child referred to social care should be in care.
I don't think any parent deserves kids, I think parents have a certain level of responsibility towards their kids. That is as true for me as a parent as anyone else.

Social workers have a responsibility to be professionally curious, it is shown again and again in SCRs that it is asking questions, chasing down facts, linking effectively with others which helps reduce risks for children.

But too many seem to confuse curiosity with making things up or misconstruing facts, and even when called out in it, refuse to change things and run with the lies forever more