Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be confused about social services

427 replies

whentheraincame · 15/08/2022 19:06

Bit of a long one but it's something I have thought about a long time. There's two narratives:

SS don't do enough; don't act to remove children in obvious danger (happens sometimes of course)

SS are overzealous; remove children from loving homes (going to happen at times, right?)

there was a show over ten years ago called I Want my Baby Back and it was absolutely heartbreaking and admittedly it terrified me. Basically hairline fractures were found in children and parents were blamed for abuse. The argument was (I forget details and could never watch again) from some doctors that these were the result of Vitamin D deficiency (which let's face it, was endemic a while back and in the news loads)

So the argument was those children were wrongly removed. One mother cried "I want my baby" and honestly it's never left me. I'll have a cry about this later as I always do if I think too much about a child being removed from a loving mum.

So my question is if anyone has proper insight. I'm scared of SS in general. Although I actually had involvement with them myself when I left an abusive ex and they came to check I was not going to go back, nothing further happened once they met me - so proof they are fine I guess.

But I remember seeing a lady on the news, well spoken, and saying SS need to return her children who were removed. I had a friend tell me in work once that a friend with undiagnosed autism got the children removed due an incident where one got hurt by the other (which happens. these things happen, children do get hurt and it's often an accident that couldn't be prevented)

I guess I just don't want to see SS as evil child snatchers, and want insight into how they operate in reality and what actually gets children removed from parents' care?

OP posts:
Namechangeforthis88 · 15/08/2022 19:15

Basically, they can't win. You will probably never hear both sides of the story in full. People can say their children were taken away for no reason and it's rare that social services are in a position to give their side.

From time to time we have tragic cases, and the pendulum swings towards taking more children into care, then over time it swings back, until the next time.

Scotland and England have both had major reviews of children's services in recent times. The English one was more recent, the Scottish one led to a big commitment to overhaul services.

Thornethorn · 15/08/2022 19:11

It's very hard for them to get it right.

It does take far too long for them to check that fractures aren't caused by medical conditions rather than abuse. There is a terrifyingly long wait when it should be an afternoon or few days work, given that a baby stands to lose its primary carer until a paediatrician has weighed in. Foster carers are scarce.

I've known children be supported wonderfully to stay at home and others don't seem to have a chance to live at home. A bit of a lottery. Social workers can also get tunnel vision if they think a child is adoptable. That shouldn't even be a word but they use it. It means desirable, really.